Stacey Abrams Exposes the AI Industry's CARTEL Playbook

Stacey Abrams
1 follower
1 Video View·Sep 17, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker argues that recent calls from AI giants to \"slow down\" are not selfless warnings, but a coordinated effort to form a legal cartel and avoid genuine oversight. He contends that these companies are lobbying the federal government to preempt state-level regulations while continuing to aggressively expand data center infrastructure at the expense of local taxpayers.
On Saturday, the Chief Executive of Anthropic, Dario Amadei, called on his own industry to slow down.
Within a day, the heads of OpenAI, XAI, Google DeepMind, and Microsoft chimed in to agree.
Four of the most powerful companies on earth stood up in the same weekend and said their product
may be moving too fast to control. In my political thriller, Coded Justice,
I use the best intentions of a tech billionaire with a novel AI technology to explore what
happens when those high ideals meet the capability of an overconfident chat bot
and an LLM with a God complex. Why? Because I take AI worries seriously, unlike our president,
and I want folks to have the context they need to understand what everyone is talking about.
Likewise, I want to take this warning to slow down seriously, but I need all of us to notice
what didn't happen this weekend. My concern isn't about what they proposed, but who they asked.
Because the day before Anthropic's announcement, Wired reported that OpenAI had gone to Congress
with a question. If we coordinate with our competitors to pace ourselves, does that violate
the Sherman Antitrust Act? Seems reasonable, but competitors agreeing to jointly restrict output
is the oldest antitrust violation there is. So they went looking for permission to break the law.
These pseudo-selfless tech giants ask Congress for permission to do what they've been told not to,
to create a cartel that circumvents the rules we already have, that are intended to give the people
both insight and control of their consumer decisions, and if necessary, to block monopoly power.
And here's the thing, we've seen it before. The Phoebus cartel was a 1920s international alliance
of major light bulb manufacturers. Yes, light bulbs. But they colluded to intentionally shorten
the lifespan of incandescent light bulbs. Why? So they could sell more of them and block the
longer lasting ones. It worked, and the tech titans of the time made millions. And if the
tech bros truly wanted quick checks on their power, going to a Congress that has been structurally
incapable of the most basic oversight seems a bit odd. Especially given that even if a bill passed,
it would likely take years and be vetoed by the anachronistic head of government who thinks we're
playing a game of chicken with China. If the four horsemen wanted actual oversight, they could move
fast and get it done at the local level where the people are already clamoring for action. But they
did not ask a single state legislature. They did not ask a public service commission. They did not
ask a county planning board. And these are the only bodies in this country that have actually
slowed anything down. Now look, I write for a living. I also work in politics. You may have heard.
And both of these are about timing and communications. The chorus of agreement that
we heard this weekend was not spontaneous. It was coordinated. At the same moment this industry is
asking Washington for permission to create the OPEC of AI, its political operations are asking
Washington to strip the states of the power to regulate AI at all. And their PACs are funding
candidates who won't fight back. On December 11, 2025, the White House signed an executive order
directing the Attorney General to create an AI litigation task force. Not to help us, but to
sue states over their existing AI laws. And then they tasked the FCC and the Commerce Department
to help stop oversight. For any wayward states, the White House threatened noncompliance. They said
any state refusing to sign an agreement to not enforce their AI laws risks losing the federal
broadband money that wires rural counties. No one from the tech oligarchy has written a screed
about this usurpation of local authority or the urgency of state intervention. Instead, states
have been given an ultimatum. Either relinquish your authority over the most consequential
technology of our lifetime, or we'll take away your internet money. And this is not theoretical.
On April 24, 2026, the Justice Department intervened in XAI versus Wiser in the federal
court in Colorado. The United States government joined with a company that is strip mining
communities to build data centers for the mutual objective of striking down Colorado's AI law.
I spent 11 years in the Georgia General Assembly, seven as the Democratic minority leader. I know
what it means when the federal government shows up as a co-plaintiff against a state statute.
But I also served before that as Deputy City Attorney in Atlanta, where I watched bigger
governments disagree with local protections. And when that happens, what you end up with is a
jurisdictional land grab called preemption that's cloaked as efficiency. You see, the argument is
simple. Don't allow the people to protect themselves. Wait for the federal government to decide
what kind of protection they deserve. But the thing is, Congress actually agrees with me.
It has, for once, understood its own frailty and its gutlessness. In July of last year,
the Senate stripped a state AI moratorium out of the reconciliation bill by 99 votes to one.
99 to one. And then the same idea was dropped into the defense authorization bill
and rejected. Twice offered, twice refused. When Congress says we can't save you,
believe them. Which is why the authoritarian pact with tech oligarchy turned to executive
orders and a litigation task force, because that's what you do when you know you can't get
the votes. What they worry about is that we'll realize that we don't need their votes. We have
the power already. Lena Kahn, who ran the Federal Trade Commission, made the argument this weekend
better than I can. Her point was blunt. There is no AI exemption from laws that are already on the
books. Law enforcement at the local level already has the authority to charge companies and their
executives for releasing dangerous, unvetted, defective products. Shipping a flawed AI tool
without adequate measures to stop it can already be an unfair or deceptive practice
under federal law and, by extension, analogous state laws. In fact, some state attorneys general
are already exploring criminal liability. Every state in this country has a consumer
protection statute. They were written for door-to-door fraud and defective toasters,
and they apply to AI. The attorney general of Kentucky has sued chatbots under Kentucky's
its privacy law and its statutes governing online services directed at children. Any state can file
a similar suit tomorrow. Last Thursday, the attorney general of Florida proposed making
companies criminally liable when their AI systems participate in crimes, after prosecutors found
chat logs between chat GPT and a defendant in a Florida shooting. State laws can be misused,
and these are not attorneys general who routinely served as the people's lawyers
as much as the instruments of the state's legal brutality. When there is common ground,
we can walk together. Which brings us to data centers. In the whole of this weekend's kumbaya,
nobody proposed slowing the build-out. Google, Microsoft, Meta, and Amazon are projected to
spend roughly $725 billion on capital expenditures this year, up from 77% over last year.
Data center demand drove capacity costs up 174% for 2025-2026. Average residential electricity
prices nationally are up about 42% over the last five years. The models may need to pace themselves,
but the construction apparently can run full speed ahead. So while Washington argues about
permitting frontier models to collude, our protections must come from closer to home.
We've got proof. 95 local moratoria and bans on data centers have been enacted in 2026,
roughly four times the total of all of last year. Zoning boards and ballot measures are doing what
four CEOs and a congressional inquiry have not yet managed to accomplish. In the legislatures,
more than 300 data center bills were filed in over 30 states in the first six weeks of the year.
Oregon already has created separate rate classes so that these facilities carry their own cost.
Arizona has a bill keeping grid connection costs off of residential customers. At least 18 states
are working on special rate classes for large energy users. As for the rest of us, we now need
to get to work. How? Using steps eight and nine in the 10 steps to freedom and power. First, we need
to show up at the public service commissions in our states, which is one of the most powerful bodies
that most people are completely unaware of. Nine states elect their utility regulators,
and they are on the ballot November 3rd. Georgia, Alabama, Arizona, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska,
North Dakota, Oklahoma, and South Dakota. Here in Georgia, District 3 and 5, which are elected
statewide, are up for grabs. And last November, Democrats flipped two of these seats because the
bills were too high. The commission sits at three to two. Two seats decide who sets the rate you pay
and whether a data center pays its own freight. Look, nobody's going to pour a million dollars
into telling you about a public service commission race, so I need you to go find it on your ballot
anyway. Second, we've got to speak up and engage. Rate cases and large load tariff filings
take public comment, and almost nobody files any. A utility commission hearing is one of the few
left in American government where showing up still has an effect. Why? Because the industry
comes every single time, and they know you won't. So if you're there to watch them,
the elected officials can see you too. Third, use your county commissions. 95 localities have
already done this. When a facility comes to your planning commission, the question is not yes or
no, it's how. So read the fine print and demand the details. Ask for a separate rate class,
written indemnity so rate payers don't cover stranded costs, water disclosure, a decommissioning
bond. Quiz your county leaders and teach them what they need to know. Will you vote for a separate
rate class for large load so my bill doesn't subsidize theirs? Would you sign an agreement
not to enforce this state's AI law in exchange for federal broadband money? Look, good public
policy requires debate, and our economy and our future are yoked to these AI companies, I'm clear.
And I appreciate that they are talking about slowing down the speed of a technology that has
grown exponentially beyond speculation into actual existential harm. However, a slowdown designed by
its beneficiaries should raise eyebrows and questions. Worse, a slowdown that puts out the
fire but ignores the flood leaves too many behind. The people who can actually set the terms are
elected in seven weeks in races that most of us skip over. State legislative races, county commission
races, public service commission races. But this time, let's pay attention and let's slow down how
fast they try to shut us up.
