This Might Be the Best Ice Cream Flavor Ever… (Coffee Oreo) | Claire Saffitz

Frosty Recipe
434 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedClaire Saffitz demonstrates how to create a professional, creamy Coffee Oreo ice cream using a custard base. By utilizing concentrated coffee to avoid ice crystals and carefully timing the addition of Oreo pieces, she achieves a balanced dessert that blends bitter coffee notes with sweet, crunchy textures.
Hi everyone, I'm Claire Saffitz.
Welcome to my home kitchen.
Today I'm showing you a recipe
for the greatest ice cream flavor in the world,
which is coffee Oreo.
Debate me in the comments.
♪ Doo-doo-doo-doo, doo-doo-doo-doo, doo-doo-doo person. ♪
When I started talking about coffee Oreo,
Vince was like,
well you get a scoop of Oreo ice cream,
you get a scoop of coffee.
No, no, that's not what it is.
It is one flavor that is coffee ice cream
with Oreos in it.
I had never ever heard of this flavor.
It's like growing up, we went to Baskin Robbins.
since this was like not one of the 32 flavors.
But when my parents moved to the Boston area 20 years ago,
Boston, Massachusetts is like crazy into ice cream.
And then we'd go to Cape Cod
and like in the summer go to ice cream places.
And this is where I first like learned about coffee Oreo.
It was a flavor that we saw everywhere.
It's like, this is the greatest ice cream flavor
of all time.
And it's the texture, it's the flavor.
Coffee is one of my favorite dessert ingredients
because it's bitter and very flavorful
and pairs so well with sweet flavors and dairy.
It's like meant to be this ice cream flavor.
It's just so good.
When you're making coffee ice cream,
you can't just add a cup of brewed coffee
to your ice cream base
because you're adding so much water.
So the strategy has to involve adding
like a very, very concentrated coffee.
And so we're going to talk about how to do that.
And today I'm going to use comment here.
Ingredients.
So this is a variation on my go-to ice cream base.
I have here two cups of heavy cream.
I have three quarters of a cup of milk.
So I'm decreasing the amount of milk slightly to compensate
because I'm going to add some coffee to it.
Five yolks.
And I make a custard base.
I do like a crème anglaise basically base for my ice cream.
Then I'm adding some sugar.
It's three quarters of a cup.
This is a kind of an optional ingredient.
I feel like it's the kind of thing
where if you already have it, add it.
If you don't, it's fine.
It's not worth buying it separate,
but this is some dry milk powder.
It helps to enhance texture.
It gives you like a smoother result.
A big pinch of kosher salt.
I'm using vanilla paste.
I just love seeing the little specks in the ice cream.
That's important to me.
And then six ounces of Oreos.
You could use any like any Oreo type cookie.
For the coffee flavor, I'm using comment here.
And comment here works with some of the best coffee roasters
around the world and has a special brewing method
that's then flash frozen.
And it comes to your house frozen in these recyclable pods.
The flavor is very, very intense.
So it's perfect application in a coffee ice cream like this
where I want lots of coffee flavor, but not a lot of liquid.
This one is from Winslow Coffee Company in Massachusetts,
fitting for our coffee Oreo ice cream.
So special equipment, really basic.
I have my sauce pan.
So we're gonna, we have to cook the custard,
cook the base and make sure the eggs are cooked.
I like to temp it.
So I have an instant re-thermometer
just so I know that I've hit that temperature
where the eggs are cooked.
And then like a strainer to strain the base.
And of course the main thing you'll need
is a ice cream maker.
So you can use the kind that like you freeze the insert.
So if you're gonna make this,
make sure you're freezing it 24 hours in advance.
I have this really fancy one that I got a couple years ago
that has a self cooling.
So you just plug it in and go.
My love of coffee, like cold coffee desserts
is well documented on the channel.
We have a coffee granita episode.
Delicious, so easy.
We have a coffee stracciatella semifreddo.
No churn, delicious.
But truly, I think the like the queen of all coffee,
cold desserts is coffee ice cream.
That's what we're gonna make.
Before I get into the recipe,
I wanna thank our friends at Cominteer
for sponsoring this episode.
Everyone here knows I love my cup of coffee.
One in the morning, maybe one in the afternoon
is a little treat.
And I love Cominteer because they work
with the best independent roasters from around the country
and they make coffee that is flash frozen in aluminum pods.
They ship right to your house.
The pods can go into your curbside recycling.
But beyond just the convenience factor,
I love the quality of the coffee.
You can have it any way you like, no machine required.
So sometimes in the morning,
I'm in the mood for something iced like today,
pour a little milk over it.
You make a latte or you can have it hot in the morning
by adding hot water.
And I love that you can go on and select by flavor profile.
So the folks at Cominteer sent me some ones
based on what I like,
which is like a really nicely roasted coffee
that has notes of caramel and chocolate.
Delish.
So we're gonna do our coffee Oreo ice cream
served affogato style with a little more Cominteer
poured over top, and it's going to be so good.
So I wanna say thanks to Cominteer
for sponsoring the episode.
If you wanna learn more about Cominteer
and all the different coffees they have
and save on your order,
go to the link in the description below.
And now back to the recipe.
The first thing I'm going to do
is get my dairy into my saucepan.
And we're gonna bring it up to a simmer.
So I'm just gonna put it on medium.
And this is two cups of heavy cream.
And this base that I described,
the like two cups cream, one cup milk,
although in this case I decreased
that milk quantity slightly.
But this is my go-to base for like most flavors.
It's that proportion of two cups cream,
one cup milk thereabouts, and five yolks
that I think is like spot on.
And anywhere between a half
and three quarters of a cup of sugar,
depending on your flavor.
So that's the milk.
And like I said, I decreased the milk slightly
because we are going to be adding liquid
in the form of very, very, very strong coffee.
I'm going to add to my saucepan
a portion of the sugar.
You can really eyeball it.
Let's call it like around half or even two thirds.
So we wanna dissolve some of the sugar that way.
And then we're gonna reserve some of it
for whisking our yolks.
I'm gonna also add my salt.
Just a big pinch of salt is there
to bring out the flavor.
And my powdered milk.
Now I'm gonna add to this a teaspoon of vanilla paste.
That part's eyeballed.
So I'm just gonna whisk this.
I wanna encourage that sugar to dissolve.
And then while that's heating up,
I'm going to combine my eggs and the remaining sugar.
If you had to get one of your recipes on a Tuesday,
which would it be?
I'm feeling really, really smug
about that She Can't Talk to Tan these days.
I just think it's innovative.
I really do.
Oh!
Oh my God.
Woo!
How much did I lose?
I'm talking about how amazing I am.
Probably about half of it.
I'm talking about how amazing I am.
And then did I lose half?
No, I did not lose half of it.
I lost like three tablespoons.
I got distracted talking about how amazing I am.
That was karma in real time.
Don't you think?
I think you just weren't paying attention.
No, I wasn't.
I was singing my own praises.
Just patting myself on the back.
Hold on.
Let's just get cleaned up here.
What was I talking about?
All right, let's get...
Sheet pan tartine is your greatest creation.
That you're gonna have it engraved on your tombstone.
Yeah, that one I'm feeling good about at the moment.
I don't know, I think that is.
But the grasshopper pie stands out
because that was such good mint chip ice cream.
Okay, let's get this back nearly at a simmer.
All right, we're gonna whisk together our yolks
and the remaining sugar.
I'm gonna add that together.
This is the basic method for any type of custard.
So it's, this step is called blanching.
Or I'm mixing the eggs and the sugar.
So you wanna whisk this until it's a little bit pale.
There's not so much sugar here,
so you're not gonna have this really dramatic
lightening effect that you get in some recipes.
So we're gonna take our hot dairy base
and slowly whisk about two thirds of it into the yolks.
This is a gentle method of increasing the egg temp
where you're not shocking them
and the risk of overcooking them.
Am I spilling?
All into the control unit.
Okay, perfect.
Now everything goes back, whisk this whole mixture
back into the saucepan.
And I'm gonna scrape all of it back in.
Okay, so now we want to whisk this constantly
until the eggs are cooked
and that's gonna create this thickening effect
in the custard.
So I wanna cook this until it's around 170.
I have a feeling it's pretty close
because of just the texture that it is now.
Oh, I'm at 171.
I'm cooked, I'm done.
So let's get this off the heat.
And now I'm going to add my coffee.
And the reason I'm adding it now
is I don't really wanna cook the coffee into the base.
I want that flavor to be as kind of like fresh as possible.
And what's great about using Cometeer is it comes frozen.
The coffee in these capsules is designed to be diluted.
So you add water to it to enjoy it.
And it comes in these like, you know,
nice tiny little capsules that are recyclable.
What's great about that is because there is so much flavor
in these small capsules,
I don't have to add a lot of liquid, which is what I want.
It's like, you don't really wanna add a lot of liquid
to an ice cream base
because you don't want a lot of water
that's gonna form ice crystals
and make an ice cream that's not smooth.
So I also need to cool the base down.
So by adding like the basically the frozen capsules
to the base, it helps me to cool it down.
I'm gonna add three of them.
So I'm gonna add, I'm just gonna rinse them
under a little bit of water to loosen the capsule.
So just a little bit of that was, you know,
barely warm water just to thaw the outer layer.
These are gonna go right in.
So all in, this is adding around five tablespoons of liquid.
So that's why I had decreased the milk quantity
a little bit and it gives it a really beautiful color.
So if you're making this at home
and you're not using the Cometeer coffee,
which has, you know, it comes in these small capsules
with really, really intense flavor, use espresso.
You could even beef up your espresso flavor
with a little bit of powdered espresso,
but just know that the quality of the coffee
that you're adding is going to determine
the quality of your final ice cream.
So now what we wanna do with our base is strain it.
And that's because often what happens is
you get like little bits of egg
that didn't really dissolve into your custard,
whether they got overcooked
or whether it was just like that little weird part
of the yolk that doesn't quite like break up
with everything else.
So I wanna strain it
because this is gonna make our finished ice cream smoother.
Good color.
The color is nice, right?
And this makes, this base recipe makes
about a quart total volume.
And that's about the capacity of your average
like at-home ice cream maker.
So it works out well.
I just wanna scrape in the little vanilla seeds.
Hold on.
Little less than a quart because I spilled.
So now under normal circumstances,
this just goes into the fridge and it chills.
Really ideally it chills overnight.
You want to spin,
you want the base to be very, very cold
before you put it in the ice cream machine.
This one, I wanna spin kind of right away
or as soon as possible.
So I'm gonna stir it over an ice bath to get it cold.
And then we're gonna spin it.
I'm just gonna rush that process along a little bit.
So for my ice bath, I have a bowl here.
I'm gonna add cold water to the ice.
You only wanna fill the bowl like a third of the way
because of the displacement.
And the bowl that I'm using inside the ice bath,
I always use metal
because it's gonna have faster heat transfer.
So it's gonna cool down faster.
And then pour in our base.
Get all those vanilla seeds in there.
This is just stirring.
And that's to keep the mixer moving
so that new base is coming into contact
with the cold bowl underneath.
So I'm just gonna stir this until it's cool to the touch.
I'll probably refrigerate it briefly
while my ice cream machine cools down,
but then we're just gonna go right
into spinning the ice cream.
I have my base that's just keeping cold in the fridge.
I'm gonna just break up my Oreo pieces.
This is six ounces of Oreos.
And I have thought probably more than the average person
about ice cream mix-ins and what makes good or not good.
And I think cookie, like hydrated cookie
is one of the most just pleasing textures
and I love it so much.
So I add the cookie pieces
toward the end of the churning process.
While the ice cream is like frozen but not fully set
and that helps to encourage some hydration of the pieces.
It's like when you go to scoop it,
you don't hit a hard piece of cookie
that then has to like get dug out.
It kind of just cuts right through
and that's what I like best.
I'm not turning them into crumbs.
I'm just breaking them into pieces
and the churning of the ice cream
kind of further breaks it up
because I like that different size.
I like when it's different sizes.
Want some light larger pieces and some smaller pieces.
So this is six ounces.
I'm gonna add most of it into the ice cream
toward the end of churning
and then I'll save a couple pieces for sprinkling on top
because then it's actually kind of nice
to get like a piece that might be a little crunchy
and then the rest are kind of soft.
I forgot how many pieces six ounces is.
I think it's probably around 15 cookies or so.
So I'm gonna set these aside
and let's get the ice cream spinning.
I just pour this in.
This is gonna spin for a good 20 minutes, I think.
It's only when it's like 90% of the way there
that I'll add the Oreos.
I have a cake pan, a metal pan that I just froze
because I like to have the ice cream hit something cold
so it doesn't immediately start to melt
when I get it in the freezer.
So I'm gonna scrape it into the pan,
top it with the Oreos and it needs to freeze solid.
I have a batch that I made last night
so we can pull that out and taste it after it's fully set.
Metal is good because you want it to be able to get cold
and maintain that temp.
Oh yeah, this is such a nice texture.
And I love how the crumbs have really broken down
but are still in larger pieces in some places.
This is really the ideal.
It has that stretch
that really good ice cream or gelato has, which I love.
And the best part is that you can leave.
It's like, oh, I scraped it as best I can,
but then really you leave some in the ice cream maker
so that you can taste it.
So then we're just going to spread this out.
Sprinkle those last Oreo pieces over top.
Kind of press them down in.
And then this just has to freeze solid.
And I'm gonna pull out the one I made last night.
I'll cover it right now
because I'm gonna pull this one out.
It's like, did someone come in last night
and take a little piece of that ice cream out of the corner?
Yes, and it wasn't me.
So I'm gonna get cleaned up
and this is going to temper a little bit
because it is frozen solid.
So I'm gonna let it warm up slightly
and then we're gonna scoop it and taste it.
And I decided that in the spirit
of this being the greatest ice cream flavor ever created,
we're gonna serve it affogato style,
really play up the coffee.
So I'm gonna grab some more cometeer
and a serving bowl and my scoop.
So I have my thawed cometeer right here.
My ice cream has tempered.
It's getting like a little melted around the edge,
which is perfect.
And then I have a little bit of milk
because one thing Harris does
is like if he's eating ice cream,
sometimes he likes to pour a little cold milk on top
to dilute some of the sweetness
and then it kind of gets like a milkshake texture.
So I might do like a little coffee milk pour over
in the spirit of affogato.
All right, so I have my scoop and my serving glass.
Oh my gosh, this,
maybe you can let it temper a little too much.
This is such a nice texture.
How did this melt?
I wasn't even out for that long.
I guess it's just a nice ice cream texture.
Oops.
It fits though, it should be at the tip.
And then maybe just like a little pour over.
Oh my gosh, I'm so excited to eat this.
And then I love that coffee at the end
because the ice cream is kind of perfectly sweet,
but then having that extra bitter shot of coffee on top,
it's like so perfect.
All right, anyone in the comments below
who was like, this is not the best flavor of ice cream,
is wrong.
Oh my gosh.
Ooh, if you're not as big a coffee lover as I am,
make it, you can skip the coffee pour over.
But like, it's so perfectly balanced,
bitter, intense, aromatic, creamy, sweet enough.
Then the Oreo is like,
it's not like the Oreo is adding a lot of flavor.
You do get some of that cocoa,
but the texture, the kind of soft, hydrated crumbs
and like occasional crunch from a bigger piece
is so satisfying.
And then if you let it melt a little,
you do kind of get coffee milkshake.
This is the kind of thing that makes me want to keep
my ice cream maker out all the time
because to me, the hardest thing about making ice cream
is just getting the machine out and getting it ready.
And I don't want to have a barrier
to making this a lot more times
because it is so good and really, truly easy.
Like the ice cream maker does all the work.
You cook a custard, add some coffee to it.
I used Cometeer, you can use espresso at home.
If you don't have an espresso maker,
I would go to your favorite coffee place
and have them brew you a couple shots of espresso
and just take it home and stick it in the fridge
and use that.
And the rest of it is super easy.
So I really hope you try it.
I want to thank our friends at Cometeer
for sponsoring this episode.
If you want to learn more and save on your order,
you can go to the link in the description below.
I want to thank Cometeer for sponsoring
and for making such great coffee
that you can have ready in an instant at home.
I love drinking it and I also really love using it
in baking, especially coffee ice cream.
So I want to say thank you so much for watching
and don't forget to like and subscribe.
Co-co-co-co-co-co-co-co-co.
