Ecommerce: Helping Brands Scale Top of Funnel Acquisition w/UGC & Influencer Creative w/Josh Zhang

Chase Dimond | Email Marketing
43 followers
I'm excited to share today's interview I did with Josh Zhang. Josh is the CEO of Gainfluence, helping consumer startups grow.
In this interview with Josh, we talk at length about how he helps pre Series A brands scale top of funnel acquisition through UGC & influencer creative.
We also talk about how important follower size is or isn't, as well as the social platforms he likes to work on.
You can follow Josh on Twitter here: https://twitter.com/joshlzhang
#ecommerce #emailmarketing #shopify #ecommercebusiness #digitalmarketing #email #emailmarketingtips #klaviyo #tutorial #chasedimond
Hey guys, we're here for episode 25 of the e-commerce opportunity.
I'm joined by Josh.
Hey Josh, how are you?
Doing well, man.
How about yourself?
Doing well.
Thank you.
Do you mind kind of starting with what you're working on right now?
Yeah, absolutely.
Um, so like I said, my name is Josh.
Uh, I run a company called Gainfulence.
Um, we work with, uh, pre-series A, uh, consumer tech startups.
So anything spanning from e-commerce, DTC, um, all the way to, uh, consumer
FinTech and, uh, you know, consumer FinTech, FinTech, uh, that stuff in general.
So, um, we're helping them grow so they can raise their series A.
Awesome.
And when you say you're helping them grow, like what are the main levers or
channels that you're, you're leveraging for that growth?
Yeah.
So most of the companies we work with are very early.
Um, they, most of them just raise a seed round.
So the clock is ticking.
They're looking to, um, you know, raise that series A in like 12, 18 months.
Right.
So they really need to hit that, like, you know, whatever, like the 50% to a
hundred percent month to month, you know, cumulative growth rate.
Um, most of them come to me for acquisition.
So they think they have a problem with the acquisition channel they're running
on or, uh, the, the mechanism, the tactics they're running their ads with.
Uh, but all of them, you know, they come to me, I take a look at their ads.
And most of the time, the problem is their niche is off, their offer is off.
You know, they haven't quite found that, you know, product market fit.
Right.
And that's kind of where I come in.
Um, and I help them, you know, really nail in that offer.
Um, and then we start running the ads, um, and, you know, testing
accuratives, influencing marketing, that sort of thing.
Awesome.
And what is your background?
Is it on the SAS side?
Is it on the e-comm side?
Like, what is your background?
Yeah.
So I, um, I started out being, I was a product manager at Dropbox.
So kind of a unconditional, uh, background for, you know, someone
on e-comm, but I was a lead product manager for Dropbox paper.
Um, that's the, uh, you know, more document product that Dropbox also
was, uh, AB testing running and running AB experiments for Dropbox, uh, business.
So upselling for users to Dropbox pro Dropbox business.
Um, and that's kind of where I learned, you know, growth.
So how do you, um, so top of funnel, how do you get users in
and how do you retain them?
How do you make sure they don't turn?
And if they do turn, how do you, you know, run email marketing?
Like, you know, you do.
Um, to, you know, get them to come back.
So, um, that's where I started.
And, uh, the first market I tackled was, you know, e-comm DTC.
That is kind of where the biggest opportunity was.
And, uh, you know, we're, we're not a founders who, you know, bought a
ton of inventory and they can't clear it.
Right.
That's kind of where I started.
And, um, so helping them clear inventory.
And then we moved out to companies or funded.
So they just wait to see around, like I said, and you know, they're just
looking to scale and grow at that point.
So, um, using a bunch of different mechanisms, um, and anything from
AB testing their landing page all the way down to what I'm really focused
on right now on the acquisition side, which is, um, building out like a
raw content pipeline for, for these folks to use to pass, you know, what
is that format that can get me, you know, that like seven days or less
and Facebook ads, TikTok ads, that sort of thing.
Awesome.
I want to talk about the content in one second, but how did you go from
working at Dropbox to working for yourself and how did you get your first client?
Yeah, that's a great question.
Um, so I was at Dropbox for about two and a half years.
I was running a growth team.
Uh, so, uh, Dropbox paper was essentially launched out of my team.
Um, and it's essentially like a top of funnel, uh, feature
to get people into the funnel.
So, you know, the way Dropbox makes money is they have
several different like levers.
So Dropbox paper was one of the free products.
Dropbox free product was another one.
Get a ton of users in, and then they upsell the crap out of
you on like the backend, right?
So that's the notifications, email marketing, you know, any, any time.
I don't know if anybody's Dropbox, but the second you log in, there's
like 20 different banners, right?
Telling you to pay them.
So, uh, so I was the one like kind of running those kind of things.
And.
Um, and yeah, when you're at a P where you're a PM at one of these,
you know, uh, big tech companies, you're constantly getting hit up by
every startup under the sun, right?
Because they think your process is, you know, gonna, gonna blow
their startup up, right?
Which is not true.
Like at a tech company, a big tech company, um, what you're
focused on is process, right?
And that is not necessarily, you know, what like a startup needs.
Right.
So, um, so I saw a huge need there, like these startups, like
they really need help if they're not growing fast enough, their
tack or their CPA, whatever their, you know, the MR is just like,
you know, they're, they're struggling.
Right.
So, um, so a big opportunity there, um, to, to help them, uh, not
necessarily using everything I learned from Dropbox, which could be a
different use case, but really helping them dial in, like, how do you test things?
How do you test offers?
Right.
How do you test different niches?
Which, which is a super important at that stage.
Um, and I was also friends with a bunch of VCs.
I was in San Francisco for like four years.
So, you know, they were introducing me to the portfolio
companies that were struggling.
So I don't know anyone's in the VC world, but like 90% of these funds.
Portfolio companies are struggling, right?
All kind of betting on that top, like 1% to be the next Uber.
Um, so they just had a bunch of companies who need help.
So that's kind of how I got started.
Um, you know, uh, a lot of these companies that came in were e-comm.
So, um, you know, at one point I was just making more money from that
than what Dropbox is paying me.
So I just, you know, ended up leaving and doing that full time.
Got it.
So you had the full-time job, you kind of were doubling up doing some
side work, kind of consulting that thing accelerated faster than the
job Dropbox thing is you want full time.
Um, so what does your team look like today?
And like, what are some of the roles on your team?
Like, what are these people doing?
Like, I guess the question is like, what is your process?
And I'm not asking for your secrets, but like, what is your process?
Like, what does your team look like and how do you work clients?
And what does that end result?
Yeah, definitely.
Um, so on the e-comm side, uh, we were getting a lot of, uh, you know, uh,
we're getting a lot, they just raised around, right.
They just raised a seed round.
So, um, our, our team is, uh, three people total, uh, with Victoria and
who are mainly sort of managing the campaign process.
When I say campaign, that could be anything from, Hey, like I just raised
around, um, I got some inventory.
Like I really, I need to grow like five X what I'm doing right now.
So we go in and we're looking at like, okay, like what, who's your audience,
right?
And like, is your offer actually hitting in there?
So anything from, um, looking at their Facebook ads manager to looking at their,
um, GA dashboard to looking at their landing page, the UX flow, all these
things.
Um, and that's more Anna side, Victoria side, we're really testing heavily
on Facebook ads right now with influencer creatives.
So she's the one that kind of manages our network of influencers.
We have about, um, 10,000 following us on Instagram.
We have about another 20,000 who follow us on our email.
So managing that network and working with these creators to create like, you
know, that perfect, like sort of format and also helping these brands build out
that content pipeline.
So anyone who runs Facebook ads, you know, a big struggle is how do you, how do I
get like a pipeline going?
Right.
So how do I just consistently get 50, a hundred, 200 different pieces of video
creatives every single month?
Um, cause one thing works in February.
It doesn't work again in March, right?
Whether it's you saturate your audience or it could be some other brands saw what
you're doing, right?
They went through your ass library and they copied your format.
It doesn't work anymore.
Right.
Cause everyone's now is, uh, is doing that now.
So, um, so constantly refreshing that creative and work with the creators.
Um, so that's kind of our operation right now.
Uh, me personally, I'm focused on building partnerships.
So I'm spending all day talking to the founders or VCs or angel investors to, um,
to sort of just get brands in.
Um, but, uh, yeah.
And also kind of, you know, going outside of our current vertical.
So looking at, um, you know, right now we're going heavily in supplements right
now, so talking to a lot of stuff on folks.
So having these kinds of conversations.
Nice.
And just to clarify, so are you guys providing the assets for, you know, top of
funnel marketers to actually run, or are you also managing the paid
spend and running that too?
Yeah.
Um, we, yeah.
So right now we're focused mainly on the creatives.
So that's a great question.
Um, we used to run some of the ads, um, as everyone knows, like that, that, that
process, the media buying process is getting automated like every day, right?
It's Facebook is getting better and better at, you know, finding your audience for
you.
So a lot of the, a lot of the tactics, you know, everyone's talking about, you know,
like six months ago, it's not super relevant today.
Um, you know, and then with like iOS 14 and, you know, just a lot of the, a lot of
the, you know, pixelating and how do you, you know, someone looks at my ad, they go
on Google and they come back.
How do I do attribution?
A lot of these things are, you know, they're just not as, uh, relevant anymore.
So, uh, we're right.
So right now the number one thing I tell people, the most important thing you can
do on the acquisition side is building out that raw content pipeline.
It's not even necessarily like, you know, figuring out like, what is the number one
silver bullet format?
Cause it's going to change every month.
Right.
So it's, how do I build out that like network of, you know, if you're using
influencers, how do I build that network of creators, right.
Over time.
And it's going to take years.
Um, how do I, how do I constantly have a process of iterating every
month, uh, based on the results.
Right.
So some of the stuff I've learned from Dropbox, like super relevant.
So, um, so really sort of nailing down that pipeline is kind of what we're
focused on, uh, buying ads right now is just not adding that much value.
Yep.
Makes sense.
That's helpful.
So in terms of like the assets that you're creating, a lot of it sounds like
it's centered and geared towards the top of the funnel, or there are other
use cases of the assets where you're creating specifically the lifestyle
or product shots, or you're creating assets for email.
Um, are you specifically focused on creative for top of the funnel or is
your creative kind of universal where it could be used across, you know,
whatever the mechanism is.
Absolutely.
That's yeah, that's a great one.
Um, so, um, we are using a lot of UGC right now on, uh, landing pages.
So, um, we are currently partnered with three, like Shopify agencies,
agencies who are, you know, building, building out the sites.
Um, a lot of venture studios, you know, we work with them, like they're
focused on launching new brands, which really entails like just launching
the website, right on Shopify and.
Um, using, using UGC creatives, influencer creatives.
Um, especially if you're in a space, if you're selling a product
that requires a lot of trust.
Um, so I mean supplements, right.
Um, you know, we talked earlier outside of e-com like FinTech, right.
Uh, like FinTech is a lot of trust problems, right?
You got to put in your social security number, right?
Like, who are you?
Like, why should I put in my personal info into this, into this funnel?
Um, and, uh, if anyone's familiar with like consumer FinTech in particular
personal finance, that sort of thing, um, you need UGC, right.
Or nobody's going to sign up.
So, um, so a lot of, so a lot of this is being used now on landing pages.
Um, anything that's a little bit complex.
So, um, uh, either in terms of like using the products or, uh, you know,
going along the lines of like supplements, like what is this actually do?
Like what, what are the ingredients in this?
What are the actual benefits also applies to some skincare products
that are a little bit more niche.
Um, we're working with this company right now.
Um, you know, beauty stat, right.
It's, it's a, it's, it's a vitamin C vitamin C, like skin refiner, right.
It's, there's some nuances, like, like what does this exactly do?
And it's also targeted more so like an older audience.
So, um, they want to know like every single thing that's in this bottle, right?
So when they're landing or landing page, like explainer video, um, of like your
customers and customers would look like you in the video, that's kind of what's
converting the actual sale itself.
Putting that on the landing page could be the checkout page.
Um, definitely underutilized right now.
Um, I don't see a lot of brands doing this and I think it's a big opportunity
is if you're having shopping cart, abandonment problems, or people are just
like, you know, putting stuff in the cart and they're not buying, um, try doing that.
I think, uh, we, we see a lot of good results doing that.
That's awesome.
So question I have in terms of like the influencers that you're working with,
how important is their following size?
Like, does it matter?
Does it not matter if you're just looking for good creative, you're
more looking for people that just have like the aesthetic on their profile
that you matter to your brands on a particular basis, or does their
follower size help?
Yeah, dude, these are spot on questions.
Um, so the answer is no.
Um, so, um, people, we, people think we do like purely influence marketing,
just our company's name is game influence.
Does it make sense?
Uh, that's people think I'm like a influencer media buyer.
Um, I used to do that stuff.
Not quite anymore.
You know, I used to buy, you know, YouTube videos from like David
Dobrik and Mr.
Beast back in like 2018.
That's kind of how I got started this stuff, but, um, yeah, I mean, uh, like
the, no, the controversy, the controversial answer is like influence
marketing, like the way most people do it, like doesn't really work.
Right.
If you're spending, you know, like a $5,000 on like Instagram posts or
Instagram, whatever, Instagram story, YouTube video, whatever your product
costs, $10, you're not going to move 500 units from that post.
Right.
It's ridiculous.
Yeah.
So, um, the, the second thing I tell people is Facebook, Instagram,
TikTok, Snapchat, if you're running on that, like those platforms.
We'll always, always be better at finding your audience than
what you're doing manually.
Right.
What I mean by that is when you're running Facebook ads, that their
algorithm, their ML is going to be better at finding your customer better
than the influencer sharing that on their channel.
And the only people that see that are like her audience, right?
Like it is essentially organic, right?
If you think about it, you know, so the, the, the way to do it is getting
content, um, you know, people who are just really good content creators,
regardless of smaller size, regardless of what their, you know, their account
looks like or their grid looks like their aesthetics, um, if they're good
at making content, they understand your products, they, um, you know, they
look like the audience that you're selling to, right.
If you have that nailed down already, um, you know, that's
really what matters, right.
Um, it, it, it's not, it's not necessarily our, our, one of our
clients right now, you know, supplement company, their best performing
ad is something I shot like myself.
So I literally went downstairs, my lobby added to my life when I shot
something and it outperformed like everything they've ever done, you know,
and that company's been out, it's been around for like four years.
So, um, you know, and like, you know, there's so much like young guys, right.
So, um, so yeah, it's, that's kind of a, that's kind of the key there is
people generally misunderstand.
Influence of marketing thinking is like sponsor pose.
You guys spend a lot of money when in reality, the platform ads would do
better than anything you can ever do.
Yeah, dude, that's awesome.
So in terms of whether someone like wants to work with you or even kind of replicate
a process, you know, that's similar or different for themselves, like what are
the, like the kind of primary steps that someone needs to take, like, do they
just need a product with a label and some branding, do they need a website?
Like for someone to work with you or to do this themselves in house.
What steps would someone need to take just to be ready?
Yeah.
So I would say, um, the, the, the companies we had the most success with
are if you have a niche and offer doubt it, right.
So if you kind of think about the product market fit, like process, right.
Um, I said earlier, you know, company brands come to me thinking I can help
them with acquisition, like at their acquisition channel, um, when that's
like the last thing you should be worrying about, right.
It's important, but it's like the last step in the process, right.
That comes after you have your niche out and you have the problems out
and like what their problem is.
You have, um, like what they call the transformation, right?
Like what is your promise to these, to these customers?
Um, so for skincare, it'd be like before and after, right.
Like removing acne, whatever it might be, um, pricing, right.
Um, that sort of thing.
Like these things all come before, like what, like how do you do
targeting on Facebook ads, right.
Or what channel I should be running on, which is what most of
the things they come to me for.
Um, so I would say someone come to me if you have your niche and if you really
like understand like your customers, what the actual problem, you have all
that dialed in and we can just like skyrocket your growth, that's perfect.
But, but even before that, you know, if you don't quite have that nailed
in and we can, like, I help a lot of companies test, right.
There was a company, you know, I worked with, uh, you know, in the past
few weeks, um, the reason that they thought their customers were buying
from them, we're not the actual reason they're buying, right.
That happens all the time.
They just had a fundamental misunderstanding of the company, of the market.
Right.
So we help them get, uh, you know, help them get, get different
accuratives from different people.
It's, you know, offering, doing different offers.
Um, so testing different offers to different audiences and then eventually
found the one that kind of worked for them.
And then like that was reflected in that good cap, right.
And the growth rate.
So, um, so I would say, you know, both, uh, but preferably if you have like
your niche already dialed in, we can just like make it skyrocket a lot easier.
Awesome.
In terms of like the, the final product, right?
Like the creative that the brand is going to receive to run, uh, or to leverage.
How much of that is like them coming to you after they have some of those
things saying, I want it shot this particular way, and here are some
examples, or how much of that is you saying to them with you and your two team
members, the three of you guys saying, Hey, based off your demo and what we
know, based on other things we've seen or other things that we've shot, you
guys need to do it like this.
How much of it is them coming to you with the vision?
Are you kind of driving the vision with your agency?
Yeah, that's a great question.
Um, I, the number one thing I tell most brands, especially founders who have
like hit it a few times, I mean, like they had an exit before, because then
they think like, they know like everything that like, you know, that that
works, um, it's, you know, I always tell them like first principles, right?
Like you always assume, you know, right.
I've done multiple lifestyle brands.
I've done multiple stuff on brands.
I've done multiple skincare brands and it's different every single
time there is no like one playbook.
If you think about the number of factors, like go into an asset
seating, there's a lot of factors, right?
Um, timing, for example, right?
Like if you're doing, if you're doing like, you know, the thing right now
with the apparel, right, it's the, the, the conventional wisdom is lifestyle.
Right.
That's kind of what works, right.
We just did one with this like handbag company and that wasn't the case, you
know, um, because everyone is running a lifestyle images, right?
Because if you go into any like Facebook ads, um, Facebook group,
right, that's what they tell you, right.
It's, you know, get some, you know, get, get someone to, um, you know, do like
go to brunch, like take a photo of them at brunch with their handbag.
Like, that's kind of what they tell you.
Um, and then a million brands did it doesn't work anymore.
So things are constantly changing.
You've got to always be reiterating.
So, um, so we kind of tell them is, um, you don't know anything.
Number one.
And number two is much more important to, um, build out like a content pipeline.
Um, like focus on the process, not like the actual format.
Right.
So the analogy with investing is, um, don't pick stocks, like put
it in like index fund or something.
Right.
You might not agree with that, but it's, it's kind of what I'm
suggesting for the creative side.
Um, so that you have this like all weather portfolio.
So it doesn't matter if I was 14 comes out, it doesn't
matter these platform changes.
It doesn't matter what happens that are external.
If you have this content pipeline, you can get great content, a larger
value of great content because you have this network of creators built up.
Um, that's kind of what you should be focused on.
Right.
It's much more logistical than like, I'm going to bet on this one thing.
Right.
Which never works because things are constantly changing.
So we do have some best practices.
Um, I always ask them, what are some of the critiques that
performed in the past, just so I can get some insight into
your customer's psychology, right?
Like, oh, this is, this happened because of why.
Right.
So I have something to go off of, but after month through month, month four,
it's, it's pretty much, you know, you're kind of starting from scratch.
Awesome.
And the final question I have, I'm super appreciative of
your time and your insight.
Um, do you, do you ever think about like number of credit needed based off of
number of dollars things spent per month?
So for example, like say someone's going to spend a thousand dollars,
$10,000, $100,000 with the number of creatives, each company, like the
recommendation that you say a thousand dollars, you need X, you know, $10,000.
You need two X.
Like, do you have any framework or any kind of like roadmap that you look
at based off of like spend, or do you not look at it that way?
That's a good, that's a great question.
Um, I typically go off at different assets.
So, um, depending on what you're already doing, like if you're running
ads for like six months, you know, you already have some kind of process going.
Like, it's hard for me to go in there and like scratch everything, start from new.
But, um, yeah, I mean, it's, uh, it's a bit more complicated than that.
Cause there are a lot of brands we work with where like, they're still
testing their offers, for example.
Right.
So they might have like 10 different assets, you know, um, and they're testing
like 20 different offers, whatever it might be.
Right.
So then for each offer, we're like, okay, well month one, let's do three
creatives for this offer, offer a.
And for offer a, um, and then the three, three creatives for that
offer, uh, are three different formats.
So one could be unboxing.
One could be testimonial.
Another one could be lifestyle, whatever it is.
Right.
Got it.
Um, so I think about it more, less about like as a percentage of Aspen, but
more, uh, from a sense of like, what are you trying to do here?
Right.
What is the purpose?
What is the angle, right?
If you're testing offers or you're testing niches or you're testing, uh,
formats, uh, that's ultimately, then you kind of, you can like mathematically
kind of build out this, this framework of, you know, of, of the quantity of
creatives you're going to be testing for each variable.
So that makes sense.
Awesome.
And the last question I actually just thought of, sorry.
Um, with, with all like the iOS 14 stuff and whatnot, as your process and kind
of your thinking change, or is it the same?
Yeah, that's a good question.
Um, the answer is no.
So based on going off of what I said earlier, um, the, the, the angle for most
brands, when you're running Facebook is you want, you don't want to worry about
these kinds of things, right?
Like it's going to affect you obviously, but, um, you, your goal should be to,
like I said, like build out that, what I call it, that all weather portfolio of
creative.
So like that content pipeline, right.
That like, it just kind of, you're just, it just comes in, right.
It comes in, you put on the ads.
Um, you, you know, kind of shut up and noise, um, regardless of what happens.
Um, cause also now it's, you know, your, your ad creatives are ultimately what
determines the performance, right?
It's not really what you're doing, like I'm targeting or whatnot these days,
right.
It's testing copy is testing creative, you know, it's testing your PDP, that
sort of thing.
Um, just all the, you know, the three big components of what a Facebook ad is.
Um, so that's ultimately what determines performance.
So I tell founders, like, don't worry too much about, um, everything else.
Just focus on building that raw content pipeline.
And in the long run, like it will work out.
Sweet.
Josh, appreciate you answering all these questions.
I really appreciate the insight.
Thank you so much for being here.
Best way for someone to follow you, work with you, work for you.
What's the best way for someone to get in touch?
Yeah.
You can drop me a DM on Instagram.
I'm just acting.
I guess I gain influence.
Influence.
That is G A I N F L.
Awesome.
I'll grab that link and I'll drop it below.
Thank you so much for being here.
Yeah, absolutely.
Thanks for that.
All right.
Cheers.
