ERISA Long-Term Disability and Social Security Disability Offsets Explained

Disability Insurance
6 followers
23 Video Views·Sep 17, 2026
When obtaining long-term disability benefits, there will likely be disability offset provisions. You may file claims for both Social Security benefits and for benefits under the long-term disability policies provided by your employer.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAttorney Price McNamara explains the relationship between long-term disability (LTD) insurance and Social Security disability benefits, specifically focusing on how \"offsets\" work. He clarifies that most insurance contracts allow companies to reduce LTD payments by the amount received from Social Security, often leading to unexpected overpayment demands from the insurer.
Hi, I'm Price McNamara. As an ERISA insurance claim attorney, I get lots of questions about
ERISA benefits from clients and other attorneys. One question I get all the time has to do with
the relationship between receiving long-term disability insurance benefits and also at the
same time receiving Social Security disability benefits. Okay, so here's how it works. First,
someone becomes disabled from working. They get a diagnosis of an illness or a horrible injury
that leaves them disabled from working for a long period of time, maybe permanently. Second,
they file a claim for long-term disability through the insurance that they've purchased
through their workplace. Third, they file for Social Security disability insurance because
that's something that they're entitled to from the government if they become disabled from working
for long term. Well, let's suppose that the long-term disability insurance claim gets approved
and the long-term disability insurance company owes you $2,500 a month in long-term disability
benefits. Now, let's say also that your Social Security disability claim gets approved and
Social Security owes you $1,500 per month in benefits. So, you would think in total you're
going to be getting $4,000 per month in benefits if you add those two together. Well, unfortunately,
under the insurance policy, under the long-term disability insurance policy, it doesn't work that
way. Instead, what happens is the long-term disability insurance company comes to you and
says, by the way, now that you've received Social Security disability insurance, we get to offset
that $2,500 that we owe you per month by $1,500. In other words, subtracting it from the $2,500
that we owe you and now you only get $1,000 per month from us, the long-term disability insurance
company. So, why is the insurance company entitled to come to you and say we're going to offset any
amount that we get from Social Security disability? Well, the reason is most insurance policies have
that provision written into them and the insurance policy is really the contract that governs the
relationship between the insured and the insurance company when a disability claim does get filed.
So, it's written in the contract but most people don't realize that it's there at all until after
they become disabled and after they start receiving the long-term disability benefits
and they're told this by the insurance company. So, when do most insureds who are receiving benefits
first hear about this offset right that the long-term disability insurer claims? Well, oftentimes
it's when they receive what's called an overpayment letter in the mail from the disability insurance
company and the overpayment letter will say in effect, hey, we the long-term disability insurance
company have been paying you $2,500 per month for 10 months and we have learned that you've received
Social Security disability payments for those same months in the amount of $1,500. So, we should
have been paying you $1,000 per month which is the $2,500 minus the $1,500 from Social Security
disability but we've paid you too much. Therefore, the amount that we've overpaid you not only are
we going to offset the $1,500 a month for the future payments we make to you but you owe us back
that extra $1,500 a month that we've overpaid you since we didn't realize you were receiving
the Social Security disability. So, that's how Social Security disability offsets work in
connection with long-term disability insurance benefits but everything boils down to what
writes the insurance policy, the contract between you and the long-term disability insurance company
gives to the long-term disability insurance company. Not all policies are written the same.
Sometimes the long-term disability insurance company is telling you that it's entitled to
an offset that it's not entitled to. So, if we can ever take a look at a policy for you,
let you know if any claim for offset or overpayment is correct or incorrect or if
there are errors in the calculations, we'll be happy to have a look at it for you.
So, I hope this was helpful. If we can answer any questions about this topic or really any topic
having to do with a denial of ERISA insurance benefits, give us a call or visit winmybenefits.com
and send me a private message. We'll be happy to help. I'm Price McNamara.
ERISA is all we do. I hope you have a good day.
