Did Mets fans go over the top with Pete Alonso love? | Straight Outta Flushing

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 16, 2026
Pete Alonso hit his 300th home run at Citi Field a place where he's hit a lot of home runs
124 of them actually on Tuesday night against the Mets and this week there's been a lot going
on with his return to Citi Field. I was there for that on Monday and now on Tuesday night
he hit his first home run not as a Met at Citi Field as a member of the Orioles and it was a
historic one 300 right big number he hits that and there's been so much going on and so much
talk about how the fans have reacted to this how the fans have reacted to the whole Pete Alonso
comeback and there is a lot to digest and I think there's a way to talk about this with some nuance
here now Pete Alonso's 300th home run came in the ninth inning of a game the Mets ended up losing
7-5 to the Orioles in extras and his homework ties the game in three came off of Kodai Senga
Mets fans know this well they've seen Pete Alonso hit some late games home runs
none probably more memorable than in 2024 against the Brewers in the playoffs off of Devin Williams
that's the only thing that would have made this more ironic had this come off of Devin Williams
and had it not come off of Kodai Senga but it's a game-tying home run and before we get to that
let's just go back a little bit to Monday night and I talked about this in the episode of Straight
Outta Flushing that I did with my co-host Wardy on the field and we talked about the love that we
saw from Mets fans to Pete Alonso on Monday night we saw it pre-game we saw it during the tribute
video we saw it during his first at-bat we saw fans wanting him to hit this home run right they
wanted to see that Wardy actually went out here predicted that he hit two home runs in the series
well he's got one and there is a segment of the Mets fan base that wants to see Pete Alonso hit
home runs against his former team and they want to celebrate him and all that and I get that
but let's also consider the situation of what happened on Tuesday night again it's the ninth
innings game the Mets are trying to win I understand they already eliminated from playoff
contention not much to play for this has been an underwhelming season for the Metropolitans
in Flushing however when you show up as a fan you're still trying to see your team win at least
that's what I hope that's what I thought I understand you want to celebrate a homegrown guy
who is the franchise's all-time home run leaders and some people have feelings about whether he
should have still been here with the Mets allowed to let go how you feel about David Stearns and
I'll get to that in a second because I think more of this has to do with David Stearns
I get all that but you're still a Mets fan they're rooting for your team to win
my opinion you can't be cheering for the ops to hit a home run that ties the game
in the ninth inning time and situation matters here for me if this was in the sixth inning
and the home run tied the game or took the lead or whatever it might be first inning
fine you want to cheer you want to give him a standing ovation you want to give him a curtain
call which the Mets fans did here but in the ninth inning of a game you're trying to win
that the guys on the team that you're supposedly cheering for are busting their ass trying to win
and you're out there cheering for the ops now I get it you wanted to cheer Pete Alonzo you
want a tribute and give him his props for everything he did for the franchise and there
was a time and place for that and that was Monday night but that passed and now it's over even if
you still wanted to see him hit a home run hit his 300th home run in series I got that that's fine
but standing ovation curtain call in the ninth inning for a game that he tied up that's it's
it's just a bit much from the Mets fan and I think it's deeper than this for the Mets fan I know the
Mets fans gonna say to me Dex we need something to cheer for in this year that's been so disappointing
been frustrated with this franchise we've seen good players come and go I don't have to tell
the much older Mets fans older than me talk to them about June 15th 1977 they know about Tom
Seaver getting traded at a time when he was a three-time Cy Young award winner and how much
that hurt the Mets fan base this is a guy three times Cy Young award winner who led them to a
World Series title in 1969 Mets fans have felt the pain I don't have to tell you about that I
understand that that's fine and you do a pain from this year and I get all that however at some point
you have to comport yourself as a fan base in a franchise that isn't just out here looking for
something anything to hold on to and cheer for but understanding that there's a time and place
and when somebody's the opposition when they're the ops you can't be out there cheering for them
when they hit a game time home run there's got to be a code there has to be a line and where is the
code and it has bothered some of the players Francisco Lindor said on Monday because there
were some Mets fans cheering against Jonah Tong wanting him to give up the home run which was
weird to me as well too and he said they should have been more cheers and more support for Jonah
Tong. Shawn Minaya who pitched on Tuesday and let's give him credit because we always talk about
athletes and wanting athletes to be honest with what they say to the media and how they feel
where Shawn Minaya was honest here he was asked by Steve Gelbs of SNY he was asked how he felt
about the reaction that the Mets fans gave Pete Alonso to that 300th home run it was a game-tying
homer in the ninth inning he said it was kind of crazy Shawn Minaya is right he's right like
think about it for a second for the guys that have the Mets jersey on that are out there busting
their behinds still trying to win games the Mets team has played better since the all-star break
better since the trade deadline you've seen the passion you've seen the enthusiasm hasn't always
led to wins but think about how those guys feel where they feed off the energy we talk about this
all the time in sports they feed off the energy of the fans that come out to support them and I'm
not saying that there's every way to tell fans how to cheer not to cheer because fans pay their
hard-earned money for the tickets and I understand all that I get it you show up you pay your money
you pay for parking the ticket prices all that you want to cheer however you want to cheer but
there's got to be a standard among the Mets fans who are always talking this talk around the Mets
we talk about it on Straight Outta Flushing there's talk about changing the culture what starts
with the fans too starts with the front office but the fans too and the energy they provide
salute Peter Alonso please do that shower him with all the respect and later this week Mets
fans will also salute Carls Beltran who deserves to be showered with all the respect as his number
gets retired on Saturday at Citi Field but there's got to be a standard here I also understand and
this is why it's important to talk about this with nuance and not make this a hot take I understand
that some of the Mets fans you saw this happen over the last two games part of their cheering
for Peter Alonso and putting all this out there is their ire with the president of baseball
operations David Stearns because following that you heard some Fyder Stearns chants you heard it
at different times sprinkled throughout these two games against the Orioles the last couple of days
at Citi Field and listen you want to go there you want to chant Fyder Stearns I get it and
cheer Peter Alonso maybe you feel like that's your way of sticking it to Stearns I say okay
I say okay that's fine but I've been saying this for a while Mets fans if you're really frustrated
if you really don't like the product on the field if you really don't like what happened this year
if you really wanted to stick it to ownership or the front office whatever it may be
the way you do that is by not showing up when you're showing up you're still spending money
for the ticket spending money in the arena in the field Citi Field excuse me that is still a
situation where your dollars are not really backing what your mouth is saying here okay
and I get you want to stick it to David Stearns it's been a rough year some feel that Alonso
should still be here and then he has had a solid season he's now hit his 300th home run
and a special moment for him and I also do want to credit Peter Alonso because Peter Alonso
met with the fans who caught the 300th home run ball three of them after the game and he signed
their jerseys and told them hey anytime they want to come down to Camden Yards to watch him play
he's going to hook them up the whole nine all that great job by Peter Alonso on that and obviously it
was really dope for him to come back to Citi Field and hit his 300th home run so there's a lot around
this the franchise all-time leader in home runs should be honored to such Mets fans though you're
doing a little bit too much with cheering him in the ninth inning of a game he tied are you trying
to win or not at some point you got to make the opposition feel like the opposition it can't be
that comfortable and you wonder how much that continues into this series is every Peter Alonso
hit or home run going to be cheered is there a point where we're just like okay we're done with
the celebration here again I think there's got to be a code there's got to be a line one of my
favorite quotes from my favorite show of all time the wire quote from Bunkmore in there says a man's
got to have a code fans got to have a code too what's the code Mets fans are you just cheering
for anything okay to celebrate Peter Alonso's greatness it was okay to shout him with the love
that he showed the fan a guy who's proud to be a man a guy who clearly did not want to leave
this past offseason it's okay for all that but still got to have the players that are in that
feel like they're supported so when Sean Manias says felt crazy to see Mets fans cheering and
giving the curtain call to somebody who had a game-tying home run again I don't think he's wrong
I understand why he felt that way I understand why he said and I applaud him for saying it
because he's right are you with us are you against us there's a time to show love and
there's a time to get back to rooting for your team and hopefully now with these two
games behind us the Mets fans can get back to rooting for their team
