Hey guys, today I'm here with John and we're gonna be talking about direct response and some
advertorial type stuff. John, welcome. How are you? I'm good, man. Thanks for having me. Yeah,
excited for you to be here. Do you want to start with a quick background on yourself and then kind
of dive into the presentation that you have? Sure. So I'm a copywriter and I've worked with a lot of
direct response companies, both info products as well as physical products. And then lately,
over the last couple of years, I've done a lot of work with a few e-commerce brands and
basically taken some of those ideas from the direct response space and applied them more to
front-end as well as back-end e-commerce. Amazing, man. Well, I'm excited to learn from you. Feel
free to share your screen and hop right in. Yeah, absolutely. Just a second. How about now?
Awesome. Yep, we're here. All right. So the title of this little presentation is Horror
Advertorials and the subtitle is the future of e-commerce front-end funnels. But I've got a
question mark at the end of it. I'm going to show you my arguments and then you can decide whether
that makes sense to you, whether you believe it. So first, I want to draw an analogy between email
marketing, the way that it's being done in e-commerce and front-end funnels, the kind of
stuff that I'm going to be talking about. I think there's a similar path of development and in a
the way that if you could do email marketing really well five years or 10 years ago in the
e-commerce space, I feel like there's a similar opportunity for advertorials today. And as it
keeps developing, as it keeps growing, it's going to stop being as much of an opportunity, but it's
still going to be something very important, just going to be something that you have to do to be
successful. So really quickly, the way that e-commerce email marketing went the way that I
saw it, once upon a time in the prehistoric times, companies weren't sending anything out.
And then 100 years ago, they started realizing that yeah, you can send out coupons and that
can really drive sales. And then eventually, we move into the space where we have complex flows
and you're trying to build a relationship, you're trying to do some marketing and selling
through the emails and even delivering value in the email itself. So rather than just being a very
transactional thing, it's becoming more of a relationship. And I think something similar is
happening on the front-end funnel side. So once upon a time, if people were running ads,
they would send it straight to the offer page and they would say, here's this amazing product,
do you want it? Eventually, 100 years ago again, we figured out that there are all of these pre-sale
pages or there are prelanders, whatever you want to call them, basically some sort of piece of
copy that you put in between the ad and the offer page. And today, the question is, where is that
going and what's happening next? And that's basically what I want to tell you. So my pitch
for where it's going is this thing that we've been doing, which is this idea of horror advertorials.
And I'll tell you exactly what that is, basically dramatic, first-person blog-style advertorials.
A few case studies, I worked with a company that was doing basically dropshipping products
at different times, maybe five to 10 different product funnels. We use the same system on all
of the funnels. And at the high point, we're doing 2000 sales a day using just these advertorials,
driving traffic from Facebook to these advertorials and then to the order pages. And then
even the high point, if the high point was 2000 sales a day, then the standard was somewhere
between 1000 and 1200 sales a day. And that went on for a long, long time.
Also, we did a lot of marketing on the back end to sellers who came in through these funnels.
And we compared, I could see the results of running these kinds of advertorials versus all
the other types of pre-sale pages, advertorials, whatever product pages that we were seeing.
All those other types of pages, at best, we would be getting 1% to 2% conversion rate. With these
kinds of things, we were getting 5% to 10% conversion rate. Some of this was, of course,
because we were getting people who were coming through these funnels and they were probably
reacting to this kind of marketing very well. But I still think that it's another piece of the
evidence to say that there's a lot going for this type of in-between copy. And then one recent
client that I did this for, they were using various kinds of pre-sale pages, advertorials,
kind of content type stuff in-between the ad and in-between the actual order page. And by
squeezing in one of these order advertorials in-between their ad and in-between their product
page, they managed to scale from 2000 a day in ad spend to 12K in profitable daily ads.
So this stuff, again, these are kind of bits and pieces of evidence to prove that this might
actually be worthwhile. Just to show you what I'm talking about, again, this is kind of the typical
funnel. On the left, you have a Facebook ad. On the right, you have some sort of e-commerce product
page, offer page. And in-between is where this advertorial goes. Now, the funnel is very simple
and it's very similar or it's basically the same as every kind of, let's say, modern e-commerce
funnel that is using this kind of in-between piece of copy. But what is different is kind of
the way that the copy is written. And you can see a little bit of a slice of this advertorial,
which is actually that $2,000, $2,000 case study. And what I want to walk you through is how this
copy is different from other stuff you might see online or that you might be running inside
of your own business. So what's different? I thought about it, I looked at it, and I
come up with five elements. None of these is really new in the sense that these are all direct
response fundamentals. If you look at sales letters, at video sales letters, if you look at
good direct response copy, you're going to see a lot of this stuff going on. It's just that
as far as I've seen, most e-commerce brands, even the ones that are running
cold traffic that are running kind of longer or medium-sized copies, they haven't caught
on to all five of these elements. And I feel that you need all five of them to work well,
at least based on what I've seen, A, running a lot of cold traffic to these offers, and B,
sending a lot of back-end traffic to other ones. So element one is that instead of a
kind of a new style article, it's more of a confession style article. So another way to
look at it is that it's third person versus first person. So if you look at this thing on the right,
this is kind of a classic advertorial that you can see online right now. So it's something that
looks like kind of an exciting click-baity article, but it's very third person. There's
nothing personal inside. And if you compare it to this, this is a confessional thing. This was
actually not something that we ran. This appeared on Medium. It was a company. This was not even
an e-commerce brand. I just thought it was a very good example. It was a company that was selling
some sort of software for helping keep your kids safe online. And they had this advertorial,
but it was very kind of provoking and intriguing, and it was written in first person.
Second element is that, you know, rather than focusing on the product, you focus on the
process. And that's a much more polite way of saying that these advertorials tend to be rather
negative, rather than being very optimistic and being very cheery and saying, oh, my God,
I have this incredible product I want to tell you about. So this is basically saying,
you want to focus on the conflict that the prospect is feeling and highlight that.
So again, this is kind of a typical thing you might see. Incredible product. Everybody needs
this. Everybody loves this. Versus how I finally managed to fix my poor turtle-like posture.
So this is very much problem focused. And it's, again, going back to that first one,
it's first person style. Third element is that this is really where the horror advertorials
that I'm talking about separate kind of from the rest of the pack, is that a lot of the
advertorials that I see online, they do a lot of description. So it's a lot of talking about the
problem. It's a lot of talking about the symptoms rather than kind of jumping straight into the
action. So I don't know if you can read this little blurb that I have here, but it's from an
advertorial that's running right now. It's kind of a version of that classic, you know, always a
bridesmaid, but never a bride, because the woman finds out that all these guys don't want to date
her because she actually has bad breath. And this is the intro to the advertorial. It's basically
three paragraphs preparing you for the bad thing to happen. So she's looking to start dating. She's
dating, but it's not working. But there's no story. And then compare this to this other blurb,
which is actually this is something that I wrote. And this was part of an advertorial that ran for
years where we're selling dog seatbelts. And I think we sold, I don't know, maybe around $10
million worth of dog seatbelts using this advertorial. And this thing jumps straight
into the story. So this woman got into an accident. The dog was scared. She was scared. They were
screeching on the concrete, but they were okay because of the dog seatbelt. And then it goes
into the rest of the story. So you jump straight into kind of a scene. And the way that I imagine
it or the way that I think about it when I'm writing these things, think about TV, because
if you look at any kind of a, you know, 28 minute TV show, not going to have a four minute intro
lead in immediately jumps into some sort of scene where you're watching CSI, I'm not even watching
any kind of TV show anymore, immediately jumps into some sort of dramatic scene. And then you
can, you know, once you've kind of hooked people in, then you can take a step back and give them
more of the explanation. This is super critical. And I think this is really kind of what
separates successful stuff from terrible stuff. Terrible stuff has all of the elements that I've
talked about so far, but it is basically made up. So, you know, don't make stuff up or don't
allow your copywriter to make stuff up. David Ogilvie, this famous Madison Avenue advertising
guy, the saying, the customer is not an idiot, she's your wife. And people are not idiots. They
can tell if you're making stuff up. And the example that I have here is this thing that I showed
earlier, which is, if you read this now, I'm not a mom, I don't have a three year old kid.
This looks perfect. This is not, this doesn't sound like it was written by a real mom. And
B, this is not a real problem in the sense that, you know, if you go online, and if you're looking
through forums where moms congregate, there are no anguished articles on vitamins that are
15 grams of sugar instead of 5 grams of sugar. It's not a real problem. Moms are not
complaining about this. And if they are, they're definitely not saying stuff like this. Like,
that's why, as a responsible parent, I do everything I can to make sure my child has a
balanced diet. Parents don't talk about this, right? And then compare this to a little bit of
a slice of this editorial that I showed you at the start, which is selling a very similar product,
the vitamin for kids, the healthy vitamin for kids. This worked really well. Like I said, it
allowed them to scale the offer six times or six over what they were doing before. And this is
basically taken, you know, these are words that these moms were actually using on these moms
forums. And this was to do with a real problem that these moms were seeing. This was a problem
that something, you know, this was something that a woman who has a kid might genuinely stay up at
night and have, you know, nightmares about. So if your kid is having tantrums at the store,
if you can't control your kid, if you feel that, you know, you are a parent who
is failing her kid and you don't know what to do, these are genuine problems. And these are
what these moms are talking about. They're looking for solutions. And if you can have a solution
that in some way legitimately ties into that, the way that, you know, some sort of nutrition
health camp. And if you feed those words back to the audience, it's much, much more powerful,
and it feels real and people get something. And then the final point is that this thing
that I call premature revelation, which is that, again, marketers and copywriters are really,
really eager to talk about their solution, you know. And again, this goes back to not
really understanding the market and not really doing adequate research. And the way that I
this happens is, again, you can have all of the aspects of everything I've talked about
up to this point. But the basic structure of your editorial is I had a problem,
and then I found a solution. And it's amazing. Now, let me tell you that, right. And lots of
times when people are reading copy, they're not convinced they haven't been sold yet,
just because you haven't kind of paced their experience adequately. And because they're
not emotionally invested. And the way that I compare it to, you know, structure creates intrigue
and demand and kind of this emotional involvement. And if you think about Dr. House, Dr. House,
the TV show has a super predictable structure. Every episode follows the same structure.
And you want something similar in your editorial. So rather than saying I had a problem,
then I found the solution had a problem. It was bad, but then things got worse.
And then you tried everything because you knew that you had to fix the problem,
except that nothing was helping. And then all the stuff was bad. And then of course,
there's a magical random encounter, once in a lifetime thing with a person who could potentially
help you. And they tell you about something, except that it's still not the thing that helps.
And there's a new letdown because you expect them to help. And it's not that. And then you're
getting deeper and deeper. And eventually, you know, your back is against the wall, you maybe
go back to that recommendation, you got that magical one time encounter, you order the product,
maybe the first impressions are, you're still skeptical, and the first impressions are a
little bit shaky, but you give it a try. And then finally, there's a glimmer of hope. And you know,
you get into the solution where, yes, it worked out. And now let me tell you why after this entire,
you know, trials and tribulations and trip up the mountain. So that's basically a recap is
first person problem focused, so rather negative and focused on the problem,
starting out with a dramatic snapshot, in their own words, and not made up stuff and full of
twists and turns that keeps people emotionally engaged. And that's basically all I want to share
except two final points, which is that the brand impact of this, I personally, I worked with these
guys who are doing drop shipping, they weren't concerned at all about their brand. We were not
getting any kind of blowback from the marketplace about these advertorials. But I always felt that
it was kind of this thing that, you know, companies do, if they're really comfortable doing direct
response marketing, if they're not super concerned about building their brand first. But again,
recently, I've had some experience working with companies that have a very clean brand that have
kind of a very good relationship with their brand. And they ran this kind of same kind of thing,
the one that I showed you at the start. And here's some of the comments from
the actual ad that was driving people to that editorial. And, you know, universally, they were
either generic Facebook, Facebook comments saying, interestingly, whatever, you should see this,
or, you know, a few of them were, okay, this was really cool information, can I find out more and
so on. So there was, there was no, there was no blowback in terms of people saying, you know,
I can't believe that you're running this kind of overly dramatic copy that is not talking about
the product, but it's trying to, you know, manipulate people by talking about the problems.
And so to wrap it up, so this, I think, one way or another, I think is going to be the future of
ecommerce in terms of acquisition campaigns in the front end. And again, to kind of wrap up that
ecommerce to, I mean, sorry, the email to the front end funnel analogy, you know, if you go,
if you went back maybe 10 years, you had a lot of smaller companies who were just selling products.
And if you told them, you know, you should run email campaigns, you should send emails
regularly to people who sign up, you should maybe even email daily, or at least, you know,
regularly, people would say, who wants to hear from a company that is selling, I don't know,
dog secrets. And it turns out that a lot of people do want to hear from a company if you're offering
valuable information, if you are helping them out, if you're creating some sort of
connection and relationship. And similar thing, I think, with these front end funnels. So,
you know, who wants to read dramatic stories about their own problems? And again, it turns
out a lot of people do, it works really well. And I think, you know, again, this is my argument that
either this or some sort of proven thing that's already proven itself in kind of the direct
response space in the very competitive niches, you know, the sales letters and the VSLs that are
running hyper competitive loss type stuff, or make money online stuff. You don't want to have
necessarily those kinds of customers, you don't want to have those ads. But a lot of those ideas
are really good. And I think a lot of them will come to the account. So that's, that's basically
it. Dude, this was fantastic. I'm super intrigued. This is super interesting. I can't wait to
actually get this interview live. So thank you so much for being here. This was awesome. I had
no idea what to expect. And you crushed it. So thank you. Best way or ways for people to
find you online? How can people get in touch? How can people follow your journey?
Yeah, absolutely. So if you want to follow or basically I have an email newsletter,
and that's pretty much the only way you can follow what I'm doing. So if you go to
beyakovich.com, my last name, if you find it on the interview, find my last name,
type in .com after that. And you'll find my blog, you'll find a place to opt into my newsletter.
I have probably 900 or so like blog posts on there. I'm writing a lot. And if you want to
read more about ecommerce direct response marketing, you'll find a lot of stuff.
Sweet. I'll drop a link below. John, thank you so much, man.
Absolutely. Thanks a lot for the interview. It was great.
Of course. Cheers.
Thanks.