The Congressional-Executive Commission on China holds a hearing at 9:30 ET on Sept. 16 titled “A Son and Daughter’s Appeal to Xi Jinping to Release Their Dad, Jimmy Lai.” The hearing examines the imprisonment of Hong Kong media entrepreneur and democracy advocate Jimmy Lai and issues involving press freedom, judicial independence, and the rule of law in Hong Kong.
Witnesses: Sebastien Lai—son of Jimmy Lai; leader, #FreeJimmyLai campaign Mark L. Clifford—president, Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation; author of “The Troublemaker,” a biography of Jimmy Lai
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This hearing serves as an urgent appeal for the humanitarian release of Jimmy Lai, the 78-year-old founder of *Apple Daily* and pro-democracy advocate. Currently serving a 20-year sentence in Hong Kong, Lai's release is sought on compassionate grounds so he may support his daughter, Claire, who is battling aggressive cancer.
The Commission will come to order and first of all, I want to thank our very distinguished witnesses for being here
And I do want to thank C-SPAN for being here
You know
They have the sole authority to pick what they cover when they cover it and they have been kind enough
And gracious enough to come here today because they want to hear especially from you Sebastian on behalf of your father
But also from our other very distinguished witnesses, so thank you to them
For getting this message out to the American public
Especially in this very timely fashion on the eve of the summit with President Trump and Xi Jinping
Today's hearing is about Jimmy Lai and an earnest appeal to Xi Jinping from Jimmy's children to set him free
on humanitarian grounds
They are grateful, the family, that President Trump has personally raised Jimmy Lai's release with Xi Jinping and they respectfully
Asked him to do so again at the upcoming summit
We will hear directly from Jimmy Lai's son Sebastian speaking for himself and on behalf of his sister Claire
Who was initially scheduled to join her brother today?
Sadly Claire was recently diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and has begun treatment. We are thinking of her
We are praying for her and wishing her a full recovery
Sebastian who has been tenacious on behalf of his dad
testified on behalf of his father back in
2023 and he will momentarily speak to us again. He said and I say in part
Quote my father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from a maximum security prison
He cannot hold her hand
She wants nothing more than have him with her for this fight
We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her and
For a 78 year old man who has already suffered enough
Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment
Jimmy Lai is 78 years old as we all know he has spent six years in detention in February a Hong Kong court
Sentenced him to 20 years in prison
Following his conviction under the national security law. It was the longest sentence thus far imposed under that law
for a man of Jimmy Lai's age and given the seriousness of his health concerns a
20 year sentence carries an obvious and deeply troubling
humanitarian consequence
His son Sebastian has described it as a death sentence
And that is why time matters
Jimmy Lai is not being in prison because he committed any act of violence whatsoever
His son has emphasized that his father has never never advocated violence
Rather Jimmy Lai used his voice his newspaper and his public platform to support freedom and democracy
As we all know he founded Apple Daily a newspaper that
Became one of the Hong Kong's most prominent pro-democracy
Publications the newspaper was forced to close in 2021 after authorities arrested its senior executives and froze its assets
Jimmy Lai himself was arrested in August of 2020 and
subsequently prosecuted
under Hong Kong's national security law
His case therefore raises fundamental questions about the meaning of freedom of expression and freedom of the press in Hong Kong today
It also raises very serious questions about the rule of law
Hong Kong was promised a high degree of autonomy autonomy and
Preservation of its existing legal and social systems under the one country two systems framework matter of fact in the Sino-UK
Agreement they promised for 50 years that the basic law would remain in
Effect and the basic law looks a lot like our own Bill of Rights. It's an amazing law and the
British were able to come to an agreement when they handed over Hong Kong that all of these protections would be preserved for at least
50 years
It's not 50 years
unfortunately, our Commission has
Investigated this very very vigorously the Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act, which I sponsored
Scott Flipsy we introduced it in
2014 as the umbrella revolution was taking hold and five years later or so it became law
Marco Rubio played a key role on the Senate side
We did it on the House side and it's the law and it recognizes that yes
We want that special character of Hong Kong
I'm surprised Xi Jinping doesn't see that this is in his own interest in terms of economics
But they are choosing a different path
regrettably
Jimmy Lai's case is an embodiment
Embodiment of what has happened to so many of the best and the brightest in Hong Kong
Joshua Wong and all of these other great people who and I've met with him. He's he's now
Going to be sentenced and very severely
So what an amazing guy as are these others who just say in a nonviolent way? We want freedom democracy
For Hong Kong and we want it for all of China really but Hong Kong. Let's start there
So it's it's very very troubling
This is all about whether or not journalists can report freely when the government can shut down a newspaper and prosecute its publisher
It's about whether a society can retain meaningful freedom of speech when criticizing those in power and becomes a national security offense
It's about whether courts can remain generally independent and so-called national security laws are used against political opponents and
Critics and it's about whether the promises made again to the people of Hong Kong will have meaning
You should also remember the human dimension of this case for more than five years
Jimmy lies children have had to live with the reality that their father is in prison thousands and thousands of miles away
Sebastian has spoken publicly and with great eloquence and grace about his father
I mean what what a chip off the old block, you know
The love and the compassion that he shows for his dad and the same goes for grace
So my hope our hope as a commission the Congress hope because we've passed a resolution
Calling for his release is that Xi Jinping will see clear to do it when he meets with our president
Claire has spoken about her father's deteriorating health as well and
The increasingly limited information about his medical condition Claire has also spoken about something I think is so important to understand
About his faith his faith in God. He's a Catholic
She said that her father is not in prison because he's a Catholic
But that his father has been a major that his faith has been a major source of his courage
That he has shown throughout this ordeal
She gave me a print of a wonderful picture that he painted
Drew of Our Lady and it's hanging very prominently in my office and every day that I see it
I think and pray for his release
The combination of faith and courage is part of Jimmy Lai's story and should not be left out
And why why do they persecute someone because they believe in the Almighty it's just too much
Yesterday senator Sullivan who is the chair?
I'm co-chair of this Commission and he's a great great senator and cares deeply about Jimmy Lai
We introduced the Hong Kong political prisoner accountability act of 2026 to establish a clear framework for accountability if Hong Kong
Political prisoners were to die in custody as a result of inadequate medical care abuse inhumane conditions or other
actions or omissions by detaining
authorities
Who can forget the Nobel Peace Prize winner who suffered so horribly from cancer?
And and couldn't even go and receive his Nobel Peace Prize
And died in prison. Well, we need to we need to work on that really really strong
So I want to just again thank our without objection my full statement will be made a part of the record
But I want to thank again our witnesses and I would like to introduce our panel. We are joined first by
Sebastian Lai
Who leads the international campaign to secure the release of his father Jimmy Lai Sebastian has worked?
tirelessly to ensure that his father's case remains a priority for the government's and includes the UK government because he is a UK citizen and
Legislatures around the world. He is no stranger to this Commission
As I said, he testified with great eloquence and compassion in 2023 and we welcomed him back today
We will also hear from mr. Steve Yates. Thank you. Mr
It's for being here senior research fellow for China and national security and policy and Chung
You young fellow at the heritage foundation. Mr. Yates brings decades of experience in national security and China policy
Including service in the White House as a senior national security adviser to Vice President Dick Cheney and as president of Radio Free Asia
He will also help us consider how the u.s
Can use diplomacy and other policy tools to press for Jimmy Lai's release and hold Beijing and Hong Kong authorities
Accountable and then we'll hear and we welcome. Dr. Mark Clifford president of the Committee for Freedom in Hong Kong
Foundation and author of the troublemaker his biography of Jimmy Lai
Dr. Clifford knows him Jimmy personally and has served as director of the next digital
Publisher of the Apple Daily when Hong Kong authorities forced the newspaper to close
He brings both a personal understanding of Jimmy Lai's story and deep experience in Hong Kong journalism press freedom in the rule of law
So I would like to turn the floor to you. Mr. Lai for such time as you make him
Thank You co-chairman Smith and as well as the members of this Commission in terms who have been
my
As you mentioned my sister Claire was to testify besides me today a few weeks ago. She was diagnosed with cancer. I
Was with her in London last week as she began chemotherapy
My father learned of his own daughter's diagnosis from Maximum Security Prison. He can't hold her hand
He wants nothing more than to have him with her for this fight
We hope the Chinese authorities will consider what compassionate release would mean for her and for a 78 year old man
Who has already suffered enough? I?
Want to thank America President Trump who has been a true champion of my father's
His administration and the senators and members of both parties whose support has never wavered and only gotten stronger
This is moral courage and my family does not take it for granted
By the end of this year, my father will have spent six years in the maximum security prison in solitary at 78
He is the oldest political prisoner in Hong Kong with his 20-year sentence looming over him
If he's not freed soon, he will most likely die in prison
But the real question is for what?
Three times in his life. My father has already paid dearly for freedom
The first time it cost him his childhood
He was a porter at the Guangzhou railway station when a traveler from Hong Kong tipped him a bar of chocolate
He figured that if this came from Hong Kong Hong Kong must be heaven
At 12, he hid in the bottom of a fishing boat to get there and for the first time in his life
He tasted freedom
The second time it cost him what many thought was his life's work
He started on a factory floor and ended up with a clothing empire then came gentleman
My father wrote that what he thought of the man who ordered the massacre and
Beijing gave him a simple choice your stores on the mainland or your conscience
He saw the company walking away from the largest market on earth and built a newspaper instead on the principle that information is choice
And choice is freedom
It's first editorial asked are we not afraid of
1997 of the handover, of course we are but we refuse to be intimidated by fear
The third time it cost him everything in
2010-20 the national security law was imposed in Hong Kong by the Chinese government
criminalizing overnight any form of democratic expressions
Past and present so six years after that fishing boat. My father again faced the decision
He faced as a boy to stay or to run
Only now he had far more to lose by staying and far more to protect
He stayed for our beliefs and he stayed to protect others
That is the man they have in prison
What happens now is no longer a test of my father's courage. It is a test of ours
America understands in his bones that freedom dies with the last man willing to defend it and
That the cost of not standing up for liberty is not felt until it is too late
In my father this nation has found a kindred spirit a week from now president. Xi will be a guest in this city
Our appeal to him is simple. My father poses no threat
His imprisonment makes him a symbol of injustice. His death in prison would be a disgrace
Let Jimmy Lai come home to his family and let him sit beside his daughter in her hardest moment
very very much
Sebastian for that testimony and for the appeal that we hope will be heard at the White House as
well as in Beijing and
If anyone can persuade
Both parties and I know the president will raise it
And again having a guy like Marco Rubio who used to co-chair this Commission, you know
He gets it a hundred percent. I know it will be elevated
And again, your voice will be heard. I'd like to now yield
Let me just a comment very briefly where Joey today by Paul protect
Paul is in the back wall was the chief of staff for the
China Commission for years
Who also did that great job and he continues to do that work on the other Commission and we want to thank him for his
leadership
Bipartisan working for Nancy Pelosi for so many years. And of course, the whole product had worked on my behalf
Thank you very much
Chairman distinguished members of the Commission, especially to Sebastian for his personal witness
Son's testimony for his father is an incredibly powerful witness
Hope that humbly I can make a small contribution to talk a bit about the man
About the policy history and about the summit. I'll try to be brief
My name is Steve Yates. I serve a senior research fellow for China and national security at the Heritage Foundation
I appear in my personal capacity and the views expressed are my own
First the man China cannot abide
I first met Jimmy Lai in the late 1990s as a young policy analyst
In the period immediately following Hong Kong's transfer from British to Chinese sovereignty in the years that followed
I was privileged to meet him at his home in Hong Kong in Taiwan and during visits to the United States
Conversations with Jimmy always combined substance and character. They ranged across his extraordinary personal journey in business and public life
faith
China's evolution under the Communist Party of China
Hong Kong's historic role at the intersection of opportunity and control
He rose from poverty as a migrant child to great success twice
Entirely different and highly competitive industries. I've never met anyone like that
He carried a deep and visceral identification with the hardships borne by Chinese people under the party's economic and political policies
As documentaries before his imprisonment make plain
He has a heartfelt desire for the genuine liberation of the Chinese people to fulfill their potential
The truth is Jimmy Lai is the highest profile political prisoner in party custody not because of what he has done
But because of who he is
He represents a form of genuine Chinese identity
The party cannot abide a citizen who lifted himself and many others from poverty to success
Entirely outside the political patronage system a citizen who places his faith and his fellow man above the party in
That vision that is widely shared by traditional Chinese families
the foundations of America's approach to Hong Kong rests on a series of geopolitical wagers the opening of China and after the Cultural
Revolution the promises of reform and opening in the Deng Xiaoping era the sunset of the British Empire
Marked by the Sino-British Joint Declaration and the post-cold war conviction that engagement and integration would bring China into alignment
with widely held international norms
The promises of one country two systems the and eventual universal suffrage enshrined in Hong Kong's basic law
rest on those wagers
Many including me held those assumptions in good faith the evidence from the 1990s to the present argues
overwhelmingly against their wisdom
Reality intervened
original policy assumptions premised on Hong Kong's high degree of autonomy within the People's Republic
Have given way to the need to treat Hong Kong as one country one system
Unfortunately, the Sino-British Joint Declaration is now treated as an historic artifact in practice. The international covenants are disregarded
Appeals to or by international institutions or Great Britain have minimal effect at this stage
Congress with the support of the executive branch have made a meaningful adjustment in Hong Kong policy with the Hong Kong Human Rights Democracy Act
and the Hong Kong Autonomy Act
Together those statutes included a range of penalties for those who undermined the commitments of the Joint Declaration of the basic law
President Trump has twice raised the case directly with Xi Jinping
Appealing for his release citing mr.
Lai's age and health after a long trial and suggesting that a release would serve bilateral relations in China's standing. I
Believe the president was moved to raise this case by Jimmy Lai's extraordinary life
And still more by the absolute devotion of Jimmy's children in making the case for their father's release
That case is more compelling today with Claire Lai having shared her cancer diagnosis publicly
As a father who held his daughter's hand through the truly terrible circumstances and ultimately lost her
I can attest there has been no greater pain in my life
Not being permitted to hold her hand through those times would have been unimaginably worse
She didn't ping China should not be making a dying man and a daughter confronting grave illness
Endure additional cruelty in the service of a political trophy
This is no longer principally an appeal to law foreign or domestic
It is a litmus test of whether there remains any reason to believe
There is a future in Xi Jinping's China for the kind of man that Jimmy Lai is a
Child of God a lover of the real China and one of China's greatest entrepreneurs
The loss of that hope is what broke the wagers on which policy was founded
this may be one of the last tests of whether that break is a temporary defect or an enduring feature of the system a
Release would not restore in 1997. It would not revive the Apple Daily
It would tell the world it would tell President Trump the chairman she can still choose mercy when the world is watching
That is a signal about leadership
It is a signal about whether any understanding with this counterpart is worth the paper on which it is written. Thank you. Mr. Chairman
Well, thank you very much co-chair Smith
I also want to thank the honorable members of the Commission for the opportunity to testify today
And above all for your support for Jimmy Lai in the cause of Hong Kong freedom
now when President Trump hosts
Chinese Communist Party General Secretary Xi Jinping next week
The general secretary is expected to bring along a large entourage of business leaders
But it's ironic that perhaps the greatest business entrepreneur that we've seen
In the post-war period Jimmy Lai will be sitting in solitary confinement. He won't be joining President Xi
He won't be helping
develop China's economy
he won't be creating the thousands of jobs the
millions of dollars of wealth that he previously created and I think that's that's very telling that
Xi Jinping would rather have one of the greatest businessmen of his generation in jail than helping develop the country
now
my
Predecessors on the on this panel have talked about how Jimmy's in prisons the story of freedom in Hong Kong
How freedom was crushed as China broke its promises to the people of Hong Kong and to the world
But I think it's it's important to underscore that it wasn't just the existing way of life
Hong Kong people were to throw off the colonial yoke after after Britain left. They were to be masters of their own house
They would have universal suffrage as it was mentioned before and Jimmy is in jail
Because he wanted to hold China to these promises
so I'm proud to have known Jimmy since 1993 and as
Co-chairman Smith mentioned I served on the board of directors of his media company
And I was there as the the government crushed illegally crushed the company
I think it's important to put Jimmy in a historical context. He's a man. He's a father
He's a fantastic host. He's a wonderful person. He's he is one-of-a-kind
None of us will ever meet anybody else like Jimmy, but he's unique in Chinese history
Few people of course have had the courage to stand up against the Chinese Communist Party
One of those who did you co-chairman Smith you mentioned Nobel Peace Prize winner Liu Xiaobo
made the ultimate sacrifice paying for his principles with his life dying while in Chinese custody and
This we're here today because this may be our best last chance to ensure that Jimmy doesn't suffer the same fate
Jimmy is unique in that he has principles that he's willing to sacrifice for them and
of course he had he had financial resources, and he had a media empire which
the the party found
Intolerable and Jimmy knew what he was doing
I remember seeing him on the stage of the Grand Hyatt Hotel in June
1997 a few weeks before the handover
Where Al Newhart founder of USA Today did a session with him and asked him about what would happen after the handover and Jimmy?
Started crying, and he's a very emotional guy
But still to be crying on stage in front of a packed ballroom of 500 or so people
And he said he expected to go to jail so Jimmy knew what he was up against as
Some of the previous speakers mentioned he came out of absolute poverty. He came out of famine
He left China at a time when?
45 million people or so were dying during the so-called Great Leap Forward so Jimmy knew what he was up against and yet
for decades
He he kept fighting. He gave up his meat his
Clothing empire to invest more heavily into media
But it's also important to remember and it really shows us
I think the cruelty of the Chinese Communist Party to remember that not only was Jimmy non-violent
Not only did he always eschew the the violence that?
Sometimes broke out on the streets of Hong Kong, but he has no personal political ambitions
We're not talking about someone who would be the next Nelson Mandela or the next Navalny
We're talking about a man who believes in freedom who wants to be reunited with his family with his daughter
With his son actually with with all of his children and enjoy the last years of his life
I
Think it's important to remember how singular he is in
embodying both free markets and the freedom that we think of
Civil liberties free speech freedom of worship and of course President Trump has been a terrific supporter
He promised two years ago on the campaign trail that he'd free Jimmy
He said it would be very easy. Of course. It hasn't proven to be so that's nothing to do with President Trump
That's to do with General Secretary Xi Jinping
now
President Trump, I hope should realize that he can and
Should and must I would I would argue
Free Jimmy lie
It would help cement his reputation as someone who's able to do the hard deals to get people out of prisons in
Unimaginably dark places. He has a terrific record on this almost unparalleled
I do think Jimmy is a very very tough case and we can only hope that the the
President continues to to push ahead
I also want to underscore so one of the points that was made about Jimmy's relation with with America
He is in jail
mostly because he believes in
American values American
Principles and because he had the temerity in the eyes of the Chinese Communist Party to come and meet with officials in
Washington with some of the people in this room back in
2019 and that was seen as collusion with foreign forces
I think that's that's arguable under any kind of international or any kind of common law
Jimmy is not in jail legally, but he is in in jail because he believed that the United States
Embodied the sorts of values that Jimmy embodies
So of course while this hearing focuses on Jimmy
I just like to to finish by reminding people that Jimmy is just one of hundreds of political prisoners being held
in often appalling conditions
Key members of the Hong Kong Alliance Chow Hung-tung, Li Chuk-yan, Albert Ho have just last week
been sentenced
For using the phrase end party end one party rule
Act student activist Joshua Wong who co-chairman Smith
Mentioned is about to be sentenced
under more bogus charges
Hong Kong's prisons as my colleague Francis Hoi behind me and other colleagues have
Recently revealed remain dangerously overcrowded intensely surveilled and
structurally abusive
We did a report on this a year ago
Francis and the team came out with an update earlier this week and among other shocking findings
Found that guards in Stanley prison are rehearsing are doing mock drills for what to do
If and when Jimmy Lai dies in prison
I mean, this should be a real clear warning sign to all of us that we their time is running out
In closing, I'd like to emphasize the release of Jimmy Lai would be something President Trump Republicans and Democrats
Indeed freedom-loving people around the world would applaud
It would be a unifying event at the time when the world really needs it
Of course, I'd be happy to answer any questions particularly about recommendations for congressional executive action to help Jimmy Lai
But I would like to thank you for introducing the Jimmy Lai accountability act
I think that will go a long way towards letting the Chinese know that there will be consequences if their
Repression of Hong Kong and of Jimmy in particular continues. Thank you
Thank you very much for your testimony your recommendations. The legislation has been introduced by both of us
Senator Sullivan and I it's bipartisan as it should be as this whole effort has been to say that you know
There's not much that unites us here on Capitol Hill these days
the cause of Jimmy Lai and the cause of human rights and democracy in Hong Kong and in China mainland China does and
And I think that speaks a lot about you know, how?
Why don't you care? I mean, it's it's really important. You know, I I've chaired 107
This is the 108th hearing on human rights abuses in China
Like Marco Rubio and a few others. I can't go there anymore. I want to go. I don't want to go badly
To talk to people there talk to officials and it occurred to me while you're talking. Dr. Clifford that the
Xi Jinping himself is violating the national security law by collaborating and meeting with President Trump
I mean it shows you the the
Foolishness of a law that says mere contact is actionable under that egregious law and you know
When they were making a deal
They'll talk
Day and night when you're talking about respecting the dignity of their own people
And that you know, we we care about their people
We want the people of China to flourish and to thrive and we want the Chinese Communist Party to recognize
They have responsibility. These are universally recognized human rights
These are not something that we just came up and you know
Distilled the night somewhere in Congress or at the White House. These are universally recognized human rights
And again, I hope that Xi Jinping realizes that when they break as they have
The Sino UK agreement that's a treaty and you promised and if you don't honor that treaty
Why should we have any?
Anticipation and and hope that you'll honor other treaties. So it's it's a very serious
You know, it brings I think and with all due respect dishonor
To the government of China. We we want them to matriculate to be more of a democracy and that can happen
Cumulus case is one of and that's why this is an appeal
What we're doing today is saying we're appealing based on on the humanitarian issue of a man
Who is very very elderly 78 has a number of problems illnesses that need to be addressed
And now added to that and as you said, so eloquently
Mr. Needs when you talked about now as a father was held his daughter's hand through truly terrible circumstances and ultimately lost her
I can attest and that you of course just a moment ago
That there has been no greater trial in my life not being permitted to hold her hand through those times would have been
unimaginably worse
Xi Jinping's China should not make a dying man and daughter confronting a grave illness
Endure that additional cruelty in the service of a political
trophy
So well said and just right from the heart and you said it too as well Sebastian. So I
Asked you, you know if you wanted to elaborate especially on follow-up, dr. Clifford again
We do have this bill which we will push very hard to try to get enacted into law, but the other Chinese government, you know
Someday people are gonna look back in China and say
What did Xi Jinping do?
You know, why did why did he do so many things that he does especially to a man like Jimmy Lai?
I mean, he is a icon of goodness
And and to get a trophy of a political prisoner
Who's he trying to impress, you know fellow communist leaders or what?
So maybe you want to speak to some of those consequences
That you think we should follow up with
Well, thank you very much co-chair Smith
I would just like to add that the administration has not only sent the wrong signals
But seems to be being played by the Chinese. So first of all in July we
We let the national emergency
Under an executive order expire which meant that nine Hong Kong officials nine Hong Kong and Chinese officials who have been sanctioned
Were no longer on the sanctions list include including the Secretary for Justice
Who I see has just been invited to a closed-door session with the American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong
So these guys are out of the box. We have to start holding
Chinese and Hong Kong human rights abusers personally
responsible and I think the an indication of the
I know it's the temerity or the freedom with which China thinks it can act came last Friday
I mentioned the Chow Hong Tong and the other members of the Hong Kong Alliance were just sentenced
This is on the eve of Xi Jinping's state visit to the u.s
They didn't even have the decency to come and go and wait until the the general secretary was back in China
At least the hapless Keir Starmer when he was prime minister
They gave him they humiliated him in Beijing in many respects
But they gave him the the face of waiting until he'd been back nine or ten days before they sentenced Jimmy
So to sentence the Hong Kong Alliance people on the eve of this trip to me looks like a slap in the face the administration
So I think until you start we start holding the Chinese accountable personally
But I would also say through through economic and other measures accountable. There's not going to be any change. They feel
Increasingly emboldened and I think the entire world should be worried not just Jimmy Jimmy Lai's
Family and those of us who know and love him, but really the entire world because China thinks that it can act with impunity
On the issue of the business community
One of the biggest disappointments I and others have had over the years has been their unwillingness to
To speak out with even a less than bold voice on behalf of human rights in China and Hong Kong
I remember in the early 1990s when we were arguing MFN and human rights linkage
the administration then under
Bill Clinton actually had
butcher of Beijing come and
hosted at the
Mid-90s at the White House, you know, he's a guy that ordered the
tanks
Chatien was his name, but I met with the Chamber of Commerce in the early 1990s when we this battle and MFN was surging and
I said
You guys can make the biggest difference in the world
There's a two-hour meeting it was the Beijing US Chamber of Commerce in Beijing
And they were just touting the talking points from the Chinese Communist Party, and it was very disturbing
They even told me the religious freedom was flourishing and I said where?
You know, that's not what I hear and that's what you know, I meet with people who suffer for their faith
Is the communist model we saw it the Soviet Union we saw it in Romania we saw it in these block countries
We see it everywhere North Korea. So what are you talking about? So I
If somehow we could get them engaged
The acid the summit that was held in San Francisco was another opportunity for the business community to really assert themselves
They ought to be speaking now about Jimmy Lai, you know, the Chamber of Commerce should put out a strong statement
Let this great man go
For humanitarian purposes, let him go. So I
Remember leaving that there was one very lonely
human rights officer from the State Department at that meeting and about five people from the
from the economics
Section who kept telling me how wrong I was that we ought to link
Genuinely link human rights with trade and if they don't
achieve
Significant progress and we had the votes, you know people forget this we had the votes again. It was bipartisan
I've worked with Nancy Pelosi and Frank Wolf
we had the votes to truly take away MFN unless there was serious and significant progress and and I wrote an op-ed for the
Wall Street Journal on this and it's like Bill Clinton said give me a year
Executive order a great executive order
You know, and I think that was the business community again that said somehow they'll again matriculate from from a dictatorship in the democracy
We just trade more now
I think the the onus is on the business community and right now they can speak out on behalf of
Give me lie on the eve of the summit. So we we appeal to the business community
You know the next deal. Okay, but how about
Saying this great man should be free and to join his son and daughter
so next steps or anything you think we should be doing on this and again, my colleagues are
Really in accord. I mean the Democrat and Republican problem. If this is the last day of a session
We didn't know that was going to be the case when we set this up. So, you know, there's a lot of people on the floor
doing
For speeches with with bills and all
This is the last day maybe tomorrow, but before the midterms we're supposed to have two more weeks
So I I just say that as to why some of the members that care deeply are not here today like Molinari
the China
Select committee, you know, he sends his best to you. So anything else you like
Well, I I would just try to punctuate
That many of us have lived through this
Narrative that held out the prospect of what China is how it can be engaged and what would lead to meaningful change
I would like to appeal to the businessman and President Trump's mind
That no businessman goes into successive meetings without having an accounting of what was discussed in the first and the second meeting
What are the measurable?
changes that occurred
what was promised what was delivered and you wouldn't have a succession of
three four or five meetings without holding yourself and your counterpart accountable for I
Came and this is what I promised and this is what I did you came. This is what you promised
And this is what you did
There's a broad menu and I would make no bones about it having worked for presidents and vice presidents
There's a full menu and China has made the menu more full by helping fuel the Russian war machine by making the Iran situation
more difficult
Fentanyl still comes into our country. There are a lot of issues and some some might say well
why this I would say why this because all other avenues are
Exhausted we are at I think a true threshold point of trying to decide
What exactly is the kind of country and leader?
We're having to deal with and what can I reasonably expect in return for engaging you?
We showered you with wealth
Technology access and opportunity to the point where the only sentient thing you had to do was say yes
They did nothing to lift people out of poverty
we did that and
They didn't even give a thank you in return. They took more and
We are now at a point where we opened up trade
We opened up access to our universities. We opened opened up wide-ranging
Engagement and are we safer?
Are they more responsible is the world better off?
with this arrangement oddly now the world is more dependent on the
unreformed regime and so why this now I think we're left with an acid test example of
If you don't have within your system or within your character as a leader
to give a humanitarian release
to one of
your citizens
Supposedly, I think that's ambiguous
But one of the people in your party's custody
To go through this dark period where you can no reason of no reasonable person could say he poses a threat at this point if you
Can't do that
Then there is no reason to believe there will be a deliverable on a trade negotiation
on
easing the
support for murder against innocent Ukrainians or
Innocent people in the Middle East or innocent Americans
Who have been protected from the flood of fentanyl largely by what we've done on our southern border
Enforcement on the high seas and other areas and with treatment against overdoses
It is not because the Chinese have shut down more factories
And so if if if the reason why this why now is because we've tried these other baskets
We've linked human rights we've unlinked human rights we've come into the WTO we've engaged
We've had broad trade agreements. We lived through kovat and haven't really held you accountable and
Still we ask what can we expect in return and I think at this point
This president the businessman and the one who the only one who has really raised this
Sole case at the absolute highest level
This is the last test of what America and maybe the world can reasonably expect from Xi Jinping's China
That's why I think this matters and I think it's even more crystal clear in
2026 than the debates we lived through in the 1990s about whether to link human rights and democracy whether to have normal trade relations
All of those things now, we've been mugged by reality for a generation and this is where we are this asset test
So that would be my humble appeal to everyone in the Commission
And those that used to be on the Commission who now may have the president's here
Thank you
At the risk of going slightly outside this Commission's remit I would like to underscore what mr.
Yates said
Hong Kong is and the world's most important node for ensuring that military
Technology gets into the Russian war machine and the Iranian war machine again
Xi Jinping could shut this down tomorrow
I think it's very important to remember that during this period of engagement during everything that has
Happened during these last three or four decades. We've helped bring China into the world economy
We've seen things ranging from Jimmy Lai's
Imprisonment the imprisonment of hundreds of other brave peaceful Hong Kongers to the Uyghur concentration camps the largest
Civilian internment since the Nazi period and as I think just I just want to underscore what mr.
Yates said, you know, we're in a period this is really an asset test and I think Jimmy's freedom is
You know, it's emblematic of Ken the general secretary of the world's largest
dictatorship
Agree to at least let this man live his last years in freedom
or is he determined to have a political trophy that he can mount on his wall and
You know see Jimmy die in prison. I mean, it's just the the stakes really couldn't be higher
And again, I just want to say I don't know if this is our last chance at the summit, but it's our best last chance
You know Sebastian you last saw your father in August of 2020
If you were here today exactly, what would you say to him?
um, I
Mean it's it's been five years since I've seen him. I hear about his health declining every single day and
And it's sometimes a painful realization of thinking that if you if I saw him again, I he
He would physically look different. I don't know how
He would be mentally
And and it's it's really it's it's really sad it's really sad
It's really worrying but then I remember one of the things that he said when he was first arrested
He was left that out the first time and someone asked him Jimmy knowing that the last 30 years
All the work the resources you put in has has led to you ending up in this little Hong Kong jail cell
Do you regret it and
He replies
You know, I had a lot of time to think if they give you a little thin little blanket. You can't really sleep
so I thought about the last 30 years and I
I realized that I wouldn't have changed a damn thing
So I'd probably tell him I'm incredibly proud I am of him how incredibly proud
so many people who hear a story of a man who is willing to sacrifice everything that he has for these liberties that
Maybe we're on the world believe our human rights
and that you know that there's many people fighting for him and
And I believe that enough if enough people would tell
President Xi that it is not in his benefit to kill this man who the symbol of the liberties that we we
how we love and treasure that hopefully that will
Mean that he will one day be free because for Xi Jinping
It's it's a it's a phone call with his 70-year-old man on a plane and he's back home with his family
Either do you like to add anything before we conclude?
That was Sebastian again
Know that your sister is in our prayers
But the your father is such a brave man one of the greatest men ever I
Just you know to give it all up to risk it all for everyone else. I mean, that's the
Greatest example of selflessness
That one could have he is truly a hero that words thrown around so often it almost becomes cheap not in his case
He is a true hero of democracy and freedom
And of goodness and that we will never cease
in Congress to try to effectuate his release and
Sadly languishing in the gulags of China, but uh, thank you for your steadfastness
You're just an amazing son, like I said a chip off the old block