Why Did Kingston Never Become Canada’s Major City?

Geography By Geoff
3 followers
1 Video View·Sep 15, 2026
This is the most important Canadian city you've never heard of.
Sitting along Lake Ontario lies the city of Kingston.
At one point, Kingston was the capital city of Canada, yet today it's largely unknown
and has fallen into the shadow of the nearby cities of Toronto and Ottawa.
So what happened to Kingston, and why didn't it become Canada's major city?
Considering the vastness of Canada,
a massive amount of people live in a relatively small area of land.
For example, even though around 16 million people live in Ontario,
a huge chunk of them, about 13 million, live in the small region of Southern Ontario,
which makes up about 36% of the entire Canadian population.
The reason for this is the region's waterways.
The Great Lakes all sit near the south of Ontario, along the Canadian-American border.
They are Lake Superior, Lake Michigan, Lake Huron, Lake Erie, and Lake Ontario.
Together, with all of their channels,
they constitute the largest freshwater system in the world,
holding about 21% of the Earth's surface freshwater.
Water, of course, is the source of all life, and this is particularly true for Canadians.
With North Ontario and the rest of Canada facing brutally cold conditions,
the Great Lakes offer refuge for people.
The waters help regulate the climate
and prevent winters from being as cold as they are elsewhere in Canada.
As a result, the region of Southern Ontario has a humid continental climate,
with summer highs of around 29 degrees Celsius,
and winter lows dropping as far as negative 30 degrees Celsius.
Despite this big swing in temperatures,
Southern Ontario is much more suited to human habitation compared to the north.
This humid continental climate allows for the ideal soil conditions for agriculture.
The area surrounding Lake Ontario and the St. Lawrence River is known as the Mixed Wood Plains,
and offers a large variety of soil and tree types.
A prime example of these ideal conditions lies about 50 kilometers north of Lake Ontario,
in a region known as the Holland Marsh.
This is a wetland that has come to be known as Ontario's Vegetable Basket,
in reference to its highly fertile organic soils.
The waters also provide drinking water, fishing access, and transportation routes for cargo,
so it makes sense as to why so many people chose Southern Ontario to be their home.
This is where the city of Kingston comes in.
Kingston is located at the far northeastern end of Lake Ontario,
which is the smallest of the five Great Lakes,
with a surface area of about 18,970 square kilometers.
To the east of Kingston lies the St. Lawrence River.
This 500 kilometer long river sprawls in a northeastern direction,
eventually reaching the Atlantic Ocean through the St. Lawrence Estuary.
This river is vitally important for Canada, as it offers the country a direct line of shipping
from its fertile interior regions to other ports around the world.
Suffice it to say, without the St. Lawrence River, Canada today would look very different.
Which brings us to the question of this video.
If Kingston sits at the mouth of the St. Lawrence River,
Canada's most important river, along Lake Ontario, one of the largest lakes in the world,
and in Southern Ontario, with direct access to Canada's fertile land,
then why didn't it ever grow into a major city and port?
Well, to understand this, we have to jump thousands of years into the past.
There's no sponsor for today's video.
Instead, a quick shout out to you.
Since you're watching this video, you should go subscribe to my Substack newsletter,
where you can get even more geography.
Every week, I write an article that pairs with a weekly video,
like this one on how Toronto became Canada's major city.
So just click the link in the description below,
or scan the QR code, and I'll see you there.
The history of Canada is steeped in war and water.
Of course, the first people to inhabit the areas around modern-day Kingston
were the indigenous Mississaugas people, a tribe composed largely of Anishinaabe-speaking peoples.
It's estimated that the presence of different indigenous groups in the region
date back as far as 9,000 years,
with the first permanent encampments in the Kingston area dating back to the year 900 Common Era.
But things eventually changed as European settlers made their way across the Atlantic.
Throughout the 1600s, European explorers continued to venture further and further into North America.
But as they traveled more inland,
it became increasingly difficult for them to return to their settlements along the Atlantic coast.
Transportation was slow, and roads were non-existent.
Because of this, new towns and outposts were constructed across the region,
particularly along navigable rivers, which made travel and transportation easy by comparison.
Of the European colonists who explored North America,
it was mainly the French who focused on Interior Canada,
which was considered part of a vast region known as New France
that stretched from the mouth of the St. Lawrence River,
through Interior Canada and the Great Lakes,
and all the way south along the Mississippi River to the now-American city of New Orleans.
Despite its namesake today, it would be the French who would first settle Kingston.
Kingston, initially named Cataraqui, was established in 1673 by Louis de Bois de Frontenac,
the governor of New France at the time.
And the town was a strategically chosen location for a new town and military fort,
as its nearby bodies of water made transport into and out of the area much less challenging.
Not only was the town set up to establish a military presence in the region,
but also as a means of engaging in the fur trade,
the primary economic engine for New France at the time.
And because there was an abundance of animals residing by the nearby lakes,
this made for a natural area where trade could occur.
Throughout the 1600s and 1700s, there were countless wars and battles between the French,
the British, and different indigenous tribes.
Large portions of land across Canada were constantly being contested,
so there were many different understandings of what Canada actually was.
Was it French? Was it English? Was it neither?
This all changed in 1763, when the British forces defeated the French to win the Seven Years' War,
a war more locally known as the French and Indian War.
As a result, the Treaty of Paris was signed.
Here, France officially relinquished large pieces of Canada to Britain.
Cararachi was now under British control, and was renamed Kingston.
After this, trading and transport ramped up significantly in Kingston,
as it quickly developed into the number one city for both economic and military purposes.
The region of Southern Ontario was surveyed in greater detail by Britain,
and the area surrounding Kingston, in particular,
was praised for having all of the necessary resources for a major city to be built around.
The mixed wood plains ecozone contained an enormous amount of both deciduous
and coniferous tree species, so timber became one of the greatest exports from Kingston.
There's one more waterway that drew people to Kingston, but this one was built by humans.
At the time, because such huge amounts of goods and materials were being transported
out of the region, it was necessary for a canal to be constructed to connect Kingston
with Ottawa, and furthermore, eastern Canada.
In 1832, the Rideau Canal was constructed to the north of Kingston.
This not only made the transportation of goods safer,
by no longer having to navigate challenging parts of the St. Lawrence River,
but transportation was now much faster.
The construction of the Rideau Canal had a big effect on the passage of water in the area,
but had an even bigger effect on the passage of time in Canada.
Suddenly, getting goods from the interior of Canada to Kingston was quick and easy.
Then came 1840, and the Act of Union was signed,
officially recognizing Canada as a united province.
And, as a result, Canada needed a capital city.
Now, let's think, which city at the time had a strategic location,
large amounts of resources, and was easily accessible by water?
That's right, it was Kingston, which officially became the first capital city of Canada in 1841.
From here, you'd be safe in assuming that Kingston would continue to thrive,
and would eventually grow into a major Canadian metropolis.
But things very quickly fell apart.
Kingston would only hold capital city status for three years, being stripped of the honor in 1844.
So this raises the question, what exactly went wrong?
In the decades after the War of 1812,
Britain feared that Canada could potentially be invaded by America.
The two countries were already locked in a bitter negotiation over the Oregon Territory to the West,
so it wasn't entirely without reason this could happen.
And with Kingston sitting on Lake Ontario,
the American forces could simply come over from the other side of the lake and attack the capital city.
Considering Kingston to be too vulnerable, the decision was made to relocate the capital.
Over the next few years, the capital city jumped from Montreal to Quebec City to Toronto,
before finally being awarded to Ottawa in 1857.
Ottawa, which was farther away from the border and was surrounded by a lot of forestry,
was considered the safest and most optimal choice for a capital city, which it remains to this day.
But now that Kingston was no longer the capital city,
would it be able to keep up with its quickly developing neighbors?
The answer to that question is, honestly, no.
In 1867, the British North America Act was passed,
and Canada became a federated country.
From here, Canada began to enter the modern era.
Of Kingston's two neighboring major cities, Toronto and Ottawa,
both cities began to develop their own unique identity.
Ottawa, as the designated capital city, quickly shifted into the political center of Canada,
while Toronto soon emerged as the economic center.
People flocked to each city in search of a better life,
and Toronto and Ottawa both began to rapidly grow in size.
Toronto first saw a massive surge in immigration in the second half of the 1800s,
with Irish people in particular coming to the city, fleeing from a potato famine back home.
Over the course of 40 years, from 1851 to 1891,
the population of Toronto multiplied in size six times over,
leaping from 30,000 to 180,000 people.
As is the case with every country in the world,
the bigger cities were given more resources and funding to accommodate their larger populations.
As they neared the late 1800s, new train lines were constructed around the country,
connecting Toronto and Ottawa with other large cities such as Montreal and Quebec,
and eventually even some of the major U.S. cities across the border, such as Boston and New York City.
And while these train lines did connect to Kingston,
they began to accommodate the former capital less and less,
as its population and national relevance were stagnating.
More so, train lines during this time became the primary way for materials to be transported.
So there became a steady decrease in cargo ships traveling to Kingston.
And for those cargo ships that still visited Kingston,
the city became less capable of providing large quantities of timber as years went by,
due to long-term deforestation of its surrounding areas.
So, as Toronto and Ottawa continued to grow, Kingston failed to develop at the same speed.
And that brings us to today.
Today, Toronto is the most populous city in all of Canada,
boasting a population of a staggering 6.4 million people in its metropolitan region.
It's built around a very strong service and knowledge economy,
meaning that its workforce is highly educated,
and the city is home to a large array of specialized jobs.
As an example, it is the heart of Canada's financial sector.
The country's major banks are mostly based there,
as well as many of the world's leading technology companies.
On top of this, it holds the Toronto Stock Exchange,
the home of the Canadian stock market.
Meanwhile, Ottawa is a mere 90 miles north from Kingston.
And although a fraction of the size of Toronto,
Ottawa still holds a population of about 1.4 million people.
And as the nation's capital, it's home to countless government departments and agencies.
As for Kingston itself, the major city that never was,
it has a population of around 170,000 people today.
Which isn't too small,
but it certainly never became the major city that it was once envisioned to be.
Now all that said, it isn't all doom and gloom for the city.
Kingston has recently developed a reputation as a culture and tourism hotspot,
with the city hosting several film and music festivals every year.
Also, they still make great use of their access to water,
with water sports being a popular pastime.
So, if you prefer a slower and more relaxed way of living,
Kingston may just be the place for you.
There's a great irony in Kingston's history.
The city's rise came as a result of its proximity to Lake Ontario,
and its fall also came as a result of its proximity to Lake Ontario.
Sometimes, history is just kind of weird like that.
There are a million cities out there that could or should have become
the major city for their respective country.
The reality is that history and geography all play a role in how our places develop.
And for Kingston, both its history and geography were not on its side.
Hey, this week I'm still in Thailand,
but I'm exploring one of its best and wildest national parks.
And you should come join me over on my other channel.
I hope you enjoyed learning all about Canada's major city that never was.
If you did, please like the video and subscribe to my channel.
And be sure to check out this other video
on why Astoria, Oregon never became a major city on America's west coast.
Thanks for watching.
See you next time.
