Why Would A Man With $25 Million Buy Whole Life Insurance for Cash Value?

Finance Shield
6 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explains why high-net-worth individuals may purchase whole life insurance as a financial asset even when they have no need for the death benefit. Using a case study of a finance executive, it demonstrates how the product serves as a low-risk, tax-advantaged alternative to fixed-income investments when designed for maximum cash value.
What I wanna cover today is why would anyone
buy a whole life insurance policy
if they don't need life insurance?
So there's someone who I've been working with
for more than a year,
and he just started a whole life insurance policy
where he's putting $1 million into the product.
And to give you a little bit of context,
he doesn't need life insurance.
He's got more than $25 million in liquid
in his brokerage account.
If he and his wife die,
their kids are gonna be set for the rest of their life.
So he doesn't need life insurance.
And when he first looked into it,
he wasn't that interested.
He was very skeptical.
And when he did look into it,
he knew what questions to ask
in order to stress test the policy
to make sure it would actually be
a good place to put his money.
And I'll show you exactly what he asked,
how he stress tested the policy,
and then we'll look at the option
that he moved forward with.
So to kick things off,
a little bit about him.
He is a managing director at a Fortune 100 company.
And what he does specifically is
he runs the fixed income portfolio division,
which means Fortune 500 companies,
private equity firms,
and people with hundreds of millions
and billions of dollars
will come to him and his company and say,
we want you to manage our assets.
He's very, very good at what he does.
He has some experience with whole life insurance.
He understands that the cash value is a fixed asset.
So he's viewing how it would fit
on his personal balance sheet.
He sees that it carries very low risk,
and he looks at the Sharpe ratio,
which measures the volatility of an asset
and sees that it's very, very attractive.
So he's attracted to it for that reason,
but the main thing that he liked,
and he said this when we met yesterday was,
when I look at the tax advantages
along with the safety that comes with it,
that's what I like.
That's really hard to find.
So here's the thing.
When we first connected,
he was very skeptical.
And a big reason why is because he sees marketing material,
whether it's podcasts, videos, whatever,
where things are just not described accurately.
Because he has a very strong finance background,
he can read through stuff that he hears and says,
yeah, that's somebody just trying to prop up the product
so they can sell it in an easier fashion.
So he'll often see or hear
how the returns are described inaccurately.
For example, put your money
into this whole life insurance policy,
get a dividend of 6%,
and then you can take a loan at 5%
and you have a positive 1% spread.
Absolute nonsense,
because the dividend rate is a gross rate.
He knows that and then he just disregards
anything else he hears from someone who says that.
Then he sees scenarios
where only the best case scenario is shown.
He doesn't like that.
He wants to be able to stress test
and see worst case scenarios.
And then when he hears things like this,
well, you're looking at it the wrong way.
This I hear a lot,
where you'll have an insurance agent
explaining the benefits
of cash value life insurance to someone.
But if they're speaking to an investment banker
or anyone with a strong finance background,
you got to be careful here
because the investment banker looks at the product
and says, okay, why I'm going to put money here
is because of the tax advantages
that come with the cash value
and that long-term IRR of 4% to 5%.
Because if I'm in a 40% tax rate,
this is an absolute no-brainer,
a 4% to 5% IRR with low risk
and is tax-free if I follow IRS rules,
like why would anyone not do this?
That's why they do that.
The thing is, to get a 4% to 5% IRR quickly,
the product needs to be designed with minimum commissions.
And typically, these guys will vet companies,
they know how to look at the financials
of an insurance company,
and they'll typically want one of the four major mutuals
for MassMutual, Guardian, New York Life,
and Northwestern Mutual.
Why I say all of that is because an insurance agent
who says you're looking at it the wrong way
or you need to change your thinking doesn't like that
because if you're looking at the major mutuals
and you're designing it to beef up that IRR,
it is going to minimize the agent commission.
So the thing is, when you work with someone
with a strong finance background
and they press you, either A, you've got to agree with them
and design the policy for high cash value,
or they just won't work with you
because they know what to look for.
And I love that about working with people
who have a strong finance background.
I also see this a lot with engineers
who we work with quite a bit.
So anyway, what he's doing is he's moving $1 million
into a whole life insurance policy over four years.
When we look at the internal rate of return,
which is between four to 5%, it's about 5% by year 20,
with the tax advantages,
that again is why he's putting money here.
The taxable equivalent yield makes it an absolute win-win.
And I'll show you that as well when we look at the numbers.
Here's the thing though, before we just look at the numbers
and show you the best case scenario,
here's what he wanted to test.
And we tested this together.
The design of the product, the break-even on the cash value,
and then also looking at those,
but with conservative assumptions.
Meaning, don't just show me the internal rate of return
based on the dividend rate today, lower that dividend.
And show it to me based on the guaranteed values as well.
So you can do that with any whole life insurance policy.
So here's the policy
that he ultimately decided to move forward with.
You've got a million bucks going in over four years,
250 per year, okay.
There's your cash value, break-even point,
just about year three, you're positive by the fourth year.
Great.
This illustration is based
on the current dividend interest rate.
So if I go down here, results,
based on the 2026 dividend schedule.
What you can do is reduce the dividend interest rate.
Here's the exact same policy, set up the exact same way.
You'll notice though, by the fourth year,
the cash value is exactly $1 million.
That's less than what we looked at in the last illustration.
The reason why is because what we did here
is we reduced the dividend rate by a full percent,
so 100 basis points,
MassMutual's 2026 dividend rate is 6.6%,
which means this illustration shows a 5.6% dividend rate.
So let's take a look at these side by side.
Here's the 6.6% dividend rate.
Dividend rate is a gross rate,
meaning his money at no point in time
will grow by 6.6% if his dividend rate is 6.6%.
He was interested in one thing,
which is the internal rate of return during all years.
First, address the elephant.
Worst part of any whole life insurance policy,
the upfront hit on cash value.
You've got an 8% loss,
mainly because of the insurance expenses
that come with the product, their heaviest upfront.
When we look at right around the year 20 IRR,
I'm gonna circle year 21 because it's a clean 5%,
that got his attention.
For a safe place to put money, 5% IRR,
he's like, okay, why would anyone not do this?
But then we made it conservative.
Here's the 5.6% dividend illustration.
What do you notice?
Now the IRR is about 4%.
Notice we lowered the dividend by a percent
and the IRR is about a percent lower.
Then what we did, a 4.6% dividend,
which I think is extremely conservative, but that's okay.
So here we go, just about a 3% internal rate of return.
And then just for fun, here's the guarantees.
So looking at the guaranteed rate,
which is 2% with this product,
there's your IRR at less than half a percent.
Now, frankly, this is unrealistic
because it assumes that no dividends are ever paid
starting day one.
And it also assumes that the insurance company
is charging the maximum allowable rates
for the cost of the term insurance riders attached forever.
So it's like worst case, worst case,
never seen it happen one year, let alone all years.
But anyway, it is still beneficial to look at
so you know what is contractually guaranteed.
Now, what did we talk about earlier?
Saw the breakeven with each of those
that was highlighted in yellow.
Conservative assumptions, we looked at that.
This guy, taxable equivalent.
What is that?
Well, what that is, is if I have an asset
which I can book as a tax-free IRR,
provided we don't met the policy
and we follow IRS rules,
what would I need to earn in a taxable asset
in order to get the same net return after tax
that I'm getting with this life insurance policy?
He's in a 40% tax rate.
He actually said he'll probably never be
in a tax rate lower than 40%.
Here's the taxable equivalent.
So based on the current dividend rate of 6.6%,
when we look at year 21,
an IRR of 5%, if it's tax-free,
means you would need to earn 8.33%
in a taxable asset.
An example would be a high-yield savings
or treasury bills where we have to pay taxes
on the interest every year.
We would need to earn 8.33%.
And then after paying taxes based on our 40% rate,
our net would be 5%.
So that's what that taxable equivalent IRR represents.
It's showing what you would need to earn
in a taxable asset, and then after paying the taxes,
you'd be left over with the IRR you see
on the life insurance policy.
So that's what he was looking at.
And again, based on the current dividend rate,
got it, made sense, great.
But then we looked at it based on the concern
of conservative dividends.
So here's a 5.6% dividend rate.
20-year IRR, just about 4%.
Taxable equivalent, 6.65.
Still attractive.
This is conservative, by the way,
and I'll explain why in a minute.
But then we also did the same
with the 4.6% dividend rate.
When you look at that same point in time,
the equivalent is about 5%.
That's the thing right there.
When you stress test these policies,
if you go so conservative where it's almost unrealistic
over that long period of time,
like a 5% taxable equivalent yield
for someone who's looking at this
as a fixed income alternative,
like that right there is what they're attracted to.
And we see this all the time
on the individual and corporate side of things.
So why I say that those are conservative,
especially the 4.6, but even the 5.6,
and this gave him a lot of peace of mind as well,
is illustrations could be true or false,
but they're gonna change as time passes.
We tracked the actual results
of whole life insurance policies for all of our clients.
So we were able to show him over the past 10 plus years
what these policies have actually done.
And we can even show here was the original illustration,
and then here's what it's actually done
as the dividend rate has adjusted.
And then we also have policies
from the major mutual companies that are older than me,
where we can show him here's the actual IRR over time.
The thing is, the product does need to be designed properly
in order for it to produce what he is looking for.
And the reason this was such a concern for him
is because he has a whole life insurance policy
where he puts away 50K per year.
He bought this from someone else.
And in the first year, his cash value was extremely low.
It's going to take something like eight to 10 years
just to break even, and it's very, very slow.
So in looking at that and having experienced that firsthand,
that's where that hesitancy and skepticism comes in.
And that's where learning about how to design a policy
the right way like this, where cash value is the goal,
help someone see, okay, here's how I get the maximum benefits
and that is where we see people put money
into whole life insurance
when they don't need the life insurance,
because he is a prime example of that.
Anyway, hope you enjoyed this video.
Let me know if you did,
because this is one of my favorite topics
to talk about actually.
If you did, please let me know in the comment section below
along with any other questions you might have.
And as always, I hope this helps.
So if this was helpful and you'd like to go deeper,
here's what I would do next.
Step one, download the free case study using the link below.
It'll make everything we talk about feel more concrete
because you'll see actual numbers on paper.
And step two, if you're serious
about a high cash value life insurance policy for yourself,
whether it's for your business, real estate,
or you're just looking at a safe place
to save money with tax benefits,
I've used the calendar link on that page
to book a custom policy design session.
On that call, we'll ask a few simple questions
about your situation.
We'll go over an illustration with you on the spot
and we'll walk through the year by year numbers
so you can decide if it makes sense for you.
No pressure, just math and options.
And if you just wanna keep learning for now,
feel free to subscribe
and check out the other case studies on the channel.
As always, I hope this helps.
