Millions are working into their 80s. Why can’t Americans retire anymore? This Is America

Aljazeera
59 followers
6 Video Views·Sep 14, 2026
This is America and this is a country where getting old is starting to look like a financial
risk. 80% of Americans now say the country is in a retirement crisis. The reasons vary from
vanishing pensions to depleted savings to the social security program projected to run short
by 2032. So we're asking, is America building a real plan to grow old or just running out the
clock as the problem ages? Let's get started with Alex Marquardt in our DC studio.
Thank you, Heidi. A growing number of Americans, from teenagers all the way to people in their
70s, they are questioning whether they can ever afford to retire. Social Security's primary
retirement trust fund is expected to run out by 2032. And if Congress does nothing,
payments to beneficiaries of social security will be cut by nearly a quarter. Many people don't have
enough personal savings to make up the shortfall, and that matters in a country where nearly a fifth
of the population is over the age of 65. So let's go back to Heidi Jo Castro now, who looks at the
fears around social security's future and the response here in Washington. Thank you to the
team. 74-year-old Tweri Marshall reads a letter from a student. The only reason I'm smart is
because of you. Among the thousands of young lives she's touched during her teaching career,
that's still going. Yeah, I'm still working. I don't use that word a lot, but I have to be
employed, you know, financially so that I can, you know, maintain the legacy, you know, the home,
the quality of life. Rising property taxes on the home where she grew up and the high cost of living
have kept Marshall from retirement. The house is one thing, and then groceries. I mean,
I have a beautiful refrigerator, but there's not much in it. You know, I mean, I do a pot of rice
and I, you know, make sure I have some frozen vegetables and all of that so I can eat. More
and more older Americans are working into their 70s and 80s. They're waiting to retire due to
high cost of housing, health care, more personal debt and declining employer-paid pensions. Not
having enough money for retirement is now the most common financial concern of Americans,
and 80 percent say they think the country is facing a retirement crisis. These young workers
at Mia Cain Cafe in Rockville, Maryland, are students just joining the workforce,
and they're earning not just for themselves. Like all American wage workers,
6.2 percent of their pay, in addition to a matching amount paid by their employers,
goes to the federal government's Social Security Fund. That fund sends monthly checks to American
retirees who can begin collecting the payments in their 60s. But for 16-year-old student worker
Tanisha De Silva, there's a Social Security math problem that, at the moment, has no solution.
America's population is aging, and the ratio of workers paying into Social Security to retirees
drawing money out is far smaller today than when the program began in 1940. The Congressional
Budget Office predicts that in six years, the Social Security Trust Fund will be down to zero.
And there's no telling what will be left for today's young workers when they retire in the
future. If I'm working and part of my paycheck has just been removed and there's no guarantee
that I will ever get it back, then it's kind of just like I'm working for free.
She says it also pains her to see so many older people working despite health problems and age.
It's either work till you die, basically, or die working.
Washington is aware of the problem, but neither party wants to raise taxes
or the retirement age to address the Social Security funding gap.
President Trump has tried to expand Americans' access to retirement savings accounts,
but almost half don't have them. So for now, the country's working elderly are left to struggle,
and the working young are left to worry. Heidi Jo Castro, Al Jazeera, Rockville, Maryland.
And here to discuss whether the U.S. does indeed have a retirement crisis,
we have Rachel Gressler. She is a senior research fellow at the Plymouth Institute
for Free Enterprise at Advancing American Freedom, and Alex Lawson. He is an executive
director, the executive director, at Social Security Works. Rachel and Alex, thanks so much
for being with us on this really important subject. Rachel, I want to start with you,
because you have said that the current retirees, they're doing very well by historical standards.
At the same time, when you look at the polling, 80 percent of Americans
say that the country is indeed facing a retirement crisis. So how can both of those things be true?
Yes, and so the good news is that today's generation of retirees, mostly the baby boomers,
are by all measures doing better than any generation in history. Their real incomes
have increased more than 30 percent over recent decades, and a lot of the reason they're doing
better is because they have other sources of income today. It's not only Social Security,
and it's not only defined to benefit pensions that Americans have traditionally gotten in the
workplace, working in one job for their entire career. The reality is today, most people have
some other form of savings outside of Social Security, and in those areas, in 401ks, we've
seen tremendous growth, and you can see the positive returns that come from those investments
over time. But we do have a bit of a retirement crisis in the sense of Social Security will be
bankrupt in six years from now. It will not be able to pay full benefits, and there are also
problems in state and local pensions, as well as some of the union and multi-employer pensions
that are massively underfunded, and something will have to change with those. Alex, I see
you shaking your head. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of problems, but the main one is the word
bankrupt is just not true. That's just, you tell people that they're gonna get nothing so that you
can come in and convince them to take less than they're owed. It's a tactic to undermine confidence
in a system that works, and the problem is that not many of the things that were said are actually
the reality on the ground. You have tens of millions of seniors who rely on Social Security
for almost every penny that they have, and the only problem is those benefits are far too low.
You have seniors today who are facing a choice in the richest country in the history of the world
between staying in their home or buying the medication that they need to live. This is because
the rich, the billionaires, have taken all the gains of the economy and put them in their pockets,
and they're not satisfied there. After they do that, they destroyed defined benefit pension
plans so that they could get more of our money in their pockets, and now they have their sights set
on Social Security. So let's be clear. Social Security cannot go bankrupt. It's funded by
current workers, but if Congress does nothing in 2032, there will be an across-the-board benefit
cut of around 22 percent. That's the problem. 22 percent benefit cut. The solution has to prevent
a 22 percent benefit cut. So just to back up, I do want to get into the Social Security specifics,
but Alex, you're disagreeing that this is a conversation about the future. You're saying
this is a conversation right now, and the retirees right now are also in crisis. Absolutely. I mean,
just look around. Look at the prices that people are paying right now. They're being crushed. It's
an affordability crisis across this country, and seniors are on fixed incomes. They don't get the
ability to make more money. So when costs go up for them, it means they have to make hard choices,
and that means for millions of people in this country choosing between cutting a pill in half
to stretch the medications that they need to live. And let's, again, this is the richest country in
the history of the world. We don't want people to just be scraping by. After working their lifetime,
they should be able to retire with dignity, and they can. All we have to do is have billionaires
pay the same rate into Social Security as everyone else, and this is no longer a question
at all. We can expand benefits for everyone in the country. Let's just take a look at the landscape
across the country in terms of ages and where people stand in their lives. How many are in
retirement? When we talk about retirement and an aging population, this is the current makeup in
the United States. The majority are in the 25 to 64 age range, and then in the 65 and older
population, that is surging as boomers move into retirement. And then when we look at where people
are age-wise across the country, we have a map where they are aging fastest. In Maine, they have
the oldest median age of 44.9 years old. Utah, out west, has the youngest median age at 32.6
years old. Rachel, could you just pick up on something that Alex just said a moment ago? How
much do you believe that Social Security is the one thing standing between millions of retirees
and poverty? Well, the reality is that Social Security was created to be an anti-poverty
program, and I actually think that the solution for it is to get back to the roots of Social
Security. And so by and large, I said baby boomers, retirees today are doing very well. But
there is a reality that some on the very lower end are not, and they are living in poverty.
Seniors do have the lowest poverty rate of any group, but nevertheless, there are seniors living
in poverty. And so when we're looking at a system, and Alex is right, it's not bankrupt. It will be
insolvent. It will only be able to pay somewhere between 72 and 78 percent of benefits. So when we
get to that point, the focus needs to be on protecting those who are truly in or near poverty,
and I would argue even lifting up some of the benefits on the lowest end. But if we're going
to do that, and if we also have a fiscal crisis in the U.S., and we have $40 trillion in debt,
we have to recognize the financial reality of this. And Social Security was started out as an
anti-poverty program in the wake of the Great Depression, when millions of people lost their
entire savings. And its founder said, we're starting this program because we don't want
younger workers to have to pay for preventing poverty and old age. Well, today, that's all we
do with Social Security. There is no actual money in the trust fund. There are IOUs. Every dollar
that comes out of each of our paychecks goes directly to current benefits. And so we are
already, we have indebted younger workers today. And so anything that is done to increase the size
of the program will come from younger workers. And so we have to say, yes, we could have some
benefits lifted up at the bottom for the true purpose of preventing poverty, but we're also
going to have to talk about gradually reducing benefits at the upper end. You know, Social
Security was not meant to pay for greens fees and for cruises. It was meant to protect against
poverty. In this conversation about retirement, we often talk about the three-legged stool, right?
You have Social Security, which is one of the main pillars, one of the legs. And then you've
got personal savings that people have accrued over a lifetime of working. And then you've got
pension plans, hopefully. Hopefully for, certainly for those last two. Alex, you have mentioned
taxes that are needed among the wealthiest Americans in order to sort of essentially
right the ship. What does a sustainable path look like to get Social Security back into
solid financial shape? It's really simple. We spend so much time like talking about this
that people are convinced that it's hard. It's not hard. This is the thing that most people don't
understand and know. People only pay in on the first $184,500 of income. After that, they don't
pay in a nickel more. That's the cap. And what that means is for the vast majority of the American
people, they pay in all year long. They pay in on 100 percent of their income. But for someone like
Elon Musk, he pays in on a tiny fraction of his income. He stops paying in on the first second
of the first day of every year. All we have to do is have Elon Musk and his ultra wealthy friends
pay the same rate on all of their income, just like the rest of us do. And then not only is
there not a 22 percent benefit cut in 2032, we can expand benefits for everyone. So here's the
facts. The next presidential administration is going to have to deal with this. And there are
only two paths. One of them says, let's let the billionaires who cheat and rob and do all of the
things that they can to avoid paying their fair share and who are rife in the Epstein files just
got $4.5 trillion in tax handouts to these less than a thousand people. Let's protect them by
stealing tens of millions of hardworking Americans earned benefits. Because remember, no one gives us
Social Security. It's our money. We pay into it and then it's there for us when we need it. So the
solution is simple. The problem is billionaires not paying in on all of their income. So let's have
billionaires pay in on all of their income, both earned and unearned. And then there's no benefit
cut for hardworking Americans now or in the future. Well, the unfortunate reality of the finances
today of the United States is that you could confiscate the wealth of every single billionaire
in America and you could hardly fund the government for one year. So while it might have been the case
historically that you could lift the payroll tax cap and you could cover some or most of Social
Security's shortfalls, that's not true today. It would maybe finance 40% and it would end up with
a 56% top federal tax rate, 66% when you include state and local taxes. And I think, again, I want
to get back to the history of the program. The founders originally said that they were going to
exclude anybody who made the equivalent of about $60,000 today in income because those people would
not need social insurance in retirement. It was expected that they could save on their own. At the
end of the day, they said, okay, we'll include them but we'll keep a cap because that was
administratively easier to do. But the reality is the U.S.'s payroll tax cap is far higher than any
other country and raising that cap will not only not solve the problem but it will lead to
economically detrimental tax rates. Am I understanding your argument correctly, Rachel, that you would
like to see people be allowed to take some of their Social Security money, putting that into
private accounts that can be managed by themselves or be managed by fund managers, for example. In
short, are you arguing that you should be allowed to remove money from the one guaranteed benefit
from the government into something that is more privately run? I would like to see a situation in
which individuals would have the option to have a personal account. And so if they want to do that,
they would actually still have to contribute to Social Security because it does have insolvency
and it's got undefunded liabilities. So the employer side of the payroll tax would continue
to go into Social Security. They're paying in for something. They're not going to get any more
benefits accrued in the future. But I think the option should be there for somebody, especially
these younger workers who see the reality. They don't know what their Social Security benefit is
going to be. And yet they know, hey, if I could save these taxes on my own, I'd have three times
as much in retirement. They should be able to take that half of the tax that they pay, put it in
something like the federal government's thrift savings plan that they have for federal employees
and to have that grow over time and see an actual return. Because the reality is, yes, we're paying
into the system, but the money is not there. You don't earn a dime on it. Anything you get is
coming from your future children and grandchildren out of their paychecks.
Alex, why do you disagree?
There's very little there that's correct. First of all, when it was set up, FDR signed it into
law saying this is the cornerstone upon which we're going to build an ever-expanding system
of economic security. It wasn't an anti-poverty program. That's part of what it did. It is the
largest anti-poverty program in America, not because that's what it was designed to do. It
was designed as a social insurance program to keep Wall Street's greedy little fingers out of
our money. Wall Street doesn't make a nickel off of Social Security. That's why they want you to
be able to have the option to invest in their products. We've heard this before. There used
to be things for your younger viewers called defined benefit pension plans. And then the exact
same people said, you know what, if we get rid of those and just let the miracle of the market,
you're all going to be rich. Some people did get rich. Wall Street got rich. And workers
are worse off today than they were when defined benefit pension plans were a thing
that people knew about. Defined benefit pensions were invested in Wall Street.
Defined benefit pensions were defined benefits. They weren't savings. So the switch to a
defined contribution, which is the difference between a 401k and a defined benefit pension plan,
right? So that switch switched people from guaranteed revenue to savings. Guaranteed,
defined contributions. And everyone lost except for the ultra wealthy. The same play is what
they're trying to do on Social Security. Get rid of the guarantee. Gamble it all on Wall Street.
Somebody is going to get a new yacht, but it's not going to be the working people who are paying
into the system. Our Social Security system works. It works as it's intended to, including
the trust fund. Baby boomers have pre-funded their own retirement, which is not worthless IOUs.
They've been saying that for 91 years. These are the same. Yes, these are the same government bonds
that are in the bottom of all of Wall Street's banks. That's the truth. The safest instrument
in the world, U.S. Treasury bills. When the billionaires don't pay in to Social Security,
it's exhausted the trust fund 30 years early. That's why it's 2032 and not 2065,
because billionaires have taken all the wealth since 1980 into their pocket, and that's above
the income cap. That's not me talking. That's a Social Security actuary. You can look,
if you want to Google Steve Goss. The income distribution is the entire reason that we're
facing 2032 as the choice that we are. But the choice is, should we make the hardworking
Americans who've played by the rules, done exactly what we're supposed to? Should we get our benefits
cut or the billionaires who caused the problem, should we just have them pay the same rate that
we do? Can we talk about the problem? Yes, there was a design for Social Security and things didn't
work out how were planned, and part of that was that it was supposed to be a forced saving system,
and because people lived longer, because Congress continually increased the benefits over time,
because they adjusted them to wages instead of prices, benefits are about three times what they
thought they would be at the beginning. And so today we have a system that is much bigger than
it was. It's not that billionaires aren't paying enough into it. It's that when Congress started
the system, it was a 2% payroll tax. That original 1937 brochure that went out to every American
said, we will never take more than 6 cents of your paycheck. Today it's taking 12.4%,
and just to keep the program going once it becomes insolvent, we'll take 17% of paychecks.
And so no, it's not just about the billionaires not paying their fair share. There is no way to
solve it with just the billionaires. You have to talk about ordinary Americans, and when we have
younger individuals and families today that are facing difficulty affording housing, affording
health care and other things, we're talking about an enormous tax increase. We're talking about them
paying up to $20,000 a median household just for Social Security, and looking at the big picture,
the government today, Social Security and interest payments alone are $20,000 for every household in
America. And so how we're going to address Social Security, yes, we need to. We need to protect
people, but it can't be about just raising taxes because the money is simply not going to be there.
It's all about just raising taxes because the money is not in people's pockets to steal.
The only place that we can go is the place that's causing the problem,
the billionaires and the ultra-wealthy who aren't paying in.
It's not stealing from them what they've stolen from us. You show me a billionaire
who hasn't made his fortune by stealing the labor of his workers and exploiting them.
I'll wait. You can Google it and send it to me. But yes, we're going to have billionaires pay
their fair share in and not cut a single penny from Social Security because Social Security
is keeping millions of people out of poverty. Right now, it costs about 6% of GDP. In 2100,
do you know how much it costs as a percent of GDP? 6%. It's a flat line. It's the picture
of affordability. You find me anything else that looks like that, you can't.
We can afford Social Security. Social Security works. All we have to do is have the bravery
to tell the billionaires who are the problem that they're going to start paying their fair share.
Let's just take a look at what retirees need these days in terms of savings to get a better
sense of what we're talking about here. Here's the average annual household spending for people
over the age of 65. In 2024, that number was just over $61,000 per year. When you add in
projected inflation at 2.2%, by 2032, this year that we've all been talking about during this
program, the number is expected to be more than $73,000 per year. That's almost 1,000 that's
needed more per month. One thing I'm confused about is Social Security is immensely popular
politically across the board. I think I was looking at a poll earlier today. It's like 95%
approval rating. Rachel, when we look at this looming deadline of 2032 to save the trust fund
part of Social Security, what are the political hurdles to getting what needs to be done done?
It is very difficult politically because nearly every American is part of Social Security and
certainly older Americans tend to be more active in their voting because they're aware of the
issues facing Social Security. It's very difficult to touch the program in any way. Add on top of
that the fact that Social Security legislation cannot move through a reconciliation bill.
You essentially need 60 votes in the Senate. It is going to be difficult, but the new senators who
come in this year, they will be in office when the program becomes insolvent in 2032. They will
have to do something about this. You can have competing bills out there. Ultimately,
there's going to have to be bipartisan buy-in. Perhaps a commission. There hasn't been a lot of
success with these in the past. I think that if you had that, there've got to be some teeth tied
to it, including a forced up or down vote in Congress. Just looking at the political calendar,
we cover a lot of politics on this show. Let's assume that Democrats take back the House.
I don't want to get into a guessing game over the Senate, but Alex, what would you like to see
in the last two years of President Trump's term before the next presidential election,
which as you both noted, will then run into that 2032 deadline? What we need to see from Democrats
is get a bill to expand Social Security onto the floor and watch the Republicans
cower in fear. The Republicans' plan is to never talk about the fact that all they want to do is
cut people's benefits. They have no other plan. Raising the retirement age, 21% benefit cut.
The reason they don't talk about their plan is because it's deeply unpopular and they'd
immediately lose their job. So Democrats should make them vote on a plan to expand Social Security
as many times as they can, setting the stage to make Social Security the issue that the next
presidential campaign is run on, because for the American people, it will be. I'll just say,
it's simple to solve this because the American people are united. Republican, Democrat,
Independent, they all want to see not a penny of benefit cut. And this certainly plays into the
affordability debate, which is, of course, as we all know, front and center in every election
conversation these days. Rachel Gressler, Alex Lawson, thank you both very much for a fascinating
and passionate conversation. And that's all from the team here in Washington. I want to hand it
back to Heidi Jo Castro and Al Jazeera's Global Headquarters in Doha. That's it for this edition
of This Is America. We leave you with one question. Why hasn't America and its richest
research system in the world found the cure for cancer yet? We're back with that topic on Tuesday
at 1830 GMT, 2.30 p.m. Eastern. From all of us in Washington, goodbye for now.
