#Archaeology#Medieval#BayeuxTapestry Is the Bayeux Tapestry the ultimate piece of medieval political spin? Today, Giselle puts seven claims from Britain’s favorite masterpiece to the test using real archaeological evidence, excavated longships, horse bones, and battlefield finds! From false myths about King Harold’s death to hidden Anglo-Saxon rebellion in the margins, we’re unravelling the truth behind the 1066 Battle of Hastings, Norman Conquest.
Thank you to History Hit for sponsoring this video! Sign up to History Hit and start watching today: https://eu1.hubs.ly/H0gFQZ50
You can become a certified Dirt Nerd and watch exclusive content by becoming a channel member here: / @archaeologistsnotebook
00:00 Intro 02:04 The setup 03:38 Claim 1: The fleet 05:52 Claim 2: Attack of the ponies 07:54 Claim 3: Military gear 09:37 History Hit 10:02 Military gear cont. 12:18 Claim 4: The arrow to the eye 15:20 Claim 5: Written in the stars 17:33 Claim 6: Slice of life 20:16 Claim 7: The oath Bonus: Censorships?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video analyzes the Bayeux Tapestry, an embroidery depicting the Norman conquest of 1066. By comparing the artwork with archaeological evidence, the narrator distinguishes between the biased political propaganda commissioned by the victors and the accurate physical records of 11th-century technology, warfare, and daily life.
It's one of the biggest, baddest pieces
of political spin in human history.
It spans an impressive 70 meters in length,
features over 600 people, 200 horses,
and some surprisingly explicit little naked men.
I am, of course, talking about Britain's
favorite medieval masterpiece, the Bayeux Tapestry.
Hey, Dirt Nerds, I'm Giselle.
I'm an archaeologist,
and welcome back to The Archaeologist's Notebook.
Today, we are unpicking a massive historical mystery,
because here is the first big lie
about this iconic artifact.
It's not a tapestry,
and it almost certainly wasn't even made in Bayeux.
Instead, this legendary piece of art
is a cruel embroidery,
hand-stitched by Anglo-Saxon needle workers
right across the English Channel in Kent.
But for nearly a thousand years,
it has stood as the definitive visual record
of the Norman conquest of 1066.
It shows the context, the highs, lows,
and eventual legacy of the Battle of Hastings,
the culmination of Harold and William's struggle
for the English throne.
But as an archaeologist, my question is,
how much of it is actually true?
History is written by the victor,
and this 950-year-old piece of embroidered art
is also the record commissioned
in celebration of the Norman victory.
Can we trust it to tell us what really happened?
Well, thanks to the incredible work
of textile archaeologists, conservators,
and a few others,
we can test the tapestry against physical evidence
pulled straight out of the dirt.
Today, we are putting seven famous claims
from the embroidery to the ultimate test.
We're breaking down the ironclad truths
and quite blatant historical myths
that rewrite everything you think you know
about the Norman conquest.
And stick around,
because we've also got a hilarious tale
of Victorian censorship
involving some very prudish needlework.
So sit back, relax,
and let's find out what's really lurking behind the Beo.
Before we get started,
we need to understand exactly what this object is
and who paid for it.
Most scholars have argued
that the work was almost certainly commissioned
by Bishop Odo of Beo,
who just so happened to be
the half-brother of William the Conqueror.
What a funny coincidence.
Can't imagine that'll come up later.
Odo wanted a massive visual monument
to celebrate the Norman victory,
to be hung in his brand-new cathedral in Beo around 1077.
But here's the rub.
The people he hired to stitch it
would have been the conquered Anglo-Saxons,
as in the guys his side had just defeated.
This means that hidden within
this glorious celebration of Norman triumph,
in the margins are subtle nods, jokes, and details
left behind by the Saxon needleworkers
who actually lost the war.
Because of this,
the embroidery acts as an incredible material catalog
of the 11th century.
Within its 70 meters of cloth,
hundreds of everyday objects, weapons, and animals
are rendered in painstaking detail.
For decades, historians argued
over whether these illustrations were realistic
or just pure artistic fantasy.
But that's where archaeology comes in.
When we excavate an 11th-century site,
we can compare the physical artifacts
up to the embroidery and see if they match.
When they do,
we know the artists were drawing from real life.
When they don't,
that's when we can assume
a little bit of medieval spin is at work.
So let's start the countdown.
Claim number one takes us out to sea.
The Norman fleet was made up
of magnificent clinker-built longships
featuring terrifying dragon-headed prows.
This fleet was huge and imposing,
built specifically to transport
an entire invading army across the English Channel.
Is this true or false?
It is true.
The tapestry dedicates a massive amount of real estate
to the Novigio scenes,
showing the step-by-step construction of William's fleet.
We see workers felling massive oak trees,
using specialized broad axes to shape the planks,
and assembling classic Norse-style longships.
Now, you might wonder why the Normans,
who were living in northern France,
decided to build ships
that look exactly like Scandinavian Viking longships,
complete with those fierce dragon heads on the bow,
and the overlapping clinker style of hull construction.
Well, the word Norman literally comes from Northmen.
These guys were the direct descendants of Vikings
who had settled in France a couple of centuries earlier,
under the Viking Rollo,
who became the first ruler of Normandy.
Their maritime technology hadn't lost its roots.
And how does archaeology back this up?
Fortunately, there have been plenty of excavations
of Viking-age and early-medieval vessels.
In the 1950s, a number of 11th-century Viking longships
were carefully excavated
from the bottom of Roskilde Fjord
at the Skoldelev harbour in Denmark.
These are now known as the famous Skoldelev ships.
And alongside the Gokstad ship,
discovered even earlier in Norway,
at the turn of the 20th century,
they show the exact same clinker-built construction technique
seen in the embroidery.
The overlapping planks,
the T-shaped axes used to split the timber,
the central masts,
and the side-mounted steering oars.
These are all features of Scandinavian maritime design.
Archaeology proves that these tapestry artists
weren't inventing fancifully grand ships.
They were accurately recording a traditional,
highly effective style of shipbuilding
that allowed William to ferry thousands of men across the sea.
So score one for historical accuracy.
Claim number two.
Did the Normans ride into battle on ponies?
If you look at the tapestry,
the horses look remarkably small
compared to the men riding them.
For generations, people just assumed this was bad art.
I mean, medieval perspective isn't exactly known
for being photorealistic, right?
Weird proportions are standard fare.
So, true or false?
This is actually true.
This is one of my absolute favourite facts
because it completely shatters
our modern pop culture image of medieval warfare.
When we think of a knight in shining armour,
we picture them charging into battle
on a massive, towering stallion,
a giant beast like a modern shire horse or a Clydesdale.
But the archaeological record
tells a completely different story.
A groundbreaking, massive zooarchaeological study
led by researchers at the University of Exeter
analysed thousands of medieval horse bones.
These were from 171 different sites in England,
dating from 300 to 1650 CE.
And what did they find?
They discovered that the vast majority
of medieval war horses,
including the highly prized Norman Destriers,
were actually under 14.2 hands high.
To put that in perspective for non-horse folks,
14 to 15 hands tall is the size of a modern large pony
or a very small, lightweight horse today.
It's about 1.5 metres.
So when the tapestry needle workers
embroidered these knights with their legs
dangling down past the horse's belly,
they were actually being incredibly accurate.
These small, compact, agile horses
were designed for speed, manoeuvrability
and quick bursts of power in the chaos of a medieval battle.
Being small, nimble and swift was a requirement.
Archaeology proves that the tapestry artists
were simply sewing what they saw,
a battlefield full of highly aggressive, armoured ponies.
Imagine that charging at you.
The military gear, weapons and armour
depicted during the chaotic battle scenes,
including the kite-shaped shields,
chainmail hoburks and terrifying axes,
are highly accurate reflections of real 11th century warfare.
True or false?
This one is an absolute ironclad truth.
And we've got the archaeology to back it up.
The tapestry provides a detailed visual account
of 11th century military technology.
We can see the Norman knights
wearing long mail shirts called hoburks,
conical helmets fitted with a protective metal strip
over the nose called a nasal guard
and they're carrying those distinctive,
elongated kite-shaped shields.
Meanwhile, the English Anglo-Saxon defenders
are shown using round or oval shields
equipped with massive two-handed battle axes
capable of cleaving a horse and its rider in a single blow.
For a long time, we only had these stylised images to go on.
But 20th century excavations changed that.
In an archaeological investigation
around the historic Battle Abbey site,
the actual location where the Battle of Hastings took place,
archaeologists recovered authentic weapons.
Among the finds was a genuine Norman long-tanged arrowhead,
specifically designed to penetrate heavy chain mail.
This is a ridiculously rare find,
not just because of the amount of time that's passed,
but because of the rampant looting
of the battlefield that followed.
Most loose weaponry and equipment,
particularly those off the bodies
of the defeated Anglo-Saxons,
are shown being looted in the margins of the tapestry.
You can actually see examples of this yourself
thanks to this episode's sponsor, HistoryHit.
Dr Emily Ward and Professor Michael Lewis
pieced together the entire story of the tapestry
with forensic detail,
alongside lovingly rendered shots
of the original piece in all its glory.
If you can't make it down to the British Museum,
I highly recommend uncovering the Bayeux Tapestry
if you haven't had your fill at the end of this video.
Anyways, back to the equipment.
In the tapestry,
one of the most obvious ways you can tell the armies apart
is from their shields.
Harold's army made use of the traditional,
Saxon-styled round shield,
whilst the invading Normans
kept a lighter kite-shaped shield
to cover the length of their bodies on horseback.
We can see this reflected in the historical record.
The Sutton Hoo burial site
contained the original metal accents,
rim, and shield boss of an Anglo-Saxon shield,
perfectly replicating the design
of those carried by the Saxons in the tapestry.
While we haven't got quite as lucky
finding surviving 11th-century kite shields in France,
there are plenty of contemporary illustrations
showing kite shields in use.
They were popular with the Vikings,
the Normans' Nordic ancestors,
and two surviving 12th-century kite shields
were discovered in Poland in the early 2000s.
Even more incredibly,
authentic battle axe heads
were discovered right where the Saxon front line
would have stood on that fateful day in battle.
In 1951, during some straightforward roadworks
over Marley Lane,
they uncovered the head of a Saxon battle axe
dated back to the 11th century.
These physical iron artifacts
match the shapes and proportions
of the weapons stitched into the linen cloth
almost perfectly.
You can see the axe head yourself at Battle Museum,
or, failing that,
the 2014 Hastings Special from Time Team.
Shout out to Sir Tony Robinson.
There's another part of the tapestry
that's committed to accuracy
that's a bit bloodier.
The margins stop showing birds and mythical beasts
and instead fill up with dismembered corpses,
severed heads,
and stripped bodies being plundered by scavengers.
This matches the harsh reality
uncovered in archaeology of medieval mass graves.
Excavations of historical battlefields across Europe
reveal that the primary cause of death
was massive trauma to the head and limbs
from heavy bladed weapons,
and that bodies were almost always stripped
of their valuable armor
immediately after the fighting stopped.
You can imagine that Anglo-Saxon needle workers
were keen to include this reminder in the margins,
that this glorious conquest
came at the brutal, bloody cost of their countrymen.
King Harold, the last Anglo-Saxon king of England,
died by taking an arrow straight to the eye
during the climax of the battle,
arguably the most famous scene in the entire tapestry
and the thing British school kids
are all taught in classrooms.
It's a legendary historical moment,
commemorated by a massive arrow sculpture
at the actual battle site today.
But is it archaeologically and historically sound?
Is it actually true?
This one is going to shock a lot of people,
but it is false.
Seriously, absolute fake news.
Now hang on, stay with me here
because we need to unpick some historical drama
to understand how this myth
became accepted as absolute fact.
If you look closely at that specific section
of the tapestry today,
you clearly see a man clutching an arrow
that is piercing his eye or helmet.
But here's the problem.
That's not what the original
11th century embroidery looked like.
We know this because of textile archaeology
and historical records.
The original tapestry has been transported,
rolled up and knocked about in the last 1,000 years,
consequently receiving a lot of damage.
So back in the 18th and early 19th centuries,
the tapestry underwent heavy French restoration
and scholars made detailed drawings and engravings
of the original textile.
And in those earliest surviving drawings,
that famous arrow isn't there.
Instead, the figure appears to be holding
a regular spear or a javelin.
Now, during the grand restorations of the 19th century,
French needle workers re-stitched
many damaged and frayed sections of the cloth.
Believing the later literary myths
that Harold died from an eye arrow,
they quite literally added new stitch lines,
transforming a broken spear shaft
into a fully fledged arrow,
hitting the king in the face.
To make things even more confusing,
the Latin inscription reads,
King Harold is killed,
right across this entire panel,
which features two distinct figures.
One is the man with the controversial arrow spear
and the other is a regular foot soldier
right next to him being brutally hacked to pieces
by a Norman cavalryman's sword.
In fact, some contemporary historical accounts
written right after the battle
actually state that Harold was cut down
by a squad of four Norman knights,
not picked off by an anonymous archer.
So logically, that would make the king
our unfortunate figure on the ground there.
So where did the myth most likely come from?
In the Middle Ages,
dying from an arrow to the eye
was considered the ultimate symbol of divine punishment
for a liar who broke a sacred oath.
The Norman narrative desperately needed Harold
to be a divinely punished villain.
So the story evolved over the centuries
and Victorian restorers literally stitched that myth
into physical reality.
Odds are it's a big hit piece from the Normans
and we've been passing it around as fact ever since.
A massive, terrifying and surprisingly hairy star
appeared in the night sky just months before the invasion.
Which the English court interpreted
as a catastrophic omen of impending doom.
In the 32nd scene of the tapestry,
we see a crowd of Anglo-Saxons
pointing up in absolute horror
at a bizarre multi-tailed celestial object
flying overhead
while King Harold sits trembling on his throne.
Is this cosmic event historical fact
or just theatrical flair?
True or false?
This one is true.
This one shocks a lot of people
because it feels like the kind of thing
that a work of propagandist art would feature.
A claim that their victory
was literally written in the stars.
But there is a scientific and credible reason
for why this star would have appeared
to those doomed Englishmen
on the eve of their great battle.
What those medieval stitchers were actually rendering
with their woolen threads
was none other than Halley's Comet.
Today, modern astronomers can calculate
the precise orbit of Halley's Comet
back through thousands of years.
And their calculations show
that the comet reached its perihelion,
its closest point to the sun,
at the end of April in exactly 1066.
Contemporary chronicles from all over the world
confirm this.
Records from the Byzantine Empire,
China, Ireland, and across Europe
all describe an incredibly bright, fiery star
with a long tail
that dominated the night sky for weeks.
They all corroborate the same thing.
To the people of 1066
who didn't understand orbital mechanics,
this was surely a terrifying message
written by the hand of God.
The inclusion of Halley's Comet in the embroidery
shows just how deeply embedded
this cosmic event was
in the collective memory of the generation
that lived through 1066.
Now, the Normans say that the comet
appeared around Harold's coronation
as an omen of ill portent,
which isn't strictly true.
It was April, months after Harold's coronation.
But we'll allow them that little bit of extra spin.
Beyond all the blood, guts, and cosmic portents,
the tapestry creates a historical record
of everyday life,
including cooking, feasting, elite architecture,
and cutting-edge medieval agricultural machinery.
True or false?
This is a resounding true.
While the battles get all the attention in history books,
for an archaeologist,
the domestic details in the tapestry are goldmine.
Because the needleworkers were everyday people,
they populated the background scenes
with the exact tools, buildings, and objects
they used in their own daily lives.
Let's talk about heavy machinery first.
In scene 10,
there's a small, easily overlooked image
of a man broadcasting seed across a field,
followed by a mule pulling a heavy,
spiked frame across the soil.
That frame is a harrow,
a vital agricultural tool used to break up clods of earth
and cover seeds to protect them from birds.
So why does this matter?
Because this tiny embroidery detail
is the earliest known visual representation of a harrow
in the entire history of Western Europe.
Before this find,
we only had vague written descriptions
of early medieval farming techniques.
This single image confirmed when and how
this crucial piece of agricultural technology
was being deployed in the English countryside.
Moving from the fields to the kitchen,
the tapestry gives us a clear insight
into a full medieval kitchen scene.
We see servants preparing a massive feast
for William and his nobles.
They're cooking meat over an open fire
on long, iron-roasting skewers,
transferring food onto flat platters,
and pouring wine into beautiful,
polished drinking horns with elaborate metal rims.
When we excavate medieval trash pits
or analyze high-status halls,
what do we find?
The exact same three-legged tables,
wooden bowls, iron skewers,
and decorative metal fittings for drinking horns
that are illustrated on the cloth.
Archaeology proves these needle workers
were sewing the exact kitchenware
used to serve William his victory dinner.
The same goes for the architecture.
The tapestry carefully illustrates elite structures,
including Edward the Confessor's Westminster Palace,
the spectacular tidal island of Mont Saint-Michel,
and the rapid construction
of a wooden Mott & Bailey Castle at Hastings.
Excavations of early Norman castle mounds across England
confirm that the timber palisades
and earthen profiles shown in the embroidery
are highly precise blueprints
of how these structures were built.
It's a complete 11th-century world,
perfectly preserved in thread.
The entire Norman invasion was completely,
legally, and morally justified
because Earl Harold had previously sworn
a solemn, sacred oath over holy relics
to support Duke William's claim to the English throne,
an oath he willfully broke.
This is the absolute core narrative arc
of the entire tapestry.
It is the political foundation
for everything that follows.
But is it an objective historical truth?
True or false?
This is perhaps unsurprisingly false.
Now, let's unpack this carefully
because while the act of swearing an oath
might have physically happened,
the narrative context surrounding it
was complete political spin.
According to the Norman story stitched into the cloth,
Harold traveled to Normandy voluntarily in 1064
on a diplomatic mission,
where he grew to love William,
fought alongside him,
and happily swore a vow to step aside
and let William take the crown when King Edward died.
That's the Norman account of everything that happened.
But when we look at independent contemporary accounts
and the broader historical and geopolitical reality
of the time,
a very different picture emerges.
Harold didn't go to Normandy for a holiday
or a voluntary diplomatic visit.
He was actually shipwrecked on the coast of Pontus
and captured by a local count
who then handed him over to William.
Takes on a different tone, doesn't it?
Harold was effectively William's captive
at the time of this supposed oath.
He was far away from home, isolated,
and completely under the physical control
of a notoriously ruthless medieval duke.
If Harold did place his hands on those holy relics
and swear an oath to support William,
he did so under extreme duress,
sort of like a forced confession.
In the medieval world,
an oath made while being held prisoner
could be considered legally and morally void
because it lacked free will.
However, it was still an oath in the eyes of God
and, from the Norman perspective, binding.
The Anglo-Saxon needle workers knew this
and were working under Norman supervision.
So they illustrated the event exactly as William demanded,
framing it as a voluntary binding contract
to make Harold look like a treacherous perjurer
who deserved a cosmic punishment.
Now, before we wrap this up,
I promised you a hilarious story of historical censorship
and it involves the scandalous parts of the tapestry
that the history books often leave out.
Let's look at the margins again,
where those needle workers had their fun.
If you look closely at the original 11th century borders
of the Bayeux Tapestry,
you'll find that the Anglo-Saxon needle workers
had a very bawdy sense of humor.
Scattered between the fables and birds
are highly explicit illustrations of little naked men,
rendered in full, unvarnished detail.
Hey, it was the Middle Ages.
People were less prudish.
Fast forward 800 years to the 1880s.
A group of talented English needle workers,
led by a woman named Elizabeth Wardle
and the Leek Embroidery Society,
decided to create a magnificent,
full-scale, accurate replica
of the entire 70-meter masterpiece
so that Britain could have its own copy.
Housed in the town of Reading,
just a short hop on the Lizzie line
from our studio here in London.
But when these highly respectable Victorian ladies
reached the scenes with the explicit little naked men,
they found their reference pictures
had been doctored by the staff at South Kensington Museum.
Their 19th century sensibilities simply couldn't handle it.
So they did as instructed,
but they took some creative liberties.
They literally censored the Norman conquest
with Victorian underwear.
And if you want to see this hilarious piece
of censorious 19th century history with your own eyes,
you can actually visit the full replica today
at the Reading Museum in England.
So, what have we learned from applying archaeology
to the world's most famous embroidery?
We've learned that while the overarching political narrative
is an incredible work of Norman propaganda,
the physical world it emulates is amazingly real.
From the clinker-built hulls of the longships,
the compact stature of the warhorses,
right down to the tiny iron arrowheads
and the earliest ever drawing of a farm harrow,
the Bayeux Tapestry is a vibrant living catalogue
of an era of massive transformation.
It may have engaged in a bit of a political spin,
but the truth of the event is all there to see.
And if you want to see this legendary artifact for yourself,
you are in absolute luck.
The original Bayeux Tapestry is scheduled to be on display
right here in London at the British Museum.
I will definitely be standing in line
to see those 70 meters of history in person.
And possibly telling everyone about the archaeology behind it all.
Now you can too.
So, what do you think?
Did Harold really get hit in the eye?
Or are you completely Team Spear Theory now?
Let me know your thoughts down in the comments below.
Don't forget to hit that like button,
subscribe to The Archaeologist's Notebook,
and ring that notification bell
so you never miss a dive into the past.
Thank you so much for watching,
and I'll see you in the next one.