Hertz made one of the biggest bets on electric vehicles in the rental car industry. It bought tens of thousands of EVs right as prices were near their peak. Then repair costs climbed, demand disappointed, resale values collapsed, and Hertz started dumping barely used Teslas for massive losses. Somehow, that was only the beginning. Hertz later embraced AI scanners that can automatically detect vehicle damage and bill customers without human review. Some renters ended up facing hundreds of dollars in charges over tiny dents they could barely see. Meanwhile, Hertz is sitting on roughly $18 billion in debt, spending hundreds of millions on interest, and facing questions over how it represented its liquidity to investors. The company even had to raise more debt just weeks after suggesting its cash position was improving. To make the whole story even stranger, used EV prices eventually rebounded after Hertz had already sold off much of its fleet. Hertz managed to buy near the top, sell near the bottom, take massive depreciation losses, and end up in an arguably worse financial position anyway. This is how one of America's biggest rental car companies went from bankruptcy comeback story to a company increasingly defined by debt, controversy, and a long list of questionable decisions.
TimeStamps: 0:00 - Hertz Downfall 1:06 - The EV Gamble 7:19 - Code Rabbit 8:59 - Every Scratch is Money 12:17 - “Soft Market”
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Hertz is facing a severe financial crisis caused by a failed EV strategy, controversial AI billing practices, and extreme debt. Massive depreciation of electric vehicles and poor market timing led to heavy losses, while aggressive AI-driven damage charges sparked customer backlash. The company is now struggling with $18 billion in debt and facing lawsuits over misleading investors.
Hey guys, quick note before we get into the video.
I've been pretty busy moving between states and working on my startup,
Silo, so my brother is filling in for me on this video.
Let me know what you think in the comments.
With that out of the way, let's get right into it.
The rental car business just had its best quarter in years, except for Hertz.
And the reason is pretty wild.
Their CEO said electric vehicles are now mainstream,
then soon after, dumped tens of thousands of EVs at a low price.
But things have gotten so much worse, and it seems like it's entirely their fault.
EVs are now the saving grace for the rental industry.
Hertz are also being sued for misleading shareholders.
And now, their AI will bill customers for fake damage without any human review.
Everything keeps getting worse and worse for Hertz.
So, how did it happen?
How did things go from bad to worse?
Okay, let's start with those EVs.
After that bold announcement from CEO Mark Fields,
Hertz announced it was going to add 100,000 Teslas to their fleet.
And that was just by the end of 2022.
Of course, the real number they got was about 35,000.
They also planned to buy 65,000 Polestar EVs over 5 years,
and were even planning to add models from GM's electric brands later on.
A bold move, but Hertz needed one.
They had just emerged from bankruptcy the previous year.
They also did this for a few reasons.
First, they thought this would lower costs.
Gasoline prices were high and volatile.
Not only that, EVs promised significantly lower overall maintenance costs.
No oil changes, no complex transmissions,
and fewer parts to break down meant less time in the shop and more time on the road making money.
At least, that's how it seemed.
But there's more.
The industry, at the time, was giving clear signals that EVs were the future.
Tesla had just passed a $1 trillion market cap.
Their profits were skyrocketing.
The legacy automakers were now pouring billions into battery factories.
So, it seemed that EVs were now mainstream, to quote CEO Mark Fields.
But things seemed to backfire in almost every way.
EVs don't need oil changes, but they have other problems.
Hertz found that its repair costs were actually 20%
higher than for comparable internal combustion vehicles.
If a Tesla gets in a minor collision, it often requires specialized,
expensive parts and labor that only the manufacturer can provide.
Data showed that the maintenance and repair costs for EVs
were significantly higher than for gasoline cars in its fleet.
Plus, while repair costs were high, adoption was low.
Range anxiety, the lack of charging infrastructure,
plus vacations often involve long-distance driving, which is a weakness of EV cars.
And this, with the high repair costs, contributed to an even bigger problem.
Hertz bought tens of thousands of EVs, expecting them to hold their value well
in the used car market after their rental life was over.
But the opposite happened.
Due to a multitude of factors, like soft demand, a trade war with China,
as well as an influx of cheaper EVs from China, prices for EVs began to come down.
Ford had to cut prices of the F-150 Lightning by as much as $7,000.
So what happens when the price of a brand new car drops by $7,000?
It hammers the resale value of every used model already on the market.
With all of this chaos happening, just imagine what was happening for Hertz.
Suddenly, the asset value part of Hertz EVs bet looked far worse than for gas cars.
Okay, so their EVs are worth less.
So what?
Well, rental car companies work a little differently.
Rental companies, like Hertz, use asset-backed securities.
If Hertz wants a $30,000 car, they borrow $30,000 against it.
The bank's security is the car itself.
While holding that car, they'll rent it out.
Let's say they make $18,000 while paying off that $30,000 with its interest.
Then sell it for maybe $22,000.
They repay the bank, but they made good rental income, so they profit.
There's operating costs and interest of course,
but the main thing is rental cars or less assets and more backed securities.
Hertz isn't really a company that owns half a million cars.
It's a company that operates half a million cars owned by bondholders.
So if used car prices drop, that's a bigger difference Hertz has to pay its lenders.
But Hertz' fleet was massive, so just a 1% drop in used car value costs Hertz about $75 million.
This is why they initially went bankrupt.
And when the pandemic killed travel and briefly tanked used car prices,
Hertz couldn't keep up with those payments.
But now it was happening all over again, just with EVs.
Hertz also saw $245 million in charges related to depreciating expenses from the EV sales
in just the fourth quarter of 2023.
Hertz began selling them off.
20,000 of them, many of which were Teslas, just two years after ordering them.
Many were barely used Tesla Model 3s, listed as low as $20,000.
Roughly half of what it had paid for them a year prior.
The depreciation hit was so severe that Hertz had to become
creative in unloading its excess EV inventory.
Hertz began asking renters if they wanted to buy the EVs.
For example, Hertz offered one customer a 2023 Chevy Bolt for about $18,400.
And another, a barely one-year-old Tesla Model 3 for $17,900.
This was bad.
But things have gotten so much worse, way worse.
This move, while it may have been smart at the time, has put Hertz in an even worse position
as EVs have unironically become the saving grace of rentals.
Now, Hertz are being sued by investors, but not for selling the EVs.
Something much worse.
But before we get to that, we need to talk about another new technology Hertz embraced.
Since EVs have gone so well, we have to talk about Hertz' strange experiment with AI.
AI has undoubtedly changed at least one industry, coding.
But this created a new bottleneck.
There's more AI code than ever, which means devs now spend more time reviewing code than
writing it.
And reviewing 30,000 lines of code by hand isn't realistic either.
But a generic agent doesn't fix it.
It can quickly lose context on past pull requests, comments,
changes, or discussions that happen in Slack outside the code.
That's why developers use CodeRabbit.
This is CodeRabbit, an AI code review agent that pull requests before it emerges,
finds the issues, and fixes them in one click.
It analyzes pull requests, reasons over your code base,
and gives you easily digestible feedback before changes are merged.
Reviewing a PR normally means reconstructing it file by file,
but those files are listed alphabetically, which tells you nothing about how the change works.
So, use a change stack, which regroups them into cohorts and layers.
So foundations come first, and the code depending on them comes after.
But that's just the start.
Inside the change stack, click on the overview page.
This gives you the full context, with a summary,
actionable blockers, along with all PR reviews and comments in place.
Then use TimelineView to see the full chronological story,
every change, approval, comment, so you don't have to piece together scattered threads.
So you know what happened, and just as importantly, why it happened.
CodeRabbit is installed on 3 million repositories
and reviews around 2 million pull requests every week.
Ship better code faster with CodeRabbit.
Try CodeRabbit by clicking the link in the description.
Thank you to CodeRabbit for sponsoring our videos.
In 2025, Hertz entered a maintenance partnership with UVI, worth tens of millions per year.
They said this would be transforming its vehicle maintenance process.
And soon, customers began to experience the, uh, fruit of this partnership.
Jessica Fields returned her Hertz car to the Atlanta airport.
She's a Hertz Gold member, so a loyal customer.
But 17 minutes later, she got a notification saying damage was detected.
I was really mostly confused because I didn't see any damage when I dropped off the car.
She returned and asked to see the car, but Hertz staff refused.
She asked for a manager.
She was declined.
So she chased up Hertz again and again, and she was finally given pictures of the damage,
as well as a charge.
Do you see the terrible state she left the car in?
Yeah, me neither.
Apparently, there were two minuscule dents in those orange squares.
Fields didn't see any damage when she dropped it off,
and it sure looks like there's no damage.
But then she got the bill.
$160 for the dents.
And $190 in administrative fees.
$190!
$350 in total.
When she tried to dispute the charges, the email link mysteriously didn't work.
Thing is, Hertz aren't the only ones using AI to detect damages.
But Hertz are a bit special.
Some other car rental companies reportedly use AI as a tool,
but require human staff to review before billing customers.
However, Hertz is apparently the only car rental company in the US
that issues damage assessments to customers without human review.
Yeah, so the $190 for administration is basically free revenue for Hertz.
Because it's not like a human went and looked at it.
It's not just fields either.
Hertz said that fewer than 3% of vehicles scanned by their system are billed for damages.
Though, whether that 3% actually have damaged vehicles is another story.
You could see Hertz' focus.
Future technology?
Maybe.
But primarily, ways to cut down costs by removing areas of labor.
And maybe implicitly, get more money out of customers.
But here's where the story gets a bit complicated.
Revenue for Hertz is down 6%.
2024 was also down 3.44%.
But they're now making way more money.
And in Q2 2026, they had a gap net income of $64 million.
At least, that's the way it seems.
In reality, things couldn't be worse for Hertz.
They are currently drowning in debt.
And despite promising that they had strong cash to survive,
just a few weeks later, had to go and raise more debt.
Now, they're being sued.
Plus, there's the most ironic part of all of this.
The EVs they sold, which turned out to be a saving grace, just not for Hertz.
If you've watched this far, consider subscribing.
It helps the channel and means you won't miss future videos.
In Q4 2023, Hertz had $245 million worth of depreciation charges that quarter alone.
So, they sold.
After selling them off en masse at a huge discount,
EVs are now the best performing segment in the market.
In 2026, the EV index was up 12% year over year, and non-EVs were up just 1.7%.
So, Hertz bought the peak with EVs, sold at the bottom, before EVs spiked.
Nice.
For those still holding EVs, their financials are much better,
and their asset value is up, so depreciation cost is down.
But, Hertz didn't get those benefits.
And potentially even worse, their stated reason for selling was wrong.
They sold because they thought EVs wouldn't hold value.
And now, it's the opposite.
Of course, the market could change again, but the timing for Hertz couldn't be worse.
And, it gets worse.
In mid-2026, Hertz stated,
Current unexpected softness in the used car market caused losses,
and caused them to adjust their EBITDA forecast.
But, that doesn't seem to be the case.
Cox Automotive's Mayhem Index tells a different story.
The MUVVI reached 212.9 in June, up 2.1% year over year.
And remember, EVs were up 12%.
Fairly suspicious.
Which brings us to an even bigger problem they have right now.
After emerging from their 2020 bankruptcy, Hertz had lost a lot of money.
A net loss of $747 million in 2025, and a $2.8 billion loss in 2024.
Hertz had no money, and they owed a lot.
Hertz had two giant debt piles.
The vehicle debt, which we talked about in Chapter 1,
is about $12.7 billion, car loans backed by cars.
But also, another non-vehicle debt.
Corporate debt.
Total debt is $18 billion, which makes their interest expenses pretty big.
$259 million just for Q2 2026, and for the first 6 months, $515 million.
As for Q2 2026, that gap net income of $64 million wasn't really from the business.
Gap net income benefited from gains on the sale of real estate locations,
on which we completed sale leaseback transactions,
as well as re-evaluation of other exchangeable notes and warrants issued in prior years.
A just net loss was actually $47 million.
So they don't have money, and they have a ton of debt,
which means a ton of interest, which it's already paying with debt or other means.
So the question became, how long can this company keep operating
before it needs to ask someone for money?
Which brings us to their Q1 earnings call,
and Hertz Liquidity, the reason they're being sued for misleading shareholders.
In the call, CFO Scott Harrelson said liquidity was $837 million,
expected to reach just under $1 billion by the end of Q2, and north of $1.5 billion by year end.
This is basically the cash they have, and what they can draw immediately.
Harrelson was basically saying that Hertz has a long runway,
and can safely pay their operating costs and obligations for a good while,
without taking on more debt.
But just 6 weeks later, after promising liquidity was good,
Hertz, you guessed it, needed money.
But there was a problem.
No one wants to lend to a company like Hertz.
They're not doing well.
So they did something else.
They announced a $350 million bond at 6.75% interest.
They then cut their profit forecast to somewhere between $50 and $80 million.
To get that $350 million, they issued new shares,
37 million of them, and lent them to JPMorgan Chase.
And this is crazy.
One of its affiliates intends to sell the borrowed shares
and use the resulting short positions to facilitate transactions
by which investors in the notes.
The activity described above could affect the market price of the common stock.
Basically, Hertz lent them shares to short,
aka betting against Hertz' stock, which Hertz doesn't receive proceeds from.
Not only was their liquidity promise just not true,
but to get more capital, they had to let someone bet against their own stock.
Even worse, there wasn't enough stock around to borrow to do so.
Roughly 30% of the tradable stock is sold short,
about 10 times what a normal company carries.
They just made more, diluting existing shareholders.
So you can probably guess what happened next.
The allegation is that Hertz told investors the money was fine
when it knew this was coming.
Strangely enough, the lawsuit named the defendants as the company, of course.
But also CEO Gil West and CFO Scott Harrelson.
The more ironic thing, I think, is that Hertz technically hit their goal.
It landed at $984 million in liquidity.
Just to get that liquidity, it needed more debt and to dilute shares.
It's not a bad time to be a rental car company.
But boy is it a bad time to be Hertz.
They're barely a company at this point and more a debt and interest paying machine.
Little profit, high liabilities.
Will they collapse?
Who knows.
But their current state might be even worse.
Hertz isn't the only car company in a strange position.
You might recognize this.
The Carvana vending machine.
A used car dealership which somehow ended up on the S&P 500.
And the whole thing might be a gigantic pump and dump.
Click here to learn the rest of the story.
But until next time, I'm Shreed.