China’s economic miracle is starting to look like an economic nightmare. Paychecks are shrinking, spending is drying up, and even government employees are taking major pay cuts. Beijing says it has a plan to fix the economy. But what if the CCP’s solution is making things even worse?
Want to know what REALLY scares the CCP? YOU! Join the China Uncensored 50 Cent Army today! https://chinauncensored.tv Operation Honey Pot: Paste this emoji 🍯 in your comment below.
China is currently trapped in a deflationary spiral, where negative economic expectations lead to defensive saving, collapsing demand, and subsequent wage cuts. Despite the CCP's attempts to stimulate consumption through \"Common Prosperity\" and redistribution, retail spending remains stagnant as systemic mismanagement persists.
Chinese people are going broke.
Welcome to China Uncensored, I'm Chris Chappell.
Join me in fighting YouTube censorship by engaging in Operation Honeypot.
Leave a honeypot emoji in the comments below in honor of everyone's favorite pooh bear.
Go to China, Elon Musk says. It's awesome.
I mean, look at what you'll see.
Wow, China is living in the future.
Totally worth the risk that you might be wrongfully detained.
So, yeah, maybe that's bad advice.
You'd think an African American would be more upset about mass incarceration.
Sure, this looks cool, but it hides something really dark.
Chinese people are going broke.
Okay, there are plenty of other dark things I could talk about.
By the way, I don't even know what's playing on screen right now.
I literally just told my editor, take your pick.
Nightmare fuel is China's main export.
But this is an economic episode.
I know, most of my viewers feel military topics are what's sexy.
But if you want to hear something really sexy,
let's talk about deflationary spirals.
Oh baby!
A deflationary spiral happens when people become negative about the future of the economy.
So they start saving money defensively.
That makes demand for consumer goods collapse.
So merchants and platforms embrace wars and cut prices.
But that erodes their profits.
So companies lay off staff or cut wages.
That means income declines more.
And then people have even more negative expectations.
And it all just spirals.
Oh, bet we get demonetized for that one.
Gonna need to put a content warning on this for all that smutty dirty talk.
Subscribe to ChinaUncensored.tv.
This is a deeply serious show.
Anyway, here's the thing about deflationary spirals.
They're a really slow, painful way for an economy to die.
And that's exactly what's happening in China.
And it all goes right back to the CCP.
For a while now, China has been seeing slowing wage growth.
But it's gotten worse over the past few years.
There's been widespread pay cuts that's driving down consumer spending.
From central government offices in Beijing to major state-owned enterprises,
employees have faced substantial pay reductions that have reduced household budgets.
And when I say substantial pay reductions, I mean substantial.
One woman speaking to ABC said,
I can barely make a living.
Probably leading many to say,
la-ti-da, Ms. Fancy Pants here bragging about barely making a living,
while most of us can't make one at all.
Meanwhile, a Shandong resident said that
county and township-level officials in their province had their salaries slashed by 30%.
So it's not just the common man suffering.
The Party bureaucrats have been suffering as well.
Hmm, not good for the regime.
By the way, that Shandong resident gave a fake name to Radio Free Asia for safety reasons.
Well, doesn't that just tell you something about how awesome China is?
People are terrified of their government finding out they complained about their pay cuts.
Can you imagine someone in the US being afraid of criticizing the government?
Our country is founded on that.
That and whatever's going on here.
He's fine, by the way.
But Red Bull or whatever energy drink was behind this probably needs a new marketing strategy.
But it gets worse.
What's really bad for the regime is that benefits for police officers have also been reduced.
Authoritarian regimes really don't last long when the muscle isn't happy.
These muscles are less happy than my quads when I do a leg day at the gym
for the first time in 6 years.
Don't worry though, the Party still finds plenty of money for the military.
But the pay cuts have driven down consumer spending.
This has been going on for more than a year now.
Complex economic point here, but when people don't have money, they don't spend money.
That's this part of the deflationary spiral.
Which is why back in July, the CCP unveiled a new plan to boost consumption.
Not that kind of consumption.
The idea makes sense, at least on paper.
If you can somehow get people to spend more,
businesses have more money, so they hire and expand.
They create more jobs.
People have more money, so they spend.
And that ends the deflationary spiral.
But how do you get people to spend more when they don't have money?
Let me introduce you to the magic of communism.
I'm sure it's worked every time it's been tried.
Back in 2021, Xi Jinping lifted a line out of Mao's playbook
by calling for Common Prosperity.
Xi wasn't using it how Mao used it.
China's not going back to collectives.
At least not yet.
Xi just kind of wanted to narrow the massive wealth gap that exists in China.
So he vowed to adjust the excessive incomes of the super rich.
But don't worry, Common Prosperity does not mean killing the rich.
They have to clarify, because they really did that back in the day.
But here's how it supposedly works.
The state is just going to spread the wealth around a bit,
take more money from the really rich,
and put it into ordinary folks' pockets.
Then they'll buy stuff, and China can get out of its deflationary hole.
Deflationary hole.
Found the name for this economic porno.
It started in the finance industry.
Last year, Chinese authorities announced a new round of finance sector pay cuts
to reduce costs and increase efficiency.
The finance sector in China is a bunch of state-owned banks and institutions,
so the Party can easily do that.
Okay, cool.
Take money away from the people who are, you know, economically productive.
That's what the finance sector does.
Sounds like communism so far.
And next, they're going to redistribute it to the people, right?
Right?
Well, hey, remember all those Party bureaucrats that had pay cuts?
China's government has increased the wages of public service workers.
Yep, sounds like communism.
According to Xue Haoling, a Monash University economics professor,
the government workers lay the foundation for the government's management.
China relies on them for keeping their government stable.
Could it be that communists aren't actually good at planning an economy?
But they force businesses to run fancy light shows,
regardless of their energy bill.
Some Chinese regions are also raising minimum wages,
with the question being, will it help boost consumption?
So bureaucrats and minimum wage earners might be getting more money.
Well, great!
At least some people have more money, right?
Is consumption going up?
Is China pulling out of that deflationary hole?
Well, the numbers are in.
In July, during the busy summer and holiday season,
China's National Bureau of Statistics predicted a modest 1.5% growth in retail spending.
It ended up being 0.6%.
Oh dear.
In fact, just a few months ago,
consumer spending actually fell for the first time since Covid.
People still aren't spending.
There could be a lot of reasons for that.
They could feel pessimistic
because of oil shortages caused by the Iran War.
Or that there's been ongoing issues with, forget pay cuts,
people not getting paid at all.
Or it could be that the mandatory increases in minimum wage
are shuttering all the small businesses
who now have to suddenly pay their employees more
while they're stuck in a deflationary spiral.
See, this story is exciting.
I bet you're glad you clicked.
The loss of small businesses means
fewer jobs and less money in people's pockets,
despite the state increasing minimum wages.
It's almost like communists aren't good at planning an economy.
So Chinese people are going broke.
And there doesn't seem to be a way out,
at least not with the CCP planning the economy.
But hey, at least the CCP has enough money for its military.
And you can make sure I don't go broke
for making a show that speaks out against China
on a platform that likes to censor and demonetize
channels that speak out against China.
By joining my exclusive website, ChinaUncensored.tv.
I mean, if you thought the deflationary spiral was hot,
well, you see what I put on my own website,
where I don't have to worry about YouTube censorship.
Just click here or the link below.
Once again, I'm Chris Chappell.
See you next time.