Will the new ERISA disability regulations help disability claimants?

Disability Insurance
6 followers
28 Video Views·Sep 11, 2026
As of April 1, 2018, new regulations from the U.S. Department of Labor’s governing Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) disability benefit claims became effective. Disability insurance attorneys Gregory Dell and Cesar Gavidia discuss how these new regulations affect disability insurance claims.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedGreg Dell and Cesar Gavidia discuss the 2018 Department of Labor ERISA regulations aimed at protecting disability insurance claimants. They analyze new disclosure requirements for benefit denials, the potential for increased transparency, and the long-term legal timeline for these rules to impact court rulings and insurance company behavior.
Hi, I'm Greg Dell here with Cesar Gavidia, and Cesar, I want to talk to you about these
new Department of Labor ERISA regulations, and it started back in, actually it's been
going on for years, and in December of 2016, the Department of Labor said, guess what,
we have these new rules and we're trying to protect consumers, I mean, they're trying
to make it better for claimants, and then they took a lot of comments and feedback back
and forth, and then finally, April 1st, 2018, the new regulations went into place, and they
said all the insurance companies had to be in compliance with these new regulations,
so we're only filming this video in August of 2018, so it's only been about coming up
on five months of these regulations being in place, so I want to talk to you a little
bit about one particular aspect of the new regulations and how we are starting to see
some companies implement them and what kind of impact we think these changes are going
to have.
So, one of the biggest things that was going on was the improvements to the disclosure
requirements, and basically what that is, and obviously we're only talking about ERISA
claims, is what information does a disability insurance company need to give to a claimant
in the initial stage when they deny a claim, and then again on appeal, and there's lots
of things that were changed, so I'm going to go through a few of these and we'll discuss
what impact we think this change is going to have, and if we've seen anything yet at
all.
So, the first one is saying that when you get a benefit denial notice, it must contain
a complete discussion of why the plan denied the claim and the standards applied in reaching
the decision.
That sounds like familiar language.
It sounds like what they were supposed to be doing in the first place, completely disclosing
the reasons for denial and explaining why that person's specifically being denied so
that they could appropriately address it through an appeal.
So it sounds almost like they're saying you have to just keep doing the same thing.
Well, yes, I mean that is what they were saying beforehand, but I think what happened is they,
you know, when they opened this up for public comment, they got about 175 letters from insurance
companies, from lawyers, from the advocate groups and all of that stuff, and basically
what they said is this is a problem that these denial letters, and how often do we get these
one or two page denial letters that basically say nothing.
So the idea is they're saying, look, you need to be more complete.
Whether or not we're going to see a change, I doubt it.
I don't know what you think or what you're starting to see.
Every company is going to be different.
I think it's still too early.
I'm not seeing much of a change yet.
I don't know what you've seen.
Well, I can tell you that there are companies that, you know, we're getting recent denials
on that the denial letters seem just as vague as they were pre-January 2018 when the regulations
went into effect.
So in terms of more completeness or more detail explaining why the person is not entitled
to benefits, I'm still seeing and we're still seeing the medical records don't support your
restrictions and limitations.
Not explaining what the medical record, what they need to see in terms of what type of
restrictions and limitations should be imposed, what their doctors and the physician consultants
that they consult are specifically opining.
Sometimes they don't even give the identity of that physician consultant.
They're still doing that.
So in terms of...
Well, that's going to segue us into the other thing that they said.
But you know, everything we're going to discuss today is going to take months if not years
to play out.
Because even with...
So these regulations went into place April 1st, 2018, so that means it doesn't apply
to anyone until anyone who was denied after April of 2018 and then anyone denied after
April 1st of 18 has six months to do an appeal, which goes to October of 2018.
And then if they deny that claim, we're first going to be filing lawsuits at the end of
2018.
And by the time we get around to the courts and asking them to, you know, enforce these
new regulations against the company to determine if they acted unreasonably or violated the
new procedures, we're not looking to opinions on this new law till late 2019 at the soonest.
And that's in the district court.
Then if they're appealed, we're not going to have any appellate law on this till 2020.
So you're looking at actual binding opinions at some point in 2021, 2022, maybe 2020.
Yeah.
Well, I'm hopeful it's 2020, but we'll see.
So let's segue into the next one where you mentioned that they don't even name who the
doctor is.
And the next regulation change was the basis for disagreeing with the views of healthcare
or vocational professionals whose opinions were provided by the claimant or obtained
at the behest of the plan, regardless of whether they were relied upon in making the claim
determination.
So basically that's saying that they have to provide a basis for why they disagree with
the plaintiffs or the claimant's doctors and or the vocational rehabilitation.
Now if this happens, it would be shocking to me because it's rare, in my opinion, that
they comment other than just list the records.
What do you think?
Yeah, I think you're right.
They basically regurgitate the medical chronology, the medical records, the medical history,
and they really don't address specifically what distinguishes their doctor's opinion
from the claimant's doctor's opinion.
Right.
Because it says right here, the basis for disagreeing with the views of healthcare.
And what they added here was vocational professionals as well.
Right.
You know, as a tip to anyone who's watching this, and some people choose to do their own
appeal, is, I mean, if they got to respond to all of this, you better try to get as many
doctors as you can to give opinions, and voc rehabilitation reports are going to become
that much more important.
And the other thing is, and I think people need to be aware out there, that if they are
pursuing the appeal process, I don't see any claims, any appeals being done within that
first 45-day period that they have to decide these appeals.
So expect that it's going to be extended to those 90 days.
Right.
So we'll see how that plays out, but I'm definitely going to really possibly increase the doctor
support and consider a lot more voc rehabilitation reports.
It also says, which is something that was out there from case law, but now they've kind
of codified it into the law, was they have to provide their basis for disagreeing with
a finding of disability by the Social Security Administration.
How many times do we see the language that just says, oh, their standards are different
than ours, therefore we're not going with that?
I don't think that's not going to fly anymore.
It's not.
And, you know, quite honestly, the fact that they have to now specifically explain what
is different, I've never seen in one denial letter them address Social Security Disabilities
independent physician consultant that is, you know, not even retained, that they go
out and have, do a complete review of that claimant's medical file, their medical history,
their restrictions and limitations.
I've never seen them once address that.
So it's going to be interesting to see it now, if they do.
And it's going to be important to get the Social Security file, and keep in mind, you
may not know this, well, you know this, but they may not know this, it can take quite
a while to get the full Social Security file, sometimes months, unfortunately, to get a
complete copy of the file.
And I did see just recently in an appeal that I'm handling, the disability insurer say,
we need extra time because we're requesting the Social Security file.
That used to be on the claimant to provide.
That was their responsibility.
In this case, and it still may be, but the disability insurer is actually proactively
going out to obtain that Social Security file.
Right.
I still think the claimant has the burden of getting it.
I agree.
But if they're asking for it, then.
The next part of this improvements to disclosure requirements is that the benefit denial notice
must contain the specific internal rules, guidelines, protocols, standards, or other
similar criteria the plan relied upon in making the adverse determination or a statement
that such guidelines do not exist.
And that statement used to only come in the denial letter after the appeal.
So that's a big change because a lot of people call us, well, not a lot, but some people
call us and say, I did my own appeal.
And they never got any of the protocols, the guidelines, or anything that the carrier relied
upon to make the determination.
So now basically all the claim handling and everything that the disability carriers rely
upon, they're going to have to tell them right away in that initial letter, hey, this is
available for you and the companies are going to have to have their act together and provide
all of that stuff.
And the reason that's important is because if there is some departure from the procedures
and guidelines that they have in place, that could be the basis to finding that they acted
in an arbitrary and capricious manner if it has to go beyond the appeal stage into litigation.
The last one, which is interesting, is it says, benefit denial notices must contain
if the denial is based on a medical necessity, experimental treatment, or similar exclusion,
an explanation of the scientific or clinical judgment for the determination or a statement
that such will be provided free of charge upon request.
So we almost never see that.
Never.
Talking about the medical necessity or experimental treatment, I mean, we almost never get anything
on that.
So I don't think we'll see much of a change on that.
But these rules, which was funny, when it came out from the Department of Labor and
you look at their intent of what it was, and they say, the new rules add important
procedural protections and consumer safeguards for claims for disability benefits.
They protect claimants from conflicts of interest, increases transparency, and ensures that claimants
have a fair opportunity to respond to the evidence and reasoning behind the decision.
The rules also ensure that protections for disability claimants parallel protections
that already apply when workers file claims for group health benefits.
So that's the goal.
That's language straight from the Department of Labor.
That's not our opinion, which may be sometimes biased because we always help claimants.
So that's the intent here.
That's what's going to be in the Code of Federal Regulations for Section 503.
And those are things that we're going to argue in court documents and say, judge, this is
not what it was pre-April 2018.
This is a new, hopefully tilting the scales more towards the claimant, that this has to
be fair, this has to be transparent, they have to act reasonably.
They can't try to hide behind this curtain and talk like it's the wild, wild west of
how they're going to evaluate a claim.
So they didn't go as far as getting rid of discretionary clauses, which we would have
liked to have seen them do.
But I think they're heading in the right direction to try to make it more lax and better for
claimants.
I think so.
And I was surprised not to see that as well.
Because there are, as you know, a number of states, I think we're around 11 or 12 states
now that have banned the discretionary clauses.
And we really need uniformity there.
Uniformity in the sense that it's banned across the nation.
Because it's what tilts the scales in favor of the insurance company in almost every case.
Right.
Well, we're going to watch all of these regulations as they progress, and we're going to continue
to report on how each company is implementing these changes so that claimants around the
country can be aware of what's going on and hopefully help them to continue their claim
or help them out with their appeals if they get denied.
We're going to talk, we're going to do some other videos about some of the other changes
that have been made to the regulations and how we think that will impact claimants.
Again, overall, I think this is a good thing for claimants.
I'm hoping that it will help as much as the Department of Labor intends for it to.
If you have any issues with any disability insurance carrier, whether it's short-term
or long-term disability, feel free to call any of our attorneys.
We always offer a free initial phone consultation, and we welcome the opportunity to speak with you.
