6 Insurance Company Tricks After a Texas Car Accident (Don’t Fall for These)

Auto Insurance
2 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 10, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedPersonal injury lawyer Shane McGuire explains six common tactics insurance companies use to minimize payouts and details the strategies his firm employs to combat them, emphasizing the importance of documentation, expert testimony, and patience during negotiations.
Hey, I'm Shane McGuire, personal injury lawyer here in Texas, and today I want to talk about
six things that illustrate how insurance companies think. So six areas where insurance companies have
a particular way of thinking and then what we do to combat it. So number one, if there's not
immediate treatment, you're not injured. That's what they say. And here's what happens. You get
in a car wreck, you have adrenaline going, you're like, ah, maybe I'll get over it. Maybe I'm just
going to be sore and you try to move past it. Man, an insurance company, you don't go to the ER
within a couple of days after a wreck. They just think that you're not hurt. So you call me after
a wreck and you say, Shane, I was in a wreck. I didn't immediately go to the ER. Maybe you're
worried about money. Maybe you're worried about the hassle. I'm going to tell you,
go to an urgent care facility or go to one of these freestanding ERs where they will cater to
you and you can get in and out pretty quick. That will A, make you feel better and B, will redound
to your benefit later as we are negotiating your case. So don't let them get away with saying
you're not injured. Go to a doctor and have them document that you're injured and treat you for
the injury. All right. Two, second thing the insurance companies have is that if you're not
engaged in active treatment, then you're not injured. Now, listen, there's some injuries
for which you're not going to do active treatment. You have broken ribs,
you're just going to sit there and hurt. Okay. There are things like that for which there's
not a lot of ongoing treatment, but for the most part, you have a back injury, shoulder injury,
neck injury, knee, man, we need you going to the doctor, getting physical therapy,
going to the Cairo, getting an orthopedic consult. And so what we do to combat this is
even in a non-catastrophic case, even if you're hurting, but you're not like overwhelmingly hurt,
hey, we're going to send you to the doctor. We're going to make sure that you get chiropractic,
PT, pain management if you need it, because we're not going to let that insurance company just say
that you're not hurting. We have to document your pain and do what we can to make you feel better.
All right. Third little trick insurance companies have is regarding medical bills. It's like
Goldilocks and the three bears. They will say your medical bills are too low. And so we don't
very much. Or they're going to say they're too high and they're going to hire experts to say
your bills are too high. How is that even possible? You go to the doctor and let's say you
use your health insurance to pay for all of your medical treatment. That health insurance write
down, it's going to make your bills super low. You've seen those EOBs that you get after you've
gone to the doctor. You may have been charged $5,000 for something. And then health insurance
is a contractual write-off to get it down to like 800 bucks. Well, the auto insurance carrier sees
that and they're like, oh, you have $800 in medical bills. We will settle your case for $2,000.
And then conversely, if your medical bills are 10,000, they'll say, oh, your medical bills are
10 grand. That's way too high. Your medical bills should have been 1,500. We will now pay you $2,000
to settle your case. It doesn't matter. They'll say your medical bills are so low that you're
not going to get a lot of damages or your medical bills are too high. And so they're not going to
give you a lot of damages. So how do you combat that? We have experts that we hire at McGuire
Firm to testify to the reasonableness of the charges of the providers that our clients see.
You have to have that to prove your damages at trial and to prove it to where an insurance
company is going to be willing to pay you for it. Your doctor's charge for treatment
is reasonable and customary in the geographic area where that treatment took place.
Okay. Fourth trick insurance companies have, they'll say, if you're done treating,
you're not hurting anymore. This comes up all the time. Often, here's where you see it,
is my client will have had, say, a back or a neck surgery or a shoulder surgery. And you're like,
okay, you know, you're done. You've cycled through a bunch of care leading up to that.
And then you had a surgery. And so you're not really in active care at that point.
However, you come to me and you're 35 years old, you're 40 years old, and you have a back surgery.
Hey, I got news for you. You're going to be doing a lot better because of that surgery,
but you're not done with your lifetime of treatment. So you're going to have to go
back to the doctor. And there's all kinds of literature about how the body continues to break
down after a lumbar fusion or after this or that knee surgery or shoulder surgery or whatever.
Once you're tinkering with the body, man, there is kind of a lifetime of issues with that.
You're better because you had the procedure. You're better than you otherwise would be.
But it's not like you're totally fixed for all time. So you are going to have damages going
forward. Don't let the insurance company get away with that. So here's what we do at McGuire Firm.
We hire a life care planner. Her job is to write down every aspirin you're going to have to take
for the rest of your life as a result of the injuries you had in the wreck that you hired
me for. So the way you combat the, oh, you're done treating is you hire a life care planner.
That life care planner talks to the physician who did the surgery and they will outline future
care and needs that you have. And then we use that to negotiate the claim and then try the
case if we have to try the case. Going along with that, number five is they will argue,
you know, you had a preexisting condition. Anybody, any client I've ever had over the age of
like 25, the defense, the insurance company is going to hire some doctor who has decided instead
of healing people for a living, he would like to shill for insurance companies and write reports
saying this guy had a preexisting condition and so we don't owe for the back surgery that he has.
Well, here's the reality. Every human being starts to degenerate after a certain age. You look at
anybody's spine, an MRI of anybody's spine after the age of like 25 or 30 and you are going to see
what doctors call degenerative changes, just like the graying of the hair. You're going to see
degenerative changes in the back or in the knees or whatever. But you know what? That doesn't mean
that you can't be injured because of a car accident. It's critically important that your treating
physician, the treating surgeon in your case, is not only a surgeon who can fix you, who can treat
you for your injuries, but is a surgeon who is an advocate for the patient. You need to have
physicians you can trust who will say, yeah, this person has degenerative changes in his back,
but they were exacerbated by the car wreck and the injury he had in that wreck. And this surgery is
not due to degenerative changes. It's due to the injury he had in the car wreck. And so you have to
have a physician who is also a patient advocate in the context of the case. And we have that at
McGuire Firm. And man, I can't tell you how beneficial that is for our clients at the end
of the day. Lastly, negotiating. Here's something you need to know about negotiating. Insurance companies,
they always want to do this. They will always settle your case. They'll always settle it
cheaply and early. If you want a quick settlement, you're going to get a quick undersettlement. So
sometimes you need that. Sometimes I've had a client who has a grave financial issue, but that's
not what you want. What you want is to be able to hold out. So at McGuire Firm, we pride ourselves
on maxing out the value of every single case. And so here's what I wanted to share. I just had this
case settled yesterday for $2 million and here was the case. So it was a UTV wreck and my client was
unbelted passenger in a UTV and the driver of the UTV was underage. They flipped the UTV and my
client is seriously injured. And there's a lot of insurance in this case. Well, my client, her
medical treatment was paid for by health insurance. So whereas if it was not health insurance, her
medical bills may have been half a million dollars, her medical bills were maybe a hundred thousand
dollars. But we hire a life care planner to talk about her future care and needs. We also hire an
expert to talk about how those future care and needs are reasonable. The pricing for that is
reasonable. And then you have to have an economist back that up to present value. We hired an engineer
to map out how that wreck happened and how it was the driver's fault. And you put all that stuff
together, but then you're not ready to negotiate the case until after you've gone through significant
discovery. So with regard to negotiation, a year ago, I got a call saying, Shane, the primary
carrier has $10.5 million. Do you want it? And I said, I appreciate that call, but I don't want it.
The case is worth more than that. So finally we mediate the case and I start off way high and we
ultimately end up at $2 million. And the only way I could settle that case with $2 million from my
client is by turning down a million and them saying over and over again, Hey, all we have is a million.
I'm not going to take that. And then they said, well, if I make a call, I can get one and a half
million. And so the mediators working with us is like, Hey, you know, what do you want me to do
this? And I said, here's the reality. I did work for insurance companies for years.
They're not saying they could make the call and get one and a half unless they knew they can make
the call and get one and a half. So they've already talked about it. And what they do is
they put these structures in place to make it act like it's more difficult to negotiate
than what it is. So they'll round table these cases and shoot the bull about value,
then send the frontline adjuster out to the mediation and say, Hey, try to bring this in
for a million dollars. But if you need to, if you need us to say, you're going to make a call
and we'll settle it up to 1.5 or whatever. That's what the setup was. It's like dealing
with the finance guy at the car dealership. You know, there's something kind of scammy going on,
but you don't know what it is. Well, I've been on that side of the docket. I know exactly what it
is. So when the mediator says, Hey, they said, if they can make a call, they could get one five,
maybe I said, well, we know they have one five. And then the mediator goes in and says, Hey,
if I did a proposal at 1.75, would you, how much pushback would I get? And they're like,
well, we don't think you would get a ton of pushback. Well, now I know that they've been
told to come settle the case with me. And so the whole day I was at $2 million.
Like they had 2.5 in insurance. I was like, I'm just going to do this for $2 million.
And I told them from the very beginning, I have this at 2 million and I'm not budging.
I'll just let you know what my number is. I'm seriously 45 minutes into the mediation.
I just told them my number. And then eventually they believed me and they paid us $2 million.
Why? Because I had done all the work on the front end because I had a great client who trusted me.
You map out liability with the engineer and the damages with the physicians and the life care
planner. And then you're ready to talk about money. Money is literally the last thing you
talk about in these cases, because you don't know what the case is worth until you've addressed the
6 things that we've talked about in this video. And for more advice on how to maximize the value
of your car wreck cases, follow us at Meguiar Firm. Subscribe to Meguiar Firm.
