The Geoff Wilson Show: Your Best Arguments AGAINST My Card Market Optimism
17 Video Views·Sep 9, 2026
So last week I put out an episode titled,
this isn't 2021,
why I'm not worried about a sports card market crash.
And you guys had a lot to say about it.
Now in that show,
I explained that even though the sports card market
is unbelievably red hot right now,
I'm still very bullish about the long-term.
And while a short-term downward price correction
is certainly possible and potentially even likely,
I said that I believed the market as a whole
would be significantly higher in five to 10 years
than it is today.
Some of you agreed with what I said.
Some of you thought I was completely insane.
And some of you made arguments that caused me to rethink
or at least refine some of what I said.
So let's talk about it.
The Jeff Wilson Show is brought to you by Arena Club,
the official home of Slab Packs.
Now available every day,
Slab Packs offer an exciting way
to collect rated cards with confidence.
Plus every pack comes with an instant offer
to buy your slab.
Don't miss out.
Explore the latest Slab Packs and more
by downloading the Arena Club app.
Just search Arena Club in the app store
and use promo code SCI for 20% off your first purchase.
Here we go from the Arena Club studio inside Cards HQ.
Now I'm not gonna rehash my whole video from last week
about the reasons why I think this isn't 2021
and why I'm not worried about a sports card crash
or at least a 2021 style sports card market crash
happening again.
I assume many of you probably saw the video last week
or maybe saw some of my posts on social media about it.
Well, I know a lot of you saw the video
or saw the posts because there were hundreds,
maybe thousands of comments.
And I understand why this is a hot button topic
for a lot of people right now.
You've seen the market go berserk.
And for some of you,
you're probably really happy about where prices are
because you probably have your collection
may have become a lot more valuable
over the last year, year and a half.
But at the same time,
maybe you're very worried
that we're about to be on the edge of a cliff
like what happened back in 2021.
Or maybe you feel like you've been left on the sidelines.
There were a lot of people in the comments
who are seeing all the prices go up
and they feel like it's affecting them in a negative way
because it is harming their ability to participate.
It's making everything so expensive
and just out of reach for a lot of collectors.
And I get those point of views.
And so I think there's a lot of,
just a lot of tension around this
and around where the sports card market is right now.
And I get it.
And we're gonna talk about your comments
and the comments that some of which I think
were very on point and others,
I think were very off base.
So again, I'm not gonna spend a lot of time
on last week's episode,
but let me just at least remind you quickly
of the 10 main points that I made.
The first was, I said,
today money is flowing towards much better cards,
cards of the goats,
than it was back in 2020 and 2021
right before the sports card market drove off that cliff.
Number two, I said,
collectors better understand scarcity today
than they did back then.
Number three, and this one was very controversial
amongst a lot of you.
I said, in today's sports card market,
there are more collectors and fewer pure flippers
than there were back in 2021.
We're gonna talk about that
because a lot of people disagreed with that one.
Number four, I said that set building is returning
and that's a good thing
for the health of the sports card market.
Some people didn't agree with that one as well.
So more to talk about there.
Number five, I said participation in sports cards
is at record levels.
Number six, I said fanatics still has room to grow,
which I think people largely agreed with,
but people had some interesting takes
as to why that's a bad thing for the sports card market.
Number seven, I said athletes are actively joining the hobby.
Number eight, I said international growth
remains largely untapped.
Number nine, I said the hobby's infrastructure is stronger.
And number 10, I said the market already survived
its stress test.
And by that, I mean,
we've already been through a market crash.
It already happened coming off of 2021
and the hobby is now back stronger than ever before.
Now, what I didn't say in that video,
and I wanna be clear about this again,
I didn't say that card prices cannot go down.
In fact, I said, and I believe the exact opposite of that.
I said, it is entirely possible
that we will see a price correction
and the price of many cards,
all cards could drop 20%, could drop 30%.
Absolutely, that could occur with how hot things have been
over the last year, year and a half.
We could see this price correction in the next six months.
We could see it next year.
We could see it the year after that.
I'm not sure, but at some point in time,
we will see a price correction
because even in healthy markets,
there are price corrections.
Happens all the time in the stock market.
Prices run up and then they pull back somewhat.
Now, if the market's healthy,
they'll eventually run up again to all-time highs.
And then maybe they pull back
and then they go up again to all-time highs, right?
And so hopefully, I think the sports card market is healthy.
I think it is.
And I think that a little bit of a price correction
coming up sometime soon here should be expected.
But I also think if you look five years, 10 years out,
we should be seeing prices at levels significantly above
even where they are today.
And I don't think we're gonna have
another 2021 style systemic collapse.
I don't think that.
So I put this video out.
I put these comments out on social.
And what did you say?
Well, maybe to nobody's surprise,
one of the first groups of comments that I saw
was people saying Jeff's view is biased
because he has businesses in the hobby.
So he has to say positive, optimistic things
so that the hobby will continue to grow.
Okay, I got a couple things to say to this.
First of all, duh, that I had businesses in the hobby.
Yes, clearly I have many business interests in the hobby.
In addition to a huge collection, you know?
So yes, I'm heavily, heavily invested in the hobby.
I'm not trying to trick anyone there.
I think I've been pretty open about that fact.
But you're giving me too much credit
that I can control the entire market
just by sitting here and being optimistic.
Like if you think that's the reason,
like if you think I'm sitting here saying optimistic things
because I'm trying to control the entire market
and make the market grow,
I think you're giving me a little bit too much credit.
Look, I appreciate it.
I'm honored.
I'm humbled that you think me sitting here
in front of this microphone talking into the camera
can control a market with tens of millions of participants
and billions of dollars being transacted every single month.
I'm humbled that you would think that,
but that's not reality.
So no, I'm not sharing optimistic comments
just because I'm trying to, you know, control the market.
And here's something that's gonna surprise you.
Guess what?
I don't like the market surging up
the way it has been over the last year.
You're probably surprised to hear that, right?
I don't like it.
You know why I don't like it?
Because I would rather see slow and steady growth,
not big surges that could be followed
by big corrections, right?
And as I've said, obviously in my video last week,
I don't think we're gonna have a monumental,
massive, you know, correction,
but we inevitably will have prices decrease some
just because of how hot the market has been.
I would prefer slow and steady growth.
I would prefer that the market grow 10% to 20% a year
for the next 10 years
rather than the market grow 60% this year
and then next year it's down 25%.
I would actually prefer not that
because I believe huge run-ups
followed by big swings down
make the market feel unsteady.
And unsteady and volatile is scary to new collectors.
If you're getting into a market,
if you're new,
if you're trying to learn all of this
and get into this for the first time
and maybe buy investment cards for the first time,
you don't really wanna do that in a market
that is surging
and then could have maybe a quick drop-off
because of how hot it's been.
I'd rather you do that in a market
that is consistently going up 20% a year,
15% a year,
and feels like it's gonna continue
on a pretty slow but steady growth
for a long time to come.
Because that way,
I know you're gonna have a good experience.
If the market's surging
and you buy at the moment that happens to be the top,
you're probably gonna have a bad experience
because you're probably gonna see your card values go down
and then you maybe bring them back into Cards HQ
to try to sell one of your cards
four months from now
and you're surprised to learn it's down 20%
or down 25% or 30%
from where it was four months ago.
I don't like that.
I want slow but steady growth.
So no,
I'm actually not encouraging
this crazy spike in the card market
because I don't think that's the healthiest thing
for the card market.
Slow and steady is what I would actually prefer to see.
But at the end of the day,
I don't control the market.
Nobody does.
And the market is gonna do its thing.
And that's how we've seen things play out
the last several years.
The market has done its thing
and I sit here and commentate on what is happening.
Okay, another big theme in the comments
is that the macro economy
absolutely can crush card prices.
I heard this a lot.
One YouTube commenter made this point very well.
He said,
in a true financial crisis,
people sell even assets they consider safe
because they need liquidity.
And on Facebook,
somebody commented,
food and gas come before sports cards.
And you know what?
They're absolutely right.
If we get a severe recession,
financial crisis,
huge unemployment spike,
or liquidity shock,
card prices probably go down.
And they could probably go down a lot.
I agree with that.
But this isn't really a rebuttal of my thesis
about the health of the card market.
That is a risk to virtually every asset class.
If you have the economy drop out,
stocks are going to absolutely get hit.
Real estate will probably get hit.
Luxury goods are going to get hit hard.
And yes, collectibles will also probably get hit.
The interesting question though
is what happens afterwards.
Does demand permanently evaporate?
Or does the category recover?
Well, I believe the category will recover.
And while everything may decrease
during an economic decline,
I believe when you get on the other side of that,
sports cards will come rallying back up
likely faster than most other investment categories.
That's my guess.
And that's what I believe will probably happen.
So yes, be careful.
If there is an economic decline on the horizon,
it could affect the entire market, no doubt.
But it will affect everything.
And that's the reality that we live in.
Unless you're going to liquidate everything
and put it in cash,
then I guess that's kind of how you ride that thing out.
Right?
Okay.
In terms of my list of the 10 points,
the point that was pushed back on by far the most
was when I said,
today there are more collectors and less flippers.
People very much disagreed with this.
Instagram had comments like,
there are more pure flippers than ever.
Where are the collectors?
And I saw that across all the different platforms, right?
Comment after comment, after comment,
even Darren Rovell chimed in on my list and said,
he agreed with some of the points on my list,
but he very much disagreed with that point.
So let me say a couple of things.
First of all,
are there more flippers today
than there were in 2020, 2021?
Maybe.
Maybe I underestimated that.
Maybe I underestimated the amount of flipping activity
that is still going on today,
but there's a very important distinction.
The number of flippers
versus the percentage of overall participants in the hobby.
I still believe that from a percentage standpoint,
there are less flippers today
than there were back in 2020 and 2021.
Now the hobby is a lot bigger today.
There's more, many more participants overall.
So maybe the number of flippers today
is also greater than it has ever been in history before,
but the overall hobby is much greater
than it has ever been in history before.
So as a percentage,
how many flippers versus collectors are there today?
I still think that from a percentage basis,
there were more flippers back in 2020, 2021.
And there's a little bit less today.
Percentage-wise, I still believe that's the case.
Back in 2020 and 2021,
that era to me was all about flipping
and it was all about speculating
on whatever breakout rookie star
is gonna have a good night tomorrow.
I mean, you saw just crazy stuff happen.
You saw some no-name basketball player
get called up from the G League.
And in his first game coming out of the G League,
he scores 18 points.
And the next day his cards are up 600%.
You saw that happen all the time, all the time.
And those were the cards
that everybody was paying attention to
and that everybody seemed to be buying.
It seemed like back in 2020 and 2021,
people were buying cards strictly
because they wanted to be able to sell them a week later.
For double.
And I don't think today feels that way
nearly as much anymore.
I don't think that's what people are doing
nearly to the same degree.
I just don't.
That doesn't mean flipping is not part of it.
That doesn't mean people still aren't speculating.
That doesn't mean that a baseball prospect
who gets called up
isn't going to see his cards go up 500% still
because that still happens.
But it just feels to me like
that's just a much smaller part
of the overall market today.
Now, there were a lot of people
who said, well, wait a minute.
Go to a card show.
Look at all of the people at the card show
that are buying.
All the people walking around
buying out dealer tables.
What are they doing?
Because they're certainly not collecting.
Fair point.
You know what most of them are doing?
They're buying those cards for repacks.
That's what all those people are doing.
All those people walking around card shows,
buying out dealer tables.
They get all their sticky notes.
They're pricing things out.
They're buying for repacks.
Is that flipping?
It's a little different.
I don't really consider that flipping
in the same way.
It's really acquiring inventory
for a business in a sense.
It's the same way that Cards HQ
buys at card shows all over the country
and then sells the cards on our website
and in our store.
Is that flipping?
Well, we're a business.
That's what we do.
That's what every card shop does.
That's what every repack does.
They buy cards
and then they resell them.
We're professional resellers, right?
So are repack buyers.
I don't consider that quite the same thing
as flipping.
When I think of flipping,
I think of somebody who's buying Zach Wilson
because they think he's going to have
a great game this Sunday
and his cards are going to be up 30%
on Tuesday of next week
and they can flip them on eBay
for that profit Tuesday of next week.
That's what I think of flipping.
And there was a lot of that happening
back in 2020 and 2021
and I think there's a lot less,
at least as a percentage,
of that happening today.
So less flipping, more flipping.
I guess it depends how you're going to define it
if you're going to include repacking in that at all.
Now what I will say,
another theme of comments that I heard
was that there's a ton of breaking today,
a ton of repacking today.
There's a ton of chance taking today.
Money being spent on chance.
Yeah, that is true.
There's a lot more breaking today.
There's a lot more repacks today.
So if you consider that speculation,
it kind of is in its own way, right?
But that's still different
than what drove the 2021 singles bubble.
Breaking, repacking,
it can absolutely become overheated.
Expected value can get bad
and people can spend beyond what they should.
And that does happen today,
more than ever before.
But that doesn't necessarily create the same mechanism
as thousands of people all piling
into the same Justin Herbert or Zion Williamson's cards
just because everyone expects their prices to rise.
It's different.
So that's why I say flipping is less today
than it was back then.
But depending on how you want to look at that,
I can understand why so many people felt differently
than I did about that topic.
Hey guys, let me take a quick minute
to tell you about cardshq.com
because almost everything in this store
is available for sale on our website.
All of our sealed product,
all of our graded cards,
and many of our supplies are all available
on cardshq.com.
So next time you're ready to make a card purchase,
check out cardshq.com.
Okay, some other things I heard from you.
One is that manufactured scarcity
and parallel overload are problems.
Okay, I think that's a fair criticism for sure
of the industry overall.
One Instagram commenter said,
does the hobby actually understand scarcity better
as Jeff is saying?
Or has the industry simply become better
at manufacturing and marketing scarcity?
Fair point.
I think yes.
Yes, the industry has become better
at manufacturing and marketing scarcity
without a doubt.
I mean, you got a player now,
every year each player probably has
a few hundred different one-of-one cards, right?
A one-of-one no longer is what it used to be.
A gold out of 10 or a black out of 10
is no longer what it used to be.
Players have dozens of parallels
in every single product
and then a bunch of inserts.
And then sometimes those inserts have parallels.
Case hits aren't as special
when there's bunches of case hits, right?
And there's so many different products, right?
So it does maybe weaken scarcity
if it's heavily manufactured.
That's a fair point.
Now, at the same time,
a couple of things I'm going to say
in response to that.
At the same time,
if they didn't create all these inserts,
if they didn't create all of these one-of-ones,
then everybody would hate the products
because all of the products
would be filled with just base cards.
Or if they printed less product overall
so that they could still maintain
a reasonable ratio
of being able to pull parallels
in one-of-ones and everything,
then the price of those boxes
would be four times what they are today.
So pick your poison.
It's very difficult right now
for the manufacturers.
Demand's so high.
So the only way they can make,
they have to make more product
to meet the demand
so prices don't go even crazier.
But then in order to make more product,
they have to make more inserts
and parallels in one-of-ones
because if they don't,
it's going to make all of the boxes
very hard to pull anything
and then people are going to get mad
when they buy an expensive hobby box
and it's nothing but base cards.
And that's it.
So it is how manufacturers
respond to the growth of the hobby.
I understand why people
are concerned about it.
I don't think there's a perfect solution
to that problem.
And I want to make
one very important distinction as well.
Most of the money today
that I was talking about in my video,
it is not flowing into buying,
you know, number to 10
Dylan Harper cards.
Some of it's going there for sure.
Dylan Harper has actually been pretty popular
in the sports card market this last year.
So some of it's going there
but the cards that I was talking about,
the ones where really all the,
the vast majority of the money is going
I was talking about 1980s Michael Jordan cards
and 1990s inserts,
rare inserts of Ken Griffey Jr.
and Barry Bonds and,
you know, Kobe and players like that.
I was talking about a lot of older cards.
I'm talking about Tom,
you know, early career Tom Brady
or even Tom Brady's first case hits
like Downtowns and Gabooms
back when they didn't actually print that many
Downtowns or Gabooms.
And those cards, they can't be recreated.
And that's the category I'm talking about.
So when I say collectors understand scarcity
more than ever before today,
they're looking into the past.
They're looking for scarce cards
of the greatest of all time.
And there actually are a lot of very scarce cards
when you look back 10 years,
20 years, 30 years, 40 years.
There's a lot of scarcity
in some of those eras of the hobby.
So even if today you feel like things are overprinted
and there's too many parallels
and too many one-on-ones and all these things,
I would say, okay, yes,
but that's not really what has driven the market
over the last 18 months.
What's driven the market
is people buying the rare cards of the goats
from a decade or decades ago.
That's what is driving the market right now.
Another thing people said in the comments
was that goat cards can absolutely become overpriced.
And that just because people are buying goats,
it doesn't mean that those cards won't go down in value.
And guess what?
That, yeah, that's absolutely true.
In fact, we already saw that happen.
In the last crash back in 2021,
we saw Michael Jordan's 1986 Fleer
absolutely tumble in price.
We saw Tom Brady's contender's rookie ticket auto
absolutely tumble in price.
We saw LeBron's exquisite rookies
and Topps Chrome rookies from 2003
absolutely tumble in price.
The goat cards got crushed
as did all of the speculative cards.
But here's the big difference.
The goat cards all came back.
And today, all of those cards that I just mentioned,
they're way back up in the market.
Many of those types of cards
have already gone way past their all-time highs
back in 2020 and 2021.
Some haven't gotten back there yet,
but they're all heading back in that direction
and most are past those all-time highs.
The Michael Jordan cards came back.
The Mac Jones cards did not.
The speculative cards largely died.
But the great cards of the all-time greats,
they came back.
And they're hotter now than ever before.
So yes, Jordan can go down.
Kobe can go down.
LeBron can go down.
Griffey can go down.
Brady can go down.
But if I'm thinking five years out,
if I'm thinking 10 years out,
I'm going to bet you that their cards,
especially the good quality ones,
the scarce ones, the iconic ones,
they're going to be worth more
five to 10 years from now than they are today.
Might they go down 20% or 30% next year?
Sure.
Might they be two or three times more valuable
than they are today, five or 10 years from now?
Yeah, I bet they will be.
That's my guess.
And guys, let me just be clear here, right?
Like this is not financial advice.
I am just telling you what I think
and giving you my observations of the sports card market.
But nobody knows for sure.
This is risky.
And I get that people in the comments are like,
hey, I'm being too optimistic.
This hobby is full of risk.
There's risk around every corner.
This whole thing could crash out and die.
Sure, could happen.
100% could happen.
I don't believe it's going to happen.
And I gave you all the reasons in the last video
why I don't believe that that's going to happen,
but it could.
It's risky.
None of us know for sure.
I'm just telling you what I believe.
And what I believe is if you buy the really good cards
of the great goats,
those things are great to lock in your safe
and hold on to for the longterm.
And by the way,
this isn't just like a phenomenon of the last five or 10 years.
Like look at the history of the hobby.
Topps has been making baseball cards for 75 years.
And those baseball cards,
they've gone up for most of those last 75 years.
I mean, that 52 mantle,
it's only gotten more valuable as the decades have gone by.
So there's actual long-term track record here to look at.
This is not a five-year phenomenon.
You got some real track record in history
when it comes to the sports card hobby.
And I believe that track record in history
on a macro level will continue long into the future.
Okay, another thing I heard a lot of in the comments
was that the hobby is getting too expensive
for normal collectors.
In fact, one person on Instagram said,
this isn't for the normal guy anymore.
And a lot of people responded and liked his comment.
Yeah, that's fair.
Look, a normal collector isn't buying a $50,000 Kobe card.
And now normal collectors have a lot of trouble
stomaching the price of a lot of sealed products.
Hobby boxes, a lot of releases have become very, very expensive.
And people are concerned about that.
It's become less attainable.
The high-end cards have become less attainable.
Sealed products, very expensive.
All of this is true.
But I would also challenge the fact
that participating in the hobby requires that.
And I'm not trying to say things aren't too expensive.
But what I am trying to say is
there's a lot of different ways to collect.
And there's a lot of Jordan cards.
And there's a lot of Brady cards.
And there's a lot of Ken Griffey Jr. cards.
And there's a lot of vintage cards
that are attractive, that are desirable,
that even in some ways are iconic,
that are under a hundred bucks.
Under a hundred bucks.
There's Cards Inside Cards HQ right now.
You could buy a Tom Brady card for $40 from the 2000s.
That's really attractive to look at.
I got one on the shelf.
You can find these cards.
You can find LeBrons and Jordans and Currys and Bradys.
And you can find any player you want to find under a hundred bucks.
It may not be the card that's making the headlines.
It may not be the card that's getting posted all over social media.
But there's still the opportunity.
And honestly, a lot of those cards
still prove to be pretty good investments.
You don't have to be spending $20,000 on a card
for it to be a good investment for you.
The Jordan market, the Michael Jordan market,
the entire market has moved up.
There are Michael Jordan cards that you could have bought
for $10 a year ago that are now $40 or $50 cards.
There's plenty that have gone way beyond that,
that were very affordable cards.
There's $80 Michael Jordan cards that are $300 or $400 today.
You could have bought that for $80 a year and a half ago.
And the same with Tom Brady and the same with Ken Griffey Jr.
The list goes on and on.
So it's not just the high end of the market that moves things.
The high end of the market gets the headlines.
But really with these GOAT players,
the entire market has been moving up.
And you can get in at any level.
So while I do agree that the hobby has an affordability problem,
I don't think that that should be an inhibitor to participating.
And I don't think that should force you onto the sidelines.
It may just force you not to buy the card
that's being touted on social media,
that hit the record sale number,
but buy something that's a little bit more under the radar.
And when it comes to sealed product,
yes, I would love to see hobby boxes be less expensive.
I don't like collectors walking into Cards HQ
and having to shell out as much money
as they sometimes do for some of these new products.
I'd like there to be a better value return,
but it's largely controlled by supply and demand.
And the demand is there right now.
What I will say that I do think Topps is doing a good job at
is they are deliberately trying to maintain lower priced products,
such as for example, Topps flagship football,
which just came out a couple of weeks ago.
They tried to price that at more reasonable levels.
And they try to make a lot of retail product available
at all kinds of different price points.
And they succeeded.
That product hasn't, you know,
spiked 300% in the market since release.
You can walk in to Cards HQ
and you can buy a hobby box or a blaster box
or a mega box of Topps flagship football,
the brand new product and feel okay about doing it.
And so I want to see Topps continue to
keep an eye towards affordability
and to segment their products in such a way
so that there is plenty of offerings available
for collectors who want to come in
and buy something for 50 bucks
and don't feel like they got to spend $500
in order to get something that they can enjoy opening.
Okay.
Another comment I heard,
fanatics growing doesn't automatically mean
collectors are healthier.
In fact, one person on Instagram said,
fanatics growing is good for fanatics.
That doesn't automatically mean
consolidation, exclusivity,
and higher wax prices are good for collectors.
Yeah, I agree.
That's not what I was arguing.
I wasn't, I'm not arguing
whether fanatics growth is good for collectors
and, you know, higher wax prices are good for collectors.
And look, as you guys know,
I've got a deep business relationship with fanatics
and I am a proponent of what tops and fanatics are doing.
I think that they are making a lot of right moves.
I think they are doing a lot of good things.
I understand that the popularity
they have brought to sports cards,
which they absolutely have brought in a lot of collectors
and have really made the whole thing more popular.
It has led to higher wax prices.
Obviously the fact they have exclusivity
has led to less choice for collectors.
So I understand there's criticisms
and things that collectors don't like as well.
But what you can't argue with
is what my original argument was based on.
Fanatics has absolutely grown
and will continue to grow the market.
Fanatics, whether you like them or not,
and whether you like their tactics or not,
you cannot argue with the fact
that fanatics has done a very effective job at marketing
and will continue to provide more marketing
for the sports card market as a whole.
They've done a very effective job
at getting more athletes involved.
They've done a very effective job
at building international distribution.
They've done a very effective job
of getting the hobby more mainstream exposure.
They've done a very effective job
at getting more new collectors to enter the hobby.
And guess what?
This surge in demand from new collectors
is a large reason why card prices have gone up.
Look, fanatics can grow the market enormously
while still making decisions
that collectors disagree with.
That can happen.
But my argument was that fanatics
has and will continue to grow.
They're just getting started.
They will continue to grow the market.
And that part of my argument,
I completely believe is true.
100%.
Fanatics is gonna continue to grow this thing.
Honestly, whether you feel like
it's in the best interest of collectors or not.
Okay, another thing I heard,
people were saying Pokemon and TCG
could be considerably more vulnerable than sports cards.
Sure, probably is, I guess, right?
I mean, you think sports cards have been hot
over the last 18 months.
Go look at the Pokemon market.
Go look at how...
It's funny.
If you go into market movers,
and you look at the charts of a Tom Brady or a Michael Jordan,
you're gonna see like this big spike on the chart, right?
Over the last like 12 months.
Then go load a chart of some popular Pokemon card.
And the spike it's seen over the last 12 to 18 months
will probably put the spike of the Michael Jordan card
or the Tom Brady card to shame.
It will make it look small.
Compared to the spike of what we've been seeing
in the Pokemon card market.
Obviously, the Pokemon card market
is actually what has the grading company shut down right now.
Because there's been such a massive spike
in grading in Pokemon.
It's not sports cards that have shut PSA down.
It's Pokemon cards that have shut PSA down
with their value levels.
So is Pokemon actually the market
that's in the bubble right now?
Maybe more than sports cards?
But at the same time,
Pokemon has an even deeper true collector base
than sports cards.
It has a bigger collector base.
More people involved in Pokemon.
Bigger fans of the Pokemon IP.
If you don't believe me,
spend time here in Cards HQ.
The aisles on the Pokemon side of the store
are busier than the aisles
on the sports card side of the store.
And the people that are coming in to buy the Pokemon,
I would argue that the vast majority of those people
are collectors.
Not flippers.
Collectors.
So yeah, the Pokemon market might be overheated.
Maybe even more overheated than sports cards.
But the underlying franchise and collector base
are exceptionally strong.
And in reality,
I also don't think that the Pokemon market
is that connected to the sports card market.
So I don't think that that argument necessarily changes
what I was saying about sports cards.
Okay, couple other comment sets here.
People challenged my idea
that set building is making a comeback.
I saw people in the comments saying,
you know, people haven't collected sets since,
you know, 1991.
And you know, the vintage collectors
who build all those sets are dying off.
And you know, stuff like that, right?
That's actually not what I'm talking about.
And I should have clarified,
but I'm not talking about people
building 792 card sets
of top series one baseball.
That's not what I'm collecting about.
No, I'm sorry.
Not collecting.
That's not what I'm talking about, right?
What I am seeing
is something that I barely saw five years ago.
And that is collectors intentionally assembling
complete insert sets.
Take a little scan around Instagram
at various card accounts.
And you're probably gonna see collectors
championing the Kaboom set they just built
or the Downtown set
or the Duncan Go-Nuts set
or the Noise Boys set
or the TakeIt2.net set.
Collectors are set building,
but they're doing it differently today
than they used to.
They're building complete sets of all kings.
They're building complete sets of ultraviolets.
They're buying complete sets of anime cards.
They're building case hit sets.
They're building insert sets.
They're building rainbows.
Parallel rainbows of a particular card.
And look, I'm not saying
this is like a huge segment of the hobby.
It's not.
This is still probably a small minority
that are trying to build these sets.
But set building went from almost invisible
five years ago
to noticeable today.
And that's progress.
And set building is collecting.
And so that's what I like to see.
All right.
One other argument.
This one I laugh at
that a lot of people made in the comments.
They said,
because Jeff is saying this time is different,
that means we're obviously in a bubble.
Come on, that's not analysis.
Every market environment is different.
Sometimes this time is different.
Can be wrong.
But sometimes things are actually different.
And things are actually different today.
The question isn't whether someone uttered the phrase.
The question is,
what are the underlying facts?
And I'll give you the facts.
In 2020 and 2021,
there was pandemic behavior.
You had the stimulus,
the liquidity,
the checks being sent to everybody
that people were spending on cards.
You had extreme
rookie and prospect speculation.
You had retail product flipping.
You had a bunch of brand new
inexperienced market participants.
And you had dramatically
weaker hobby infrastructure.
That's not like today.
You can't just sit there and say,
you know,
it's a lazy, lazy comment
to say that
because I'm saying this time is different
means that it's not different
and that we're in a bubble.
That's lazy.
No, everything is different today.
Today we have a different market
with different participants,
different products,
different businesses involved,
different distribution mechanisms
and different demand sources.
So you can agree
whether those differences are sufficient,
but simply saying famous last words
doesn't actually rebut
any of those differences.
That's just lazy.
Stop being lazy.
Come on.
Make better arguments than that.
All right.
I want to end on this.
There was one argument
that people made in the comments
that actually was in favor
of my overall thesis
that this isn't 2021
and the sports card market
is going to be healthy
for the long term
that I didn't think about.
I didn't put it on my list,
but I think it was actually,
it would have been a good addition
to my list if I had thought about it.
There were several people
in the comments who said,
kids and families
are a bigger reason
for optimism today
than ever before.
A commenter on my YouTube video said,
he said,
you should add number 11 to your list.
The number of kids in the hobby
and at card shows.
Actually, a lot of people said this
across Facebook,
across Instagram,
across Twitter
when they were responding
to my comments.
Now look,
the kids getting into the hobby
are not driving
the Michael Jordan PSA 10 prices,
right?
That with these record sales
that we're seeing,
but they are building
the collector base
of 2035,
2040,
2045,
2050.
And that matters enormously
with my thesis being
that I believe
in the long-term
of the sports card hobby.
If I'm saying the cards
that are popular today,
the cards that are setting
these record prices today
will actually be more valuable
in the long-term,
10 years out,
20 years out,
30 years out.
You need those kids today participating
because that kid today
at the card show
who's spending 80 bucks,
you know,
to buy cards,
that's that same person
that 30 years from now
is going to be spending $80,000
to buy a Grail card,
right?
So yes,
I do think the number of kids
that have entered the hobby,
and we all see it,
go to a card show.
You'll see it everywhere.
I do think the number of kids
entering the hobby
is a really good healthy sign
for the long-term.
And I didn't mention it in my list,
and I should have.
So there you go.
That is a summary
of the comments
that I heard the most
in my thoughts.
And did those comments
change my mind overall?
As a whole?
No.
I still strongly believe
in the long-term future
of the sports card market.
And I don't think
we're going to see
a crash,
at least like we saw
back in 2021.
But what the comments did do
is they correctly pointed out
things that we all need
to watch out for.
We need to be careful
about the broader economy
because a bigger economic decline
could absolutely
have a negative effect.
We do need to look
for a slowdown
of collectors
coming into this space.
Because if cards cool down
in popularity with new collectors,
that's going to be a problem.
We also need to
look for a slowdown
with the popularity
of collecting with kids.
Because if cards
lose popularity with kids,
that's going to be a problem
30 years from now.
We need to look for regulation
because regulation
coming into the sports card market
could have unexpected consequences
which could slow the market down.
We also need to look for slowdowns
in international expansion.
If that doesn't take hold
and investment stops
going international,
then that may not be a great sign
for long-term growth.
And of course,
if something bad were to happen
to one of the major players
like Fanatics or PSA,
that could have a bad effect
on the sports card market as well.
But outside of monitoring
and being careful
and keeping an eye on things,
which is absolutely smart
and the right thing to do,
I'm going to remain optimistic.
I'm going to remain bullish
about the long term.
And once again,
let me be clear.
My optimisticness,
my bullishness
doesn't mean that I don't think
prices will correct at some point.
They will.
Someday,
maybe not long from now,
you're going to see
some of these goat cards
that have been superheated
over the last 18 months,
you're going to see them drop
20% or 30%.
Maybe more.
That will happen
at some point in time.
It's not a matter of if,
it's a matter of when.
That happens in every healthy market.
It will happen in sports cards as well.
But look at it over five years,
10 years, 20 years.
I like the direction we're going.
All right.
There you go.
That's my analysis of your comments.
Thank you for being so spirited
in everything that you had
to say back to me.
I love reading your comments,
even if I don't agree with them.
I love reading them
and I love hearing what is on your mind.
And of course,
don't forget these full length episodes
of The Jeff Wilson Show
are available on The Jeff Wilson Show
channel on YouTube.
They're also available
on Apple Podcasts
and on Spotify.
So make sure you listen
and subscribe everywhere.
And I'll see you soon
with my next one.
Take care.

