Thrand,Marquez and Eldgrim test out a Iron age large leaf shape Celtic spear on a 16 gauge / 1.6mm hardened steel 15th century style breast plate. Thrand test his overarm throwing slide technique, the pool cuing two handed spear thrust, the pike style two handed thrust and an all out spear throw to see how devastating a piercing can be achieved! This a viewer reply to Arms and Armour who suggested it over the car hood tested. This includes a special appearance of the Middle bronze age spear head made by Neil Burridge tested on the extreme piece of 15th century armor. So sit back grab an ale or mead and enjoy this test of spear metal and techniques for an exciting conclusion medieval effectiveness.
***Thrand also address Deadliest Warrior once again and gives a comment to his good friend Skallagrim Nilsson so be sure to watch the entire video :D
Be sure and like us on Facebook / thrand Be sure to Subscribe to our Youtube channel at https://www.youtube.com/user/ThegnThr... Help us keep channel going on Patreon / thrand
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Grind tests the penetration capabilities of a Celtic spear against 16-gauge (1.6mm) hardened steel armor and a gambeson. By comparing various striking techniques, he demonstrates that while the armor provides significant protection, certain high-velocity motions can still pierce the metal.
Break through the walls that they build in my mind
I see it, you won't go where the flow
The rebel inside is the power I hide
Let it go out of control
Heyo, Grind here, and I'm back in a reply video
We got lots of people giving lots of comments on our minivan hood
Which is basically a 20 gauge piece of metal, about 1mm
I think it's .95 of a millimeter
Which at one time period, yes, bronze and early metals
When they didn't have a lot of iron
They would use sheets of stuff like that
With padding behind it and stuff
But later centuries as you go on
I mean, they used extremely thick breastplates
Late, late centuries to stop firearms
When they started getting better and better firearms
But at a good range around, I don't know
15th century or so, 16th century
You've got stuff that's around, I don't know
About .6 millimeters
So it's about a 16 gauge
And a small degree
There are more extreme heat treatments
Where you get a gun that's actually not damp at all
And pretty much spring back
So it's slightly heat treated, but we've got a 16 gauge
I've got the Celtic spear
Which is actually really broad
Which in some ways with its ridge
Because it's an Iron Age design
Helps with its armor piercing
But it also kind of makes it harder in some ways
Other shapes that might be better for the time period
But what I'm going to do is
Since I had a viewer that gave me a comment
And he said that the hood gives an unrealistic view of armor
Or actual armor that's made into armor
Not just metal punched through
We're going to test it on this today
See if we can get any penetration
We'll try the one-handed techniques
Two-handed technique and maybe a throw
See what kind of piercing it puts into this
If it can penetrate
So let's get started
Oh, and by the way, I looked
So I can give you a proper reply
Your name seemed to be armor something
I don't know if you have a site or what
But if you give me a comment down below
I'll make sure that I put it in the title
And a link to who asked me to do this
Because I looked and either you were moved to a comment
I'm just unable to find it
Because I'm not sure exactly where it was at
But anyway, no problem, let's get going
Alright, I'm going to try an overarm throwing slide
That I always do in all the videos
And test out that has a lot of potential
For one-handed piercing of metal
I'm the best at it
In trying to pierce things like this
So let's see what happens
Got a nice dimple and a small hole
That's right over the padding
Off to the side, let's try again
That's pretty decent
Makes it cut into the gambeson slightly
And got a hole
I don't know if it killed anybody
But it actually did pierce the 1.6mm
Or 16 gauge metal
Even after being slightly hard
Not too shabby
Let's try one more good one with this
Oh, that's the best yet
Now, grant you, that's not a kill
That still made a hole in the armor
And I'm guaranteeing the shock
Will be quite devastating to the person
If it hit, they'd feel that
It's the best piercing we've got on this thing so far
And a sword could not do that
Okay, we're going to try a two-handed sliding technique
Where I try to throw it through here
On this, it didn't do much better
Let's try again, maybe I need more power
Heck, the overarm seems to be doing better
Than the slide on this thing with this spear
Let's try again
Actually, we got the best penetration
For the overarm throwing slot
Not something I would have expected
This won't quite impress it
Let's go ahead and try a throw on that
It's a full-out throw
This was our overarm slide throw
This is the full-out throw
It's a hair more penetration
We actually got into the gambeson
And it dented the armor in quite a bit
So you might have actually made the guy bleed
Maybe
I don't know where it's against his chest
This is actually a wide one, this is actually backplate
I didn't use the chestplate
Because the chestplate just doesn't have angles
To even try to hit it as easily
So that is a good point on armor
This is mostly just to test the quality of the armor
The actual metal plate, if you hit a dead center hit
It is quite wider
And a little more damaging
Than the actual throwing slide
The throwing slide is pretty dang close
It actually outdid the pool killing in this method
Make sure it wasn't a fluke
I don't think it was a fluke
I had to do that
Almost the exact same as we got here
And real close to the same depth we have here
Back in an old video
Marquez had hit me
When he was representing the samurai
With the spear this way
And he wanted me to test that
So I'm going to throw that in real quick
And see what that does
That's pretty decent
Not too bad
That was another one from it as well
We just tested that out
But this gives you an idea of what that one is doing
That's putting the body weight behind it and coming in
That is not bad
It's pretty decent
It's a different part of the armor we're hitting
But it's almost, not quite
Comparable to the overarm slide
And most of that
But that's putting the whole body weight
Behind the spear
That's me coming in down at an angle
And leaning into it
I think he had a good idea there
It gives you a lot of power
Most certainly
What I'm doing here
I'm going to hold it kind of like a pikeman would
And there's different ways to do this
I can bring my arms all the way out this way
You do get a long range of motion
But it's already set up
And the reason a pikeman would hold it this way
Is because of the weight of the forearm
But this is using all the arms and the body
To thrust
That's why this arm's all the way in and this one's all the way back
I'm going to use my body weight and everything
And try to see if I can
I got the same thing from the
Throwing slide
From the two-handed spear
It turns out the overarm throw
Or throwing slide is actually doing more damage
Than the
Other techniques
Let's try that one more time
So we don't get an argument
That's me putting my body
Into it and everything
And that's from a pike style
Or a two-handed thrust style without a slide
We're getting these
The one with the slide we're getting a little better
And then the actual
Throw was the deepest
So if you're out there Scallagrim and people told you
Not to throw spears in combat in close range
It did that
The overarm throwing slide
Which is akin to the throw
That's why I call it a throwing slide
And make sure I throw that part in there
It's a throwing motion
Did that which is very close to this
And everything else was just a little less lackluster
All this stuff would hurt
I wouldn't want to get hit that way
And our viewer that requests seeing this had a good point
This would protect you
1.6mm metal
Slightly hardened and shaped properly
Would protect you if you were wearing it
I wouldn't want to get hit with any of this
It would hurt
You might have a little blood
But you'd still be alive
Anything less than this
You'd have a hole through
It'd be in your chest somewhere
Be sure if you're out there
To let me know who you were
Leave a comment down below
So I can reply to you properly
Address you in the title
Put a link in there
If you all want to
Go over to Facebook
We have a Well of Remembrance page
And you can like us there
You can ask for a membership
Which I'm sure we'll give it to you
Over at the Fame Thran Boat Crew
Which is on Facebook as well
And be sure and subscribe to us here on YouTube
And be sure and like our video if you like it
And let us know down below what you think
I hope you enjoyed it
I think it was a fun episode
I'm glad he suggested this
And I'm going to have one hell of a time
Trying to fix this press plate up now
Because I hate throwing anything away
Or thinking it's destroyed
But I think it's still got a lot more good use in it
Anyway, Floravel
Hey, you know what?
I remember when Deadliest Warrior said
That a bronze spear would bend
On a Japanese press plate
You know what?
I don't really think that would happen
It didn't
It actually made it through
I need to resharpen it slightly
But we actually have a hole into the gambeson
I'm quite impressed
Deadliest Warrior
We may not be done with you yet