What Is It Like Living In Alaska With 3 MILLION Tourists??? #alaskaliving
Did you know that 2-3 million tourists visit Alaska every year? As you might know, that is WAY more people than actually live in Alaska. What is it like living in Alaska with so many visitors every year? Do Alaskans feel like they're being overwhelmed?
Jamin, a real estate broker, analyzes the critical role of tourism in Alaska's economy. He examines the financial dependence of various regions, the resulting housing crises caused by short-term rentals, and the contrasting social attitudes toward visitors, arguing that intentional development and hospitality are essential for the state's long-term survival.
My name is Jamin.
I'm your first friend in Alaska, and I'm an associate real estate broker in South Central
Alaska.
And today, we're going to be talking about all things tourist industry right here in
Alaska.
Before we get started though, do make sure you give this video a like, subscribe, and
do all that good stuff, and let's get into it.
First off, I'm going to say tourism is a big deal in Alaska.
Like in the years looking at 2023 to 2024, I think approximately three million people
visited Alaska, and only about 740,000 people live here, so you can see how many more tourists
there are in Alaska compared to people who actually do live here.
Adding further kind of layering to this, like the Alaska Travel Industry Association says
that there is actually about 5.6, I'm going to make sure I get this right, billion with
a B dollars spent in Alaska on tourism, and this does create about 48,000 jobs, and it
does actually create about $157 million worth of tax revenue.
Tourism is a big deal in Alaska, and let's jump into it and see how Alaskans actually
respond to it though.
Okay, so looking at the different parts of Alaska, I think is probably going to be the
most useful way to kind of figure out how Alaskans really respond to tourism.
Where I'm at in South Central Alaska, we don't really see too much of it, right?
We might have some hotels, Airbnbs that'll fill up around this time of year, but looking
at places like Anchorage and the Mat-Su Valley, usually this is more of a jumping off place
for most people.
Most people, they're going to be looking at Denali, they're going to be looking at the
Kenai Peninsula, or they're going to be looking at Southeast Alaska.
They're not usually coming to Alaska to go check out Anchorage or the Mat-Su Valley,
so we'll get some of them, but it's not nearly as much.
Even like the Airbnbs and stuff like that, it's not really a huge part of our ... Proportionally,
it's not really a big part of the housing market here in South Central Alaska.
For the most part, Alaskans here, being South Central Alaska, we're just not really going
to have a really strong opinion either way, and just really have an appreciation for the
contributions that they make to the overall economy of the state.
That's pretty much it.
Like I said before, most of the tourists are going to be going to these remote destinations,
so let's take a look at each one of these specifically.
If we're looking at Denali, I honestly don't know how the economy of the interior survives
without the tourist industry.
Yes, they do have the bases up in Fairbanks and everything.
That only goes so far.
Really, I've seen a ton of buses going up that way, and it's full of tourists.
We're going to be spending money and going to restaurants and going to hotels, and really
doing things that are going to create jobs in that area.
I have a really, really hard time thinking that the entire economy of the interior of
Alaska survives without tourism.
I could be really wrong, but I just have a hard time seeing how it would.
Looking at the Kenai Peninsula, I'm going to say economically, they're probably a little
bit more independent of the tourist industry, but not too much though.
A big part of their economy is definitely going to be coming from the tourist industry,
because they've got the lodges down there, they've got the buses that are constantly
coming and going, they've got the cruise ships that'll show up in places like Seward, and
I think Homer as well, correct me if I'm wrong, but while yes, the Kenai is a little bit more
independent of the tourist industry, I'm just not seeing a scenario where if tourism just
went away, that the economy in the Kenai would not seriously be hurting or just completely
dilapidated.
I could be wrong, but I have a hard time seeing that play out any other way.
Diving a little bit deeper into the Kenai and how tourism impacts it, I will say that
the issue of Airbnbs in smaller towns like Seward, the Airbnbs are going to be a much
bigger deal, because if you have a small little market like that, and you have about 300 homes
or so, which is about, I think what I saw recently as far as all the Airbnb options
like in Seward during the peak tourist time of year, that obviously only aggravates a
problem that they have with housing shortage down there.
I've had a number of people who have really been wanting to move to Seward, but could
not find any housing.
Now, I will also say, it is disingenuous to try to put it all on homeowners who are just
trying to maximize how much they can make on their property and using it as an Airbnb.
Seward, for years, has really stifled and not encouraged any kind of development or
growth over there, because we just want to keep it exactly the way it is.
Okay, fine, but more people are going to move here, and surprise, surprise, they're going
to need housing.
If you're wanting to attract those people, you need to encourage development.
I'm not saying clear-cut everything and completely throw the charm of the town away.
I am saying change is not an option.
It is going to happen.
Improvement is going to be something that's going to require intentionality, and Seward
has just not really done a good job at kind of encouraging that development and that growth
for decades, and it's coming back to bite them in the butt now, because now there's
such a small market, and then you have all these people that are just trying to use their
properties as Airbnbs, and that's aggravating the problem.
You get a lot of small-town politics once you start looking at some of these towns,
but it's, again, kind of impacted by tourism, but if tourism just went away, I had a hard
time seeing how Seward actually would survive in its current form if it did.
All right, you know what?
One more thing about tourism over in the Kenai Peninsula.
In these smaller towns, you have just this huge influx of population over the summertime,
and it's not just from the tourists who are showing up on their cruise ships.
You get a lot of seasonal workers that'll show up to work in the restaurants and work
in the hotels and kind of work on the tourist industry and the hospitality, and that really
does help the economy as well and creates a bunch of jobs.
I mean, the population just swells during the summertime, and then it kind of dissipates
during the winter months.
All right, one other region we're going to look at is going to be Southeast Alaska, and
I really don't think Southeast Alaska really survives without tourism.
I think they go belly up, or the town just is so dilapidated, and it just becomes so...
I don't see these communities really surviving without the benefit of the cruise ships and
the tourism and people showing up during the summer months to really enjoy the state.
That's...
Economically, I just have a hard time seeing that.
You get some smaller communities like Petersburg, Alaska, where fishing and that industry is
really what they focus on and nothing else.
But even then, they're not trying to attract tourism, but they still have tourists that
are showing up and still bolstering their economy.
And yes, Petersburg is beautiful and everything.
It's definitely not like the economic powerhouse of Southeast Alaska, though.
The fishing industry has some volatility in it as well.
And tourism is, yes, it's got volatility to it, but also, if you're going to have a couple
of volatile industries, it's better to have multiple volatile industries at least bundled
together, because there's a good chance they're not both going to be dipping at the same time.
So that does give you some stability.
It's the maximum volatility, though, when you go all in on just one of these industries.
So diversify, I guess, is what I'm saying.
Okay, let's go and take a break real quick here, talking a lot about economics.
So let's go and talk a little bit about our meetup that I host every month for people
who've recently moved up here to Alaska.
And this is really simple stuff that we'll do.
We'll go hiking, we'll go blueberry picking, ice skating, ice fishing, just kind of stuff
like that.
And it's just an opportunity if you're living up here or going to live up here in the near
future for you to kind of talk and kind of start developing those social networks with
people who do live up here and really do have a lot in common with you.
So if that would be something you're interested in, do make sure you go check out the Facebook
meetup group.
The link for that is in the description section down below.
And also, if you are thinking about moving to Alaska, do get a copy of my relocation
guide.
And how you get a hold of that is you just go to the website of mine down below, register
there, put relocation guide in the comment section so I know what to send you.
And also include your phone number because I will touch base with you and see if you
have any specific questions after having a chance to review the relocation guide.
Okay.
All done with that.
Let's keep it moving.
Okay.
Now that we've established tourism is a pretty big deal really in most parts of the state.
Let's go and break it down and see kind of what the attitudes are in these different
regions towards tourism.
And I'll say first off, South Central Alaska, we're pretty chill with it here, honestly.
And that's not too fair for us to be weighing in too heavily, honestly, because the size
of our cities and towns and all that are such where we can kind of absorb it a little bit
easier than kind of these smaller communities.
Our economy isn't so disproportionately set up to service the tourist industry.
Yes, it is a part of it.
But it's not like the big bread and butter thing that we do here.
We might get a little annoyed every now and then with the mini-mini parade every now and
then of all the people driving in their rented RVs going down the road.
And some of them may or may not know what they're doing, but welcome to South Central
Alaska.
That's what people do here.
So I'm going to say pretty chill for the most part.
And also it's easy for us to be chill when we're not the ones whose town population is
looking like just 10x overnight.
So 10x might be a little extreme.
We'll say 5x.
We'll say 5x overnight.
That sounds reasonable.
Now for the Denali area, kind of talking more about the interior of Alaska.
I've kind of had limited exposure to the folks up there and talking with them on what their
feelings are towards tourism.
My impression though has been that they are actually pretty welcoming and pretty generous
with their time and just kind of visiting with people a little bit.
But the pace of the interior is going to be a little bit slower.
And so they're usually very welcoming.
They understand, hey, these folks are here.
They're going to come.
They're going to spend money.
They're going to help the economy and they're going to leave before it gets too cold and
too dark for them.
So that's from what I've seen, they're usually pretty chill about it as well and pretty welcoming
and they kind of understand the role that tourism plays in their industry.
Well, in their economy, I should say.
All right.
Looking at the Kenai Peninsula.
First off, I'm going to say these are the communities that really and truly just get
overrun during the summertime.
They have the easy access to the cruise ships through Seward and Homer, I believe as well
and I'm sure some other communities as well.
And so they really and truly do get overrun with the number of people that are showing
up and visiting.
And for the most part, I found some communities are like really supportive and I've found
other communities that just kind of have this attitude like you're inconveniencing them
if you're there like shopping and like going to restaurants and staying at their hotels
and everything.
So seriously, get an attitude check.
But I found places like Homer are very welcoming.
I'm sure over the course of a season, it's going to get kind of old for them as well.
But again, I think they kind of understand the role that tourism plays in their economy
and they understand, hey, having to wait a little bit longer in like the traffic in this
small town is nothing compared to not having an economy at all.
Other places like Seward, though, you go there and again, it's like an inconvenience to them.
Like I remember one time, you know, went there and, you know, it's just it took us about
an hour, hour and a half to like actually get through like a line at a restaurant because
everything was going so slow.
Like the employees there, they just had a terrible attitude.
And again, it was just like you were inconveniencing them and you were like less than because you
were there.
So honestly, Seward, check your attitude.
Holy cows.
What is wrong with you guys?
And also, I remember one time seeing an ad, it was like a post something about Seward
was like making their harbor deeper so bigger cruise ships could come in.
And I'm not going to lie.
It was very entertaining going in there and like looking at all the comments in that thread
because it just turned into like this giant town hall, just brawl right there in it.
It was pretty revealing that there's definitely some strong feelings either way there.
Just know some towns are going to be friendlier than others.
And like I said, I think Homer is probably going to be the most friendly.
And from what I've seen, like Seward, probably on the exact opposite side of that.
So, you know, that is unfortunate, but it just is what it is.
OK, last but not least, let's talk about southeast Alaska.
For the most part, I'm going to say southeast Alaska can have some of the worst attitudes
about tourism really across the entire board.
I kid you not.
There were people actually in Juneau showing up to welcome cruise ships a couple of years
ago with signs just saying, oh, we don't want any more cruise ships because they shut down
the tourist industry altogether during the covid years.
And they just decided, well, this is nice.
We don't want any cruise ships or tourists here anymore.
So they were out there with their dadgum signs, like trying to protest these people as they're
just trying to show up and, you know, pour money into the community through shopping
and eating at the restaurants and everything.
And it's like they thought that the economy of the town runs on just angry retirees.
It's like, what are you people doing?
Like, what are you doing?
I think Juneau probably has one of, if not the worst attitudes towards tourism that I've
seen.
Now, there's going to be some people who are very welcoming, very kind, and also it's your
proportion of having just those nasty people with kind of, I'm going to say a nasty, obnoxious
small town attitude.
And if you've never been in a small town, the attitude is kind of, I can just do whatever
I want within this capacity that I'm working in.
And if you don't like it, who are you going to go talk to?
Okay, there's just, once you get to a point where the town is so small, it needs to have
a really good culture where people just want to do the right thing.
And that's, oh, incredible.
Like that's quintessential small town USA.
And then you have the opposite side of that, where it just turns into this mean, nasty
little attitude with some of these towns where the attitude is just, well, if you don't like
it, who else are you going to talk to?
And horrible attitude.
And unfortunately you do run into that in some towns in Southeast Alaska.
And also you do have some really warm and welcoming people out there as well.
So I don't want to just throw the entire town under the bus.
Just know that in certain areas, you might have kind of that undercurrent of resentment
there, which just is completely out of place and out of line.
Okay, so what is my take when it comes to tourism in Alaska?
My take is, first off, our state really needs tourism, okay?
If you see a tourist here, you had better make sure that you make them feel welcome
and you roll out the red carpet.
And if you are in a small town like a Seward or Homer or Kenai or any of these small towns
where you live or die off of tourism, you had better start singing Be Our Guest really
quick and fix your attitude of anyone around you who you see are just being obnoxious and
nasty to our guests that are coming to this state.
That's what I'm going to say right off the bat.
Also, if you're in a town and you don't like it and you don't like the number of tourists
that are coming in and you don't like the fact that your economy is dependent on tourism,
develop some other industries within your town, okay?
That is perfectly fine.
The problem is, like I said, you get some of these small towns that have so stifled
development in their town because we just want to keep it exactly where it's at.
We don't care about the long-term viability of this entire town or what happens in 20,
30 years when we're not here anymore.
We just want to keep it exactly the way it is right now for ourselves.
And that is an incredibly short-sighted, selfish way to live, and that's wrong.
And if you don't like the tourism, then you need to develop another industry.
And if you're not going to develop another industry, then I don't know what to do for
you, okay?
You're kind of a Goldilocks.
Go live off-grid somewhere, and that might be the best option.
There are some real issues and there are some real concerns that do deserve to be addressed
for some of these folks in these towns.
But unfortunately, when it comes down to actually having solutions that's going to be a viable
solution, a lot of the conversation just shuts down and people just wanted to complain.
So that's probably why you guys are seeing me so fired up here.
But I've kind of just gone on to a rant here.
The bottom line is tourism, it's a big deal in Alaska.
It needs to be encouraged more.
If you're looking at making a visit up here to Alaska, I'm going to say first off, welcome
to our great state, and let me know if you have any other questions.
Thanks for hanging out with me, and we'll see you next time.