Donald Trump’s $1.8 billion IRS controversy has erupted into a stunning federal court confrontation—and U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams is at the center of a ruling that strikes directly at the legitimacy of the arrangement.
The controversy goes far beyond an ordinary dispute over taxes.
Trump originally sued the IRS after his tax information became public. But after returning to the White House, the lawsuit took an extraordinary turn. According to the court’s ruling, Trump’s attorneys were negotiating against government lawyers representing the Justice Department and IRS—even though those agencies ultimately fell under the authority of Trump’s own administration.
The proposed arrangement reportedly included a massive $1.8 billion “anti-weaponization” fund along with protections against future tax audits involving Trump, his two oldest sons, and the Trump Organization.
But Judge Kathleen Williams refused to give the agreement judicial legitimacy.
In a blistering 56-page ruling, Williams concluded that the lawsuit had been brought for an “improper purpose” and criticized lawyers involved for attempting to “manipulate the judicial process.” She questioned whether genuine adverseness between the parties had ever existed and described the suggestion that they were truly opposing sides as “risible.”
The consequences went beyond harsh language.
The settlement was voided. Attorneys faced professional sanctions. One Trump lawyer was referred to the Florida Bar for possible disciplinary proceedings, while another faced restrictions on practicing before the Southern District of Florida.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by President Trump against the IRS, labeling it a \"fraud on the court.\" The ruling determined the case was a sham designed to secure personal benefits, including tax audit immunity and a massive fund for allies, leading to sanctions and disciplinary referrals for the attorneys involved.
A federal judge today blasting President Trump's lawsuit against the IRS,
saying it was filed to quote, manipulate the judicial process.
That lawsuit led to an attempt by the Justice Department to create a nearly 1.8 billion
dollar so-called anti-weaponization fund that would benefit the president's allies.
It was also used to justify an order shielding the president,
his family and his businesses from IRS scrutiny on past tax returns.
Now the judge is referring Trump's personal attorney who brought the case
and top Justice Department officials to state bar associations for potential disciplinary action.
CNN senior justice correspondent Evan Perez joins me now.
So Evan, the six-page ruling, walk us through it.
What stands out? Why is it so important?
Yeah, Casey, you don't normally see judges issue 56 pages of just scathing.
We just heard the core of a 56-page ruling that does not mince words.
This is not a routine tax dispute. This is a federal judge declaring that the
president of the United States used the court system itself as a tool for personal benefit.
1.8 billion dollars. An anti-weaponization fund.
Permanent immunity from tax audits for Donald Trump,
his two oldest sons and the Trump organization.
All of it wrapped inside a lawsuit Trump filed against the very agency he now controls.
Judge Kathleen Williams looked at the paperwork and said the quiet part out loud.
There were never two opposing sides. There was only one side wearing two different suits.
That is not a settlement. That is self-dealing dressed up as justice.
And when you hear Trump's reaction, you will understand
exactly why this ruling cuts deeper than money.
And they try to use this so-called agreement, this settlement, to say,
no, you can't look at us. What this judge is saying is that you can't even refer to that.
Now, I'm not sure whether she has the power to do this,
but she's basically saying that since this lawsuit was a farce from the beginning,
you can't now call this a settlement in good faith.
All right. Evan Perez reporting for us. Evan, thank you, as always. Really appreciate it.
My panel's here, and we're also joined now by CNN senior law enforcement analyst,
the former deputy director of the FBI, Andrew McCabe.
Andy McCabe, what do you see in what the judge has done
here, and what would you underscore as this potentially goes forward?
Because as Evan said, it's not clear exactly what power the judge has here,
how this materially affects things. But certainly it is, at the very least,
a symbolic blow to a president who cares quite a bit about symbolism.
Oh, it's a strong symbolic blow. It's also potentially a much more than that,
depending on where these referrals about the attorneys involved, where that stuff goes.
But Casey, the thing that jumps out to me here is many people were surprised by the creation of this
fund to compensate the president's supporters. Many people were shocked by the conveyance of
immunity, despite the current acting attorney general's rejection of that term,
immunity for tax problems. But the judge here went far beyond that. She looked at the actual,
factual circumstances in the way that this sort of fake lawsuit has made its way through the process,
and really relied on those for her conclusion. So in other words, the Department of Justice
never actually answered the complaint in this matter, which enabled this thing to just kind of
hover assigned to a judge, but it never actually took on the form of a lawsuit in which a matter
is of controversy and two sides are fighting over it. They never filed a complaint. The plaintiff
allowed them to get away with that. And that gave the plaintiff the ability to basically dismiss
the lawsuit without getting the judge's approval, which is exactly what happened here in return for
these very suspicious agreements. Another great point is that there were many other victims of
this IRS problem. So the person who inappropriately shared the tax information of citizens did it not
just for Donald Trump and his family, but for many other people as well. Some of those folks
filed lawsuits and the Department of Justice jumped in and defended the IRS in every one of those
suits. They could have done the exact same thing here as the president was a very similar plaintiff,
but of course they objected. They decided not to. So there were all kinds of facts in the background
here that really made this entire thing look like exactly what it was, and that is a fraud on the
court. Yeah, remarkable. And Elliott Williams, you pointed out this piece of what the judge had to
say, and it was aimed squarely at the acting attorney general. Acting attorney general blanches
apparent capacity to speak for both plaintiffs and defendants, sign a settlement document on behalf
of all parties, and then repudiate part of that agreement demonstrates that there was actually
only one party whose interests were being represented throughout this case, which is a
fundamental perversion of how the system is supposed to work. Fair, proper, protected the American
people. Those are the words coming from Trump and his allies. The 56-page order says the opposite
in colder language. The lawsuit was filed for an improper purpose. There was never adverseness
between the parties. The entire proceeding was an attempt to obtain the court's stamp of legitimacy
for an arrangement that could not survive open scrutiny. Go deeper. In 2020, Trump's tax returns
leaked. The New York Times reported he paid only $750 in federal income tax the year he won the
presidency, and nothing in many prior years. He sued. After returning to power, he turned that
same lawsuit into a vehicle. His former personal lawyers sat on one side. Officials he appointed
sat on the other. The result? A nearly $1.8 billion fund and a shield against future audits.
When public pressure forced the fund to be abandoned, the immunity language was kept.
Judge Williams refused to let the court be used as a rubber stamp. She referred one of Trump's
lawyers to the Florida bar and restricted another. That is not a warning. That is the system beginning
to reject the arrangement. In her 56-page decision yesterday, the judge determined lawyers on both
sides of the case, including Trump's attorneys and lawyers for the Justice Department and IRS,
tried to manipulate the judicial process. The judge referred one Trump attorney to the Florida
bar for possible disciplinary action, and also sent her order to the New York bar,
where Acting Attorney General Todd Blanch is a member. The DOJ spokesperson issued a statement
on the ruling that reads, in part, there was no collusion in this case, and the partisan judge
who speculated otherwise has disregarded decades of precedent. Joining us now, former U.S. attorney
and MSNOW legal analyst Barbara McQuaid. Barbara, good morning. The tell always is when they
attack the credentials of the judge, because they can't do it on the evidence. But my goodness,
this ruling not just called the entire case improper, but went after the attorneys who
prosecuted it and the relationship between the White House and the Justice Department.
Yes, and I love the callback to no collusion. That's an only but a goodie. And of course,
collusion isn't really the point. It's that there is no arm's length in this relationship here.
There is a conflict of interest, because as the judge said, Donald Trump is the plaintiff and
Donald Trump is the defendant. She even cites the new slaughter case decided by the Supreme Court,
citing the unitary executive theory. If the president is allowed to fire anybody in the
executive branch, including the head of the IRS and the head of the Treasury Department,
then when he sues those people, this is not an arm's length transaction.
This is a conflict of interest. She also knows a couple other interesting things, really.
That is, she actually raised this issue while the lawsuit was pending. And two days before
briefs were due to explain to her why this was a legitimate case over which a court has
jurisdiction, they dismissed the case and instead negotiated this out of court settlement.
She said that was a real tell that there was never any case or controversy here in the first place.
You know, Barbara, we have sat through for years just looking at these asinine lawsuits being
brought. And I would just, I just look at it and say, who are the attorneys that are doing this?
Because if I had done that in Northwest Florida, I think the federal judges there would not only
sanction me, they'd probably put me under jail for a week for being in contempt. I actually see
this as a really positive step forward. These are officers of the court. They are not just
dupes of Donald Trump. They are officers of the court. Do you see this as a positive step forward
that a judge is finally treating them as officers of the court who, if they step over the line,
are going to be possibly sanctioned by the bar? I do because I think that kind of response could
have a deterrent effect on lawyers who feel like they're able to get away with it. As you know,
Joe, there is a specific law that forbids lawyers from engaging in conflicts of interest.
And she cites that rule when she makes these referrals. I think the other thing that's
important here is Todd Blanche getting quite a bit of comeuppance here, where she refers to him as
misleading at best and disingenuous at worst based on the testimony he gave to Congress last month.
He, of course, is facing confirmation hearings this week. And I think this court gives a lot
of good ammunition to the senators who will be asking questions to explain to the American people
just what was so awful about this. They attempted, as the court says, to manipulate the process and
use the court to legitimize what was otherwise an improper payout to Donald Trump. There's,
of course, the slush fund. But she also notes that this was potentially a $100 million
gift in the form of immunity from tax audits to Donald Trump himself.
And so I think that we're gonna hear a lot of questions about this during those confirmation
hearings. Grisable, laughable, absurd on its face. This is no longer about taxes.
This is about a sitting president treating a federal courtroom as a private notary public
for family business. Michael Cohen once told Congress that Trump inflated asset values to
better loans and insurance while minimizing tax exposure. The same
to erase past risk and lock in future protection. Trump's allies immediately labeled the judge a
radical and called the ruling political revenge. The order itself does not rely on politics.
It relies on a basic legal requirement that has existed for centuries. A real lawsuit needs two
sides with genuinely opposing interests. When one man controls both sides of the table,
the lawsuit is not a lawsuit. It is theater, and the theater has been shut down on the record.
Jessica Levinson joining us live now. So Jessica, let's talk about this. The judge
has accused Trump and his lawyers of having manipulated the court system. What is her
reasoning? So in part, I think what you just said that this suit was brought for an improper purpose.
And what does that really mean? I think what the judge was saying throughout the decision was
this was actually never, number one, an adversarial process. The Trump attorneys and
the Department of Justice attorneys were actually acting in concert. I believe she used the word
collusion. When it comes to lawsuits in America, particularly in federal court, what we know is
that they need to be an adversarial process. There needs to be an actual case or controversy.
I talked to my students about making sure that federal judges cannot issue advisory opinions.
And what I think the judge was really saying is you went to federal court. This was never
adversarial. You had an improper purpose. And that improper purpose was basically to try and
get a federal judge to bless a settlement that never should have been in court in the first
place. And for those reasons, that's why you see the judge say this was a misuse of the judicial
process. It threatened the integrity of the judicial process. And again, that's why I think
you see those referrals to the state bar and those suggestions that there be investigations
into the Department of Justice attorneys who are part of this case. Essentially, the judge saying,
were you actually undermining your duties as an attorney when you agreed to bring and defend
and settle this case? So what consequences could we see as a result of the judge's decision?
So obviously, the immediate consequences, that settlement fund, the 1776 fund is void. That also
means that, as you said, President Trump can now be audited. Part of the settlement was that he
could not be audited. And I think what you also see in terms of consequences,
of course, there will be political consequences. In terms of legal consequences, you see an
affirmation of the idea that if you walk into court, you can't be colluding with the other
side. This needs to be an actual adversarial conflict. And you can't use a judge to bless
something that should never have been a case in the first place. The consequences do not
end with the voided agreement. Once a court declares there was never a real controversy,
every layer of legitimacy peels away. Lawyers face ethics referrals. One attorney is restricted
from practicing in the Southern District of Florida for a year. And the larger signal is
unmistakable. Arrangements of this kind will no longer receive automatic judicial cover.
Trump and his circle continue to frame the ruling as political persecution. The paper trail says
For the first time, a federal judge examined the internal architecture of Trump's second-term power
and stated plainly that the court was being used as an accounting device for private gain.
This strikes at the heart of the identity Trump has sold for decades. The man too rich,
too powerful, and too clever to be touched by the system. When the system itself refuses to
notarize the deal, that identity cracks. Not because of a political party. Because a judge
A federal judge says the Department of Justice and attorneys for President Trump
misused the court in his civil lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service.
In her decision, Judge Kathleen Williams wrote,
This matter was brought for an improper purpose, and the plaintiffs acted in bad faith.
The president's legal team slammed that decision, writing in part,
The IRS wrongly allowed a rogue, politically motivated employee
to leak private and confidential information. Their statement goes on to read,
So what's going on here? CBS News legal reporter Katrina Kaufman has been looking
through all of this and joins us now in studio to discuss. Katrina, good morning and welcome.
What is the judge's reasoning on her scathing ruling here against the president and his lawyers?
Good morning, Errol. Yes, this was truly a scathing ruling to read. And basically what she
says is this wasn't a real lawsuit. She says it was essentially a sham, that there were no
adversarial parties. In a lawsuit, you want two sides with actual opposing views. And
she outlines how basically President Trump was just in control of every party involved in this
case. So she says there was no actual adversarial process here, and that really this was just
brought to essentially get an official legal stamp from the court to make it seem like this
had been legitimate and that the settlement was gotten in a way that was actually approved by
our judicial system. She says none of that's true. And so as a result, she essentially just says that
this cannot go forward. And what are the consequences of the judge looking into the
available evidence and making this type of ruling? I mean, the administration has said that they're
not moving forward with the settlement, so it's unclear whether it actually voids anything. But
she says that President Trump, his sons, they can't actually refer to this settlement if they're
audited later. And most immediately, Errol, there are potential consequences for attorneys here.
She refers President Trump's attorney for possible disciplinary action. There's another one of his
attorneys who was involved. She says he can't try to work in Florida for the next year. And even
more importantly, when it comes to Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, she wants this order sent to
the New York State Bar, which is where Blanche is barred, and the same for Stanley Woodward, also
for the DOJ, sent to Washington, D.C., so that this can be part of an investigation into their
behavior as well. So the judge found that their behavior was necessary enough now for review,
to the highest degree, I guess, for a lawyer. And I'm wondering how this could impact Blanche's
acting attorney general, his efforts to be Trump's nominee, to be the next.
In this case, there weren't really two sides being represented here. And yes,
tomorrow he has his confirmation hearing. It is not a good look, two days before,
for an order like this to be sent to the New York Bar Association by a judge and for the way that
he is handling himself in court, the way he's handling DOJ, to be so scathingly questioned
and rebuked by this judge. Just a remarkable development. Katrina Kaufman,
thanks for walking us through all of it. Thank you.
This is not a tax ruling. This is a ruling about what happens when power stops being
checked from the inside. The myth that Trump is too rich to be audited and too powerful to be
constrained just ran into 56 pages of dry, precise judicial language. Bad faith, improper
purpose, risible, never adverseness. If the numbers and the settlement had been clean and
truly adversarial, an independent judge reading the file would have been a routine Wednesday.
It was not. That is why this decision stings. Not because of the dollar figure,
because it opens the machine that has operated for too long without anyone lifting the cover.
If you want this case explained without the pre-packaged defense language,
stay here, subscribe, turn on the bell, and in the comments answer one question with a
straight face of your own. If that agreement had been legitimate and truly contested,
why did the judge have to use the word risible?