We Tried Secret Menu Items

Street Food
4 followers
12 Video Views·Sep 8, 2026
We tried all the secret menu items we could find!
Watch more at https://www.2ndtry.tv
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe hosts of \"Try Every Day\" taste-test various \"secret menu\" items from In-N-Out, Taco Bell, and Wendy's. They evaluate whether these custom orders offer unique flavor profiles or are merely basic modifications, weighing the appeal of \"meat monstrosities\" against simpler, more balanced customizations.
Hey guys, you know, I'm sort of known for eating menus.
But some restaurants have secret menus.
Oh, that's right. Secret menu taste test.
Hey, let's give it a try.
Welcome to Try Every Day.
Today we're going to do a little secret menu taste test.
We've got a lot of different foods from different fast food chains
and we're going to be sort of creating these things that are secret.
We're creating?
Well, so some of them are like you order them that way
and some are you order things and build it.
Okay.
At least that's my understanding.
We'll find out though.
Let's start with the place most known for secret menus, In-N-Out.
In-N-Out, I knew it.
Time to ostracize most of the country.
What's this called?
This is the animal style burger.
Oh, I love animal style.
That's just normal, right?
I guess it's true.
Like the thing they're most known for is technically a secret item.
I mean, I usually get animal style fries,
but I've never gotten animal style burger.
What is the animal style?
Okay, the patties fried in mustard.
Comes with extra pickles, YB's fave.
And it has extra grilled onions in the spread.
It's basically super delicious.
Yeah.
Let's have the double-double animal style.
Definitely toasted.
This is great.
Yeah, this is great.
It's good.
Delicious.
The toasted buns make it crunchy.
The In-N-Out sauce and mixed with the animal style
makes it even more flavorful.
And here's why it's an animal style.
Dripping.
It's a mess.
Thank you for the full roll of paper towels back here
because we need it.
Wow.
The only thing I will say,
is it a secret menu if you don't really even have a menu?
It's the most known thing.
Well, I didn't know, again, that there was a burger form of that
because animal style fries, yeah.
So In-N-Out is like famously known for bad fries, I think.
But if you get animal fries, animal style fries, it's amazing.
It changes the whole game.
Get them well done.
Well, guess what's next?
Animal style fries?
Hell yeah!
Wow, that looks good.
This is amazing.
Yeah, it's a mess.
But you can really see all the extra grilled onions,
the spread, the cheese, the slices of cheese they melted on.
And this is why the fries, it doesn't matter how bad they are
because you can just like eat it all together.
You're kind of turning it into a loaded baked potato at this point.
Yes, exactly.
Gotta get all the goo on it.
All the goo.
Oh, this is some soft fries.
Barely cooked.
Yeah, why do you think their fries are bad?
At this point, it's commitment to the bit.
Yeah, it is, really.
Because they've heard tell that people don't like them.
So they're like, nah, you're wrong, actually.
No, but they charge more for animal style fries.
Yeah.
So maybe that's why they're trying to sell more animal style fries.
I think it's just the slice of cheese.
What?
You didn't understand?
No.
I think cheese is the only thing they charge more for.
You sure?
I think.
Not sure.
It really feels like Hollywood.
We got grilled onions and just burgers and cheese.
Do you have a cutting board so I don't have to cut directly on your desk?
Yeah, I'm really kind of loving all the meat patties on my desk.
Yeah, Rachel, vegetarian of the office.
And we're using her desk for all these videos
because it's the best, longest desk we've got.
This looks almost like a five-star gourmet plate, if you put it nicely.
In a way, it does.
All right, the Flying Dutchman.
Let's cut into this bad boy.
Oh, I love how it looks.
So much onion.
This is what I was looking for in the Filipino taste test.
These are my meat cakes.
OK.
I bet this is delicious.
Why would this not be good?
Cheers.
Amazing.
You know what, YB?
This is like a high-class meal.
What?
I think it's a pork and nap dinner.
And the full grilled onion is so delicious
because it's been cooked down for so long.
I mean, how long do they have to cook these whole onion things to get them that tender?
It just needs lettuce because it's so salty.
But it doesn't need bread.
I'm not missing the bread.
No, I'm not missing the bread.
It's yummy.
The onions are my new bread.
And I think this is healthy.
Define healthy.
Low carb.
Full of protein.
Vegetables.
Healthy dairy.
I mean, cheese is healthy.
Yeah.
Pickles are antioxidants.
Pickles.
As I said before, pickles are American kimchi.
So this is every shake and ice cream flavor in one cup.
What?
Don't they just have three?
I remember.
OK, I'll introduce.
So next we have the around the world shake.
It's all of their flavors of ice cream as a milkshake.
So it's like a Neapolitan.
But I remember that they actually don't have three ice creams there.
They have a base vanilla that they add flavoring into for the milkshakes
because I did this underneath the menu.
And I was like, this is the same ice cream.
They just added a strawberry flavoring and a fudge flavoring, which is not bad.
But it's not three flavors of ice cream.
All right.
Well, let me think.
I think we'll get too close if we go at the same time.
So you can go first.
Uh-oh, you got the skinny straw.
Oh, no.
Good luck.
It's not coming out.
Good luck with that.
Really hard to get out of the straw.
It tastes more chocolatey to me.
Right?
It just tastes like chocolate.
Yeah, it does taste like chocolate.
It's good chocolate.
I look here, and I don't see chocolate at all.
But if you look in my straw, can you see in my straw?
Maybe it's on the bottom.
There it is.
Get in with your fork.
Yeah, let's get in there with my blind judgment fork.
My fork has meat on it.
First, I'll clean it with my mouth.
Now it's ready to go.
I'm going to eat it like this.
Huh.
I don't think that taught me anything.
You do see a little bit of a color.
Oh, you got it.
Oh.
Ew.
I'm trying to show the difference.
This is the only way I can do it.
It looks so wrong.
So the bottom probably was chocolate,
and the top is probably vanilla.
Yeah, and maybe there's a little strawberry somewhere in the whispers.
But I didn't find it.
I still taste chocolate on top.
That's so weird.
It does taste more like chocolate.
I think it's just because the chocolate fudge flavoring is dominating.
So for, like, being a secret item,
I'm not getting that experience that I got with the Flying Dutchman.
Yeah, the Flying Dutchman was just like, wow.
My world is rocked.
Yeah.
This is like, this is a milkshake.
Ding dong.
Taco Bell?
Yes.
Dong.
I wish that Taco Bell's was a doorbell.
Ding dong.
All right, this is the Incredible Hulk Burrito.
What?
It's hella green and healthy.
Healthy?
This is the Incredible Hulk Burrito.
It's hella green.
Hella green.
And healthy.
So let's see.
Let's look.
Here we are.
OK, so you order a beefy five-layer burrito with guacamole instead of nacho cheese.
OK.
And do not include the inner shell and no sour cream.
So just beef and guacamole.
So it's beef and guacamole.
And beans, and beans.
OK.
And beans.
And their beef is wheat and beef, by the way.
It has a wheat filler.
Cheers.
It's really wet.
It was a hard pivot for my ice cream, if I'm being honest.
My mouth is still kind of an ice cream world.
I don't think I've ever gone from ice cream to guacamole.
That's good.
I mean, I would eat it.
That's not what I want from Taco Bell.
I don't want a crunchy ice cream.
I don't want a crunchy taco.
I want something that's a chip that they turned into a food.
But it's nothing special.
I think it needs some kind of crunch, but not from the shell.
I want, like, lettuce in here.
It's not bad.
It's OK.
Yeah.
Hey, guys.
Did you know we have a free video of the month club?
We're on second try.
You can get a free video every month?
Yeah, every month is a different video.
How much does it cost?
It's free.
Oh.
Yeah, it's free.
So you go over there, and you go every month.
So when the month changes, the video changes.
Well, I should just sign up for that, then.
Because I got enough.
It's free.
And I can watch videos that are exclusive?
Yeah.
That's cool.
Yeah.
Well, this month, we should do the smoke show episode
with Ethan Nestor, where we play just to impress.
Oh, it's so funny, too.
Yeah, it's very fun.
Yeah.
OK.
That's what we're doing.
I'm going to go subscribe right now.
People claim this is the biggest burrito there.
Biggest.
This is the biggest burrito in town.
It doesn't look that big.
Doesn't.
But I'm thinking of, like, Chipotle, so.
So it's a cheesy double beef burrito,
adding tortilla strips, guacamole, and potatoes.
It looks a little dry.
Yeah, the rice looks really dry.
Looks dry.
But let's let our tongues be the judge.
The Superman.
Superman.
This is more of a meal.
A lot of rice.
And the rice plus potatoes, two starches,
is very filling without necessarily
being really satisfying.
OK.
I could use more flavor.
There's so much bread, so much starch.
I want more meat.
I want more goo.
Cheese.
Nacho cheese or something.
Some goo.
It needs more goo.
It is dry.
Yeah.
Taco Bell is sort of known as being a goo king.
So the secret menu is not so gooey.
But I guess Superman's not gooey.
Well, since we're saying secret menu,
like, neither of those are very special to me.
They don't seem secret-y.
I think to be special, a secret menu at Taco Bell,
it needs to be, like, a combination of a burrito
and, like, something else.
Like, something crazy.
I want to see a burrito inside of a Crunchwrap Supreme.
Yeah.
Like, burrito pizza.
I don't know.
Yes.
Something like that.
Crunchwrap Mexican pizza.
Yeah.
Like that.
Yeah.
That's what we're looking for here.
Not just a burrito with different stuff inside.
Yeah.
That's just a burrito.
Well, our last Taco Bell item is the Cheesarito.
Oh, tiny.
Cheesarito.
What is this?
Came with a free lactate.
Awesome.
I hope this is shredded cheese, nacho cheese,
and some other cheese, and that's all it is.
It's a cheesy roll-up.
It's like the tiniest.
It's just cheese, isn't it?
It's just a wad of cheese in here.
Yes.
What?
It is melted cheese, scallions, and then the sauce of your choice
wrapped up in a soft tortilla.
OK.
Cheese.
Yeah, let me open it up.
Someone wrote scallions, but it's onions.
Leslie corrected me.
Scallions are onions.
I was like, scallions is a fun choice.
Green onion.
This, to me, is the first thing that's truly secret.
So I'm like, that's different.
Yeah, it is different.
I've never had an onion and cheese burrito.
Same.
So I'm interested.
At least me.
OK.
All right, the cheese burrito.
It does seem like it's for children, I have to say.
I don't think children would like this.
That's too many onions.
I love the onion situation happening in here.
You like it?
Like, when I was a kid, I would have hated this because I hated onions.
I don't think the onions are raw.
I think they're just lightly sweated onions.
So they're the very beginning process.
That's what you call them.
I know it's a crazy word, but that is what you call when you start cooking onions,
they start to sweat.
It is a cooking term, I'm sorry.
I think this is slam dunk good.
Yeah?
OK, I don't like it because too many onions.
I love it.
It's an onion lover's dream.
Yeah, it is.
This is more of the onion menu than the secret menu.
This is Maddie's order.
Really?
Yeah.
I know you love all the time.
With onion?
I think with beans would be better.
It's good.
It's got like, it's got the simplicity of a grilled cheese.
And the onions give it just a little bit of extra savory vibe.
I just think it's too much onions.
And we're going over to somewhere with pigtails.
Oh, Gwendolyn's.
Gwendolyn's.
This is the barnyard burger.
The barnyard.
It's got pig, chicken, and cow.
Oh my God, look how thick this is.
Old McDonald's.
Oh my God.
Yeah.
It's a Rachel nightmare.
Old McDonald's.
It's the thickest meat I've ever seen in a burger.
It's so tall.
Thumbnail face.
Thumbnail.
Secret.
Wybie, how are you going to eat this?
I don't know.
I'm going to try to get the corner that's easier to bite because it's sticking out.
All right, let's try the old McDonald's.
It's just all meat.
I don't need anything else.
I'm getting the nuance.
Boom.
First of all, Wendy's has good bacon.
So despite being the tiniest protein in the sandwich.
Okay, I taste the chicken the most.
I taste the chicken second.
The beef to me is the thing that's only taking up space.
It tastes like a bacon chicken sandwich and also it's big.
I don't taste the beef at all.
It's mostly the bacon and chicken.
And I don't taste the bread, the cheese, anything.
Is it good?
Kinda.
This is what I'm looking for when I'm talking about secret menu.
I'm on monstrosity.
I want something like, what the hell is that?
What did you bring into my car?
You know, the crunch and the breading of the fried chicken is so seasoned.
Yeah.
It really does overpower the beef.
Like you can separate this and you would only taste this half.
I think anyone who's like trying to bulk up would love this.
Yeah.
It's fine.
It's funny.
To me, it's a stoner dream.
Barnyard Burger, it's a great, wholesome name.
Yeah.
We love to see it.
I know when you go over to Mickey D's, the secret menu items are like the McGangbang.
Oh my god.
I'm not kidding.
That's one of the street names.
Wow.
For the burger and chicken.
It's nice.
The more nice name is the McMookluck.
But the street name?
The McGangbang.
Really?
Yeah.
Wow.
Yeah.
I didn't make that up.
I come from the streets.
And this is the Meat Cube.
Meat Cube?
The Meat Cube.
Okay.
Look how big this is.
Holy ----.
A cube of meat.
No way.
This is a joke.
This is called the Meat Cube or the Graham Slam Burger, but you order Dave's hot and
juicy three quarter pound burger and asked to add another burger patty and cheese slice.
This side of it looks like an oil painting that somebody left in the sun.
It's like a cake.
You're eating it like a Dutchman.
Yeah, I am.
Okay, I'm going to go in hard.
Good luck.
Try the Meat Cube.
Oh my god.
It's a pound for sure.
Dave did it.
Dave freaking did it again.
It's good.
It's a lot.
I feel like I just ate one cube in one bite.
Yeah.
I like that there's cheese in between each layer because otherwise it would be just so
hard to get through just the solid beef.
I could use another set of tomatoes on this.
Yeah, I don't think the tomato at all.
I need like more vegetation.
I would rather have two double burgers, but this, again, is what I'm talking about.
This is what Secret Menu should be.
That's Secret Menu, yeah.
Agreed.
Because sometimes secrets should be kept.
This secret shouldn't have gotten out.
People are upset learning something.
You know, sometimes you share a secret with your family members and they're like, you
should have told me that.
But it's kind of good.
I love the visual on it.
I love watching people eat it.
It's very interesting.
I like it.
I'm getting delirious from it.
I love it.
It's fun.
It's exciting.
It's exciting for sure.
Get a bunch of your buddies in college to go to one of these and eat in.
Get a cube.
Hey, can I get a cube?
You know what I mean.
We wanted the Cajun chicken alfredo, but they don't make it anymore.
They retired it.
No.
So now it's just the spicy chicken alfredo.
I love the bread.
Ma'am?
Oh my god.
The best part.
You just need the soup.
When you're here, you are in fact family.
So this is just red pepper flake?
Uh-huh.
And it's kind of build your own.
Okay.
So I don't know how secret this secret menu item is, but.
I'm okay with a little construction.
A little DIY for the secret menu.
Because that's how you do it at the Mickey D's.
That's how you do it at the other fast food chains.
You got to order your dollar menu items.
Do a little surgery at the table.
Now you got yourself a little bit of gangbang.
That's what it's called.
Oh, I thought you were going to just add all of it in there.
I mean, we've got to be gentle.
It's going to be hot.
Is that good?
Do you want more?
I mean, when I do my Pad Thai, I usually add the whole thing.
I eat it spicy though.
Okay.
You don't have to.
Oh my God.
You said to do this.
Oh yeah, but this is not Pad Thai.
Does it not feel I was encouraged to behave as such?
I used to get fettuccine and alfredo all the time as a child.
When I was shitting my brains out, never connected the two.
Never connected the two.
The spicy chicken alfredo, dirty style.
Looks yummy.
We had to make it ourselves.
This is a lot of red pepper flake.
Cheers.
It's hot.
Wow.
I've never tried it with red pepper, but now I think I'm going to.
It is really good.
How often are you getting this dish?
Not often.
But it is one of my favorite pasta dish.
This takes the greasiness away.
I think that is the way to eat it now.
Maybe don't add the entire thing.
Maybe don't add the whole thing at YB's encouragement.
But it's good.
It's a slight burn that is perfect for a little tingle.
It is better.
It's better, for sure.
Even the chicken by itself is so good with the red pepper.
My mouth is hot and I miss the meat cubes.
What was the best secret you heard today, you guys?
The thing that wowed me the most was the Flying Dutchman.
It was just like so cool, fancy.
So fancy.
Okay, what was your least favorite secret?
Let's talk about secret menu items.
The first ones were just sort of like, that's just a burrito.
Yeah, nothing special.
Some guy subbed out some ingredients for it.
It didn't feel like a secret menu.
The secret menu for me needs to either come from the top or from deep within a Reddit thread.
I liked exploring the secrets of the fast food economy.
Same.
And if you guys have more secret menu items that you want to see us try, let us know.
That's something we tried today.
What you guys trying?
