$8 vs $50 -Can A Somm Tell The Difference?

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
1 Video View·Sep 8, 2026
Can I actually tell which wine is the most expensive… or is it all in my head?
In this challenge, I try to:
Rank the wines from cheapest to most expensive
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA wine expert conducts a blind tasting of three California Pinot Noirs priced at $8, $20, and $50. Despite the tension of a previous ban from the wine store, the experiment proceeds with the goal of identifying the wines by price and region. The taster successfully identifies the price order of all three wines, though she struggles with the specific regional origins.
We are headed to the store. My brother is going to pick out three bottles of California Pinot Noir,
$5, $20, and $50 to see if I can identify in a blind tasting which one costs the most, least,
and middle. And we have an extra challenge this time because last time we went to the wine store
we got kicked out for filming. So I'll be staying in the car and my brother is bravely going to go
in and pick out those wines for me to blind. Go undercover, try to get some cell phone footage.
It's like we're taking photos of the label or something. Yeah, we'll figure it out. Fingers
crossed. All right, so we successfully got all the wine and yeah it was a little dicey because
the same woman that kicked us out last time, same manager, was there and she came up to ask if I
needed help. Unfortunately, it didn't seem like she recognized me so I just slipped in and out.
And I waited anxiously in the car. I'm sweating already. I don't know if this
caffeine is going to help or not. All right, got all of our pinos poured. We have the cheap wine
in slot. We got the expensive one in and our medium $20 wine is in. So we're going to see
if not only can she get those in the correct order, in order of price from cheapest to most
expensive, but knowing these are all pinos from California, we're going to see if she can figure
out which region of California each of these wines are from. Just real quick, we're going to put it
on screen. We got wine number one. Wine number two is from. Wine number three is from. All right,
I'm going to get out of here. Okay, three pinos, three different prices. Will I prevail? Let's
just get right to it. This first wine was, you know, these all look like pinos. It's like a
little garnity, very translucent. That's typical of a pino. Let me see. On the nose, I'm getting
ripe cherry, something almost a little minty about it, which is interesting.
Always takes a minute to warm up. Before I took my like worst blind tasting test of my life,
we met in the parking lot outside the testing place and like squished our mouths.
Okay, I'll stop. Minty, cherry-y. Last time Michael messed with my mind by putting them like
from least expensive to most expensive. I'm trying not to let all this get in my head. It's going to
be the same thing. Did you do something different? I don't know. Fine. Predominant note of ripe cherry,
quite ripe cherry actually. Maybe a little bit of baking spice. I feel like if there was oak on
this, it was subdued. Trent the Cameraman. Trent the Cameraman, are you getting this? Are you
getting this? This is a pro in action. Ah, thank you. Thank you, Trent the Cameraman.
Uh, yeah, kind of pleasant cherry cordial. It's very light in weight. The tannins are
not really doing much, which is also normal. Normal for pinot noir.
Uh, it's hard to make a quality call when I haven't tasted the others of what this is.
I'm inclined to say that this is not the most expensive one, but I have not tasted the others.
So, let's just get on to wine number two. Uh, this one doesn't seem to have a whole lot of
character, but I'm getting really paranoid. Like, they're going to do that to me again.
Let's just call this Sonoma. All right, um, this is slightly deeper in hue. Yeah,
this one's slightly darker, browner in hue. A little more garnet-y. Something almost chocolate-y.
A little more, like, woody on this. Cherry seems more like black cherry,
whereas this one is more red cherry. Yeah, more black cherry. Pinot, you trickster, you.
I feel like today is the day that I... I think there was some oak usage on that. I'm getting,
like, a little bit of vanilla and, uh, like, baking spices. Darker fruit. This one's lighter.
There's less going on. Right, so far I'm inclined to say that maybe this is more expensive than
this one. This one I would put more in, like, a Santa Rita Hills level, I feel like. I feel
like the fruit is riper and more, like, candied here than it is on this one. So, we're going
Sonoma, Santa Rita. I don't know why I have to do this all the time. Nervous tics! I've got them.
All right, wine number three. So, they're... they're all... they're all basically the same
color. Thinking about quality level, there's an acronym they taught us in studying wine,
which is BLEK, which is... stands for balance, length, intensity, complexity, and then you can
add an optional T for topicity, like topicity of region. So, maybe if I need... I need to,
like, go through the BLEK of these. This one does not smell like much compared to the other two.
Dark, dusty cherry. Dark, dusty cherry. Dry, medium acid. Oh, let's walk through them all
again and think about balance, length, intensity, and complexity. Okay. Dry, lightweight. I don't
think there's oak on this. It's a simple Pinot, but it's a simple Pinot. So far, I still think
this is the most expensive one. I feel like there's possibly more happening on this one than this one,
but I can't tell if I like it or not. Which, to my taste, is not necessarily Pinot quality.
Which of these is the under $10 Pinot? This one, and I'm just only talking about...
This one has so much, like, ripeness. Like, I feel like this is the most expensive one,
just because it's more complex. Yeah. There's oak on this. I'm calling this Santa Rita Hills.
I'm calling this the most expensive one. So, that brings us to these two.
Swirl, swirl, reverse your swirl. That is the dance we do.
Easy drinking. Actually, they're all pretty easy drinking. They're just
light and delicious. They're not... They don't even demand food because they don't have, like,
organic structure to need that. That is one of the lovely things about Pinot Noir,
is you can just kind of, like, enjoy it. I'm gonna say that this is the least expensive,
this is the most expensive, and this is the middle. Okay. Well, the least, I think, least,
most, mid. I mean, this could even just be a California Pinot. If it's less than $10,
then it could just be a California Pinot. Still sticking with Santa Rita Hills,
and let's just call this one Monterey, or, like, a sub-region thereof, like San Lucia Highlands.
Okay, how bad did I fail? Okay, final guesses are in. Final guesses are in. How did I do?
Educated guesses. Number one, you said it is... The least expensive, and kind of could just be
California. Just a general California. Yeah, because if it's, like, a less than $10 wine,
kind of, like, doesn't speak to terroir. So, according to the bottle, it is a
carefully selected group of California. Oh, well, I'm sorry. It was carefully selected California.
And the front says Appalachian. Appalachian, California. They're just trying to make
California sound... They're making up regions. I mean, California is a way you can label your
wine, but it means... Okay, so this was the... How much did this cost? Let me see. That is...
$8. The least expensive, and it was $8. Yes! Oh, I'm so good. $7.99. Okay. Okay,
well, I at least got one. So, I got one. Correct. So, number two. Oh, I know this winery
by the labeling, the lettering. It's a good thing we hid the labels from you. Okay, so, well, let's
see. This is number two, and you said it is... The most expensive. The most expensive. You are
correct. Yes! She got all three right. It says it is located... It is the Green Valley vineyards
located in the heart of the Russian River Valley. Oh, okay. So, Sonoma. Okay, I messed that up.
So, I know I got this one right. Wait, so this one went for... Let me guess.
I mean, I feel like it should be in its 40s, but I told you 50. So, like early 50s,
called $52. It was regularly priced $49.99 and on sale for $44.99. Oh, I was right. It is less
than 50. Okay. All right. Number three. Number three. Which we already know. Is the mid-tier.
You nailed it. Do you know where it is from? Well, now that I know this is Sonoma, Russian River,
I'm still going for somewhere more cool climate. It's weird. I thought this was
more cool climate than this, but I was saying like somewhere in Monterey, maybe, or a cooler
part of Sonoma. So, this is select vineyards in Sonoma County. Oh, okay. And I thought Sonoma
County and Russian River were different places, but... Russian River is within Sonoma. Well,
then I did a really bad job picking the greens. No, no, no. That's fine. No, you did great. You
did fabulous. What have we learned from this? It didn't seem like you liked the $50 one that
much more. What was your favorite? Was the $50 one your favorite? It was not this one because
this one was just kind of like... I think I do like this one because when I first smelled this,
I was like, oh wait, price on this. Let me see. I'm going to say $24. I believe it was $19.99.
Exactly. Oh, okay. So, this one definitely tastes like a more expensive wine. There's more going on.
There's more complexity. There's more to think about. It is the most balanced of the wines,
but how much difference between the $8 and the $19.99? Okay, yeah, that just tastes more like
chemicals. Honestly, I think these are all fairly priced. I don't know that I would say one was like
a better value than the other. Well, this was very interesting and educational. I feel better about
myself and also worse about myself that I didn't get the exact regions, but we had, yeah, two nice
Sonoma wines. We had one Appalachian California. Not a diamond in the rough, unfortunately. Not a
diamond in the rough. You know, it's honestly, for an $8 wine, better than Barefoot. Get in here,
big brother. I got a glass of a good one. Good for you. You should because this definitely is the
best. If you have a style or a grape or region you would like me to do a blind taste on,
leave it in the comments below. While you wait for that next video, you should probably like
pour yourself a glass of wine. Well, I was going to say hit subscribe.
Before you get too drunk, hit subscribe. Yes, hit subscribe, bell, like, comment, all the good
things. All the good things and then pour yourself a glass because you are worth it.
We can turn off, turn off the camera now. Is it for outtakes?
Oh, yeah. Yeah, I'll get on my computer.
