What Went Wrong With Artemis 2

Heritage Horizons
23 followers
1 Video View·Sep 8, 2026
How did Artemis II finally get off the ground?
At the time of making this video, the spacecraft is now on its way to swing around the Moon; the first crewed mission to do so in over 50 years. But why has it b
AI Generated·May contain errors
The race to get back to the moon is on. Or is it? For more than 50 years, the footprints left by
the 12 Apollo mission astronauts have remained undisturbed on the moon's surface, perfectly
preserved as a symbolic trophy of Cold War rivalry. Through NASA's Artemis missions,
the plan was to get back there by 2024, and this time not just leave footprints, but to stay.
Since then, things have slipped a bit. But Artemis 1, an uncrewed mission to put the SLS rocket and
Orion capsule to the test, eventually launched on 16 November 2022. Its follow-up, Artemis 2,
was scheduled for launch in February this year. But guess what? It's still stuck on the ground,
on the launch pad in fact. No lunar footprints in sight.
So what is going on with NASA's Artemis? Will Phase 2 be taking off anytime soon,
or are there larger problems that are finally coming to the surface?
I'm Alex McColgan, and you're watching Astrum. Join me today as we propel ourselves into the
inner workings of the Artemis program, from the technical glitches currently grounding Artemis 2,
to the unexpected announcement that Artemis 3 will no longer land on the moon.
We're going to delve into the science and strategy of our return to the lunar frontier.
Will we ever get there?
Artemis is arguably the most complex engineering endeavour in human history,
aiming to establish a permanent, sustainable presence on another world. Yet as we stand on
the threshold of this new era, it seems like the path to get there is becoming increasingly
difficult. First announced in 2017, this was to be the flagship NASA program for the next decade,
in many ways attempting to revive, and perhaps even outdo, the feats achieved by Apollo in the
60s. They made it to boots on the moon in just 8 years before, and with all the technical advances
we've had since then, surely the second time round should be easy? It would seem not.
9 years after the initial announcements, and we are nowhere near.
The immediate priority for NASA is Artemis 2, the first mission to carry humans back to the
vicinity of the moon since 1972. Its aim? Not to land on the surface, but to prove NASA's life
support systems, navigation, communications, and safety systems work in deep space. A 10-day
mission. The crew, consisting of Reid Wiseman, Victor Glover, Christina Koch, and Jeremy Hansen,
were originally scheduled to launch in early 2026. However, the mission has faced a series
of technical delays since then, and the launch window has slipped from early February to 6th
of March to the 1st of April at the earliest. Why exactly? Well, let's take a look at the timeline.
On the 17th of January 2026, the SLS or Space Launch System rocket and attached Orion spacecraft
were moved to launch pad 39B in anticipation of an early February launch. This was a success,
but that's sort of the end of things going right. Nearly two weeks later came Wet Dress Rehearsal 1,
a full fueling test and countdown simulation. Whilst it wasn't a complete flop, teams detected
a liquid hydrogen leak whilst fueling. Hydrogen is the smallest molecule in the universe,
and at the temperatures required for flight, minus 252 degrees Celsius, it is particularly
difficult to contain. So a leak wasn't completely unexpected, but it's not something you can fly with
either, so it did require replacing seals and a ground support filter. Failure 1.
Wet Dress Rehearsal 2, which concluded on the 19th of February, was much more successful. The team
loaded 2.6 million litres of liquid hydrogen and oxygen into the rocket stages and completed two
countdown tests. There were no leaks, and the rocket was signed off as good to go. Until it
wasn't. Post-test, during a routine purge and repressurisation procedure, engineers discovered
that helium wasn't flowing correctly deep within the Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage, the upper
stage of the SLS. Helium is vital for these rockets. It's used to maintain pressure in the
fuel tanks and to purge the engine lines, so a leak puts the whole mission at risk. Without it,
you'd have no propulsion. The culprit was eventually traced to a seal and check valve,
but because it was located in a section of the rocket that is inaccessible while sitting on the
launch pad, NASA was forced to roll the entire 98-metre tall stack back to the Vehicle Assembly
Building for repairs. These recurring leaks weren't just annoying, in many ways they were a
sign of a bigger problem. More tech isn't necessarily better. Not only is there a lot
more to go wrong with Artemis than the initial Apollo missions, but we don't launch them very
often either. In November 1967, Apollo 4 was the first flight of the Saturn V rocket. Less than
two years later, the Apollo 11 crew was delivered to the moon by one. The last time the SLS went up
was in 2022 as part of Artemis 1. That's nearly four years ago at the time of recording.
NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman has noted that launching a rocket as complex as the SLS,
only once every three years, leads to skill atrophy among the workforce. In other words,
people aren't getting enough practice, which is leading to mistakes.
To combat this, NASA has a new plan. Increase the frequency of launches to once every 10 months.
This is meant to keep the hardware and the teams sharp, but it's still a long way off.
Artemis 2 needs to get up in the air and then out of it first.
Beyond the plumbing and what NASA seems to be politely hinting at as a rusty skill set,
there is also a deeper, more sobering reality setting in. The sheer risk of what we are trying
to do. It has been over 50 years since a manned spacecraft left Earth's orbit for the moon,
and recently NASA officials have been under fire for sidestepping questions regarding
likelihood of mission failure, or to put it bluntly, death. In the Apollo era, we were taking
steps into the unknown, and the end results were seen as justifying the extremely high risks. Now
we know it can be done safely, the tolerance for such potential disaster and the loss of life
is far less. And the truth is, flying to the moon for the first time in 54 years is an inherently
dangerous gamble. We're using new software, new contractors, and a rocket that has only flown
once before. Even though Artemis 1 was considered a near-perfect test flight,
it revealed anomalies that could be catastrophic with the crew on board.
NASA must balance the pressure to meet a political schedule with the reality that
any single Type A mishap could end the program entirely.
After two aborted launch attempts, the uncrewed Artemis 1 mission blasted off on the 16th November
2022 from Cape Canaveral in Florida. This was the first time NASA's SLS rocket and the Orion
module left the bounds of Earth. The mission lasted for 25 days and 10 hours before Orion
splashed back down on Earth, and as I mentioned, it was a great success, proving that we can
indeed make it back to the moon with a craft capable of transporting humans.
The European Service Module went one step further, generating so much extra power within
its solar arrays that it had time to use them as a selfie stick. This image is of Orion locking
back to Earth. It was only in the aftermath of the mission that the anomalies appeared.
One of the most critical issues was Orion's heat shield, particularly how it behaved hurtling back
to Earth at 40,000 km an hour. Post-flight inspections found that the ablative material
that covers the shield, called Avcoat, had chipped and eroded away in more than 100 places,
in ways that were never seen during the Apollo era despite the same material being used.
This shield stands between fragile human astronauts and the extreme temperatures
that friction causes upon re-entry, and chunks of it just broke off.
NASA's investigation into the damage found that gases generated during the intense heating of
re-entry were getting trapped inside the Avcoat material. Usually these gases vent out through the
charred layer, but because this specific material lacked enough permeability, internal pressure built
up until the shield literally cracked. With enough damage, this could lead to the entire capsule
burning up, which is not a risk you can take with people inside. On the back of this discovery,
NASA has made a rather controversial decision. Rather than redesigning the shield, they are
instead changing the way astronauts return to Earth. On Artemis 1, Orion used a skip-entry
maneuver, where the capsule dips into the atmosphere, skips back out like a stone being
skimmed on a lake, and then re-enters, the whole process reducing the speed of the capsule.
While it also reduces the g-force on the crew, it actually makes the heat shield problem worse
by allowing gases to build up during that skip phase. For Artemis 2, NASA will skip the skip,
performing a steeper, more direct re-entry that is harder on the astronaut's body,
but safer for the shield, and hopefully in the long run, the astronauts themselves. Short term
pain, long term gain. They'll be alive. It's a fairly large change to the mission,
but is in no way the biggest to hit the news lately.
The pathway through the Artemis mission has been somewhat set since the word go. Artemis 1,
prove our rocket and spacecraft can make it to the moon. Artemis 2, add in the astronauts to
test and verify all the other systems needed as they do a lunar flyby. Artemis 3, land on the moon.
For 9 years, Artemis 3 was marketed as the grand return, the moment human boots would finally
touch the lunar soil again. But as of February 2026, that plan has been scrapped. Artemis 3 will
no longer land on the moon. Instead, it has been redefined as a 30-day wall-up systems test in low
Earth orbit. I'll explain what this is in a minute, but the reason for this change is safety
and complexity. An independent safety panel warned that the previous plan carried a
compounded level of technical risk. To land on the moon, the Orion capsule will first have to dock
with SpaceX's Starship Human Landing System, the vehicle that will transfer them to the surface
in a very specific lunar orbit. The Starship is a massive vehicle that requires more than a dozen
tanker flights just to refuel before it can leave for the moon. NASA realized that attempting a
lunar landing with so many firsts all in one go, the first crew docking, the first cryogenic fuel
transfer, and the first of new spacesuits, was perhaps not the best way to do it. Instead,
Artemis 3 is now doing what Apollo 9 did in 1969, staying near Earth to test the lunar module
before anyone is allowed to take it to the moon. In 2027, Artemis 3 will see Orion rendezvous
and dock with either SpaceX's Starship or Blue Origin's Blue Moon lander right here in Earth's
backyard. This allows them to test life support, communications, and docking procedures without the
life or death stakes of being nearly 390,000 kilometres away. This shake-up in mission
planning also involves a radical change to the rocket itself. For years, the plan was to upgrade
the space launch system to a more powerful version called Block 1B, which features a massive new
upper stage called the Exploration Upper Stage, or EUS. But the EUS has been long criticised
due to delays and cost overruns. Under the new leadership of Jared Isaacman, NASA has cancelled
the EUS entirely, along with the Block 1B and Block 2 upgrades. In a major move to standardise
the fleet, NASA has taken a different route, officially selecting United Launch Alliance's
Centaur 5 as the new upper stage for the SLS, starting with Artemis 4. The Centaur 5 is a
dual-engine stage already in use on ULA's Vulcan rocket, and it represents a near-drop-in replacement
that allows NASA to abandon the costly development of the EUS. While it holds about twice as much
fuel as the existing ICPS, it is compatible with the current Mobile Launcher-1, the ground
structure that is used to assemble, process and launch NASA's SLS rocket and Orion spacecraft,
meaning they don't have to wait for the construction of more massive launch infrastructure.
It's by sticking to this standardised SLS that they hope to escape the cycle of 3-year gaps
between launches and move towards the mission every 10 months that I mentioned before.
So, to the big question I know you're all asking. If Artemis 3 is now a dress rehearsal in Earth
orbit, when will we actually land on the Moon? Well, I'm afraid it's quite a way off.
The new target for Artemis 4 is in early 2028. What I will say though is that the scientific
payoff at the lunar south pole is where the real depth of this mission lies, and it'll be worth
the wait. Unlike the Apollo landing sites near the equator, Artemis 4 is set to land at the south
pole of the Moon, a world of eternal shadows and brutal extremes. Because the Moon's axis
is nearly vertical, tilted only 1.5 degrees, the Sun stays low on the horizon, casting shadows that
haven't moved in billions of years. These are the permanently shadowed regions, or PSRs.
Inside these craters, temperatures can be as low as nearly minus 240 degrees Celsius,
colder than the surface of Pluto. This is where the gold rush of the 21st century begins,
the search for water ice. We now know that these dark craters act as coal traps, preserving ice
that likely arrived via comets and asteroids eons ago. And this isn't just a scientific curiosity,
it's a strategic resource. If we can harvest water ice from the Moon, we can split it into
oxygen for breathing and hydrogen for rocket fuel. The Moon becomes a deep space gas station,
the essential first step for any future mission to Mars. Artemis 4 will carry a suite of advanced
instruments to investigate this frontier. One of the most important is DUSTA, the Dust and Plasma
Environment Surveyor. Lunar dust is one of the greatest threats to human exploration.
It's not like Earth dust. Instead, it's made of tiny, jagged shards of volcanic glass that are
electrostatically charged by the solar wind. It sticks to everything, grinds away at seals,
and is toxic if inhaled. DUSTA, mounted on a small autonomous rover called MAP,
will study how this dust behaves when a lander touches down or when astronauts walk through it.
Alongside DUSTA will be the South Pole Seismic Station, or SPSS. This seismometer will listen
to the heartbeat of the Moon, measuring moonquakes and the frequency of meteorite impacts.
The astronauts will even use a thumper, a device that creates controlled seismic waves,
to map the structure of the ground beneath their feet, looking for the telltale signatures of
buried ice deposits. One specific area of interest is Shackleton Crater, which is 21km
wide and 4km deep. A place where the walls are so steep they exceed a 30 degree slope,
creating a perfect trap for ancient volatiles. To operate in this environment, the astronauts
need more than just a rocket. They need a new skin. The next generation of explorers will wear
the Axiom Extravehicular Mobility Unit, or AxiMU. These suits, developed in partnership with Axiom
Space and even the fashion house Prada, are a massive leap over the Apollo A7L suits.
The old Apollo suits were notoriously stiff. Astronauts often had to bunnyhop because they
couldn't easily bend their knees or waist. The AxiMU uses a hybrid design of hardshell parts
and advanced fabric joints that provide a range of motion never seen before in a pressurised garment.
The suit is essentially a self-contained spacecraft. It features a life support system
that can withstand the extreme cold of the PSRs for at least 2 hours. It includes 4G LTE communications
developed with Nokia, and a high-tech visor system developed with Oakley. Most importantly,
it is built with seals and materials specifically designed to keep the abrasive lunar dust out of
the joints and the airlock. Artemis 3 will be the first time these suits are tested in the
actual vacuum of space before they are relied upon for the landing in 2028. But as well as
all this cool science, there's something else going on in this race to get back to the moon.
Geopolitics. Despite increased costs and a desire to prove that they can execute on their promise to
go back to the moon, NASA's urgency for another lunar landing has another big driver, what they
are calling credible competition from China. Beijing has been methodically checking off
milestones, including returning samples from the moon's far side, and announcing their own plans
for a crewed landing by 2030. US officials are concerned about a space sector capture,
the idea that China could establish a presence at the resource-rich South Pole and effectively claim
their own territory. If that happens, then NASA's plans for future Mars missions and beyond could
crumble into moon dust. It's turned Artemis from a scientific mission into a strategic necessity
to win the race. Only time can tell if they will come out on top.
The journey to the moon has always been a story of trial and error. In 1969, we reached the lunar
surface because we were willing to take enormous risks in a race against time and the Russians.
Today, the stakes are different. We aren't racing to plant a flag, we're racing to build an economy.
The transition to a standardised SLS with the Centaur V stage, the low earth orbit test of
Artemis III, and the deep science of Artemis IV represent a move toward a sustainable,
repeatable presence. Simply putting a person back on the moon won't be enough to win the
geopolitical war. The moon's South Pole remains the most significant scientific target in our
solar system, a place where the history of our planet is frozen in shadow, where the fuel for
our future is waiting to be found. The road to 2028 may be longer and more complex than we anticipated,
but the foundation we are building now is meant to last not for a decade, but for a century.
On the 12th of March, NASA gave the official go for crew to prepare for a 1st of April launch on
Artemis II. With the astronauts in quarantine and the rocket back on the launch pad, I for one
really hope it takes off. After all, regardless of the technical failures, budget overruns,
and changing geopolitical landscape that have forced a radical rethink of how we get back to
the moon, it would be great to watch another moon landing, especially for those of us who
weren't around to see it the first time. A massive thank you to our astronauts on Patreon.
This video had no sponsors, but it was still made possible thanks to the hundreds of members
we have there. Link is in the description to join our growing community. Patreon is where Astrum
truly takes shape, a place for people who love space, who want to see these videos keep improving
and reaching more curious minds. Every new member keeps the channel focused on what
really matters, making the complexity of space available to everyone.
If you enjoy what we do, come join the Astrum community today.
