Prudential Disability Insurance Company (Ep. 8, part 1/2)

Disability Insurance
6 followers
8 Video Views·Sep 8, 2026
In this episode disability insurance attorneys Gregory Dell, Stephen Jessup and Cesar Gavidia of Attorneys Dell & Schaefer discuss Prudential Insurance Company and their handling of long term disability insurance claims.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAttorneys from Dell & Schaefer discuss the practices of Prudential Insurance Company, one of the world's largest group insurers. The discussion highlights Prudential's tendency to wrongfully terminate long-term disability claims by over-relying on \"objective evidence\" and ignoring treating physicians, while examining legal precedents and the impact of ERISA on claimant recovery.
Welcome back to another edition of Disability Insurance Law TV.
My name is Gregory Dell and I'm a long-term disability insurance attorney.
Today I am joined by attorney Cesar Gavidia and attorney Stephen Jessup.
We work with the law firm of attorneys Dell and Schaefer and in today's episode we are going to
discuss the Prudential Insurance Company. We do these videos on a weekly basis to give you an
idea of the way that these long-term disability insurance companies are handling your long-term
disability claim. In anticipation of today's video I did a little bit of research on Prudential
Insurance Company so that you can have an idea of how big of a company Prudential is. Prudential is
what they claim to be the second largest group insurance company in the entire world. They
currently have over 42,000 employees. Their revenues last year were $32.688 billion dollars
so that's $32,688,000,000 in revenues and just recently in the last quarter
their profits were $697,000,000. Now Prudential does all kinds of insurance products but
more specifically just last quarter their group insurance division which includes long-term
disability had $53,000,000 in profits so Prudential is a very large and very powerful
disability insurance company. Now to prepare for today we pulled some specific cases around the
country regarding Prudential and we're also going to talk to you about some of our own cases that
we've handled against Prudential including a pending class action that we recently filed
against Prudential but I want to start first with Cesar Gavidia who I think you're going to talk
about a recent case in which there was a substantial verdict against Prudential for their
wrongful handling of a long-term disability claim. Yes, this particular case involved a project
manager who worked in the construction department of the University of California San Francisco
and she had developed chronic fatigue syndrome, lupus and fibromyalgia and had filed a disability
claim with Prudential. Well Prudential approved her for about six years and then terminated her
benefits. They also denied all levels of appeal that she tried to execute.
The plaintiff in this particular case then sued Prudential for breach of contract in bad faith
alleging that the insurance company wrongfully terminated her benefits and
you see this particular thing very rarely. She also sued the independent company that set up
the IMEs for Prudential and sued the IME doctor. Well the jury found that Prudential not only
breached the contract but acted in bad faith, awarded about almost 15 million dollars in back
benefits, punitive damages and other damages as well. What they were really I think intensified
over was the fact that Prudential never contacted her friends, her family, any of her core workers
to get any of the information about her condition or daily activities and they just denied the claim
based off of this independent, purported independent medical doctor who just gave
them the opinion they wanted to hear. And you said that this jury was able to award 15 million dollars?
Well they awarded 15 million but then later on the appeals court knocked it down to 4 million in
punitive damages. They let stand some of the attorney's fees, they let stand the back benefits
that she was paid but either way it was I think a big wake-up call to Prudential. And Prudential
always writes group disability insurance policies but if this policy, this particular claim went
to a jury trial and most of their claims are governed by ERISA, how did that happen?
Well this particular claimant worked for, as I said, the University of California which
is a state-run university. Under ERISA there are certain types of disability plans that are exempt.
For instance, any governmental entities, any church plans, any plans that are self-funded
from the general assets of the company, those are the type that are exempted from ERISA and you
could actually bring state law causes of actions for them. Okay so if this claim, if the particular
claim that you're talking about was governed by ERISA then there would be no ability to bring a
claim for punitive damages or bad faith? Right, you wouldn't be able to bring, aside from perhaps a
claim for attorney's fees that is granted within the court's discretion, they may decide to do it
and they may decide not to award it, you can't bring any of the other bad faith causes of action
or any of those things. All right, well I certainly hope that 15 million dollars sent the message to
Prudential that their wrongful terminations won't be tolerated. Steve, what kind of case did you
come across? You know it's funny, like Cesar and I and a lot of calls that we do take, I found a
case here, a person insured was a florist person at the Mohegan Sun Casino and it was another case
of fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue, this would have been out of Connecticut. Of course Prudential
shoots down the case saying there's no objective evidence of the condition and that's one of the
things that the insurance companies, you'll see a lot of Prudential especially with subjective,
they say it's all subjective complaint of the insurer that you can't verify. Interesting here
and it gives maybe a little glimmer of hope for people in Connecticut, the second circuit federal
district. This is actually really favorable here where the court comes out and says
because fibromyalgia does not outwardly manifest itself, it would be unreasonable to require
objective evidence to support a diagnosis of fibromyalgia. However, the court even goes so far
and it's people suffering from fibromyalgia will know the trigger point test where the doctor is
going to check 18 certain points on your body. It said here for the second circuit federal court
that that trigger point testing if you come up with 11 of the 18 is concrete proof, it's objective
evidence of the condition. The court then went to going into how their doctors reviewed the case
about not so much looking at what was in the medical records, what the complaints were,
but were pointing to certain things that weren't there, loss of range of motion or functional
strength that weren't even usual normal symptoms of the condition itself. It's funny because even
today I looked over a denial letter, a prudential denial letter for a case that we took a call on
earlier this week and I couldn't help but laugh to myself because everything that the court was
attacking prudential on, I'm reading this denial letter and everything in this denial letter is
what they wrote in this denial letter for the most part that the court ripped apart saying
how can you require this of it. So it's just amazing how there's always a running theme and
even though in this in the case Caesar discussed where you have a large verdict against them it's
like they don't learn from their mistakes. They figure I will just keep doing it because we're
sure not that many people will really fight us. Well you know it's I heard you say in your case
Caesar and I heard Steve I heard you say it as well this objective evidence it's like prudential
is obsessed with trying to look for objective evidence and their claims handling people are
trained to say well you don't have any objective evidence so we don't think you're disabled. Well
the reality is that you don't have to have positive findings on an MRI or an x-ray or a
blood test or a cat scan or something like that in order to be disabled and prudential has been told
hundreds if not thousands of times by courts across the country that you can't deny every
single claim because there isn't objective evidence and the sad thing is is that especially
with orthopedic let's say spinal conditions the statistics are especially from a recent study out
of Harvard that 85 percent of the people who go to doctor with with some kind of spinal complaint
the doctors can't tell you the exact objective cause of that condition that doesn't mean that
you don't have the pain that you're saying you have so you need to be able to work with your
treating physicians to be able to show what your restrictions and limitations are even if you don't
have strong objective evidence.
