Benedict Rogers om Joshua Wongs domar: Det finns inga rättvisa rättegångar i Kina idag | NTD NYHETER

NTD Sverige
111 followers
Joshua Wong, som en gång var en framträdande figur i Hongkongs demokratirörelse, står nu inför ytterligare ett fängelsestraff efter sin andra fällande dom enligt den nationella säkerhetslag som Peking har infört.
Benedict Rogers, människorättsaktivist och författare till boken *The China Nexus: Thirty Years In and Around Chinese Communist Party’s Tyranny*, gästar NTD för att förklara varför Wongs domar är juridiskt ogiltiga och hur det är att leva i Kina idag under det kinesiska kommunistpartiets (KKP) drakoniska styre.
#usa #kina #covid19 #kultur
Se mer: https://ntdtv.se/
AI Generated·May contain errors
Joshua Wong, once a prominent figure in Hong Kong's pro-democracy movements,
now facing an additional prison term after his second conviction under a Beijing-imposed
national security law. Joining us now to discuss is Benedict Rogers, senior director at Fortify
Rights, co-founder of Hong Kong Watch, and author of the book China Nexus, 30 years in and around
the Chinese Communist Party's tyranny. So Ben, good afternoon. Thank you for being here with
us today. So Wong has been imprisoned since he was 24 years old. He was supposed to be released
next year. Is there any basis right now for this new case? Well, you're absolutely right,
and good afternoon. It's good to be with you again. Joshua has spent most of the last six years
in prison, and he now faces the real possibility of spending the rest of his life in jail. He's
the only person of all the people that have been charged under the national security law in Hong
Kong, which came in in 2000. He's the only person to be charged twice under this law. And it does
seem, of course, he's faced multiple other charges which have made up the sentences of the last six
years. But it does seem that the Hong Kong authorities are particularly keen to keep him
behind bars for as long as possible. Why is that the case? He spent six years already mostly
behind bars. Why are authorities keen to continue to keep him behind bars? Well, I think probably
the main reason is that he was very much the face, or at least one of the faces, of the pro-democracy
movement, particularly the younger generation of the pro-democracy movement. And he was well
connected and well respected by politicians around the world. He had access to senior political
leaders in the United States, the United Kingdom, and other places. And of course, the charge that
he is now facing, that he appeared in court earlier this week on, is the charge of collusion
with foreign forces, which essentially just means talking to foreign people of influence,
whether it's politicians or journalists or activists. But I think the reason they want
to keep him is because they see that he is such an influential and courageous young leader.
Can we just get your comments on whether you think there are serious legitimacy issues
surrounding Wong's case, overall speaking, that is? Because some of the activities prosecutors
are pointing to actually occurred before the national security lock took effect. So essentially,
the government is, I mean, to my understanding, is taking actions that was lawful when it happened,
and then calling it illegal after new laws were enacted. So can you just comment on all this?
That's exactly right. In fact, to my knowledge, I can't recall any significant
contact with key foreign political figures after 2000, after the national security law came in.
So you're exactly right. This law is being applied to Joshua retrospectively. And it's
completely illegitimate. I mean, firstly, what Joshua did should not, in any normal society,
be considered a crime, talking about democracy, about freedom, about human rights, talking about
the values that are enshrined in the Sino-British Joint Declaration that China promised to respect
in Hong Kong. So none of what he's done should be a crime. And certainly,
it shouldn't be applied retrospectively, which is what's happened.
Why do you think he thought it was best to plead guilty to the new charges?
Well, I can only offer my opinion. I can't obviously speak for him. But I assume that
the calculation was made that if he pled guilty, he might receive a slightly more lenient
sentence than if he pled not guilty. But the reality is that's a calculation that no one
really knows whether it will be successful in any significant way. And the message the world
needs to hear is that he shouldn't be on trial at all, and he shouldn't be in prison at all.
And him pleading guilty doesn't mean he's acknowledging any crime. I would assume it
means that he thinks that might result in a more lenient sentence.
Right, potentially. I mean, is there any way at all to push for a more lenient sentence,
maybe through diplomatic, legal, political pressure, any way to make that happen?
Definitely. I mean, I think there should be as much international pressure as possible,
not actually just to get a more lenient sentence, but actually to demand his release.
Because as you said, in the introduction, he's already spent more than six years in prison.
He shouldn't spend a day more. But if we can't succeed in getting him released quickly,
then a more lenient sentence is certainly preferable to a life sentence.
So every diplomatic tool should be used. The United Kingdom has a particular responsibility.
And let's remember, Joshua was born in Hong Kong before the 1997 handover. So
although he may not technically be a British citizen in legal terms, he was born in what was
a British colony. So Britain has a real responsibility to him. But I hope that the
I hope the U.S. will put pressure on, particularly with President Xi Jinping
expected to visit Washington later this month. I hope President Trump and the administration will
make Joshua's case, alongside many other cases, a priority to raise with Xi Jinping.
Right. There needs to be enough voices talking about this in order for President Trump to
take it on a more serious level. I think we're contributing a little bit right here.
But you said earlier that Joshua Wong's trial was illegitimate. How would you describe
the overall national security prosecutions and trials? Were they fair?
No, none of them have been fair at all. I think it's the case that the Hong Kong government boasts
of 100% conviction rate of all the cases that have come under the national security law. But
if you have 100% conviction rate, clearly they're not receiving a fair trial. And the reality is
the judges are handpicked by the government. They're put under pressure to deliver the
verdict that the government wants. The idea of any judicial independence has gone. And in some
cases, not all of them, but in some, particularly the case of Jimmy Lai, they've been denied their
first choice of legal counsel. Plus, all the evidence that's presented is not evidence that
in any free society would be regarded as remotely criminal. So no, they're complete sham trials,
and there's no such thing as a fair trial under the draconian national security law in Hong Kong.
This law was enacted in 2020. It was a dramatic turning point for Hong Kong. It was a completely
different society before 2020. Do you think it'll ever go back to the political freedoms it had
before 2020? Is there any path for Hong Kong to go back?
You're exactly right. I lived in Hong Kong for the first five years after the handover in 1997,
and it was a completely different place. At that time, China did
uphold, at least on the surface, the freedoms it had promised. I think the only way we can imagine
any return to freedom for Hong Kong is if there is freedom in China. So if the Chinese Communist
Party either collapses and is replaced by a democracy, or there's some dramatic reform
within the Chinese Communist Party regime, that's only imaginable without Xi Jinping.
But I don't think we can see change in Hong Kong until we see change in China.
Okay, just one last question here. So it was supposed to be 50 years, the one country,
two systems. So it apparently already happened. So what happens after the 50 years deadline?
Is it going to be even worse, do you think? Just one final question.
Well, I think that's a very real possibility. As you say, Hong Kong's freedoms, high degree
of autonomy, human rights should have been maintained and respected until 2047.
If they've already, as they have, been dismantled by the CCP less than halfway through that period,
then one can assume, unless there's change in China during that period, that Hong Kong after
1947 will just deteriorate even further and essentially become simply another Chinese city
with total control by the CCP. But maybe the silver lining is the
question remains if the Chinese Communist Party could last until 2047. Maybe this is the only
silver lining, but we'll have to wait and see. But Ben, really appreciate you always coming
on the show. Thank you so much. Thank you very much.
