Somalia v Woodhouse Drake Carey Suisse (Recognition of legitimate governments)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Sep 7, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Two important recurring issues in international law are how we tell
whether a state is actually a state and how we tell whether someone claiming to
govern a state is actually the proper legitimate government. If there is some
sort of revolution or civil war or coup and you have multiple parties each
In this case the government of Somalia ordered the delivery of a shipment of
rice to the capital Mogadishu but by the time the boat arrived a civil war was
underway and the captain refused to enter the harbour. The court later ordered
the rice to be sold and the proceeds paid into court. Some time later there
was a peace agreement involving some of the warring factions and an interim
government was formed however the interim government was operating from a
hotel room in Saudi Arabia and did not control much territory in Somalia at all
Two million dollars was payable to the government of Somalia from the rice
proceeds and the interim government appointed lawyers to get that money. The
question however was whether the interim government could be considered the
proper government of Somalia and therefore whether the lawyers could be
considered the proper representatives of the government of Somalia. Just as
Hobhouse in the Queen's bench division of the court said the factors to be
taken into account in deciding whether a government exists as the government of a
state are a. whether it is the constitutional government of the state
b. the degree nature and stability of administrative control if any that it of
itself exercises over the territory of the state c. whether Her Majesty's
government has any dealings with it and if so what is the nature of those
dealings and d. in marginal cases the extent of international recognition that
it has as the government of the state. His Honour found that the interim
government was not yet properly the constitutional government of Somalia. It
was just the result of a deal between warring factions that it had very
limited control over Somali territory and that the British government had not
dealt with it as the formal government of Somalia. The court therefore refused to
release the money. From this case we see a useful set of criteria to determine
whether a government is the legitimate government of a state.
