Global Scandal! Huawei Polishes Samsung Memory Labels, Calls It 100% Domestic Innovation

China Observer
822粉絲
Recently, a new piece of “high technology” with a distinctly Chinese twist has emerged in China’s tech community — the so-called “Huawei polished chip.” The controversy started with a mobile phone repair vlogger.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT2kPBcD6tXn8TP_aV7BmgA/join
#chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
⭐You can support us at: https://donorbox.org/china-observer-supporting-independent-news
⭐For business cooperation, please contact us: [email protected]
Recently, a new piece of high technology with a distinctly Chinese twist has emerged in China's
tech community, the so-called Huawei Polished Chip. The controversy started with a mobile
phone repair vlogger. I'm patriotic first, and then I'm just a phone repair technician.
Here's what happened. I was repairing a Xiaomi Mi 11 Ultra. The original RAM chip was a Samsung
K3LK4K, a 12GB memory chip. Then I installed an X4BN chip from the Huawei P70 Pro,
and it booted up immediately. My idea was simple. I wanted to test whether it could work on a
Xiaomi phone, because when we repair phones, sometimes we don't have the exact same RAM chip
available. For most Qualcomm phones, if you replace the RAM with a different brand, the phone
needs to have the DDR partition data inserted before it can boot. But this X4BN chip happened
to boot right away. So I downloaded the Xiaomi HyperOS toolbox and used software to read the
chip information. It identified the RAM as Samsung's. That's why I think that this X4BN
is actually a Samsung K3LK4K chip, with the markings polished off and new X4BN markings
printed on it. The claim immediately touched one of Huawei's most sensitive areas. For years,
Huawei has built much of its brand identity around being made in China, self-developed,
and a symbol of breaking through U.S. technology restrictions. In August 2025, Huawei executive
Richard Yu, also known as Yu Chengdong, told Chinese state broadcaster CCTV Finance Program
Dialogue that after U.S. sanctions, Huawei's smartphone sales once fell from more than 200
million units a year to just over 20 million units, and that its comeback was achieved
through the collective push of China's entire technology industry.
Back on December 8, 2024, during a speech at Shenzhen Bao'an Middle School,
Yu made an even stronger statement about the domestic nature of the Huawei Mate 70.
In the past, China couldn't manufacture basically any chip with real technological value.
But look at our newly released Mate 70. Everyone can see that the chip in this phone has achieved
100% domestic production. The day after the speech, Chinese media outlets including
Kalian Press and Zhongguan Chun Online quickly published headlines saying that
the Mate 70 chip had achieved 100% domestic production. But soon afterwards, Tech Insights
took apart the Mate 70 series and found that the phone still contained memory and flash chips from
South Korea's SK Hynix. This time, the chip claims were questioned again, and the term
polished chips quickly became a new online joke.
You may ask what exactly I'm polishing. I'm polishing self-developed technology.
Even polishing is self-developed. I've already finished polishing two of them.
The markings are no longer visible. That's because the surface was rough and still had
printed markings. It wasn't smooth enough, so I polished it to make the surface smoother.
Then I'll continue with polishing and finishing. That way, the surface becomes completely smooth.
There are no markings left, and it looks very shiny.
After the video was posted, commenters quickly joined in with jokes.
One person said, this vlogger should apply to Huawei as a chip polishing engineer.
Another mocked, Huawei won this round. The markings were removed to protect Samsung and SK
Hynix. Why are Huawei phones expensive? Because they add two extra manufacturing processes.
Someone also asked, tell us what else about Huawei is actually real?
They insist on using Qualcomm chips. Prices have gone up several times,
and they're still using them. Their own products are also forced to become more expensive.
What kind of feeling is this?
Commenters did not hold back either. One person wrote,
some companies are not completely useless. Although they are annoying, they have still
created many jobs. For example, those 7,000 legal staff members are truly impressive.
Another person continued mocking the self-developed claim, saying they developed
Qualcomm chips themselves. Huawei's pricing has also continued to climb in recent years.
The 2020 Mate 40 started at 4,999 yuan, equivalent to about 745 US dollars.
Later, the Mate series moved into the 6,000 to 10,000 yuan range, roughly equal to between 890
to 1,490 US dollars. While Huawei's tri-fold phone, the Mate XT, started at 19,999 yuan,
equivalent to about 2,980 US dollars, with a 1TB version priced at 23,999 yuan, about 3,580 US
dollars. Huawei has also faced years of criticism over another practice, repeatedly reusing older
chips. The Kirin 710A was released back in 2020 and uses a 14nm manufacturing process.
But in 2024, Huawei's newly launched MatePad SE 11 and Enjoy 70Z were still using this entry-level
chip from several years earlier. Meanwhile, the Nova 12 Vitality Edition, released in late 2023,
was still equipped with a Snapdragon 778G 4G, a chip from around 2021. On one hand,
Huawei has been portrayed as a symbol of breaking through US technology restrictions.
On the other hand, even in 2026, the United States was still investigating past cases
involving foreign companies supplying Huawei with components and software. A US investigation
found that between September 2020 and September 2024, Bosch supplied Huawei and its affiliated
companies with about 72.4 million US dollars worth of MEMS sensors and automotive software
without obtaining required US authorization. In June 2026, the US Department of Commerce
announced that Germany's Bosch had agreed to pay a 36 million US dollar fine. These sensors can be
used in smartphones, wearable devices, and automobiles. No matter how strong Huawei's
political backing may be, once its products reach consumers, users themselves know best
whether they actually perform well. One user said her Huawei Mate 60 1TB certainly froze completely.
What is this? I can't even shut it down. It's completely stuck. What a piece of junk.
Another user brought Huawei's Trifold phone. Just over a year after purchase, while working,
the phone suddenly developed a screen failure without warning and became completely unusable.
This piece of junk just certainly broke for no reason. The user said it was her first Huawei
phone and will also be the last. She went to customer service and was told that replacing
the screen would cost 7,000 yuan, equivalent to about 1,040 US dollars, which she called
outrageous. It was clearly a product quality issue. Apart from being suitable for running
multiple apps for office work, she could hardly find any other advantages. Daily video browsing
was laggy, responses were slow, camera quality was disappointing, the phone overheated quickly
during navigation, and it was not even waterproof. With constant small problems and failures at
critical moments, the user said the overall experience was extremely poor and she would
never buy another one. Many people in the comments share similar experiences. One person wrote,
I bought the X5 the year before last. After using it for at most a month, I sold it last month for
4,000 yuan. I lost 10,000 yuan. Another person said, I live in a residential area next to Huawei's
headquarters. Many Huawei employees there use iPhones. 10 years ago it was the iPhone 6,
a few years ago it was the iPhone 12, and now it's the iPhone 17. The Sina black card complaint
platform continued to receive complaints related to Huawei's foldable phones from 2025 to 2026.
Some Mate Xe users said their new phones developed bright lines, black screens,
or screen flute leakage shortly after purchase. Others said their screens fell just days after
the warranty expired, with repair costs reaching thousands of yuan. By July 2026, some Mate X6
users reported that the inner screen fell within one month after the warranty ended. After an
official screen replacement, problems with the protective film and inner display appear again
soon afterward, involving repair costs of around 2,000 yuan, equivalent to around 300 US dollars.
Huawei phones have faced criticism, and its computers have not escaped either.
I really don't understand why some parents keep giving this kind of junk Huawei product
as a college entrance exam gift to their children.
Aunts and uncles, take a look. Spending 5,000 yuan on this piece of junk is like buying a car
and only getting a motorcycle engine. How can something like this sell for 5,000 yuan without
anyone questioning it? And so many people still call it a symbol of Chinese technology and praise
it. What can this thing even handle? Do you believe it can't even run League of Legends?
For Valorant, you'd be lucky to just get over 100 frames per second. It doesn't even have a
dedicated graphics card, and it's made so thin it's ridiculous. If your child needs a laptop
at school for gaming or programming, they probably need a gaming laptop. This thing can't even handle
basic tasks, yet people still buy it for their children. Many commenters agree with one saying,
using a Huawei computer to learn programming is a nightmare. Many software programs aren't
supported. Another Huawei desktop computer was also mocked because of its memory design.
Guys, who gets it? Huawei's desktop computer is really creative. The machine uses a DDR5
interface, but it actually runs DDR4 memory. Huawei's memory design this time is all about
having a futuristic appearance with a nostalgic core. By using an external slot, it's created a
rare cross-category design in terms of performance. In the comments, one person mocked Huawei sales
representatives by imitating their style. Sir, this is how it works. This DDR4 memory is Huawei's
It uses DDR5's aesthetic design and quality control standards, along with Harmony OS features.
The product experience and service experience are just as good as DDR5, sir.
Some commenters also mocked Huawei's government and enterprise business. One wrote,
One unit only costs 28,000 yuan. Huawei's presence in the government procurement
market is indeed significant. In July 2026, China's central government agencies purchased
1,085 units of Huawei Qingyuan W515Y-A011 computers in a single procurement order.
In August, Huawei's Qingyuan L540X-A101 laptop also entered the procurement list,
winning an order of 402 units. Behind these machines is not just the Huawei brand,
but an entire domestic hardware and software ecosystem, including Kirin chips, UnionTech UOS,
and NFS China operating systems. At the same time, Apple and other foreign devices have been
In recent years, there have been repeated reports of government agencies and state-owned
companies asking employees to reduce or stop using iPhones at work, with some directly requiring
employees to switch to domestic smartphones. By 2024, even some private companies began
following the trend. A company in Baicheng, Jilin province, publicly notified employees
that Apple devices were not allowed inside the workplace and encouraged them to switch
to domestic products. For ordinary consumers, if they think Huawei is too expensive,
they can buy Apple, Xiaomi, or simply buy nothing. But within government and state-owned enterprise
procurement systems, once a product enters the approved list, it often becomes a long-term
business involving hundreds or thousands of units. The controversy surrounding Huawei and
accusations of misleading claims has long gone beyond just one memory chip.
If a brand's product is opened up and you find it contains Lenovo parts,
then after polishing the memory you discover it's actually Samsung. If a car's durability
test videos turn out to be AI-generated, and its so-called 5G phones only actually run on 4G,
with store employees saying 4G is faster, and its fans are very smart too, every day they either
mock Xiaomi or attack competitors. So which amazing brand is this? Well, it must be Apple
or Samsung. That's enough. If I say more, even my profile picture will get polished away. Thank you.
Huawei has also been caught by third-party organizations several times in the past. In
2018, Anand Tech found that Huawei phones including the P20, P20 Pro, Nova 3, and Honor
Play could identify the 3DMark benchmarking software and automatically activate a high
performance mode that was not normally sustained during everyday use. When testers changed the name
of the same program, the phones could no longer recognize it, and performance scores immediately
dropped. After conducting its own tests, UL Solutions, the developer of 3DMark, removed
the related Huawei phones from its rankings. It was like recognizing the examiner during a test
and temporarily giving maximum performance. But when the examiner changed clothes and came back,
the score changed. By 2026, similar controversies had moved from smartphones to cars.
On May 16, Harmony Intelligent Mobility released a promotional video for a new AYTO M9
in its Shuling Fully Active Intelligence chassis. In the video, the M9 drove at high speed over a
The vehicle body moved noticeably up and down while the cabin appeared extremely stable.
Soon afterward, some short video platforms added warnings to the official promotional video
saying it was suspected of using AI-generated technology. One vlogger also uploaded a screen
recording of the video to the National Anti-Fraud Center's AI detection tool, which returned a result
showing signs of AI generation. They claimed that AYTO used an AI video as a vehicle durability test
quickly spread online. Huawei's involvement in the U.S. T-Mobile Tappy Robot case was even more
serious. T-Mobile accused Huawei employees of improperly photographing and measuring its phone
testing robot and even removing components from the laboratory. A U.S. federal jury later ruled
that Huawei had breached contracts and misappropriated trade secrets, awarding T-Mobile
4.8 million U.S. dollars in damages. Since the start of the issue in 2013, it has still not
completely ended. Reuters reported on August 31, 2026 that criminal cases in the United States
involving Huawei, including allegations of bank fraud and sanctions violations, were continuing.
Another trial involving T-Mobile trade secrets had been scheduled for October 2027. After Huawei
built up a massive patent portfolio of its own, the situation changed again. In 2023,
Huawei and Xiaomi became involved in multiple patent disputes over the communications technology.
Eventually, the two companies signed a global patent cross-licensing agreement. The same year,
Richard Yu publicly complained at Huawei's annual fan event that some competitors were
not respecting intellectual property rights. He said someone had taken Huawei's dual rotating
water drop hinge design and simply renamed it Dragon Bone. At the same time, Xiaomi's MIX Fold
3 happened to be promoted with the name Dragon Bone Hinge. The remark was widely seen as a direct
reference, but Xiaomi is not a company that backs down from a direct confrontation with Huawei.
On December 12, 2023, Xiaomi issued a public statement directly naming Richard Yu.
The company accused him of making false statements targeting our Dragon Bone Hinge
technology without reason, seriously contradicting the facts, and demanded
that he stop smearing competitors and misleading the public. Xiaomi also publicly released the
This patent battle has continued. In 2025, Huawei sued US computer manufacturer HP
at the Unified Patent Court in Europe, accusing the company of using Huawei's Wi-Fi 6 patents.
On August 26, 2026, the two sides eventually signed a multi-year Wi-Fi patent cross-licensing
agreement, which also covers the latest Wi-Fi 7 technology. Huawei's strength is not only in
patent battles, but also in its massive legal team. Online, the company can go from fighting
competitors over patents one moment to taking self-media vloggers to court the next. In 2025,
an automotive vlogger questioned the promotional testing of Huawei's partnership vehicle,
and was later sued by related companies. By 2026, the court ordered the vlogger to pay 300,000 yuan,
equivalent to about US$45,000 in damages. Huawei's rise has also long been accompanied
by support from the military, the telecommunications systems, and state resources.
Huawei CEO Ren Zhengfei served in the Chinese Communist Party's Infrastructure Engineering
Corps in his early years. In the 1990s, Huawei began entering military and local telecommunications
markets. In 1994, Ren Zhengfei also met with Jiang Zemin and discussed telecommunications
equipment and national security. After that, Beijing increased support for domestic
telecommunications equipment companies. Huawei then received overseas financing quarters worth
tens of billions of US dollars from China Development Bank, allowing it to expand rapidly.
30 years ago, there was another company in China's telecommunications industry that was
actually even more closely connected to the state than Huawei, Zhulong Communications. At the time,
the industry used the phrase, Great China Four, referring to Zhulong, Datang, ZTE, and Huawei.
Zhulong began falling behind at exactly the time when China's telecommunications industry
was reshaping its power structure in the late 1990s. In the past, Zhulong relied on military
research institutions, the Ministry of Post and Telecommunications, and a group of all state-owned
enterprises. But during Jiang Zemin's later years, this old network began losing influence.
In 1998, the Chinese military was ordered to stop doing business, and Zhulong's most important
military technology teams gradually withdrew. At the same time, new telecom operators including
China Mobile, China Telecom, China Unicom, and China Netcom began controlling the truly
valuable procurement contracts, licenses, and funding. It was also during this period that
Jiang Minheng, the son of Jiang Zemin, rapidly entered the telecommunications and information
industry and became known as the Telecom King. Zhulong continued relying on its old military
and state-owned enterprise connections, while Huawei and ZTE had already begun moving toward
the new centers of power. Huawei later entered Chinese government projects including public
security, informatization, and the Golden Shield project. It also received support from policy
banks and quickly expanded its market share. Huawei has always emphasized that it is a private
company owned by employees. However, the majority of its registered shares are held under the Huawei
Trade Union Committee, and the company has maintained a Chinese Communist Party-CCP committee
internally for years. Under Xi Jinping, Huawei was further pushed to the front line of national
strategies such as technological self-reliance and domestic substitution. Huawei's relationship
with Chinese public security surveillance systems and its role as a tool for the CCP
have also been exposed by overseas media. In 2020, the Washington Post reported documents
showing Huawei had worked with MEG-V to test facial recognition systems, including a feature
called Awega Alem. Other public documents also show Huawei has participated in projects
involving smart policing, personnel tracking, and city surveillance. In August 2026, Bloomberg
reported that Huawei proposed building an AI data center for the Egyptian government,
planning to provide 1,408 ASIN 950 chips along with another 600 ASIN 950 or 910B chips
for military, surveillance, and other government uses. The proposal also involved facial and vehicle
recognition systems connected to national databases. This is not the first time Huawei
has exported such systems overseas. Over the years, Huawei's Safe City and Smart City projects
have entered multiple countries through the Belt and Road Initiative and the Digital Silk Road.
In Uganda and Zambia, investigations found that Huawei employees allegedly assisted local
governments in tracking opposition communications and movements. After Serbia introduced Huawei's
Safe City system, surveillance footage of anti-government protesters was reportedly
leaked to pro-government media. Kenya, Zimbabwe, and other countries have also deployed similar
systems. By 2026, a study covering 11 African countries found that every country included in
the research used surveillance technology provided by Chinese companies. Some governments initially
introduced these systems under the names of public security and counterterrorism, but later,
they were accused of being used to monitor opposition groups, protesters, and human rights
activists. On August 20, 2026, the Brazilian government announced a national AI plan
planning to invest about 2.3 billion Brazilian reais, equivalent to about 450 million US dollars,
to build an AI and supercomputing infrastructure. About 1.3 billion reais, equivalent to about 250
million US dollars, of the projects will be developed in Rio de Janeiro with partners
including Huawei and iFleetec for developing general-purpose and industry-specific AI models.
What Huawei sells today is no longer just smartphones and telecom equipment.
China's market has never been determined solely by products and technology. Huawei became an
industry giant partly because it connected itself with the Chinese Communist Party's power structure
and policy support. But inside the power struggle of the CCP, when one political
faction falls, the companies, interests, and networks attached to it can disappear as well.
