Lindsay Clancy mistrial explained: What happens next?

Fox - Fox 9
44 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 5, 2026
Okay, so if the state, if Massachusetts chooses to retry this, many believe that that benefits
the prosecution as they come back with more knowledge of how this jury may fall, how a
new jury may fall.
They might come back with a new tactic if it goes to trial again.
What do you think?
Do you think that they will choose to retry this?
And if so, who benefits?
Yeah, I mean, 11 to 1 is a heavy score to try to retry a case, right?
If you're the prosecution, that's a huge swing you'd have to overcome in a second trial.
So my prediction would be unlikely, although sometimes there's just a feeling of vengeance,
for lack of a better term, right?
And once in a while when emotions get involved, sometimes prosecutors make decisions they
probably shouldn't.
And it would be very expensive for the Commonwealth, right, to retry that case again.
In terms of who benefits from it, I can tell you I've had, I think, three hung juries in
my career.
Any time that I've had a hung jury and there's been a second trial, I don't feel like the
prosecution has the upper hand.
Yes, they know what the defense is then, but we have transcripts, right?
So every time there's a trial, there's a court reporter taking down every word every witness
says and then we order transcripts from those and those are sworn testimony and we're able
to use those transcripts to do what's called impeach a witness if they change their testimony.
So we can say, you know, at a hearing, because you can't say there was a prior trial, at
a hearing, you know, three months ago, you were asked the same question and your answer
was this that time and now today it's material different, it's this, right?
And that's called impeachment and the witness just lacks credibility if they get impeached
over and over and over or if several witnesses in the trial get impeached.
So it's hard for the prosecution to kind of pivot unless it's just one little angle in
the trial.
Right.
So but I don't I don't know how they'd be able to change much in a second presentation
in this trial.
And I think actually the defense would have the upper hand if they try it again.
Well, we heard Reddington say that he would prefer a jury trial.
He was asked whether he sees a bench trial as a possibility and whether he would support
that, whether he would like that.
And he said, I would prefer a jury trial.
What's your take on him saying that?
Yeah, well, again, with a judge, right, it's only one decision maker, a jury.
It takes 12 zero unanimously to find a guilty if you're convicted.
Otherwise, 11 to one against you doesn't count.
That would be a mistrial as well.
So most of the time people want jury trials for that reason.
The only other modifier I would have for you as we're thinking back about why might the
prosecution have an upper hand if they did retry it again would be this.
The jury makeup.
Right.
In this trial, I think it was nine females and three males, if I remember right.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
Yep.
I I would think that a female juror would be more able to weigh out the validity of
the defense's defense there with the postpartum situations.
Right.
It's men don't know, haven't experienced that sort of thing.
Some some female jurors have, of course.
And so that defense may sit better, at least with with a more weighted jury being male
to female ratio.
Right.
So what the prosecution may try to do, and they're not supposed to strike based on protected
things like genders or everything like that.
But there's ways that lawyers can try to make it appear that it isn't for an improper purpose
if they're going to try to do that.
If you get a jury that's maybe more tilted, more male than female the second time, that
could be a game changer.
I don't know for sure, but that's one thing that's coming to mind that could really alter
the next trial.
And that brings up the point.
How do you ensure a jury is impartial in a case like this?
You know, you heard the defense attorney Reddington say, I don't think you could take this case
to Japan or India and have jurors that haven't seen the news coverage of this.
How do you ensure an impartial jury?
Yeah, that's what jury selection is all about.
So first, the judge usually asks some screening questions about it.
And then after that, it's turned over to the lawyers.
Now, the reality is, is that some jurors can mask.
I've had it done once in a trial I had where there was a holdout.
Same thing.
Eleven not guilty, one guilty.
And that juror, through questioning, obviously had masked what, how she felt about the main
topic.
It was a sex assault case, right?
But the rest of the jury was like, come on, man, this is clearly not guilty.
And she held out in that and had masked her true feelings during jury selection about
some of these issues.
So that can happen.
You hope jurors don't do it.
They're under oath.
And we all have to buy into what a jury trial means, that it only means something if we
all do what we're supposed to in a trial.
But the reality is that these are deeply emotional issues.
And there are people who may choose to make it appear that they can be unbiased during
the trial or set aside any biases they have and be fair to both parties.
Hard to do sometimes.
What about the attorneys on both sides going on the record just now outside the courthouse?
I mean, you heard Reddington say, Lindsey Clancy's a wonderful person.
She's like a daughter to me.
Does that impact anything going forward?
You see his care value, right?
No matter how you feel about whether she's guilty or not or what she's accused of or
not, what I see as a defense lawyer that cares deeply about his client, that absolutely fought
hard for her, that bought into defense 100%, that didn't make the trial about him.
It was all about helping his client.
So I think he's doing a great job.
And you like to see a defense lawyer who really has good things to say about their client
because he's going to know her on a different level than any of us ever know her, right?
He knows what's underneath her.
He's been through this for a long time with her and her own struggles and has had many
private conversations with her and maybe read many private things about her that didn't
even get into evidence.
And he's her champion.
And that's what he's supposed to be when he's representing her in a case like this.
So Reddington asked the judge this week for that juror to be removed, that juror that
they've had an issue with that could not come, could not agree with his colleagues there
on the jury.
He asked that he be removed.
The judge denied that request.
I'm just curious because we saw that the alternates were still in the courtroom.
This is something that doesn't happen here in Minnesota.
In Minnesota, when you're not chosen to be in the final jury pool, you're dismissed.
But these alternates were still there and could have, hypothetically, been swapped out,
swapped in, you know, if someone had to be dismissed.
Yeah, very peculiar, right?
It's an odd motion that he was bringing.
I guess I understand why he was he was trying to help his client as much as he could.
But it's hard to say, well, juror, she, that juror said he or she, whatever it was, that
they could follow the evidence, that they could follow the rules, right?
So no matter, even though the other jurors will say, well, this juror said that they
had doubts, so they're not following the rule.
The juror said that they can follow the rule.
And the question would be, is the juror having doubt about the weight of some of the evidence
or the proof beyond a reasonable doubt?
Are they saying they have a reasonable doubt or just some doubt, right?
I don't know that all of that was clarified.
And it's not a judge's job to go into the province of the jury and get into the deliberation
room or what's going on there, right?
They're supposed to answer questions the jury has, give them the law, read back instructions,
and those sorts of things.
But I understand why the judge probably didn't want to blow this whole thing up and take
that juror out.
I mean, that probably would have led to an automatic appeal from the state if they could
appeal that situation.
This was really, really unique.
It is such an interesting case.
And now we have a mistrial, so we may see this trial go back.
We may see another jury trial.
We'll just have to see what happens.
So I appreciate you joining us, Ryan Pesce, criminal defense attorney here in Minnesota.
Thanks for your time.
Happy to help.
Take care.
All right.
We'll continue to cover that news today, a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy murder case.
