MO3 Trial: Expert weighs in on testimony's impact on jury

Fox - 4 News
16 followers
1 Video View·Sep 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thanks for joining us.
We are in the lunch break of what is this day eight of this trial, the
murder trial against Kiwan white, who is accused of killing Dallas rapper
Mo three on a busy Dallas interstate.
The middle of the day, according to the prosecution, they say that white
was a paid hit man paid by a fellow Dallas rapper, Della BZ and another
Dallas rapper, cowboy Freddy, according to the lead detective in this case.
They say that Conway and Mo three Melvin noble had an ongoing feud
lasting multiple years, which involved the death of a friend of Melvin noble.
And then Marquise Conway who's yellow BZ was shot on the tollway survived that.
And then after that, some rap beef songs were put out there.
And then, um, the manager, uh, of Melvin noble was jumped outside of a club.
Not shot, but assaulted outside of the club.
That manager actually won about $300,000 in a civil
lawsuit against yellow BZ.
There's video of yellow BZ saying I'm the one who beat him up.
Um, and so now we are here six years after this murder.
You want white is first up.
There's been a lot of damaging evidence in this case, especially
in the last couple of days.
A few days ago, a childhood friend of Kiwan white, who was in jail at the
time of this murder said that when he got out, he won white allegedly
confessed to him saying that he is the one who killed both three.
And also in Cedric Bradley's testimony, uh, saying that he was paid for this.
Um, and then after that, we heard some damaging testimony from the lead
detective, detective Eric Barnes, in this case, uh, one, just
talking about the ongoing feud.
Detective Barnes was on the staff for three days.
Judge really tried to get him off the stand, uh, because
the testimony lasted so long.
Um, but on the stand for multiple days, and then two days ago, talking
about a $40,000 withdrawal that Markey's Conway, who goes by the
rat name yellow BZ, uh, took out of his chase bank, that was pretty
damaging because according to the detective Barnes timeline, he says
two days before an alleged meetup in Irving at a car dealership between
various more who goes by trap boy, Freddie and Markey's Conway, which
is yellow BZ from that Irving meetup.
Allegedly then Conway went to his home in Frisco where he met up with another
suspect, and then that suspect in Frisco allegedly brought the money
to a trap house in Dallas to Kiwan white.
I want to bring in Alison Richardson.
Uh, Alison joined us when we first started this.
You are a jury expert, uh, now eight days into this.
And I know every trial is different.
Uh, this is a murder trial, but it's a, uh, a web, uh, because
there really seems like they're trying two cases in one talking, trying
to prove the murder for hire part.
I think they pretty much tried to do the best that they could
in proving that the alleged murder.
Um, as it relates to Kiwan white being the suspect, um, I know, you know, you
haven't been in the courtroom every day, but one just jurors are regular people.
They're not news junkies like me or someone else eight days into a murder
trial, can that start to hire out a jury?
Absolutely.
I mean, if you think about what it might be like for anyone to go back to school
full time, uh, for eight days in a row, you can imagine that that
would be a large cognitive load.
And so it's, it's, you know, it's long days, it's physically taxing.
Um, there's a lot of emotional testimony.
Um, and probably the hardest part is that they can't talk about it with anyone.
They can't talk about it with the other jurors or with anyone at home.
And as a general rule, we process information by talking
about it with other people.
Yeah.
And I mean, and I always, um, I kind of laugh sometimes at that, the rules
that jurors are given, because like I said, they're just normal people.
Right.
And so I've never been on a jury.
I've never sat on a jury, but I know that it's probably difficult
to hear all of this information.
And then you guys are going in the back or on lunch or whatever, and you're
supposed to not talk about this at all.
Um, it's something I know, uh, every jury is different.
Every case is different.
Um, as far as the demographic breakdown, um, that I've gotten from, uh, someone
that I know with the Dallas observer, uh, he said no black men on this jury.
I know, you know, everyone hears the word jury of your peers, and that can
be interpreted a million different ways.
Uh, Dallas County is a diverse County, uh, multiple Hispanic women on the jury,
two black women on the jury, and then a mix of, um, older and middle age white
men and an Asian, uh, man, when it comes to a case like this, where it's centered
around rap and drugs, like does the demographic of the jury matter so much on
a case like this, or is it really the evidence proves what the evidence proves?
I really think the demographics of the jury, and it does sound like it's a
diverse jury, even though there aren't any black men on the jury, um, it boils
down to finding 12 people who can set aside any inherent bias against the
people or the topics in this case so that they can look at all sides of
the case and consider it fairly.
The, the complexity of this case, as we've been talking about this, and I mean,
you were here with us on day one.
Um, I mean, you have the prosecution having to one prove that this is the
person who committed this murder.
Uh, but then the added part of the remuneration, which in layman's terms
mean for hire, paying someone to do it.
Well, there's been a bunch of objections, uh, in this.
Yesterday was a pivotal moment where, you know, before the trial, because this ties
back to rap and they're saying, oh, the, the alleged, uh, co-conspirators talked
about these crimes in songs.
Um, yesterday, Brie West was overruled by the judge saying she opened the door.
Why the judge ruled out some songs that were not going to be used in this trial.
And then they were able to play those songs to the jurors.
One, um, the prosecution saying mocked the deceased, the defendant, uh, Melvin
Noble, uh, days after the murder.
When the jury is getting so much information.
I mean, today was hours of testimony from an FBI agent talking about, you know,
tracing cell phones and where they were.
I mean, can some of that get kind of cumbersome?
I mean, I'm having to listen to it and pay attention because it's my job.
Um, but can the jury get too much data, um, when it comes to getting testimony?
That's a great question.
And the answer is yes.
Um, and, and really jurors look at, you know, they start to take this
information from the very beginning.
Um, you know, including, you know, some things they may have heard during
boy dire, um, and then in opening statements, they start to form.
Yes, I can.
Oh, I think you're hearing some feedback.
Oh, yes.
I'm sorry.
Okay.
Um, technical issues.
Sorry about that.
It's all right.
Going to say was that the jurors, um, they come into a trial and they
start to construct a story.
Um, and they, you know, part of what they do when they get in that
deliberation room is they look around the room and they ask everyone, Hey,
did you see the same movie that I did?
Um, and so they take that story and they start putting the pieces together.
And at some point when they start hearing an overload of information or
excessive amounts of information, um, they start to look at it and say, does
this fit the story I have going or not?
And they may just discard it if it doesn't fit.
Um, so that's generally the way that jurors, you know, put together this
information.
So with that in mind, they're, they're looking for key points.
Um, you know, and, and that's one of the reasons that closing statement can be
important is because, you know, they may be tuning out a lot of this technical
information, but then if the attorneys can come in and put the pieces together
in closing, then that might be persuasive to them.
But I'll tell you, all 12 of those jurors have an idea in their mind, a lens that
they're looking through to process the vast amounts of information in this case.
Tommy Adams is the prosecutor in this case.
And he's been trying to, I know everyone is a different learner, right?
I'm a visual learner and he, he at times has had a big calendar up on the wall
showing the month of November, um, the month that the murder happened back in
2020.
And by the beginning of this week, that whole calendar was filled in with, this
is the timeline of events.
This is when the alleged payment meetup was made.
This is the day that the money was taken out.
This is the day where text messages were given.
Um, visual aids, how much does that go into play with a jury, especially since
they can take that back in the deliberation room with them, um, to look
at the evidence, do visual aids play a role when jurors are deliberating or is
it really just honestly a case by case basis?
No, visual aids are very important because a juror is constructing a story of what
happened and a visual aid like a calendar gives them a place to put that
information as they hear it.
I know there have been studies done about trials where, um, witnesses were shown
out of order in a story, um, because they were available on a particular day.
And it turns out that if you tell the story, especially in a time sequence, if
possible, um, then it's much more persuasive than if you just give people a
bunch of information and expect them to know where to put it, because remember
they can't ask questions.
So if they have a question about something, they just have to sit there
and hope that someone answers it.
That's a good point.
For those in our viewing audience, that's just joining us.
We're in the lunch break on day eight of this murder trial against Keewan White.
According to the prosecution, they say back on 2020, November 11th, 2020, I
believe is when Melvin Noble, who went by the rap name 03 was gunned down on a
busy Dallas interstate.
You see it right there.
I 35, this was around the noon lunchtime hour.
They say that the person running towards the camera right there, they
believe that that is Keewan White.
Uh, after multiple days of getting videos from trap houses in different
places, about a month after now in December, uh, Keewan White was
arrested and charged with murder.
And these trap house videos, uh, they basically said they
started to hone in on one thing.
And I know people in comments were laughing at this, but it helped the
prosecution saying that this person happened to be wearing the same color
underwear, some light blue underwear, uh, in these pictures.
And then they said the day before the murder, he was seen holding a
weapon and wearing those underwear.
And then the day of the murder, they said that he returned to this
house wearing the same things.
And then also in that backyard surveillance video, uh, him and
another co-conspirator were allegedly burning items, the lead detective
saying that he was burning the clothes he was wearing that day.
Um, and then, uh, we heard detective Eric Barnes testifying saying that
for 18 hours, allegedly Keewan White and Devin Brown that in a car, in a
parking lot, an apartment complex where Melvin Noble was, and this is the
complexity of how Devin Brown's involved.
The woman you see right there, Jocelyn Jackson was dating at the time,
Mo three, but she is the mother of Devin Brown's children.
According to testimony, the day before the murder, Devin Brown, um, texted
his son to see if Mo three was at Jocelyn Jackson's home and Devin Brown.
Also the day of the murder spoke to Jocelyn Jackson and her, his son, uh,
seeing if Melvin Noble was still there, according to surveillance video
testimony and tracing of phones.
According to the prosecution, they say that Devin Brown and Keewan White
allegedly sat in that black Camaro in the parking lot for 18 hours until
Melvin Noble pulled out and then allegedly followed him to I 35.
Where a Kroger delivery truck captured this murder on video.
The first day of testimony, we heard from Jocelyn Jackson.
We heard from, um, two women who were on I 35, uh, and them describing one
seeing the gunman allegedly putting on his mask, and, uh, we heard from
another witness who happened to be a trauma surgeon who was heading to a
hospital and, um, his vehicle had.
Shattered windshield from the shooting.
Multiple shots were fired, I believe like 33.
Um, and the medical examiner saying that Melvin Noble had, I believe
13, uh, rifle wounds is how he described it.
Um, and so now we're at this point, six years later, uh, I've been talking
with Alison Richardson, um, who is a jury expert.
Um, Alison, the one thing interesting right now is we have a holiday weekend,
uh, after whatever happens today.
Um, and the jury can, uh, decide to, to work over the weekend.
We'll have to see if they agree to that.
The judge asked them yesterday.
Uh, she said, do you want to work this weekend?
And they just laughed at her.
Um, maybe they may be more motivated to work over the weekend and get the sober
with, um, but we're going into a holiday weekend.
Let's say, uh, we know for sure the prosecution is going to rest today.
We don't know what the defense is going to do.
The prosecution only has one more witness to call.
Um, but let's say, uh, the prosecution rests and then defense starts and they
can't finish today for some reason.
And the jury says, we don't want to work over the weekend.
Monday is Labor Day.
It's a holiday.
They wouldn't come back until Tuesday.
Wouldn't that, I mean, you've been sitting here for hours.
Listening to testimony, testimony.
Uh, who could that help or hurt the big gap in days before you hear
the defense put on their case?
Let's say the defense is not put on their case until Tuesday.
Would that hurt the defense?
Um, well, it, it depends.
I mean, the wagers, so let's say they go home over the weekend and
they don't come back until Tuesday.
They're not going to be thinking about bank records or cell towers or, you
know, any of this more technical information they're going to be thinking
about the, the moments that impacted their emotions, what will probably be
replaying in their minds would be, um, things such as, you know, that video
of, of what happened on I-35.
They've probably all been on I-35 at some point in time.
Um, so they're thinking about what if it had been me, you know, if I was on I-35
and the, the neurosurgeon's testimony was very impactful along with the other
witnesses and Mothree's mother, um, you know, there have been several moments
where they, there have, um, the testimony has captured their attention, I'm sure.
And so if, if that's the case, if that's what they're thinking about over the
weekend, it could hurt the defense.
But, you know, I, I was thinking about this and I, I, I think the way there's
two different approaches, as you would expect from the prosecution and the
defense, the prosecution has, they mentioned they had over 250 witnesses.
Um, they have, you know, thousands of pieces of evidence throughout
these different witnesses.
Um, you know, if, if they went through all of that, the jury would be in there
for months and months, but they don't need to do that to, to reach a verdict.
So, so they won't be doing that.
Um, but it's like they're putting together fibers in the rope of reasonable doubt.
Um, you know, they're, they're trying to make that rope is as strong as they can
so that those jurors go into the deliberation room and there's no doubt in
their mind and you know, that's the lens they see everything through.
The defense on the other hand is telling the jury, this is not a rope, this is a
chain and a chain is only as strong as the weakest link.
So their job is to inject reasonable doubt.
So if through some of the cross examination, they have been able to, you
know, um, inject some reasonable doubt.
And I know there were some courtroom outbursts this week as well, which, you
know, shouldn't play a role, but you never know.
It's hard to unring a bell.
Um, they could be thinking about that too.
So it could cut either way.
Yeah, you're absolutely right.
And I was about to talk about that next.
I mean, for, for a lot of people, and I've been saying this this whole
trial, because it's true.
I mean, a lot of people only see court on law and order, right?
They just watch it on TV or see clips from an actual trial.
Uh, but I know we've had some loyal people that have been watching every day.
I don't know how y'all are watching at work or whatever, but we appreciate it.
Um, the, you know, the defense only has to get doubt from one person.
You're like, you know, like talking about, uh, when it comes to deliberations,
they just have to plant that seed of doubt in, in one or two jurors.
Prosecution has to get everyone, uh, everyone on board.
Um, you mentioned the court outburst, uh, that happened yesterday.
I want you guys to take a listen.
Uh, that individual was arrested shortly after that, uh, saying
I got evidence, he didn't kill him.
I mean, and the judge gave a good speech after they came back from all that
saying, you know, it's a public courtroom, but you're secure there literally
is a metal detector at the door of the courtroom, not just the court house.
Um, could that rattle a juror or is that just kind of like a one-off type?
Well, it depends on how they look at it.
I mean, they could either look at it like, Hey, maybe there's
something we're not hearing.
And it, it could create a little bit, bit of reasonable doubt, but it
could also work against the defense.
If they look at it, um, like an attempt to manipulate them.
I mean, jurors are very sensitive to any type of manipulation
and they don't like it.
I mean, that's one of the reasons they watch the judge so carefully in a trial
is because the judge is supposed to be the neutral party and the party that
they can trust, but, um, you know, at the end of the day, it comes down
to credibility as well, so they may not assign any credibility to this
person who had the outburst, who did the outburst staying on the doubt part of
things, uh, you know, two days ago, it was a bombshell discovery when the
prosecution said, look here, Marquise Conway, two days before the alleged
payment took $40,000 out of his Chase bank.
And that was the news for that day.
That's the withdrawal slip.
Uh, that was made at a Frisco bank near, uh, where Marquise Conway lives.
But then Bree West punching back yesterday, walking through because
they did a full analysis of his bank account showing a pattern of monthly
withdrawals and between $10,000 and up to $60,000 for, for one of those months.
And so we talked about that doubt of, you know, one day the jury hearing,
Oh, well, why did this guy take out $40,000 allegedly two days
before this payment was made?
But then yesterday they hear new testimony hearing, Oh, well, he
takes out 10 to $60,000.
Uh, in January, February, March, May, June, July, and in November.
And so is that some of the doubt that you speak of that?
I mean, that can totally change one of the jurors perspective of, Oh, well,
he takes out money regularly, so he might not have made a payment for a murder.
Sure.
Um, well it could, they could take it one of two ways.
I mean, they, that could either neutralize the initial impact of seeing
that he made a $40,000 withdrawal.
Um, but, but again, jurors don't really, this isn't a debate tournament to them.
They're not looking at it like, Ooh, we have a point here or we have a point there.
They have a story probably that is going through their mind.
And if the $40,000 withdrawal, even though there may have been other
withdrawals make sense to them in their story, they're going to absorb that
information that that could be evidence, um, that he hired a hit man with this
money, but on the other hand, if they're looking at it from the other direction
and they're, they're already thinking, um, you know, I have some reasonable
doubt on this and they see the other withdrawals, then they
just discard that information.
So in other words, they'll take this information and they'll probably apply
it to whatever way they're already looking at the case.
I'm looking at the comments, um, on YouTube D thanks for saying you watch every day.
I I've been getting text messages from people and Allison,
people were upset this morning.
Let me explain to y'all.
Uh, first off, this is a, uh, we do a pool situation, right?
So it's not, you know, there's four major TV stations in Dallas.
There's not four cameras in the courtroom.
All the stations are working together to provide covers to all of our viewers.
So it's a, what we call a pool.
Um, and we have some issues with the pool today.
Um, and the elevator was also out in the courtroom.
Um, and so, uh, we weren't able to get everything set up.
Um, and so we had some audio issues, some video issues.
Uh, but I appreciate everybody's been watching and this, this
trial has garnered a lot of attention.
Um, I saw someone in the comments say, um, maybe that guy
who did the outburst was paid.
I, I can only deal with facts, uh, but the outburst was super
random, um, and came at a random time.
I, I, I know that for sure.
Um, some have been commenting about a plea deal.
Um, I know Alison, every case is different, right?
A lot of people speculated that, uh, there could have been a plea
deal taken before this trial started.
And, um, you know, a defendant can take a deal at any time.
So, uh, you know, after this lunch break, uh, they could come up with a deal.
Um, this deep in, I don't think that that's likely.
Um, but, uh, there's been a lot of damaging evidence against
Keewan white in the world of 2026, where we have so many cameras.
Um, the prosecution saying he's on video committing the murder, the
prosecution saying, uh, the same day, he's wearing these different types
of clothes the day before and the day after the trap house, uh, basically
telling on themselves because they had eight cameras still rolling.
And so the prosecution trying to connect all of these dots in this narrative,
the real question is that the payment portion of this, a lot of people.
Believe from following this trial that the prosecution may
have proven their murder case.
And to be clear that black Camaro that you see in that shot right
there from the trap house, Dallas police and no investigator
has been able to locate it.
Dallas police and no investigator, I believe have not been able
to locate the actual murder weapon.
So knowing that Allison, uh, how does a jury, a juror, maybe digest that
saying, yes, you guys have all this video and you've been showing all of this,
but why don't you have the murder vehicle?
Why don't you have the murder weapon?
Well, I mean, if you look at the evidence and I believe there was
testimony about the fact that, um, how this organization was structured.
So that no one person had direct contact, um, with Marquis Conway and
that different people knew different things that were going on, you know,
a jury can process that one of two ways.
They, a juror can look at it and say, you know, I, I look at this
as a weak link in that chain.
I'm having trouble getting to reasonable doubt because beyond a reasonable
doubt, because this creates some doubt for me.
But a different juror might look at it and say, you know, I I'm in here to
deliberate and I'm in here to put the pieces of the puzzle together.
And it's clear that this organization has done a lot of things to avoid.
Prosecution and conviction for what they're doing.
Um, but I can put the pieces of the puzzle together and, um, they're
allowed to do that with circumstantial evidence.
So, um, it just depends on which way they're looking at the case.
And, you know, even if somebody has reasonable doubt, um, their personality
comes to play with it too, because, you know, a lot of times if they're an
outlier, only one or two people who believe that way, um, then, you know,
the deliberation tends to go towards the majority.
But if they have a very strong personality, then they might be the
holdout.
Allison, it's like perfect timing for us that we have a jury expert on,
because I'm going to shift gears on you.
And I know it's the case that you likely have also been following a judge just
declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case.
Um, this was, this was multiple days of deliberation and hearing, you know,
from the court saying it was just one juror.
I mean, how often do we get this type of situation where, you know, I know the
judge can give the Allen charge.
I believe that's what it's called, but keep compelling the jury to go back and
deliberate.
How rare is it that we see a mistrial in a case like that?
It's pretty rare in a high profile trial.
Um, a lot of it comes down to probably jury selection.
You know, you're, you're looking, you know, if you're the prosecutor, you're
looking for people who might have that personality to be in holdout.
Um, but more so you're looking for people who can,
you know, on both sides, keep an open mind.
And, um, we won't know the story of why this person decided to hold out until,
you know, unless they decide to talk about it.
But, um, a lot of times the holdouts tend to be people who have a very strongly
preconceived notion going in.
And either they were, you know, not sharing that or, um, you know, they kept it
to themselves or, you know, they, they purposely kept it to themselves.
It could be a variety of things. I don't know what happened in this case.
I'm not trying to say any of that happened in this case.
I'm just saying these are things we've seen in the past.
And I know jury selection, you, to your point,
the jury selection process is so important.
I know some people say it's not jury selection is your elimination, right?
Trying to get jurors that will work in your favor.
For those who may not be so aware of this,
Lindsay Clancy was accused of killing her young children. Um,
and she's charged with the murder of those children.
But her defense is saying that this was due to a medical episode,
postpartum psychosis. I know Clancy tried to commit suicide.
She's in a wheelchair in the courtroom. How often, I mean, with the judge,
we've seen clips of, you know, the defense attorney saying, you know,
what are we going to do?
The judge got so frustrated today to say,
what do you want me to take out brass knuckles?
I think he called them brass bands to try to compel the jury. And then, I mean,
these are regular people. You don't want to just keep pushing. Um, but like you
said, a high profile case like this, who knows what,
what the conversations and the deliberation room were,
but the fact that it seems like it came down to one person, um,
could, could open the door for so much speculation, right?
Yes. Yes. And if that person chooses to, to speak out,
it'll be interesting to hear what they have to say.
But at this time we don't know why there was a holdout.
We just know that at least one person, um,
refused to, to join the group in deliberations, um,
with the guilty verdict with a guilty verdict.
And Alison, cause I know you want to take a sip of water or something.
I appreciate you being with us for so long. Just any final thoughts in reference
to, you know, a lot of people, you know,
either just see that the viral clips from a trial,
whether it be this rap trial that we're talking about or the Clancy trial, um,
so much goes into selecting a jury.
So much goes into figuring out all everyone, you know,
the public seeing all the evidence and saying,
how did they find this person not guilty or how did they find this person
guilty? I mean,
it really comes down to those 12 people sitting in there for hours, days,
weeks, however, along a trial is what would you want the public to know just
about juries until, like I said, I've never been on one. Um, but what,
what, what have you surmised just from all of these recent big trials when it
comes to juries?
Well, one, one of the concerns I have as a jury consultant is that fewer and
fewer cases are going to trial. Um,
one of the reasons is because they're so expensive and that's probably one of
the reasons this judge in the Clancy case is so frustrated is because so many
resources have been used for this trial. But having said that, um,
I'm a big believer in the jury system. I mean,
it goes all the way back to, you know, medieval England. Um,
you know,
it was one of the cornerstones that we wrote about when we were writing our
declaration of independence and our constitution. It's a,
it's a key piece of our democracy where you bring peers and people from the
community together to, um, you know,
deliberate and think about justice because we don't want the government doing
it for us. We don't want a king doing it for us like they had in England. Um,
we want people in our own community and it looks like we have a good diverse
jury in this, in this particular case. And, um,
they're doing exactly what they're supposed to do,
which is representing all of us.
Alison Richardson, our jury expert.
I appreciate you taking some time to more in time, almost 30,
30 minutes to talk to me today about this.
We're definitely going to hit you back when jury deliberation starts in this,
uh, case, but thank you so much for your time.
My pleasure, Steven.
If you're just joining us, it is just after one 30.
The jury is supposed to return at one 40. Uh,
in this case,
Mo three gunned down on a busy Dallas interstate back in 2020.
The state says that a Dallas rapper,
Mark, he's Conway by the rap name, yellow, busy,
allegedly paid Keone white thousands of dollars to do it.
I'm going to leave you with the cross examination of the last witness that's on
the stand,
a special agent from the FBI talking about tracing all of the co-conspirators
phones together and him saying that this is where they were when this money deal
was being made. Court will resume around one 40.
So we're going to leave you with the cross examination.
And then when court resumes, we'll take that live.
