HCCH aBridged 2021 - Closing remarks - Paula María All

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
1 Video View·Sep 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation discusses the critical role of dispute settlement systems and choice of court agreements in international trade, specifically within Latin America and the Caribbean. It emphasizes the need for legal certainty, party autonomy, and the adoption of the 2005 Hague Convention to reduce litigation risks and harmonize jurisdictional rules across the region.
Thank you very much, Ignacio. Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, depending on where
you find yourselves. On behalf of the American Association of Private International Law,
it's a pleasure and an honor for me here to be here participating in this activity. And I would
like to congratulate you on the magnificent organization and the speakers for their
relevant interventions. And at the same time, I celebrate the synergy that year after year
is consolidated between the HCCH and ASADIP, where the HCCH regional office for Latin America
and the Caribbean plays a transcendental role. Without prejudice to the richness of the subjects
and the various topics that have been addressed previously, I would just like to share a number
of brief comments with you. Firstly, importance of the dispute settlement system from the point
of view of international strategy for companies and individuals. There are a number of obvious
facts that cannot go unnoticed by anyone. On the one hand, increasing internationalization.
And then on the other hand, the increasing complexity of these cases as well, which require
legal solutions to reflect that reality. And thirdly, there's the question of procedural
and cooperative issues of private international law, which are center stage. Although it's well
known, what's said by Professor Moreno, that a large part of disputes in commercial private
international law cases are resolved via arbitration. I think it's essential to understand
the effects that a choice of court agreement can have on the development of disputes discussed
before the courts, especially in Latin American and Caribbean countries. In this context of
contemporary international relations shaped by current economic and political processes,
we mustn't lose sight of the fact that in this region, trade and international business and
investment are increasing rapidly. This is a time when we see that we need to have agile,
clear and flexible laws in place, which are essential values in international trade in
these countries. The analysis of choice of court agreements is an issue of vast dimensions.
We need to have secure and predictable rules in place, because a choice of court agreement,
as we said, as the previous speakers have said, plays an essential role with regard to
predictability. And the achievement of the 2005 convention is not irrelevant for international
commercial traffic, as it can reduce the economic risk of litigation, hypothetically, which might
take place in more than one jurisdiction, but in many countries in different times as well.
And it needs to be effective, and that requires a number of aspects to be taken into account,
respect for the clauses. So, the way in which the 2005 convention is written offers technical
and legal certainty to these questions, despite the fact it can't cover all of the areas, but it
does provide a number of procedural instruments to allow people to choose a court. This legal
cooperation requires an international legal system in place, which secures the legal certainty
for the different parties with regard to their operations, and also which
regulates recognition of these agreements. As a third point that I would like us to consider,
we have to think about the role of party autonomy as a criterion for the attribution of jurisdiction.
As was said by the Secretary General at the beginning, with its restrictions and nuances,
it's clear that there is a universal tendency to admit the autonomy of will in just jurisdictional
matters. However, the jurisdictional landscape in certain areas in Latin America and the Caribbean
can appear a real labyrinth with existential problems. The determination of the criteria
for jurisdiction is not uniform, there is no specific international convention on jurisdiction
for the Americas, all of the Americas overall, and the instruments and criteria for cooperation and
the recognition of enforcement of judgments can be different too. And as the Professor from Paris
said, there's also the Bustamante Accord. There are also differences when it comes to legislation
in different countries in a region. We also have to think about another important reason, which
might be particularly relevant in our countries. Given the tendency to apply Lex Fori to many
international cases, choice of court clauses offer insurance against forum shopping, and in a legally
fragmented world, the parties do not have absolute certainty ex ante as to the jurisdiction that will
settle the dispute. Hence, party autonomy allows the parties to significantly reduce this uncertainty,
as two professors previously referred to, and the Buenos Aires Convention is also one to take
into account. It's the client that decides, the parties decide on the agreement. And finally,
as a final point, I would just like us to take into account a retrospective view, as well as a
perspective view of the Convention in Latin America. From a general perspective of the
situation in Latin America, as Professor Hardy and also Ignacio pointed out as well, Mexico is the
only country that has acceded to the Convention to date. In 2005, at the time of the birth of the
Convention, the only autonomous private international law legislation in Latin America
was the Venezuelan Private International Law Act of 1998, which enshrined the autonomy of the will
as a criterion for attributing jurisdiction in property-related cases. Things have changed in
recent years. There's the Dominican Republic Private International Law Act of 2014, as well as
the Panamanian Code of Private International Law, Civil and Commercial Code of Argentina from 2015,
and the recent Uruguayan General Private International Law Act of 2020,
enshrined the autonomy of the will as a criterion for attributing jurisdiction
in international commercial transactions, obviously with certain limitations, as do
draft private international laws of Colombia and Chile. By this, I mean that Latin America,
in its autonomous private international law legislation, has taken a step towards expressly
enshrining party autonomy in jurisdictional matters in international transactions.
Perhaps this will allow us to have a more auspicious forward-looking vision of the
Hague Convention. This prospective vision implies identifying trends, opportunities,
risks, costs and benefits, and based on a critical, serious and reflective analysis,
actions and policies can be adopted in our countries in the coming years. It's not insignificant that
Brazil and Paraguay are studying the instrument with a view to its ratification. Within countries
with civil law traditions, where they're sources of international private law as well, it's very
auspicious that all are working in the same direction. However, there are enormous challenges
facing the region, and we have to try to ensure that there is a trade-off between flexibility
and legal certainty. So now, more than ever, what we need to have clear rules of the game,
because ultimately, signals sent to the market are more necessary than ever. In this respect,
striking the right balance between having clear rules on the choice of court is not merely a
possibility, but in recent times it's become a real requirement. And ultimately, today's event
has been given the name BRIDGED 2021, Innovation in Transnational Legislation, and the symbol is a
However, a bridge does not stand on one side only. It's not enough just to have the 2005 instrument.
Perhaps innovation in the field of transnational litigation today requires a thorough analysis,
first and foremost, by our countries to assess the effective viability and subsequent implementation,
without losing sight of the fact that the choice of court agreement, with all that it implies,
also carries within it the most modern idea of accessing justice as being a fundamental human
right. This analysis should not remain unfinished business for countries in the region in Latin
America, and the Academy, as well as the states that have private international law advisory
commissions in the Ministries of Foreign Affairs, can collaborate and be real agents for mobilizing
the changes that are deemed necessary. This conference undoubtedly has been a bridge to cross
and to bring together various issues, but also from an academic and judicial point of view,
and it's been extremely rich. So I would like to conclude by saying thank you very much
for taking part actively. I would like to congratulate the HCCH, and of course we are
committed to continuing to collaborate actively with the regional office for Latin America and
the Caribbean on this and so many other issues that we have in common. Thank you very much indeed.
Thank you very much, Paul. I think I'm clapping those were absolutely perfect
closing remarks. We are very grateful to you personally, but also to ASADIP institutionally
for your continuous support to the work of the regional office, of the Permanent Bureau,
and for years to come. Many thanks to you all for your presence, for your engagement today,
many questions, many could not be addressed during the sessions. This was the 2021 edition
of the HCCH, the bridge, and it is a bridge, besides the bridge, because it wishes to introduce
briefly and pragmatically these topics to nurture your interest to further study and promote
these conventions, and I hope we have met that objective. Final note to recall that the recording
of this event will soon be available in our website, and in the meantime I wish you a good
balance of the day and hope that you will join us for future editions of the HCCH, the bridge.
Stay safe, and that's a wrap. Thank you very much.
