Mapping the Informal Jurisprudence of Corporate Production and Investment Responsibility

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Sep 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker proposes the creation of a Global Industries Ombudsman Service to provide justice and compensation for victims of human rights abuses in global supply chains. By adapting domestic ombudsman models to an international scale, the goal is to bypass jurisdictional hurdles of \"hard law\" and hold global corporations accountable for forced labor and exploitation.
Well done to you all.
Last session, last day.
You're still here.
You're still standing.
Well done.
Well done.
Okay, so my presentation has a rather abstract title,
Mapping the Informal Jurisprudence
What we've just heard from Claire is what I would describe as formal jurisprudence.
I think you refer to it as soft law.
But I call it the informal system, if you prefer.
What I'll be discussing is actually quite grounded, albeit idealistic.
So I do have a specific proposal to put to you,
which is for a private ordering system that would bring justice to the victims in global supply chains
or global production processes, the victims of that process.
And even more specifically, I would be proposing that there should be something along the lines of
A Global Industries Ombudsman Service.
That's a lot to take in.
Global Industries Ombudsman Service
I have had extensive experience with domestic legal systems.
or domestic systems in which there are ombudsman services
which can handle complaints against banks and financial providers
and telecommunications industries, and so on.
So the idea is to take that basic model and adapt it to an international forum.
but the complainants would be workers and others affected by global industries.
And the goal would be to overcome some of the jurisdictional issues we face with hard law.
Some of which have been described by Claire.
So if anyone is intrigued or interested in what I'm talking about today and wants to contact me,
I'd be very interested in any ideas, any contacts, anything.
You can contact me at [email protected].
So here's my pitch.
So the idea is to establish this Global Industries Ombudsman Service.
And to succeed in that, there are two elements.
One is that you need the industries on board, which is no easy task.
That's the first step.
And the second thing is to map the jurisprudence, the informal jurisprudence,
which is somewhat chaotic at this stage,
so that there is a foundation upon which the system can operate.
So let's just define the problem a little bit further.
The issue is that the victims of human rights abuses in global production processes
All victims, with the rare exceptions Claire has mentioned.
It is extremely difficult for them to obtain any compensation.
I'm focusing on global corporations first, because they make excellent defendants.
They have money.
And secondly, they are the throughput of the clothes we wear.
and many of the other items that we have,
which in many cases are produced by slave labor and victims,
For which we benefit, global corporations also benefit.
And I would think, in some ways, we are complicit in the abuses.
that are taking place through the conduit of these global corporations.
And the kinds of corporations I'm talking about
are those in the fields of apparel, mining companies, food and beverage,
And there is an extensive list beyond that.
Now, as we've heard from Claire,
It isn't so difficult for global corporations to evade the formal legal system.
in terms of remedying any harms.
And thus they are able to use subcontracting arrangements.
and a whole range of other processes
to avoid any meaningful liability for the harms they cause.
And as I say, we are complicit in all of this.
Thus, they induce abuses in their production processes.
And various ways this is done include forced labor, child labor,
employment of workers in dangerous and unhealthy workplaces,
underpayment, deprivation of the right to join unions
For example, in Guatemala, they tend to assassinate union leaders.
That's just their little way of trying to bring a bit of order to the situation.
And also the subjection of workers to harassment and abuse.
The group of people affected by this is substantial.
The ILO estimated conservatively that we are dealing with more than 20 million people.
that are subjected to coercion, deception, and human trafficking.
More specifically still, not so long ago, the BBC conducted an investigation.
They found that there were Turkish textile factories exploiting child labor.
to the extent that they were employing seven- and eight-year-old children working 60-hour weeks.
Syrian refugees were a prime target for exploitation within these global supply chains.
And we can see here a number of UK companies that were found to be linked
to production houses using forced labor.
The difficulties with the formal system, some of which are again mentioned by Claire,
is the difficulty in seeking remedies in the home country
for a whole lot of reasons I probably don't need to go over again.
And trying to initiate action in one's home country is somewhat difficult.
So what is, this is not suggesting replacing what we have,
but perhaps complementing what we have.
Wouldn't it be great if global corporations were first to accept responsibilities?
that extend beyond their formal legal liabilities.
What if they took on responsibilities beyond that?
That's the first thing.
And secondly, what if they voluntarily established a system for compensating the victims of that abuse?
The first part, voluntarily accepting responsibility, is increasingly occurring.
but it is happening in a somewhat chaotic manner, as we will see in a moment.
It's somewhat chaotic.
So I think we need, and this is a project that I will commit to with others.
and that is what is attempting to bring some coherence to this outburst we are experiencing at the moment
of voluntary assumption of responsibility.
But for all the voluntary acceptance of responsibility that is taking place,
There are very, very few cases in which there is compensation.
or any form of remedy being provided to the injured parties.
So this is where the latest developments are not succeeding.
So we're talking about a voluntary system in which global corporations
will commit themselves to providing compensation to the affected parties.
So why would they do it?
There were a couple of reasons.
One is the reputational risk they are facing at the moment,
the tarnishing of their brand, their brand name.
The Rana Plaza collapse is one of the deadliest industrial disasters in history, in which 1,300 people were killed.
with a factory collapse in Bangladesh,
where they were producing clothes for H&M, Primark, Zara, and so on.
And there have also been many other successful campaigns by NGOs.
and other civil society groups that have embarrassed
and put at risk the reputation of those major global companies.
That's one reason they might want something fairly high-profile.
and an orderly system for providing remedies.
Secondly, there is a political and regulatory risk.
If these corporations do nothing.
And in recent times we have seen
the California Transparency and Supply Chains Act,
the UK Modern Slavery Act,
the French duty of diligence legislation,
Netherlands child labour due diligence legislation.
They are the first step.
What's interesting about these measures is their ability to capture nuanced differences in performance across diverse contexts, while maintaining consistency and reliability.
Are they holding global corporations?
at the very least requiring them to report on what they are doing
in their global supply chains.
But they are extending jurisdiction to firms.
that aren't even located in Britain.
It's just that if they supply goods or services to Britain
and their global turnover exceeds a certain threshold,
that is sufficient to trigger legislative capture.
So there is a concern for business
that legislation, having reached that beachhead,
would extend liability.
So I've talked about a voluntary remedial system,
which I have called the Global Industries Ombudsman Service.
This is modeled on, very approximately,
on a successful domestic system
that has developed over the last four decades
where consumers can file free complaints
against a bank or telecommunications company
in which they can file their complaint free of charge, at no cost,
even if they lose, all funded by industry
in which an independent, industry-funded ombudsman
They will hear their disputes and make a decision.
And that decision is binding on the firm by contract.
And I have personally used an ombudsman service before,
a financial industry, a financial ombudsman service
and we could make orders for compensation
On the order of $100,000, no, up to $300,000.
Quite substantial amounts of money can be requested.
And the company has to comply.
but if the consumer loses, that's okay,
They can take their matter to court.
So that they do not lose their right to initiate legal proceedings.
So the idea of having corporations both responsible
and being involved in some kind of informal system,
I've got five minutes here,
is that businesses,
it is suggested under the UN Guiding Principles
or proposed UN guiding principles on business and human rights
that they should establish and participate
in a grievance mechanism for individuals who are affected.
There are other international documents that are available.
requiring that industries take responsibility
beyond their narrow formal legal liability
There are voluntary codes being developed at the moment.
to an extent that goes beyond formal legal liability.
The guiding principles point to,
even though they do not specifically mention
any global industries ombudsman service
but under Principle 31, they discuss the types of things
that a remedial system should have.
It should be legitimate, accessible, and predictable.
and rights compatible.
The ombudsman may be established by a charter,
a separate company with a board,
which would have an equal number of industry members
and NGOs on the board.
Imagine we had this ombudsman.
The next question is,
What is the jurisdiction of the ombudsman?
We have an ombudsman based somewhere in the world,
Singapore or somewhere in Asia or Europe or anywhere else.
The ombudsman can hear disputes.
It's a contractual matter that is binding on the corporation.
But what is the scope of the jurisdiction?
If we look at the existing documents, such as the ILO document,
the OECD or the UN Guiding Principles,
They're somewhat vague about the reach.
of the corporation's responsibility.
For a lawyer, that's unsettling.
It's too vague.
For example, you can see that under the ILO's document,
It states that the corporation should be responsible.
for abuses that occur within its own competence.
What does that mean?
With the OECD, with which it is involved,
OECD and UN Guiding Principles
in the context of its own activities
and finally within its own operations.
The issue we have is that if there were an ombudsman,
we would need to establish a charter that would inform the ombudsman
what their jurisdiction is
The kinds of issues are how far does the responsibility extend
Where did the company go?
Is it to their subcontractors, or does it go all the way?
back to the cotton grower for the T-shirt?
What are the compensation limits?
Is it $100,000, $200,000, $300,000, $400,000, or $500,000?
What kinds of damages can be compensated?
In the case of Barak Gold, a mining company in Papua New Guinea,
where the guards of that mining company were raping
the local Papua New Guinean women
They established an informal complaint system.
in which they were awarding monetary compensation
for the affected women.
And finally, an issue that has to be addressed
are the evidential requirements.
For example, this is my final point,
The evidential requirements will not always be easy.
And this was illustrated in this recent case.
United States vs. Guatemala
in which the United States brought a case against Guatemala
for breaching the Central American
United States Free Trade Agreement,
in which it was required that Guatemala
comply with its own labor laws.
And as I mentioned earlier,
Guatemala has a history of killing labor leaders,
apart from anything else
And the United States failed in its arbitration,
and one of the areas in which it failed was
in collecting witness statements,
They couldn't put the names of the witnesses.
because they were too afraid that if their name were on it
and that went to the other side, being the Guatemalan government,
in that arbitration, then the Guatemalan government
would single those witnesses out for intimidation.
And so without witness names on those statements,
The arbitral body could not pay attention,
could not have taken them into account,
because it could not, as a matter of due process,
be shown to the other side and be challenged.
So these are the kinds of issues that will also arise
when we map out the informal jurisprudence.
Thank you.
