The Role of the Concept of Human Rights Due Diligence in Fostering Corporate Accountability

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Sep 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation examines the evolution of corporate accountability regarding human rights and environmental damage, focusing on the transition from voluntary \"soft law\" commitments to mandatory \"hard law\" obligations. Through a comparative analysis of legal cases in the UK and the Netherlands, it explores the extent to which parent companies can be held liable for the actions of their foreign subsidiaries.
My thesis focuses on the role of human rights cultures in supervision.
in social welfare contributions.
Human rights cultures imply a close connection between the principles of leadership and business.
linking human rights and matters relating to the pathways from the streets of social deprivation
Human rights advocacy available for use by social services to write human rights.
Now, as we know, one of the specific contexts of leadership principles is the fact
We are occasionally present, but what we have witnessed is different activities on the role.
social to strive to provide support for the human rights leadership programme and its development
Human services are more difficult. Here are the communities we wish to inform you about today.
We have two particular ways. The first one comes from the Social Government, particularly
social rights, and the ways in which two governments approach them. Therefore, when examining human rights
Social work practice, to begin with, I will proceed to discuss two points, focusing on them.
community and social efforts, despite the challenges of the time,
These efforts include the difference in the basic society for the resources and their
a significant part of our social lives. Therefore, starting with the UK, I will now discuss the
a recent attempt, concerning attempts that are being submitted
in Wales through community resources for Welsh society, therefore for
Community and Social Community, for the sections they took
the impact of environmental variation caused by resources,
The only way forward being promoted and implemented by society.
In fact, the presentations supported the idea that diversity is diversity itself.
affected their lives, because they were striving for diversity, diversity is what
general diversity of variation to strive, to ask, to strive, to promote the cross,
I did not know either, etc. One of the common problems that occur
That was the location of the regulation. Evidently, the implementation was for the
responsibility and the responsibility being identified even within the institutions of diversity of diversity,
to find that under Article 4 the person is connected with the shareholders of the Realm,
It will be responsible for the kingdom's contributors. The achievements regarding the responsibility
For the diversity in the accounting, and the contributors were fully aware of the situation of the accounting
Dignity with your lesser. Obviously, the accountability for the accountability was in the situation of the diversity.
with the computer literacy and the computer literacy then. Obviously, the computer literacy was obviously
for any person who is difficult, or a good part, of the report. Therefore, in any
liability, this report concerns the reports for
to use the non-EU workforce to bring in and demonstrate expertise in Wales,
with the reports regarding the use of non-EU equipment, when both operations are to be
make adjustments, but if the reports were to move toward the
These reports were taking up considerable operational effort. Therefore, at present, this is the dilemma.
Being responsible is not getting the chance to be effective.
The governments previously stated that the reports could influence public opinion in the UK.
Hefty. The use of the roads was ongoing, but the entire focus of the case was on the roads.
In Zambia. Fortunately, they have already been handled by Alex Chort, so nothing has happened.
This is where we rely on them, this is where responsibility is being fulfilled.
The law in Zambia was discretionary. Therefore, the use was
Zambia would be very much dependent on hearing.
The usage was habitual, and it was very habitual to hear.
The usage was indeed very noticeable to hear.
And for users, on the other hand, is the way in which connection would be made
The way in which connection would be achieved is through shared responsibility and accountability.
responsibility and responsibility is responsibility is responsibility is responsibility is responsibility
with responsibility. Therefore, in order to decide on these types,
The usage had to be decided by the initiative regarding responsibility.
liability arising from liability on the liability
for the activities of his responsibility. In order to demonstrate
liability, used by the liability a number of materials, and one of these was
the published tools that the Auditor General has made available
I had a connection to use life rafts
the technological significance of digitizing accountability in Wales.
Who was analyzing the vital statistics on usage
The accountability secretary's predecessors were the Simon government.
the Secretary of Accountability,
to discover that the responsibility for the Auditor General's office is linked,
It was feeling the weight of all the responsibilities.
They had been established in the Accountability Case. They were looking at the resources.
the case of Chandler and the case of Berth.
Openly, this was very important, so he did not take responsibility.
But in truth, there was indeed a real question, though only one.
I suppose it wouldn't be used openly.
According to this case,
We don't want to talk about the Berth case.
in Wales. This case concerns
deficiencies arising from original deficiencies that have been taken into account
a few social rooms. Therefore, the Berth case was
things happened at the events as well as at the different connections
the resources, but clearly, the deficiencies
He often goes out on the Berth case.
In fact, the Berth case occurred during the protests.
the difficulties. The Berth case occurs at the Berth case
case based on the Brussels I Regulation, the previous version, and the claim against a Nigerian
subsidiary was established under Dutch law, Dutch national law, and in particular Article 7 of the Dutch
Code of Civil Procedure, which allows related claims to be heard by the same court. Therefore,
not unlike the one in English law that I mentioned earlier.
Once again, Shell was acting within the law, but the claimants were misusing procedural law.
and that their strategy of bringing the claim against a parent company was actually just the
a device that was cynically used to advance claims that would otherwise have no connection
anything whatsoever with the European territory. And they were arguing that the claims against
a parent company were to fail. So once again, the judge had to define the likelihood that
A claim against a parent company could be awarded.
The claimants specifically relied on, in support of their claim, the fact that the parent company
exercised a high degree of control and direction over the Nigerian subsidiary,
but it owed them a duty of care, but he had breached that duty of care by failing to ensure
that their own links had been effectively cleaned up, and by failing to take appropriate measures
to address what they considered to be a well-known systemic problem in its operation.
Now, in the first instance, the Dutch Forum rejected the claims against the parent company.
on the grounds that under Nigerian law, there was no general duty of care on parent companies
to prevent their subsidiaries from causing harm to others through their business operations.
But in a very interesting ruling by the Court of Appeal of The Hague on December 18th
In 2015, the Court reversed that decision and stated that it could not be ruled out in advance.
that a parent company may in certain circumstances be liable for damages resulting from acts and
emissions of its subsidiary. The Court of Appeal stated that, taking into account the foreseeable
serious consequences of oil spills on the local environment from a potential spill source,
it could not be ruled out that the parent company would be expected to take an interest in
preventing spills. But I think that's the most interesting aspect of this decision.
It added, the more so if a company has made the prevention of environmental damage a priority.
activities of the group companies, a spare head, and is to a certain degree actively involved in and
managing the business operations of the companies. So here it's particularly interesting
to see how the voluntary commitments adopted by Shell are used against them, and the parent
The company's duty of diligence is somewhat enhanced by this commitment to corporate social responsibility.
voluntarily adopted by the parent company. The Court of Appeal then went on to ask a number
of questions that should be taken into consideration when deciding on the substantive
case, looking at the standards expected from the parent company in the monitoring of the
subsidiary. And what we see in this different test is a very high threshold that is expected
from the parent company. And the Court concluded that it could not be ruled out that
the parent company could not be held liable for damages resulting from the conduct of its subsidiary,
and that the claims against the parent company and the Nigerian subsidiary were closely connected
and therefore should be heard together. So here we see a similar decision, but the one that
was taken in the Vedanta case in the UK. It is, however, in sharp contrast with the English case.
on Shell, so on the same facts, but this is a case brought by over 42,000 Nigerian citizens
against Shell for the environmental damage caused by the oil spill, and that was brought
in the UK. Now in that case, in the UK case, the High Court had considered that the parent
the company did not owe a duty to a guilty claimant. In particular, Justice Fraser found that the
freefall test established in the Caparo case, particularly in relation to foreseeability
proximity and reasonableness was simply not satisfied. That the relationship between the
Ultimate, what they refer to as the ultimate holding company and the claimants was simply not close.
one, and that the subsidiary, the parent company was not better positioned than the subsidiary in
with regard to the harm they caused, and therefore it was unfair to infer that, because of that future,
The subsidiary would depend on the parent company to avoid the harm.
So on the 14th of February 2018, so very recently, the Court of Appeal rejected the claimant's
appeal in that case in the UK, with the majority opinion stating that the claim against the parent
The company was bound to fail, and it was simply not arguable that the parent company owed them.
a duty of care. So the same reasoning, the same conclusion as the one that
Justice Fraser had reached a different conclusion here, through alternative reasoning, which Amnesty International
warned that it was potentially setting a very dangerous precedent, inviting the UK
based corporations to have free rein to abuse human rights overseas. It also completely
denied the economic reality of the unity of the various entities of multinational corporations
corporations by just focusing and strictly adhering to the separation of the legal
personality principles, and in my opinion, perhaps even more importantly, it negates
The regulatory functions of European courts as courts of the home state forum.
Now I'm running out of time, so I'll just briefly mention it, since I brought it up earlier.
There are two initiatives: the case law initiatives and the legislative initiatives.
to reinforce, to make human rights due diligence mandatory, and this is just, I wanted to briefly
mention the French law on the duty of diligence, which requires large French multinational companies to exercise due diligence in order to prevent serious adverse impacts on human rights and the environment.
corporations to establish, make public, and implement a vigilance plan in order to
Identify risks and prevent serious harms to human rights and the environment.
And this is a very interesting law because it imposes these due diligence responsibilities.
to the parent company, not only in relation to their subsidiaries but also in relation
to their suppliers and they must, in order to ensure that they adhere to responsible
business standards wherever they operate.
So what we've been observing through this case law I presented and through this legislation,
I just mentioned the French one, but there is a similar Swiss initiative underway as well.
the moment, is a shift from soft law to hard law in order to make human rights due diligence
More meaningful and enhanced corporate accountability.
Thank you very much.
