Pyramid security did not stop with giant stone plugs and vertical portcullis slabs. Over time, Egyptian engineers experimented with increasingly clever ways to seal royal burial chambers, and by the Middle Kingdom some of those systems became far stranger than the famous granite blocks of the Great Pyramid.
In this video, I look at a series of obscure and often forgotten Middle Kingdom pyramids, including Hawara, Southern South Saqqara, the Mazghuna pyramids, Khendjer’s pyramid, and the “Lost Pyramid” at Dahshur, to understand how their horizontal and nearly horizontal portcullis systems may have worked.
Unlike earlier vertical portcullises, these later systems appear to have used massive stone blocks sliding across or down shallow ramps, sometimes weighing around 20 tons or more. The big question is not simply how they were closed, but whether they were designed as one-way locks: mechanisms that could be activated during burial and then made almost impossible to reverse.
Ancient Egyptian engineers transitioned from simple vertical portcullises to sophisticated horizontal locking systems during the Middle Kingdom. By utilizing massive quartzite slabs, slide-and-socket mechanisms, and potential one-way locking pins, they aimed to create impassable barriers to protect royal tombs from robbers.
When it came to pyramid security, the ancient Egyptian engineers took their jobs very seriously.
They often used a combination of trickery and sheer mass to try and prevent robbery.
The Bent Pyramid's portcullis was very heavy and opened diagonally,
but as it was of softer limestone, it was eventually cut through.
Others, like the Great Pyramid, had multiple portcullis slabs that opened vertically
and relied on their hard granite and heavy weight in a tight space for security.
A vertical portcullis with one, two, or three granite slabs secured in grooves
was common among Old Kingdom pyramids, but they too had a fatal flaw.
Take a look at this portcullis and think about how you would close it in a controlled manner.
You could just prop some wood under it and then yank the rope,
but then the slab would smash down very hard and risk fracturing itself.
Multiple sets of levers placed on either side of the lower lip could,
with enough men embracing, slowly shift the weight down from one to the other
and soften the landing. This is only possible with slabs of a manageable weight,
and if men can lever a slab down, then men can also lever a slab up and get back inside.
Having three slabs in series just meant the levering and propping had to be repeated several
times. Although none of the slabs remain of the Great Pyramid's portcullis, we have enough
information to estimate its approximate dimensions and weight. If made out of red
granite like the rest of the Alco, we would expect to see a weight of between 2.3 and 2.6 metric
tons. Heavy for sure, but completely within the realm of possibility when lowering the slab by
hand using some sort of lever. Time and again, variations of the vertical portcullis were tried
in various pyramids, and as far as I can tell, none of them ever fully stopped anyone from
breaking back in. They all suffered from what I see as the core problem. That is, if the portcullis
was light enough to be lowered into place, it was also light enough to be levered back up.
This problem was no doubt front and center in the minds of Middle Kingdom engineers,
who put all their numerous brain cells into a new method of locking a pyramid.
Here is the basic problem they needed to solve. Fully diagonal and vertical portcullis designs
had already been tried and all failed, because, in addition to the aforementioned problems,
there was not an easy way to make the process of closing the portcullis a one-way motion.
I can think of a few ways in which a horizontal portcullis could be locked from the inside during
closing, but it does not appear the ancient Egyptians did as well. Their solution to this
problem was to turn the portcullis on its side, and make the mechanism close at a horizontal or
nearly horizontal angle, but nothing as steep as what was seen at the Bent Pyramid.
One fully horizontal portcullis block at the Huara Pyramid was estimated by Flinders-Petrie
to weigh a staggering 22 tons. The nearly and fully horizontal design was implemented in at
least six fairly obscure and forgotten Middle Kingdom pyramids, with slight variations between
them. Some of these have been left alone to fill with desert sand for nigh on 80 years,
without fresh investigations or updates. These pyramids are the Huara Pyramid,
the Southern South Saqqara Pyramid, or SSSP, the two Ameni Pyramids at Dahshur,
the North and South Mezguna Pyramids, and the Pyramid of Khenjer. Today's video will explore
the new and improved security features displayed in these later portcullis systems, and attempt to
solve a few new problems encountered along the way. Because information is so incredibly hard
to find on these pyramids, I needed a bit of help. For the Pyramid of Khenjer, I must thank
Keith Hamilton and his archival research. I will barely scratch the surface of the information
provided in his guide to this complex and interesting location. His full guide is linked
in the description. For the Lost Pyramid at Dahshur, I couldn't have made this video without
the help of Jeffrey Drum and the Aceta Project. Drum is one of the few people who has actually
explored the Lost Pyramid of Dahshur in person, and he kindly gave me permission to use his photos
in this video. Both the Lost Pyramid and the Pyramid of Khenjer have suffered violence.
The entire superstructure at both sites has been torn down to the ground. Much of the
underground layout is intact, but due to missing parts of the portcullis housing, we will have to
do a bit of detective work when reconstructing it. I would like to start by showing a comparison
between all the pyramid portcullises mentioned today, and the subtle changes and improvements
we see going from Hawara to the others. Hawara is the only one of these pyramids with its
portcullis slabs all fully horizontal. In this drawing from Flinders Petrie's book on Hawara,
we see these three blocks, which Petrie calls trap doors, instead of portcullis slabs. Due to
their position in their housing, the slabs cover the opening to the next chamber from above. In
other words, a robber approaching each slab would, if embodied with superhuman strength,
go under the trap door and open the passage by pushing the slab up and over to one side.
This is of course not physically possible to do, but this is why the term trap door instead
of portcullis was used here. All the trap doors had grooves around their side, which Petrie
believed would help drag them with ropes. This seems a very impractical pulling angle to use,
and Petrie isn't specific about which side the grooves are on. If they are on the bottom,
as we will see in later portcullis housing examples, then I have a few ideas which would
make more sense than rope guides. Unfortunately, even at Petrie's time, groundwater was seeping
into the pyramid, preventing a full view of the lowest chambers. And today the matter is even
worse, with water, mud, and trash stopping entry above the portcullis blocks. The view of this
pyramid today is just abysmal, and underscores the need for upkeep and continual maintenance
at these World Heritage sites. The issue with having a portcullis completely flat and reliant
on weight is twofold. If it's hard for the robber to open, it's also hard for the engineers to
originally close it. The same tight space and tool access constraint impacts both activities.
This is perhaps one reason why all effort in Hawara was focused on closing just the first slab.
In any case, as the housing around the slab was not made of hard stone such as granite or quartzite,
it was tunneled past. It is the same lesson being shown to us again and again. If the blocking plug
or portcullis is housed in a weaker stone, that stone will be attacked and not the portcullis
or plug itself. As granite is far harder to work than limestone, this greatly increased the effort
of building. The next set of pyramids updated the portcullis design. The dates and attribution for
these Middle Kingdom pyramids is quite shaky, which makes what I am about to say a tentative claim.
If Hawara was indeed chronologically first, then the lessons taught of the problems with a fully
flat slab were certainly learned and acted upon in later pyramids. The two pyramids at Mazguna
have portcullis slabs set at a slight angle. Nothing as drastic as the Bent Pyramids portcullis,
but certainly not flat. The southern South Saqqara pyramid has basically identical portcullises of
quartzite held in housings of limestone. If we look at some of the excavation drawings of Mazguna
and South Saqqara, compared with Hawara, we will see a marked improvement in security.
At Hawara, there are both space and wiggle room above the slab between the top of the slab and
its housing, and when the slab was shut, its movement created room at the back of the slab.
Enough force applied upwards and backwards would allow the slab to be moved. Look at what happens
with Mazguna and South Saqqara. As the portcullis is being closed, it is supported on its journey
across the passage by a slide and thus seats itself into a socket on the opposite side.
Hawara does not have this socket. With the updated design, the closed portcullis can only be moved
in a single direction, back in the direction it came from. Putting a lever underneath would simply
force it against the top of the socket. If we zoom in on the drawings we have for South Saqqara,
we will see some faint lines under the portcullis. While not mentioned in the text,
the diagram identifies this as a temporary support hub. As we will see when we get to
the next pyramids, this to me is a suspicious conclusion. The portcullis was already propped
open by beams across the passage, the cement rings of which can still be seen. A stacked
stone or beam in this position would do little to stop a portcullis slab that wanted to close
of its own accord, being liable to being simply pushed to the side. As there are several other
errors in the drawings of this book, it is worth at least investigating the possibility that the
temporary supports mentioned here are the same security features seen later in the New Pyramid
Dahshur and at the Pyramid of Khenjer. To wrap up the Southern South Saqqara portcullis, please note
the grooves in the bed or slide under the portcullis. I will use these terms interchangeably.
On portcullis 1 and 3, we will see a single groove mainly on the slide, and on portcullis 2,
on both sides of the socket. Remember these and keep an eye out for them when we get to the next
pyramids we will focus on for the remainder of the video, the New Pyramid found in 2017 at Dahshur
and the Pyramid of Khenjer in Saqqara. Here we have one of the main structural drawings of this pyramid,
and indeed not much else has been published. The accompanying text describing the portcullis
is not very robust and does not give dimensions for the block. The first thing I did was to use
a photo editing tool to move the scale here in the corner of the blueprint and use it like a
measuring stick. It is of course not terribly accurate, but it's the best I've got. Using this method,
it looks like the quartzite portcullis block is roughly 2.6 meters long, 1.45 meters high,
and 1.95 meters wide. Based on these measurements, we can calculate an approximate weight of 20.2
metric tons or 44,000 pounds. Such a block, propped as it was at only a 9 degree dry slope,
would probably be in no danger of slipping down on its own. Even so, it would be best practice
to prop it with a beam here until it was time to close it. The author of the main book on Khenjer
excavations, Gustave Jacquier, believed the portcullis was held in place by a beam placed
into this small socket in the slide. He stated that the beam, resting on sand, would hold the
portcullis until the sand was drained, lowering the beam, and then allowing the portcullis to
slide down. If you have watched any of my previous videos, you will know I'm pretty enthusiastic on
sand drains in general, but here I just cannot take the bait. First, the pocket doesn't seem
deep enough for both sand and a beam. Depending on the depth of the sand in the pocket, we would
need to have a beam that was at least short enough to clear the portcullis when descended.
The sand could only fill the pocket a maximum of halfway so that the beam length could clear the
portcullis once it had descended into the pocket. Further, if the beam was in fact holding back some
20 tons of stone, removing the sand below would not trigger a slow and even descent of the beam.
No, the beam would stay put and be mightily pinched between the socket and the portcullis.
The portcullis would have to be pushed up the slope in order to free the beam,
rendering it absolutely pointless. In other words, if the beam is holding back the plug,
it would be pinched. If the beam is pinched, it's not going to send when the sand is drained from
beneath it. Lastly, the drawings show no drain or exit plug where the sand could trickle out
of the pocket. In this case, the supposed sand drain would be an unnecessary and overly complicated
solution to a problem that really doesn't exist. I credit Keith Hamilton for this idea, which is
far more mechanically sound, and one that comes from looking at a nearly identical portcullis
housing, that of the so-called Lost Pyramid of Dashur I mentioned previously. What we lack in
data and measurements, we gain in pictures, both from a Smithsonian Museum clip documenting this
discovery and opening, and by Jeffrey Drum. Here we see the slope bed of stone that once held the
massive portcullis block. The slide crosses the passageway to keep the block from tipping downwards
and being fully unsupported as it is being closed. On either side of the slide are grooves, parallel
at the lower end and angling away from each other at the top. This is, I believe, one of the most
clever parts of these portcullises. The excavation report at Kenger mentions this style of groove as
well, but due to the plug covering much of them, it does not look like Jacquier knew that they
diverged from parallel at the back. Even so, he believed they originally contained wood to aid in
the closure. Between these two pyramids, we have, in a weird way, two halves of a puzzle. We have the
pictures of the Lost Pyramid, but no excavation notes or text. At Kenger, pictures are scant,
but we do have diagrams and explorer descriptions. The portcullis was intact at Kenger, but missing
at the Lost Pyramid. So, by blending the scene of one and the unseen of the other, we can tentatively
build the most complete picture possible of what these portcullises would have looked like, given
our limited information. The Lost Pyramid also shows us the square socket in the slide that
Jacquier believed held the wooden temporary post holding back the portcullis. It doesn't look like
maybe a foot by foot square, and perhaps the same deep, and seeing it only solidifies in my mind
this is not for a support post. Any post placed in this socket would have to be as large as the
socket in order to be useful. A thinner beam would just cant over to one side, and be pinched even
more. I can't say a 12 inch square beam is impossible, but for all the reasons previously
mentioned, it does not seem likely. What does seem more reasonable would be the solution Keith
Hamilton proposed. He noted that this block sits casually next to the socket, and based on its shape
and dimensions, mused that it looked just about right as a locking pin for the portcullis. Here is
how that would work. On the underside of the portcullis, a socket the same length and width
to the one on the slide would hold a stone plug. The stone plug would be required to fit flush
within the portcullis while it was in its uppermost open position. It would not be seen from the
outside. When the portcullis was slid down the ramp, the block would fall into the socket below,
and be impossible to remove without cutting it out. The lower socket would have to be more shallow
than the upper socket, allowing the dropping plug to remain partially in the portcullis,
and partially in the ramp. Absolutely no one who wasn't involved in the pyramid's construction
would know it was there. Now what does this mean about the placement of the socket in the underside
of the portcullis? Obviously, I can't say for sure there is a socket there, and no one has taken one
of these 20 ton portcullis stones and flipped it over to check. We can, however, use the diagram
edited to show the closed position to pinpoint its location on the portcullis fairly closely.
If I simply select the portcullis and move it in Photoshop to its closed position,
you will see the proposed socket would need to be just rear of the middle in order to be placed over
the ramp socket. I know this is a fairly inaccurate way to measure, but I increased the size of the
scale ruler from the full diagram until it was the same ratio as the zoomed in portcullis,
and placed it, blurry and all, over the closed portcullis. It is a bit hard to see, but the
socket on the underside, if it exists, would only be about one meter under the block from the front.
Now let us put our basic engineering knowledge to work here, and consider what problem we would
encounter when attempting to make this hypothesized locking bolt work. As we are missing the top and
sides of the portcullis housing for which we have pictures of at the Lost Pyramid, and at
Tenger the data is incomplete, we do not know how snugly the portcullis sat in its housing from right
to left. Presumably, you want it somewhat close, but not so tight that the levering action, which
must have been used to inch it shut, would cause side to side pinching. You also don't want the
housing too much larger than the portcullis on the sides, because then the portcullis could get
off-centered, and the locking block would not drop into the socket. You need a simple method of
forcing a right and left alignment with precision, without pinching the block at its sides. We know
from the grooves at the top of the stairs here, that other stones used in closure and plugging
ran on alignment grooves, so why not here as well? We saw some hints of grooves in the drawings of
the earlier mentioned portcullises, which makes this seem like a standard practice for the nearly
horizontal closure method. There are two ways in which these grooves could have been used,
and I will tell you which one I am betting on, and why. First, and least likely, would be a
protrusion of stone, of varying length, milled onto the bottom of the portcullis to stand proud
of its bottom surface. I agree the ancient Egyptians were master stonemasons, but even
for them, getting the two aligned correctly, and the rest of the surface flattened around
them would be a nightmare, both for installation, where they would be in the way, and probably
smashed off, and for the simple problem of cutting the protrusions in relief. I prefer to think,
and this is my educated guess, that in this situation, grooves were cut into the portcullis
slide, and matching ones were cut intaglio into the underside of the portcullis block.
When placed together, the two matching sets of grooves would leave a negative space between them.
A simple wooden beam could be slid in between the portcullis and the bed, and just like that,
the two were aligned. A beam inserted into this negative space gives us a very elegant solution
to the strange divergence of the grooves at the back, as seen at the lost pyramid. This introduces
what I think is the most fun part of the video, where we get to think very cleverly about why
you'd want rails that widen at the back, and how that would fit into the overall mechanism of the
portcullis. We will have to make some plausible speculation based on a bit of deductive reasoning.
There are many ways in which this could have been done, and what I am about to propose here
is not fact, but just some of those ways. The whole idea of making a portcullis like this one,
with a locking plug, is to make a one-way action that once closed, does not open again.
It has been suggested that many of the pyramid robberies were done by the very teams of workers
who built the monuments. In that case, they would know the exact location of the locking pin,
and how close it was to the front of the block here. A few minutes work in the right location
would be all that was necessary to break through and remove it, freeing the portcullis. So, I think
a secondary lock was used, one behind the portcullis, that all the workers would see activated,
and know there really wasn't any getting around. If we concede that the portcullis block probably
slid down rails as it was closing, imagine what would happen if those rails underneath the block
were forced backwards beyond the back of the portcullis. They would slide into and encounter
this bend and bind on both sides. Thinking about the rails sliding backward up the groove and
pinching gave me the idea that has kept my mind churning day and night trying to work out all the
particulars of how that would work and be basically impossible to defeat without fully taking the
pyramid apart, which is what happened in the end. The main issue with placing any sort of prop
behind the portcullis is that once the portcullis starts to close, the distance behind it increases.
Even if the portcullis starts right flush with the back of the wall, once it is closed, there is now
a gap between it and the wall of an undetermined size. The only way to remedy this would be to
somehow get a beam wedge behind it, something nearly impossible to do using just the groove
in the rail. If you think about this problem hard enough, in deep technical detail, considering
every challenge raised by every apparent solution, the complexity of the situation will soon become
evident. The changing size of the gap means you really only have a couple options, at least in my
opinion. You could very clumsily prop a beam up behind and hope it falls right and bounces into
the groove at the back, but that has a very low chance of success. You could also argue that
perhaps the rail hole at the back of the portcullis was shaped like a half moon, and then a half moon
beam was threaded through and then somehow rotated 180 degrees with a long key so that it wouldn't
fit back again through the hole, but that seems too unsatisfactory and complicated. This is what
I landed on and what I think makes the most sense, but as I'm not omniscient, I will freely say this
is just the result of my having eliminated dozens of other options that do not work at all. Consider
this. If the rail was a square one, continuous from the edge of the slide through the curve of
the back and made of wood, either carved or bent with hot water, and then encased in stone over the
curve section, that sort of rail would not be possible to pull out again from underneath the
portcullis. The engineers would make one, maybe two, hinged and spring-loaded triggers made of bronze or
set into the beam, the lowest being exactly where the back of the portcullis face would be
when at its fully closed position. Normally held flat by the way of the portcullis,
when the portcullis cleared them, they would pop open due to pressure from a simple leaf spring.
If the triggers were stout and well made, they could easily stop the portcullis block
from ever being levered back up the way in which it had descended. You also couldn't pull the rails
out, both because of the trigger and because they were stuck around the bend in the groove.
At this point you may ask yourself, but is there any actual evidence the ancient Egyptians of this
era, the middle kingdom, had knowledge of leaf springs? Well in fact we know that they did.
In the book, Tools and Weapons of Ancient Egypt by Flinders Petrie, we see several very interesting
lists of common household tools found in Egypt, including as old as the first dynasty. We see
here images of extremely old tweezers and shears that operated on a simple bit of springy metal.
The shear's design struck me instantly as being identical to some of the clippers we had for our
sheep on my family farm. The design is timeless and perfected thousands of years ago. This tells
me that if the idea of springy metal was known by the first dynasty at the earliest, by the
middle kingdom it was undoubtedly ubiquitous. Now does this mean I can confidently say this
is for sure what was used to lock the portcullis open? Absolutely not, but it is a starting point
from which we can move looking for more evidence at similar sites with horizontal portcullises.
The Egyptians were absolutely masters of clever one-way locks and tine mechanisms,
so maybe they came up with something else even more simple and elegant. I welcome everyone who
watched this far to take the same set of facts and try and see if you can come up with a better
explanation or invalidate mine. Any proposed hypothesis should take into account the overall
mechanism of the portcullis, explain how to place a proper stop behind the portcullis that exactly
fits the space as the portcullis opens, that is it can't be cut to size and placed first when the
portcullis is open. Any theory also needs to include one-way activation initiated at the
time the portcullis closes and out of reach of the workers so that even if they knew about it
they could not undo it. What we are seeing here in these forgotten middle kingdom portcullises
is the increased emphasis on closing and locking mechanisms of the pyramids and not as much on the
massive and finely wrought outer surface construction that dominated the first wave
of pyramid madness in the old kingdom. But the problem with this is that if you make your lock
extremely good but the housing of a poorer quality the thief may not even bother picking the lock
it may simply opt to take the roof off to get inside. This is what appears to have ultimately
happened here. These smaller and weaker pyramids with more complicated locks were ultimately
demolished, torn down, and left for the sand to swallow. And swallow it does. What the sand covers
is eventually forgotten. For me I find these forgotten and mostly destroyed pyramids are
more interesting than the famous ones in many ways. This may be partly out of a contrarian notion to
focus on that which few do and partly because as you can see in this video if you are truly
obsessed with understanding ancient mechanical and structural engineering as I am these middle
kingdom monuments are bursting with mysteries to solve. I appreciate you watching my video and
please do go read the link Keith Hamilton guides these forgotten pyramids. They are listed in the
description. Thank you for watching.