Hartford Disability Insurance Company (Ep. 5, part 1/2)

Disability Insurance
6 followers
12 Video Views·Sep 3, 2026
Disability insurance attorneys Gregory Dell, Stephen Jessup and Cesar Gavidia discuss the notorious claims handling actions of Hartford.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video features legal experts discussing the business practices of the Hartford Disability Insurance Company. They highlight the company's massive financial scale and argue that its profit-driven nature often leads to the unfair denial of long-term disability claims through biased medical reviews and the dismissal of objective evidence.
Welcome to another edition of Disability Insurance Law TV.
My name is Gregory Dell and today I'm with Attorney Steven Jessup and Cesar Gavidia.
And today we are going to discuss the Hartford Disability Insurance Company.
Each week we do these videos and we discuss different issues related to disability and
long-term disability insurance and we discuss different disability insurance companies.
Hartford Disability Insurance Company, if you're watching this video, you're probably
aware is one of the world's largest disability insurance carriers.
And prior to today's video, I did some further research to see the size of the company so
that you can have an understanding as to what you're up against when you deal with the Hartford
Insurance Company.
So according to their recent numbers, and this financial information comes straight
from their website, which obviously any of you can go to, their 2009 revenues were $24.7
billion and their most recent profits for the first quarter were $319 million.
So you're dealing with an extremely powerful company.
They don't just do long-term disability insurance, they also have a variety of other products,
but with regard to their group long-term disability and short-term disability, in 2009 they had
revenues of $1,975,000,000 and they had a profit in their group long-term disability
insurance division of $193 million.
So again, this is a massive company.
They are in business to make money and they're definitely not in business to pay you your
long-term disability claims if they don't have to.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that they don't pay people because they do, but they're
going to do everything that they can do to find a reason not to pay you.
So we're going to discuss some things about Hartford today that would be relevant possibly
to your future claim and obviously if you're watching this video, you have some kind of
interest in Hartford, whether you're considering a policy with them or you have a claim and
at any time if you need assistance, feel free to call us and we'll answer any of your questions.
First issue we want to talk about is what types of doctors does Hartford work with when
they're evaluating a claim?
And I think, Cesar, you did some research on that and you can talk to some of our viewers
about that.
Sure.
Well, Greg, as you and Steve know, it's not unusual that Hartford will often go back to
the same doctors they've used time and time again and that they've paid perhaps thousands
upon thousands of dollars to do their peer reviews and their independent medical examinations.
And in this case, out of the U.S. District Court in New York, a case against Hartford,
Hartford tried to what's called move for summary judgment and essentially what that is is when
and so it's a tool insurance companies use very often to try to get the case knocked
out or a verdict in their favor before it ever goes to trial.
And they tried to do this, the federal judge in this particular case denied Hartford's
motion for summary judgment and the reason was at least what comes across and what's
highlighted here is that there was a serious conflict, the judge had a serious conflict
with Hartford and the doctors that they employed to do a review of this particular lady's disability
claim.
And citing from the case, the judge, Judge Lewis Kaplan said, plaintiff has raised more
than a suggestion that defendant may have been influenced by a conflict in selecting
doctors to review the plaintiff's medical records and in processing her claim.
First defendant obtained the services of Doctors Siegel and Doctors Garrido Castillo through
the University Disability Consortium, UDC, and this is a company that they'll use, a
third party independent physician group that they'll use to look at and review disability
claims.
And this judge found that in 2006, UDC derived nearly three quarters, 75% of its revenues
from Hartford.
So, I mean, that's a great majority of their income.
So this is an independent company that Hartford hired and then they generated 75% of their
money just from Hartford?
That's right.
And they call that independent.
Okay.
And they go on to say, UDC and the doctors it provides, therefore arguably have a financial
incentive to provide defendant with reports supporting denial of benefits.
Second defendant's selection of Dr. Richard Levy, who was a doctor for another group that
Hartford used, medical advisory group, Dr. Richard Levy to review plaintiff's records
is a matter of concern due to Dr. Levy's professed doubts regarding the existence of chronic
fatigue syndrome, the basis of plaintiff's disability claim.
So they send this woman to a doctor who has a bias against the very condition that she's
claiming disability from.
He fails to believe that it even exists and that's who they send her to for an independent
review.
Okay.
Now that's just one case.
How often do you see that Hartford goes back to the same doctor that they've used on other
cases?
It happens a lot.
In just doing my research for this case, I came up with 45 different cases where Hartford
used UDC, this third party group, to do their claim evaluation, their independent review.
All right, Steve, let me ask you a little bit about how do you see that Hartford takes
into consideration the information that is sent in by claimants treating physicians?
You know, I would have to say a lot of times, you know, in what I handle and what I see
and looking through some cases, it's not really that much.
They take it into consideration only in the sense that they still claim that there may
not be enough objective evidence.
I pulled a case that came out of Louisiana at the end of last year where it was a lawyer,
big time lawyer, had a claim, problem with cervical lumbar spine, tons of MRIs, CAT scan
showed it, radiculopathy with his nerve conduction.
He files his claim based on a physical ailment.
And they come back and they say, well, you were treating with your psychiatrist, so this
is going to be a mental health claim.
There's not enough objective evidence to support the fact that you have these physical limitations.
And it was their effort to try to basically get him into a two-year maximum under the
policy and then deny his benefits going forward from there.
And in this case-
Let me just interrupt you one second.
You said that Hartford said there's not enough objective evidence.
How often do you see that comment in a Hartford denial?
I'd have to say any time you're saying that you're in pain, they're going to say there's
not enough objective evidence.
The court, in going through the actual case, they pointed over to 30 instances where it
was either testing, MRIs, surgeries, and then all of the other findings of these, you know,
the various MRIs of degenerative disc disease and said, how can you say there's no objective
evidence?
But what Hartford would do is they would send it to one of their peer reviewers, someone
who doesn't even see the insured.
One doctor out of three only ever called one of his doctors once to get clarification,
and it was his mental health doctor.
None of his orthopedic doctors, no one that was with the physical side of it.
And what we have here, the medical reviewers, the doctors hired by Hartford are saying,
oh, it's subjective complaints, there's not enough objective evidence to be able to support
his subjective complaints.
He goes through three separate appeals, denied each time.
Social Security found that he was disabled, you know, for the physical ailments, not on
the mental health side.
And it wasn't until he finally went into a lawsuit, and we're talking, the first now
came down in 2005.
This case didn't get resolved until 2009 in court, and it was at that point that the judge
finally basically shook his head and said, what are you guys looking at?
I mean, how can you honestly sit here and say that there is an evidence of this?
You know, and this is a case, too, where it's not often that you see attorneys' award, fees
awards paid out in ERISA claims.
You have to, you know, make a claim for them.
And the judge pretty simply went through it and just set him up and set it down and, you
know, made Hartford pay all the attorneys' fees on the insured as well.
