If advanced civilizations exist in the universe, why haven’t they reached out to us? That’s the basic premise behind “The Fermi Paradox.” Theoretical physicist Avi Loeb joins “Jesse Weber Live” to discuss some possibilities. “We’re really ignorant about most of the constituents in the universe, including technologies well beyond what we have,” he says.
This video explores the Fermi Paradox—the contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial civilizations and the lack of contact. Featuring Harvard Professor Avi Loeb, the discussion examines various theories on why aliens remain elusive and discusses the U.S. government's observations of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAPs) as potential evidence of advanced technology.
It's a big universe out there, some scientists say infinitely large, so with so much possibility,
why haven't any of our neighbors said hi yet? By neighbors I of course mean extraterrestrials,
right? The fact that none of them have decided to introduce themselves, very rude at least to
our knowledge. This is something that has puzzled scientists since the 1950s. I'm talking about
Nobel winner Enrico Fermi, one of the fathers of the atomic bomb, realized that given the number
of possible planets and given the probability of those planets developing intelligent life,
he theorized that Earth should have been visited by aliens with advanced technology, not once,
but several times over. So this gap between the likelihood of advanced alien civilizations
existing and the fact that we haven't been contacted yet is what's now called Fermi's
paradox. And there have been several theory solutions as to this paradox. One says that
aliens are talking, we just don't have the proper technology to hear them. For example,
they could be using gravitational waves. There's also the theory that other civilizations may be
too young to have the ability to travel or communicate between the stars, that some of them
are advanced enough that they may have been stripped of their interstellar capabilities
by war or disaster. What about all the footage of UFOs or UAPs as they're also called? We've
shown them right here on the show. Well, another theory suggests that maybe because we're in this
interstellar zoo, all these UFOs are just aliens on sort of some sort of space safari, they're
not communicating. So there's a few of the proposed solutions. There are a lot of them.
Who better to help us find the science fact and the science fiction than the Frank B. Baird,
junior professor of science at Harvard University and leader of the UAP Science Advisory Council.
Avi Loeb. Avi, good to see you. Which theory do you like?
Thanks for having me. The theory I like the most is the answer to Enrico Fermi's question is,
where is everybody? They are here. It's just that we haven't realized that. And the reason is
obvious. You know, we had only one century of modern science since the discovery of quantum
mechanics. Most stars are billions of years older than the sun. They had plenty of time to develop
technology science well beyond our understanding. We recognize that 95 percent of the mass budget
of the universe is unknown to us. And we're really ignorant about most of the constituents
in the universe, including technologies well beyond what we have. And just imagine a cave
dweller finding a cell phone. The cave dweller would look at the cell phone and say, well,
that's a rock of a type that I've never seen before. So we have a lot to learn. We should be
humble and we should be looking out to find the evidence. And guess what? The U.S. government
is telling us they see things they don't understand. In fact, on Monday, August 31st,
I had the first meeting of the council that I'm leading, the UAP Science Advisory Council
at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. And I can tell you, first of all,
the government has things they don't understand. Secondly, they are very interesting in figuring
them out. And it's not obvious at all, based on what they know, that we are dealing with human
made technologies. OK, so let me ask you this. Is there a plan in place to try to communicate
with these things? Or we we know that there's a communication system. We just don't have the
ability to know what that is or appreciate it. We don't have the technology. Well, it's work
in progress. We imagine things that we are doing right now, like it started with radio communication
back in 1960. Until now, SETI observers were trying to find radio communication signals.
They did not see any. I just wrote a paper that is posted these days that, in fact, if they have
something far more ambitious than Elon Musk's vision of going from Earth to Mars, if they have
a whole cargo transport system between habitable planets within their planetary system, we might
see flashes of light from the beamer of this light sail technology that we can imagine. We don't
have that as of yet, but they may. Of course, they can use for transportation what is called
a warp drive. That's a distortion of space time that allows you to carry a cargo at an arbitrary
speed across interstellar distances. And I just wrote a paper a couple of weeks ago with my
colleague Sean Fell, where we showed that if such a thing passes through the atmosphere,
it would cause a disturbance, would produce a fireball or some glowing ball of air. And in fact,
there is a report from the U.S. government about orbs. These are mysterious glowing
spheres that they appear to be seeing. The FBI is reporting, other agencies are reporting, and
it's not at all clear what these orbs are. Some of them are definitely not
drones. Some might be drones, but some are definitely not. And so it's a detective story
for us to figure out what technology might be employed if these orbs came from outer space.
I would argue we should look at it as a way for us to learn about new technologies,
rather than the way that the experts behave as if, you know, we already know most of physics,
and therefore we don't see anything obvious. Well, listen, if this interstellar level of
transport and delivery is a real thing, forget Amazon. Forget Amazon. Move over Amazon. You
can't compete with that. All right. Avi Loeb, conversation for another day. Great work,
by the way. Thanks. Keep it up. I'm so happy the government has you. It's really good stuff
you're doing. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me. Now, by the way, this was also the
topic of my hot take live stream today. It's on the NewsNation YouTube. So many people join. A lot
of theories, a lot of questions, a lot of great comments about, hey, are we the seed of wealthy
alien investors? That was a new one. You can find that on the NewsNation YouTube page. You can scan
the QR code that you see right there as well.
News for all Americans.