Flock cameras: Public safety tool or privacy concern? Pt. 2

Fox - 32 Chicago
8 followers
12 Video Views·Sep 2, 2026
Welcome back. We're continuing our conversation about these controversial
flock cameras with Michael Verdon. He's a former Secret Service agent,
security expert, and Ed Yonka with the Illinois ACLU. And we want to pick up this discussion
about who has access to this data, because we've reported that there are certain officers,
bad apples, that are logging in and essentially stalking citizens with this technology.
Yeah, so to answer that question, I'll go based on my own experience. When I,
as a federal agent, I would run license plates. But to run a license plate,
you have to have a case number, and not just a case number. You're gonna be asked by a supervisor,
and this is applicable to a police department, back to very tight access.
Not every officer can run this. When we see these misuses of the flock data, I question the control,
like who has access to the database. But back to my experience, I have to have an open case number,
and why do you want to run this license plate? Also, it's an audit trail. So if there is misuse,
there could be potential consequences. And I don't know what, it's kind of gone off the rails
on some of these police departments, and they got to get it back on track.
So how do you get it back on track? I mean, we're talking about accountability.
Accountability, and I'll be candid. I would look at administrative leave,
termination for that police officer, potential prosecution. In my opinion,
to run a plate a thousand times, that's stalking, intimidation, and harassment,
and that's a criminal act.
Would that be a level of accountability that folks at the ACLU would be comfortable with?
I think that is an important level of accountability and a clear place to start.
And I think to pick up on Michael, recently, one of the vendors, Flock, and we should say,
there's more than Flock. We often talk about this as being Flock, but there are other vendors for
this, has said, we're gonna make sure that it can only be searched with a case number.
That's a good start, but that's a lot of what we heard when these cameras
were installed in a lot of places. And I think Flock having a policy about
requiring a case number is not the same as police supervisors being able to manage and
measure that at the local level. And now we've had the internet around
for long enough where I think people are getting wise to the idea of data,
companies having our data, and municipalities having our data.
So does the public, do you think, have enough information about
where the data goes once it's in these systems? Michael, I'll start with you.
Yeah, and so it's a valid concern, absolutely. So that's why I default to what the contracts
are with Flock, with these other organizations. It's a 30-day retention period unless there's
a criminal case and it's being used. That's the exception. But also by contract,
they cannot sell this information, valid concern, to a third party. So I can only go based on,
and Flock has been sued in court, by the way. My research, I looked at all the different lawsuits,
there is a plethora of current lawsuits. But prior to that, they have not lost in court.
I'm talking about Flock, talking about Flock. But that's how I'd answer that question.
The contract says 30 days and it can't share with a third party.
We should remember that it's 30 days unless there's a search,
then they can extend that out. And remember that agencies often have interagency agreements
with other law enforcement departments. And if your law enforcement agency has a very strict
privacy policy, but you're sharing it with an agency that doesn't, your policy just became
theirs. And I think that's part of the reason that you're seeing this concern.
Look, I think here's the thing. Post 9-11, we built up a surveillance society that people
just accepted and said, we're gonna do this cuz we wanna be safe. This is the first time I've seen
in 25 years that people are pushing back. And I think it has to do with Americans do not like
being monitored in their cars. There is something so-
We were gonna have to end the debate right there cuz we're out of time, but-
Thank you.
It's this kind of dialogue that's gonna lead to the all important 50 yard line on this. Okay,
we're back with our nine o'clock hour of Good Day Chicago.
