He Looks GOOD... But CONCERNING
1 Video ViewยทSep 2, 2026
He is on the way back, but there might be a huge problem that no one wants to talk about.
But he is looking good. But can it stay good for long? Let's talk about it.
Hi, welcome back to another episode of Padres Digest with your host, Andrew.
Good morning, everyone. I recorded this yesterday, but for you guys,
it's coming out today, which is tomorrow for me. You know how it works.
But today we're talking Nick Pavetta. We've talked about him a lot before,
but he just had a recent outing that I want to talk about that I haven't talked about.
But now we're talking about it, and he looked pretty good.
But I do have some concerns I want to bring up, and we'll bring them up in a second.
Before we get too deep into the video, though, please subscribe, as always.
Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Padres Digest. We're super close to 5K, so get us there.
So how did Nick Pavetta look on his most recent pitch outing?
So he was outstanding tonight in rehab. Tonight was like two or three days ago.
I forget exactly when. But in El Paso,
he had a 4.1 inning pitch, two hits, no runs, one walk, seven strikeouts on 64 pitches.
That is pretty, pretty good, if I am to be honest.
But let's take a look at the numbers, right? So we saw all the stats.
68.8% strike ratio. Let's call it 69%, because that's nice.
But his four-seam looked below average stuff-wise, 92, but didn't get hit too hard.
303 expected weighted on-base average. Not a lot of whiffs, but good chase on that.
Curveball, below average at 99, but not that below average.
Did not get that many whiffs or chases, but it did hit the zone 50% of the time.
So cool, I guess. Cutter, though.
So the cutter has a new cutter shape. And as it says on the left side,
it has a worse break, despite it added velocity, one to monitor closely.
That was pointed out to me by Giannis Anticaraputo on X.
We'll talk more about him later.
But the cutter is new-looking, but doesn't look great.
But AAA is a great time to try it out, so why not, right?
Sweeper was definitely the best pitch. 60% whiff rate on 8 pitches.
Clear best weapon of the day, 105 overall on that.
Very, very good, but he only threw it 8 times. So not great, right?
Sinker was pretty bad, to be honest. He threw it 3 times, barely found the zone.
So a ground ball pitch, but I don't think he's going to throw it very much very often.
The command was sharp, though. Like we said, 68.8% strikes,
just 1 walk and 4.1 innings pitch. Control is clearly there.
And he got 7 strikeouts, so the strikeability is definitely intact.
But these numbers look good. But like I said, there are some concerns.
But I will say, this year, besides the opening day start, he hasn't been horrible.
He's got a .450 ERA, which of course is exacerbated by the opening day start,
which is like, what, 8 earned runs against the Tigers?
But he wasn't bad, right? And so far,
MILB, his minor league stats, in 3 appearances, 8 innings.
He has a .338 ERA, .113 whip. So, you know, not bad.
So why do I keep saying there's something concerning?
So I'm going to show you this tweet, and then I'm going to kind of break down what it means.
So just bear with me for a second.
So this is from Danny Burand on X, who I like a lot because he loves stats,
and I love stats. So we both like Padres and stats.
But everything I've heard about pre-blowout pitchers is loss of grip, strength,
slash wrist stability. Both have high correlations with supination.
Supination, I forgot what the word is, but I googled it.
It's the outward rotation of the forearm, so your palm faces up.
So, yeah, if that makes sense to you.
But bias and spin rate. Pre-TJ, call me John,
foreseams tend to lose induced vertical break, gain horizontal break,
lose spin, OKC elevation, that's where they play it in Oklahoma City,
isn't dropping induced vertical break three inches and zapping his cutter.
So basically what they're saying here is that he's losing induced vertical break,
gaining horizontal break, and losing spin. And it's not because of Oklahoma City,
which is more of an elevated place. Think Coors Field.
I don't know how different their elevation is,
but I assume not as high as Coors Field, but still pretty high, right?
So expected blowouts tend to have precursor drops and grip,
grip strength, wrist stability before the UCL goes.
This obviously doesn't guarantee he is bound to blow out,
but it is a solid way to spot arms who may have something going on.
So let me show you the breakdown on that kind of.
But what I do want to tell you about, or kind of qualify it, justify it,
quantify it. Think Walker Bueller, right?
When we saw Walker Bueller back in the day, he was throwing 97 with the Dodgers.
Then he got, what, two Tommy John surgeries, and now he's throwing like 93 miles per hour.
So he basically had to reinvent his game. And he's done a pretty good job.
He's not amazing like he used to be, but he's solid.
He has solid outings, bad outings, but also really solid outings.
So maybe that's what's going to happen to Nick Pavetta,
and he's going to have to reinvent himself.
But so far, he's not looking bad in the minor leagues,
but of course, minors and majors, totally different, right?
So let's take a look at this stuff, right?
So induced vertical break, we saw that. He's losing rise on the fastball.
The fastball's hop is disappearing.
Grip weakness kills backspin.
Batters who used to swing under start making contact.
So that dropped by 1.9 inches from 2025.
The horizontal break, ball is drifting sideways.
The ball is releasing sideways instead of up and forward.
Wrist instability causes a sharp change.
Hitters pick up on fast.
Reading is hard, but that increased by 0.8 inches,
which isn't nothing, but it isn't not something.
You know what I mean?
Spin rate, though, is dropping.
Spin rate is tied directly to grip strength.
It drops before velocity does.
The earliest red flag when a UCL is under stress.
So last year, it was at 2,324.
This year, it's at 2,289, which is a 35 drop.
And you can see that all from the middle part.
The stuff overall, too, was 107 average last year.
Now it's at 92, which is a 15 drop.
So his stuff is genuinely not as good as it was last year.
Again, he just got through a horrible injury again.
I think this is the second time he's had a similar injury.
So, you know, just look out for it.
You know, just look out for it, right?
The cutter, of course, like we said last time, a second concern.
It's been thrown 0.5 miles per hour harder in 2025,
which is a 90 versus 89.9.
But a 0% whiff rate and stuff fell 11 points.
90 versus 101.
The new movement profile isn't producing results.
May reflect the same grip issues as the foreseam.
So maybe the arm problem from the injury is also affecting his cutter
like it is affecting the foreseam.
Or he's just trying to throw a new cutter
because he can't throw the old cutter.
You don't know, right?
Of course, this is pattern analysis only.
Pitch movement data, not a medical assessment.
One rehab outing is a small sample.
This pattern warrants attention, not panic.
Of course, analysis flagged by Danny Buran.
So thank you so much for that.
And of course, the contract stuff, he had 130 days IL.
So he basically didn't make it back by August 22nd.
So he has a player option, which now becomes a club option.
So if we don't want him, we don't have to sign him anymore.
So we can exercise his option to keep him.
And King, he likely still ops out.
So maybe we need a new club-friendly deal with Nick Pivetta.
I don't know, right?
But the bottom line, Padres have leverage they didn't have before.
Arm health is the only question that matters now.
What Nick Pivetta are we going to get?
Are we going to get 2025 dominant Nick Pivetta?
Are we going to get pre-Padre Nick Pivetta,
who was kind of shaky with the Red Sox?
Are we going to get injury-prone,
can't throw the way he used to be Nick Pivetta?
Hope not.
Long gone would.
I want, I would take a middle ground
between last year and Red Sox Nick Pivetta.
Give me 350 ERA.
Like, it's not great, but you know, I'll take it, right?
And there's no guarantee we'll need to sign him next year.
Maybe we can use the money to sign someone better.
I'm not saying Tariq Scooball.
But, but, but no.
Nick Pivetta, I like you.
I am rooting for you.
I love you very much.
Please do good.
But if he doesn't do good, just know he's coming back from an injury that diminishes,
is that a good word for it?
Harms pitchers and the way they throw.
So we'll see how things go.
But what do you guys think?
Do you think Nick Pivetta is going to make a solid return
and be a key piece of the Padres
and the rotation for September and onwards?
Or do you think there's some concerns and you don't know how it's going to turn out,
but you're really worried?
You let me know how you feel about it in the comments down below.
But thank you guys so much for watching.
Please subscribe as always.
Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Padres Digest.
Thank you to our channel members for awesome bonus features
and have a fantastic rest of your day.
Goodbye.
Please win more games, Padres.
Thank you.
Bye.

