Controversy around Florida flock camera surveillance

Fox - 35 Orlando
10 followers
7 Video Views·Sep 1, 2026
I talked about block cameras that has been a huge topic of conversation especially over
the past few weeks really, but especially since yesterday when FDOT essentially said
they revoked the state licenses and permitting for any of those license plate reading cameras
along state highways.
And so I want to check in with Fox 35 reporter Chris Lindsey, who's joining me live now in
our streaming studio.
And Chris, you've got an interesting angle on this because I know that one of the questions,
one of the things we've heard as well, well, there are cameras everywhere.
Why are people upset about these?
And that's exactly kind of the question that you pose to an expert that you spoke with
to get some of the differences between these license plate readers and some of these other
cameras that are out and about and other tools that law enforcement and others use.
Yes.
Well, it essentially boils down to an issue of privacy.
I spoke with a professor from the University of Florida, Jane Bombauer, who says these
cameras are obviously allowed to be outside because of the first amendment and the fourth
amendment.
So you see them on the side of the highway, they're documenting certain things.
You also see those red light cameras that are documenting whether someone rolled through
a stoplight or not.
The difference between the two is how the information is documented and what information
is documented.
So when you have those red light cameras, they are only taking a photo and documenting
it.
If the technology believes that you have gone through that light where you have these
flat cameras that are posted in various cities and municipalities, they are recording at
all times.
So it takes that information.
It documents the make, the model of the vehicle, the color of the vehicle.
It can even document if there is some sort of damage or alteration, whether you have
stock wheels or if there were some sort of new wheels that you put on the vehicle.
That obviously is very important to law enforcement, but some people we've seen have had an issue
with what this means to their privacy.
So for instance, if you're driving down the road, it can document you and say, hey, okay,
you drove past the Walmart in whatever city you're in.
And then an hour later, you can be driving in a different area and it records that for
amount of time.
You can imagine how helpful that would be for law enforcement.
But for people who are saying, well, I'm not doing anything wrong.
Why am I being recorded constantly?
Why do police agencies and other law enforcement agencies have the ability to search for my
license plate at any time?
I mean, we've seen that abused in a few cases.
And to that end, we're seeing different kind of agencies respond to this whole thing differently
as well.
Yes.
And I believe that at the end of the day, most of these agencies find the technology
helpful because we've seen instances where a crime occurs.
You don't have much, but maybe the description of the vehicle, well, they can go in the system
and say, hey, we're looking for a red, whatever sort of vehicle that they're looking for.
And that can give them an instant lead and say, okay, that passed this flat camera at
this time.
So there's no doubt that it can be helpful.
But what the issue that they've been running into is there aren't very many regulations
when it comes to this.
So we've seen incidences here in Florida and countrywide where there are law enforcement
members who are using the platform to search where their ex-husband or ex-spouse have been
and stalking them digitally.
And that can obviously be a huge issue.
So here in Volusia County, the sheriff says, yeah, this is super helpful, but there has
to be something done to regulate this so that you don't have people abusing these platforms
and that so people feel safe and that their private information isn't just being looked
up whenever people see fit.
There has certainly been a kind of a growing groundswell of pushback against these for
a number of reasons.
As some of those cases, like you talked about, have gotten some attention and just, I think,
increasing attention on these, it's been interesting to see.
You mentioned Sheriff Chitwood essentially saying it felt like the rug was kind of pulled
out from underneath him and seemed a little frustrated by the fact that the state decided
just to go ahead and kind of pull the plug rather than putting a pause on it and trying
to see what the state legislature can do.
Absolutely.
And it really impacted the Volusia Sheriff's Office hard because the memorandum says that
you have to remove cameras from all state roads.
Well, the sheriff in Volusia County says all of our cameras are on state roads, so that
limits anything that we're able to do.
One of the examples that he gave is in DeBerry, before they had the flock cameras installed
throughout the area, they were able to resolve 38 percent of the car break-ins that they
had in the area, meaning 38 percent of those car break-ins resulted in arrests.
He says that after they installed the flock cameras, that number jumped up to 83.
So the proof is in the numbers there that these things actually work.
But what it seems like there's more of an issue of the parameters surrounding them.
Who is able to access this information?
What are they able to do with this information?
And why are they doing such?
It's an interesting conversation and one we're not done yet with, that's for sure.
For FOX 35 News reporter Chris Lindsey, we appreciate you breaking that down for us and
look forward to seeing your story coming up a little bit.
Thank you.
