Crowley issues Flock camera directive

Fox - Milwaukee
11 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, also the Democratic nominee to be the next
governor of Wisconsin, is calling for limits on the use of flock surveillance cameras on
county property.
He's also ordering new rules on data access, retention, and accountability.
And joining us to break down all of this is our political reporter, Jason Calvi.
Jason, we can give the viewers a bit of a peek behind the curtain here.
We had a whole segment planned on what happened yesterday, Mayor Tyler Johnson announcing
changes to flock use in the city of Milwaukee.
We know that this has been a major national issue.
The county exec just comes out, so what do we know about these announcements?
I think it's important for everybody listening at home to realize that Milwaukee County has
an elected sheriff.
That sheriff is in charge of law enforcement for the county, not under the jurisdiction
of the county executive.
The county executive does have authority over the property, though, so he's saying he wants
to have the county corporation council, which is pretty much the county's attorneys, as
well as the attorneys, the information technology folks, come up with a policy.
So pretty much what he's saying right now is he's calling for placing restrictions on
flock, but what authority does he actually have as the county exec?
That's still, I'm not sure, because the county sheriff is the one, let's be clear.
She has the authority over policing for the county, not the county executive.
He has no authority over her, other than setting the budget, as well as running the property.
So here's what he's asking for.
He's asking the county's attorneys and information management to look at the current policies
and then develop new standards on things like, well, what the technology can be used for,
what it cannot be used for, and how long the data can be kept, and who can access it, and
under what circumstances.
He's also calling for it not to be shared with federal immigration efforts.
Okay, gotcha.
That's what he's calling for.
That's his effort.
Is it almost like down to a technicality of the sheriff controls the cameras, but the
county exec controls the polls they're placed on?
Potentially.
Okay.
Right.
We're still trying to figure that out.
That's what I'm still trying to come out.
I mean, this literally just came out minutes ago, but I think it is important to realize
that the county executive does not dictate how law enforcement is done in the county.
That's the elected sheriff.
She is her own elected official that oversees her own department.
The county executive and the county board have authority over the budget.
That's where some of these issues can be fought over, but also the county property is under
the jurisdiction of the county executive, so it's a really tricky issue here as far
as what he's calling for.
But let's not forget, he's running for governor.
True.
Yeah, and that obviously plays into pretty much every decision he makes from this point
until November 3rd.
Exactly.
So I think you have to keep that in mind when you're looking at this as well.
The entire issue of the use of these flat cameras around the country has received a
lot of attention recently.
Here in Milwaukee, we've certainly covered it as well with three different Milwaukee
police officers investigated for misuse of that system.
I guess first and foremost, very basic question, but can you set up for viewers not familiar
what these cameras do, how they work?
So the cameras are on poles across the city of Milwaukee.
There's 30 that we know of that the Fox 6 investigators have found several years ago.
They've been investigating this story since 2023, and back then, they found something
like 30 cameras in the city of Milwaukee.
So that's one issue, is they're on these poles, and what they do is they track all of the
license plates.
Every single license plate that goes by, they snap a photo of it, and they track the
license plate.
So they're able to track pretty much, they're all across the city.
And what happened was, in the city of Milwaukee, there were three Milwaukee police officers
who were investigated for misusing the system, right?
So the first one was Josue Ayala.
He was convicted.
He pled guilty.
He actually resigned from the force, was convicted, and he pled guilty, and then was convicted.
And prosecutors charged him with using that FOX system to track a romantic partner, and
that romantic partner has axed more than 170 times.
That was the first case.
And then NPD does this audit of the system and finds, there's two more people we need
to investigate.
One was a detective who was actually on the case investigating Ayala, the first officer.
You can't make that stuff up.
So he's facing charges, and we just learned that the police chief fired him August 18th.
He was discharged, is the technical term they use for firing.
And so that case is still working its way through court.
The third officer is being investigated for a policy violation, not necessarily a criminal
matter, but that he may have, or he or she, we don't know if it's a female or a man, used
that system potentially going against the FOX policies for the city.
Initially, these cameras were seen, especially by law enforcement, as an amazing tool.
You can have eyes everywhere throughout your city.
You can track these license plates, potentially connect them to vehicles known to be part
or wanted in connection to crimes, perhaps.
Now it's led to a lot of backlash as well, certainly when it comes to the misuse, but
then also the larger fears of a surveillance state.
When it comes to the city of Milwaukee and what Mayor Kevlar Johnson said yesterday,
what did we learn from him?
And then we can get into the national.
And again, the same thing I mentioned with the county executive, the city mayor does
not have authority over the police force.
That is not the mayor's ability.
We always were very clear it was the mayor announcing changes in consultation with MPD.
MPD's chief and the Fire and Police Commission are able to set the standard operating procedure,
but it's pretty much the chief that has the power.
In consultation with the mayor, he announced these changes yesterday for the FOX system
in Milwaukee.
Many of the things they're changing are that no longer will standard officers or detectives,
none of them will have access to the FOX system.
Moving forward, only supervisors will have access to the FOX system.
That's a big, huge change.
Another thing, they're no longer going to be sharing with any other jurisdictions.
In the past, MPD shared their Flock Camera database with departments across the state
of Wisconsin, and now they're only going to be MPD looking at that database.
The third change is what issues they're going to be able to tap into that database for.
Only type one crimes, that's the definition from the FBI, and it regards the most serious
crimes like your homicides and burglaries and things like that.
Then they also can use it for missing persons, as well as for drug investigations and then
abductions.
And, you know, when you talk to MPD and you talk to the police chief, they will talk about
how these cameras have solved crimes, including recent crimes as well.
We actually spoke with the police chief earlier today, if we can pull up that, that would
be great to hear from him today.
Here's what he had to say.
I think we have that sound.
Whether that is the answer, all I know is we have to have an answer.
That is obviously not the police chief, that is Governor Tony Evers, and in that sound
he was asked, would you ban Flock Cameras statewide?
Is that something you would consider?
And he said, I don't, he's kind of a low talker, it's kind of hard sometimes to hear him on
a microphone, but he says there, I don't know that that's the answer, but we need to have
some answers.
He's pretty much non-committal to banning Flock Cameras, I mean, I think when you talk
to police officers, including the police chief, they're going to point out how many crimes
they've solved with this.
So let's hear now from Milwaukee's police chief today.
Just kidding.
That's the only one that we have.
So what did he say?
You did the interview.
We'll try to get that.
Actually, Andrew Amuzu did the interview.
So, but the police chief, I've done, I did a very lengthy interview with MPD on Friday
where they laid out several cases that they've solved with the Flock Cameras in recent days.
Zolikoff, remember him?
He's the one who was charged of three homicides, two on the South side, one on the North side,
and police couldn't find him.
And they tapped into the Flock system and were able to use the Flock system to track
that person down.
That person that they accused of three murders in the city of Milwaukee, saying because of
the Flock Cameras, they knew where he was, they actually had a stakeout, and then they,
there was sort of a confrontation there when they, when they finally arrested him.
So that was one case.
There was also some kidnapping cases where they used the Flock Cameras.
There was one case where a man had kidnapped, was accused of kidnapping a woman and had
her handcuffed in the back seat, and police tracked him through the city of Milwaukee,
then through Milwaukee County, and then finally were using the Flock Cameras, were able to
alert a neighboring jurisdiction, this car is a potential kidnapping, go arrest that
person, and that person was arrested.
So it certainly can be a tool for law enforcement.
We know that.
I found it interesting, Sheboygan, another part of our viewing area, it was actually
the police department that has put basically garbage bags on the Flock Cameras there because
they thought there was an issue with how Flock was handling the contract and basically the
use of the data, the use of the images here.
So we're kind of seeing across the board, both in Wisconsin and then nationally as well,
this kind of be a bit of an abrupt turn from what this was supposed to be for law enforcement.
There's been a lot of pushback at the local level and communities asking about mass surveillance,
but also the fact that there were really three officers in Milwaukee who were accused of
potentially misusing the Flock system.
And Brian Poulsen actually has been tracking cases across the whole country, found 91 cases
across the country, including five in Wisconsin.
And so those 93 include five in Wisconsin, including the three that I told you about
in Milwaukee.
So where does Wisconsin fall nationally?
Actually, Brian Poulsen's math and his data that he's been crunching, he found that Wisconsin
was the sixth worst.
In terms of misuse?
Yeah.
So we were number six for all the states.
The state with the most potential abuse allegations, Georgia, that's the state where Flock is based.
They had 29 cases there.
Again, Wisconsin has five, including the three in Milwaukee.
We're going to let Jason get back to digging into the breaking news of the morning.
The fact that Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley has come up with a series of at least
requests for how Flock cameras are used throughout the county remains to be seen legally, whether
that is up to the sheriff or up to the county exec.
Jason's going to dig into that for us.
Thank you.
A complicated topic, but an important one that's received national attention.
