The First Civilization in the World Was Rather Strange

Weird History
157 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the Sumerian civilization in southern Mesopotamia, contrasting its brutal ritual practices with its monumental contributions to humanity. It traces the journey from early city-states and the invention of cuneiform to the rise of the Akkadian Empire and the eventual collapse of Sumer due to environmental decay and foreign invasion.
It's 1922 and a British archaeologist named Leonard Wooley is digging in the south side of Iraq
at a site called Ur and he opens up a pit and then there's a skeleton in it which fine that's
what you're digging for that's kind of like the whole point here but then he keeps digging and
then there's another one and another and by the time he's done counting there are now 74 skeletons
in that one pit alone and they're arranged and that's the part that gets me every time I read
about this there are rows of women skeletons in elaborate headdresses gold and lapis lazuli still
sitting on their skulls where they evidently died there was a set of guards near the entrance still
holding their weapons and this is the detail that I cannot get out of my head there's a musician
still curled around her harp when her fingers are basically still in the position like she's
actually stopped playing about four seconds before whatever happened to her happened to her
there's oxen in there a sledge a whole retinue laid out around one woman in the center of the pit
a woman who we now call Plobby who as far as anyone can tell was some type of queen and then
Wooley looks at all this and he sees no sign of violence or of a struggle everybody was arranged
neatly like they just walked in and then laid down there on purpose and then he comes up with
an explanation he says well they took poison voluntarily Plobby's entire court walked into a
hole in the ground drank something and then laid down to die so that they could keep serving her
in the afterlife and for about 80 years that's just kind of what everyone believed and I want
you to actually think about that for a second what would it take to get dozens of people to lie down
and die on command neatly without a struggle and still wearing their jewelry we're going to be
coming back to this because it turns out that the actual answer to this is a lot worse than the
poison story and also a lot more sumerian than the poison story in the sense that it tells you
something true about how this whole civilization kind of ran so that's where we're starting we are
starting in a hole in the ground with 74 bodies in it because that's a more accurate first impression
of the sumerians than anything else that I could have opened with these are the people who invented
writing they invented the first cities they invented the seven-day week that you are currently
living inside of and also the reason that there are 60 minutes in an hour and also apparently
ritual mass killing that's just kind of dressed up to look like a funeral all of it in the same
civilization so that is the sumerians but to explain what actually happened in that pit we've
got to go back further before er was even a city before anyone in mesopotamia could even write
their own name so as i said picture southern iraq roughly 6 000 years ago it was unfortunately not
a very nice place and not in the way that you would expect the tigris and the euphrates rivers
run through it and empty out into the persian gulf and yes that means that there's water but
there's basically nothing else there's not really a whole lot of forests there's almost no stone
no metal deposits worth you know mentioning just clay and reeds and mud over and over for miles
and you'd think okay well there's a river valley that's the niles playbook that's like that's how
you get civilization except the tigris and the euphrates don't flood the way that the nile floods
the nile is almost boringly reliable it floods up the same year you know every time the same amount
so farmers can set their whole life by it these two rivers flood when they feel like it and sometimes
they just don't flood they actually change course entirely and so what used to be a nice bit of
farmland is now either a swamp or what used to be a river is now just gone and somehow it's in that
exact same landscape with no stone and no wood and no metal and an unreliable water that occasionally
reroutes itself out of nowhere that the first great civilization on earth gets built which
already tells you something whatever happens next isn't happening because the land was very generous
it's happening because somebody figured out how to force it to work anyways before the sumerian
shows up there are already two cultures already sitting on this ground and this part matters so
stay with me first the ubayad people they're doing early irrigation they're doing mud brick temples
they're they're learning pottery the basic sort of stuff and then the uruk culture takes over and
this is where things start moving fast actual cities start developing actual monumental temples
and this early clunky proto writing system made of clay tokens which is basically an accounting
trick but you know before it even had language and then somewhere near the end of the fourth
millennium bc the sumerians show up and nobody can really answer the question of well where where did
they show up from and for a long time the obvious guess was well they didn't show up at all they
were just already there and they were the direct descendants of the ubayad and the uruk people
no mystery required except the language says otherwise sumerian isn't related to any language
really that we know of it's what linguistics call in isolate which is you know something that's
totally on its own you know we know what that word means and you can see it down at the level
of specific individual words too the major sumerian cities nipper legash the names aren't
those settlements were already there already named before sumerian speakers ever arrived
so river names lake names they pretty much borrowed it basically farming vocabulary like the words for
plow for farmer for two so they were essentially borrowed from somewhere else entirely which is a
strange thing to borrow if you think about it because you'd assume that the people already
farming the river valley would have their own word for plow but apparently that's not the word that
so the picture that's forming here is sumerian speakers arrive into a landscape that is already
inhabited that's already been named for them and then that's already been farmed by somebody else
and they layer themselves on top of it and their language becomes the language and pretty much
everything kind of gets absorbed which just ultimately kicks the question one level back
where do these people arrive from well the sumerians own answer in their own mythology
is that they came by sea from a paradise island called dilman which is we're pretty confident
is modern-day bahrain and there's actual archaeological evidence of a sumerian presence
there except the sumerians show up in mesopotamia way earlier than the evidence that we have from
dilman itself so the myth doesn't really line up with the timeline but a polish um a seriologist
named marak stepien floated the idea that they might be connected to whoever later
founded um the civilization of the indus valley other historians have thrown out anatolia the
the caucasus the arabian peninsula even tibet which is about as wide as a spread of guesses that
you can get for like a single group of people's origins but the honest answer is well we don't
really know this is one of history's actual open mysteries not the kind where the answer is out
there and nobody's bothered to look but the kind where the evidence itself just doesn't really
support any idea the kind that i love the first human civilization in history and we literally
cannot even tell you where his people came from okay so somewhere around the start of the third
millennium bc something shifts in this region and it shifts fast by ancient standards little
settlements start turning into actual cities and the reason is once enough people are living
close enough together well not everyone has to farm anymore you get specialization so you have
artisans and craftsmen and merchants and priests and then warriors and then people whose entire job
is something other than grow food or starve and the thing that makes that possible the thing
underneath literally everything else in this story is the idea of irrigation because remember these
rivers do not cooperate on their own so what do the sumerians do well they build canals dikes and
reservoirs a whole engineered network to force the water to behave however they needed to but here's
the number that actually helps this idea kind of make sense on average a single sumerian city state
was managing something like 300 square kilometers of canal laced farmland which is roughly the size
of queens new york which is like one city managing that with bronze age tools which if you've ever
tried to get your city to fix one pothole this should put things into perspective and that takes
thousands of people working in sync year after year and whoever ends up organizing that labor
you know like the person scheduling it overseeing it making sure that the right canal gets dug before
the flood season and not after that person accumulates actual power not because they
conquered anybody per se but because they're the one who keeps the water working that's how you
get to the elite class out of a swamp with no stone in it well you control the thing that everyone
needs which is water and everyone needs water because the land will kill you otherwise so you
end up with dozens of cities across southern mesopotamia uruk kish lagash and about 20 city
states total in a fairly small stretch of land most of them at you know at some point went to
chief among them religiously at least was nippur home of the temple of enlil the head of the
sumerian pantheon it wasn't really anybody's capital exactly but everyone's holy city sort
of like if the vatican had never really belonged to any one country each city had a ruler called
an nc and this title is doing a lot of work because nc wasn't just a political leader he was
the high priest and the chief administrator all at once he was running the irrigation he was
organizing the construction managing the temples collecting taxes performing the ceremonies jack
of all trades kind of guy his title literally translates to something like the one who divides
the temple land because officially all land belonged to the gods and he was just handling
it on their behalf but and this honestly surprised me the nc didn't have total unchecked power
they had a council of elders so they were citizen assemblies that got called together to make major
decisions in some cities the nc had his own temple guard which was like an armed force loyal to the
sanctuary and in wartime some cities would appoint a separate figure entirely the lugal which literally
means funny big man uh so an actual historical title that is big man which is a stronger job
title than half of the ones that we use today like i don't know i found that to be funny but
at first the big man or lugal was temporary he was an emergency wartime position so you would
appoint him then the war ends and then he goes back to just being a regular guy except shocker
the guy holding all the military power during an emergency does not love giving that power back
so the role just becomes permanent then predatory and then the nc who used to be the top of the food
chain slowly gets demoted into something more like a mayor or a high priest working under a king
that he now answers to so that's the first kind of idea of monarchy showing up in the picture
in sumer for the first time and it's not some grand founding myth it's just what happens when
temporary wartime leader just forgets to be temporary but by the start of the third millennium
bc you've got actual dynasties trying to lock this in and our main source for all of it is
this bizarre document called the sumerian king list carved into something called the weld blundell
prism which lists rulers going back to quote legendary times and the earliest kings on this
list supposedly reigned for tens of thousands of years which obviously mythological nobody's buying
that but the closer the list gets to documented history the more it lines up with actual archaeology
which is a strange thing about it so you have half fantasy and then half legitimate historical
records stitched together in the same document and it was this period the early dynastic period
where it's pretty much just city-states hammering on each other over and over and over and over again
kish under a king named mbaragesi and later his son ega controlling a decent stretch of
between kish and uruk then there are other rulers cobbling together short-lived alliances
between a handful of cities power keeps sliding back and forth between kish and uruk and nobody
ever actually unifies the entire region every city keeps its or keeps to its own customs its own
identity its own patron god even while they're all nominally part of the same broader culture
and constantly at each other's throats and this right here this exact period this exact chaos
is when ur enters the story around 2600 to 2500 bc same scramble for status and territory as
everywhere else in sumer except at ur somebody's burying their dead in a way that nobody else in
mesopotamia is doing at anywhere near the scale so with that all being said let's go back to the pit
woolley excavates you know he's the archaeologist i talked about in the beginning illustration
he excavates the royal cemetery of ur across the 1920s and what he finds in this network of tombs
is several which he specifically labels death pits which one of them is the largest he calls
the great death pit and it's got 74 people in it on its own plobby's tomb is smaller but still
2100 attendants buried around her with guards musicians you know ladies of the court animals
everyone arranged in neat two rows like there's no wounds or cups scattered near some of the
bodies and woolly looks at all that that arrangement the order of it like the cups
the total absence of anything violent and concludes that these people poisoned themselves
they drank something willingly or at least semi-willingly and laid down information to
die so that they could keep attending to their queen in the next life and because woolly was
the guy who dug it up and because the story is compelling on its own that's the version that
gets repeated in book after book for basically 80 years this was a voluntary human sacrifice
where an entire royal court walked calmly into a hole in the ground out of loyalty or duty or even
fear of what happens if you don't accept in 2007 researchers went back to this place not to the
but to the skulls themselves sitting in storage at the pen museum since woolly shipped them there
and then they ran ct scans on them and this is where things went south on a female skull from
the great death pit and a male skull from a related tomb they found paramortum fractures
that's you know fancy term for saying depressed skull fractures the kind that you get from a heavy
flat object hitting you in the head hard right around the time of death the signature of a blunt
weapon not of someone calmly drinking poison and then lying down so the story will be told for 80
years that this loyal court you know drank poison turns out to be at minimum incomplete and probably
just wrong these people weren't found dead by their own hand they were killed and then it looks like
deliberately preserved so there's evidence of heat treatment possibly even mercury used to slow down
the decomposition because whatever the ceremony was it apparently needed the bodies to look
presentable for a while after they were already dead so they were all arranged to look peaceful
because peaceful is what the ritual you know ritual people watching need to see and i keep
coming back to that because it's such a clean example of how much you know we know about ancient
history is really just like the first plausible explanation that somebody gave us and it just
repeated over and over again until it just pretty much turns into a fact at that point because it
was like 80 years of yeah they chose this like they drank poison willingly and then the actual
evidence when anyone bothered to run a scan says nope they didn't somebody made that choice for
them with a weapon and then they bashed their skull and then they just staged everything that
came after that but you know whatever this ritual actually was a funeral for a king or a display of
loyalty forced rather than offered some some belief about the afterlife requiring an entourage
you know it happened in the same city in roughly the same era as everything else we're covering
today so the same civilization that's about to invent writing the same civilization that's about
to give you a seven-day work week or week in general i shouldn't say work week it's all on
people and that's the thing that i find fascinating so that's why i'm making this video so let's start
with some of the good stuff that they did writing and writing started as boring bookkeeping which is
kind of a great origin story for what becomes literally like the single most important invention
in human history like once you've got food surpluses and trade happening well you need
some way to keep track of who owes what so early on across the wider region people are using small
clay tokens as a kind of counting system one token for one sheep 10 tokens for 10 sheep and so on i
think that makes sense fine it works fine it's functional and it's extremely low technology
but then around 3000 bc some official in uruk has an idea hey what about instead of physically
storing a pile of tokens to prove a transaction happened why not just press the tokens into a
that's it so that was the leap storing the shape instead of the object and it was from there people
started drawing directly into the clay instead of pressing tokens they made pictograms you know
a sheep a loaf of bread like a person each symbol standing for one concrete thing in the early
version of this system had something like 2 000 different signs which is a lot of them are still
basically shaped like the tokens that they replaced which is clunky hard to use and hard to
teach but nonetheless this whole idea keeps evolving the symbols stop meaning just objects
and start meaning actions and ideas so a picture of a foot doesn't just mean a foot anymore it can
mean walk or run or movement in general writing is becoming flexible enough to express thought
instead of just like keeping inventory and then a giant leap happens an actual giant leap
the sumerians figure out that a symbol can represent a sound instead of a meaning so
for example the word for arrow in sumerian happened to sound like the word for something
else entirely and instead of needing a whole new symbol for that second word they just reuse the
arrow sign for its sound which starts small but it is not small that's the difference between a
system that you can only draw um you know that can only draw you a sheep in a system that you can
actually write a sentence with with grammar and tonality with anything that a spoken language that
can do so scribes press these signs into wet clay with a cut read at an angle which leaves this
distinctive wedge-shaped mark and that's why the whole system cuneiform it just comes from the
latin for wedge and this doesn't stay a sumerian thing the akkadians pick it up and then the
the hittites and it becomes the standard writing system across the entire region for centuries
used for everything from trade contracts to law to literature that um you know might be somebody's
shopping list but this is the part that actually gets me clay actually sounds like a rather terrible
material to write on and it's also one of the most durable materials on earth if a building
burns down around it just because fire bakes the tablet harder instead of destroying it so over a
million cuneiform tablets have survived to today and archaeologists are actually still digging uh
still digging them up basically everything we know about how these people lived what they believed
what they argued about we know because they happen to write it down on something that actually fire
makes stronger instead of weaker and once you've got writing cities irrigation in a functioning
state the sumerians just start casually inventing other things at a rate that's a little absurd once
you start actually listing them out they of course invent the plow which sounds unglamorous but it
made farming efficient enough that fewer people needed to work the land at all which is the exact
same thing that the specialization stuff did from earlier in the video but now it's just compounding
on itself after that they invented the wheel and this is the one that everyone knows except
the early version wasn't actually for transporting things it was for religious processions it would
be used for carting statues of the gods and rulers around pretty much and then of course
eventually it becomes a military technology which is the first war chariots except the sumerians
didn't have horses yet so their chariots were actually pulled by donkeys so like instead of
the first military charge in human history was functionally donkey re no i no i refuse to
apologize for that word anyways but what about architecture well they're building arches and
columns before basically anyone else on earth out of mud out of bricks and reeds because remember
they don't have stone here their signature structures are ziggurats which are these
massive step temple towers and the great ziggurat is often floated as a possible inspiration behind
the biblical tower of babel story actually that's what biblical scholars do think it is
is that it was a ziggurat they also invented soap more or less by accident mixing animal fat with
lye they invented beer actually developed an entire brewing process which are with a dedicated
goddess to it ninkasi whose name literally translates to something like the lady who
fills the mouth beer not wine was the standard drink across mesopotamia they didn't have hops
so it wasn't bitter it was thick kind of sweet like closer to porridge than to a modern beer
but unfiltered enough that people drank it through straws straight out of big communal jars so the
first great civilization signature drink was a warm chunky and drunk through a straw out of a
shared jar which no notes that just kind of sounds like a modern college frat house but i mean i
wasn't in one of those but i i can only imagine that's what's going on in there but anyways i
don't know their math though is where things actually get really impressive they invented
or they used a base 60 counting system which you know and the reason is almost stupidly simple
they counted the 12 finger segments on one hand with their thumb then they used the fingers on
the other hand to track how many sets of 12 that they'd gotten through 5 times 12 60 and that system
really never left us either it's why there are 24 hours in a day 60 minutes in an hour 60 seconds
in a minute 360 degrees in a circle every clock on the planet is quietly running on a sumerian
arithmetic and this wasn't even primitive counting either they were literally solving
quadratic equations calculating volume and area of complex shapes and they understood the
relationship between the sides of a right triangle centuries before pythagoras got the
theorem named after him they were also tracking planetary movement they were compiling star
catalogs predicting solar and lunar eclipses and because they believe the position of the stars
actually shaped their human fate this was also more or less where astrology comes from their
calendar ran on lunar months 12 of them roughly 354 days you know in a year with an extra
month tossed in periodically to keep it lined up with the actual solar year and the seven day week
the one that you're using right now to plan your entire life pretty much off of traces back here
too each day was tied to a celestial body which is why the sunday is the sun's day and monday is the
moon's day and saturday is saturn's day which i think that's rather interesting but they also
wrote some of the earliest law codes that we have well before Hammurabi covering trade property
marriage inheritance criminal offenses stuff like that and they built actual schools mostly for boys
from elite families teaching them math astrology um there's no astronomy law literature religion
which is the first time in human history where going to school is a thing that exists as an
institution so quick recap they invented writing the wheel the base 60 math that's still running
your clock by the way the seven week day or seven day week beer soap formal education the same people
who staged a mass killing to look like a peaceful funeral yep same civilization that's just what an
actual complicated functioning human society looks like uh here looks like up close instead of from
you know what we see in a museum and for a long stretch the sumerians share this region
with this group called the akkadians which was a semitic speaking people um up and up in the north
and the two cultures gradually blend together they start trading they start intermarrying
borrowing gods and customs back and forth until the late 24th century bc and then a man she's or
shows up who changes everything sargon of akkad and his origin story is straight up myth before
supposedly born to a priestess instead of drift on the euphrates in a reed basket as a baby
found and raised by a gardener as an adult he claws his way into the royal court at kish
overthrows the king and then just keeps going city after city until for the first time in
recorded history one ruler controls the entire region not just sumer sargon's empire stretches
from the persian gulf to the mediterranean from the zargos mountains to the edge of anatolia
the first actual attempt at a centralized multi-ethnic state governed with appointed
officials and garrisons instead of just conquered and abandoned his armies go as far as syria where
they destroyed the kingdom of ebla in into elam capturing its capital at susa so akkad becomes
the first superpower ever in recorded history his grandson naram sin pushes it even further
he crushes rebellions across sumer and syria takes the title king of the four corners of the world
and then does something that no mesopotamian ruler ever had done before him declares himself
personally a living god a walking ruling deity not just the king of the gods or not just the
king that the gods happen to favor which is the claim that every other king had before him
that's the peak of akkad and it doesn't last trouble comes from the east the gutians i don't
know if i'm pronouncing that correctly but it was a tribe of people out of the zagros mountains and
then they pretty much start raiding mesopotamian cities um around 2200 bc a gutian leader defeats
the akkadian army outright and takes the sacred city of nippur an event apparently important enough
that he had it carved into a stone some gutian rulers get pushed back um one's even captured by
the akkadian king shark uh khali shari but the empire is already coming apart at the seams
and after that king dies the gutians take the rest of mesopotamia in a full offensive this period
gets called mesopotamia's first dark age and here's why it actually falls apart so completely
the gutians are mountain people they don't know how to run river valley irrigation remember that's
like the entire foundation that this whole civilization is built on so under gutian rule
the canal systems break down agriculture collapses cities get abandoned and then only down in the
remote swampy south does something like a traditional sumerian life keep limping along
mostly undisturbed the gutians never managed to build a stable government of their own and
resistance built from literally every single direction the akkadians come alamites sumerians
alike until a ruler from uruk named utu hegal finally defeats them around 2120 bc and drives
them out roughly after a century of foreign control what follows is a scramble among the
founder of what we now call the third dynasty of ur he unifies sumer and akkad under one rule
and he's remembered most for one specific project building the great ziggurat of ur a massive
stepped temple dedicated to the moon god nana and this one's worth pausing on because it's
the same city ur the same place where centuries earlier somebody staged a mass killing to look
like a peaceful funeral procession into the afterlife and now generations later it's the
capital of a revived sumerian golden age building one of the most recognizable monuments in the
ancient world literally the same place but under a completely different chapter now ur namu's
dynasty rebuilds the irrigation systems that the gutians let collapse and runs an increasingly
centralized bureaucracy and then the region splits into provinces under appointed officials
funded through a clever rotating tax system called the bala which is where each province
only had to fully fund the central government for about a month a year instead of constantly
it's also very likely when the sumerian king list as we know gets compiled which is a political
document as much as it was a historical one designed to link this new dynasty back to
and make this whole thing look inevitable and even though akkadian is what people are actually
speaking on the street by this point sumerian gets deliberately restored as the official
language of religion administration or administration and literature it's a formal
ceremonial language the same role that latin plays in medieval europe centuries later once
nobody's speaking it at home anymore either but underneath the restoration things are cracking
a bureaucracy that runs fine under a strong ruler turns bloated and resentful under a weaker one
and on top of the politics there's an environmental problem stacking up quietly in the background
centuries of aggressive irrigation have been slowly salting the soil and then salt builds up
and then kills a bunch of their crop yields and some historians think a huge amount of southern
mesopotamian farmland was already unusable by the end of this dynasty literally just from the salt
so the outside pressure hits at the same time from the west the amorites who are this nomadic
semitic speaking tribes start pushing into mesopotamia and then they come in they start
disrupting trade and farming as they go from the east the um elemites uh like an old rival of theirs
start pressing in too so they get collapsed on both sides the last king of the dynasty eb sin
tries to hold the line and he literally just can't the emirates keep chipping at the trade networks
the economy keeps sliding and finally in 2004 bc the elemites deliver the actual killing blow
they capture and sack the city of earth to the people living through it this was nothing short
of a cosmic catastrophe gods and all not just an army losing a war there's an exact text from this
exact period called the lament of earth and it doesn't read like history it reads like grief
that's formally organized into literature it opens up by naming the great cities and the temples of
sumer one by one and the gods who supposedly abandoned each one of them at one point it just
says that the god of the city turned away its shepherd vanished later there were corpses
floating in the euphrates brigands roamed the roads and the goddess ningal is described begging
the gods anu and enlil not to destroy her city and being refused anyway and it's not subtle it's
a city's entire population trying to process in real time watching everything around them collapse
and telling them that the god themselves ordered it and i keep thinking about the two ways that
this same city ends up in the historical record centuries earlier there's a mass killing at ur
that gets staged to look like something voluntary in silent basically no one's screaming about it
because the whole point of the staging was that nobody was supposed to see it as violence at all
and then here at the actual end of ur as the sumerian capital you get the opposite this isn't
staged this is an attempt to make it look peaceful literally it's just an entire population writing
down obsessively in agonizing detail exactly how bad it was one of the catastrophes was hidden and
the other screamed about for a thousand years after the fact same city same people more or less but
wildly different responses to disaster so after 2004 bc sumer as an actual political entity just
doesn't ever come back mesopotamia splinters into smaller amorite ruled kingdoms and the most
importantly which eventually becomes babylon especially since hamarabi takes the throne just
a few centuries later sumerian dies out as an everyday spoken language but it doesn't disappear
it survives exactly the way that latin does as a sacred scholarly language still being taught and
copied and used in religious texts long after nobody's using it to order dinner it's religion
literature science all get absorbed pretty much into akkadian babylonian and assyrian culture
and from there into basically everything downstream of mesopotamia so the sumerians
disappear as a distinct people but you're still living inside of their math every clock you've
looked at today has 60 minutes on it because somebody was counting finger segments 6 000 years
ago every calendar you own has a 70 week because somebody signed it to an each day to a different
point of light in the sky and somewhere under a few thousand years of sand in southern iraq
there's a decent chance that there's another pit like plobbies that just nobody's found yet
arranged just as neatly waiting for someone eventually to run a scan and find out what the
heck actually happened there if you made it this far thank you so much for watching the video if
you enjoy videos like this please consider hitting the subscribe button it's going to help out my
channel a lot um yeah more videos coming so i'll see you in the next one
