10 Questions Insurance Adjusters Don't Want You to Ask.

Auto Insurance
2 followers
2 Video Views·Aug 31, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAttorney Justin Ziegler shares ten strategic questions that personal injury claimants should ask insurance adjusters to gain leverage. These questions are designed to uncover the insurance company's internal valuations, the adjuster's authority, and the strengths or weaknesses of the case, helping claimants avoid lowball offers and secure fairer settlements.
I'm going to give you 10 questions that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask in personal
injury claims and other types of claims.
Watch the entire video so you can see all 10 questions that insurance companies get
bothered when you ask them.
Jay Z Helps of Florida Injury Law Firm.
I'm attorney Justin Ziegler.
The first question that insurance claims adjusters don't want you to ask is what are the insurance
limits in the case?
They don't want you to ask this question because it shows that you may be trying to get the
insurance limits and that you're more savvy than you're just average claimant and smarter
than them.
If insurance companies can do so, they want to avoid paying out the limits and pay as
little as possible.
Another question that bothers claims adjusters and they don't like being asked is if you
ask them how much check writing authority do they have.
You're essentially asking them how much can they write a check for without having to get
supervisor approval.
They may not want to answer that question because you may think the value of your case
is above their check writing authority and if that was the case, you'd need a new adjuster
assigned and they want to keep their file.
The third question insurance claims adjusters don't like being asked is what is the settlement
reserve?
The reserve is an amount of money that an insurance company, an insurance adjuster sets
aside to pay your case.
They don't want to be asked that because then you have a better idea of how much they think
your case may be worth.
The fourth question that claims adjusters don't want you to ask is how much have they
paid for the exact injury that you've had in the past for other claimants for their
pain and suffering.
Insurance companies keep very specific files that show how much they paid for pain and
suffering for certain injuries.
You're not going to have access to those and if you ask the insurance adjuster how much
he's paid in the past for pain and suffering for your same injury, he's not going to tell
you and if he does tell you, rest assured that the number that he gives you is going
to be much lower than what he's actually paid because they rarely like to show their
hand.
The best thing that you can do would be to look up past settlements and verdicts using
a jury verdict search reporter.
That's not going to really give you the exact settlements and verdicts with that particular
insurance company.
It's going to give you a ballpark value of the pain and suffering component of many different
types of injuries which you hopefully use that to your advantage.
The fifth question that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask is Mr. Adjuster, how
many cases have you made an offer to a claimant like myself and then a jury has awarded higher
than that offer?
Rest assured that there's not an insurance company in Florida that has had a case where
they haven't made an offer and at some point had a personal injury claimant go to trial
and get a verdict and judgment for higher than that amount, but there's going to be
a slim chance that the insurance adjuster tells you which cases that happened in.
Insurance adjusters are not always right with their offers and their valuations of your
claim.
That's why sometimes at trial they get hit for large amounts.
The sixth question that a claims adjuster does not want to get asked is how many times
has your supervisor awarded a claimant and paid a claimant for an amount higher than
you said your last final offer was?
If you ask them that question, you're generally going to get the response is speaking with
my supervisor is not going to do any good, you're going to hear the same thing, but there
are certain times and it happens often where the supervisor just has more settlement authority
and he may just want to get the file off the desk and closed and he may award more money.
There's never a guarantee it can happen all the time, but supervisor is a very powerful
word.
The seventh question claims adjusters don't want you to ask is what are the bad facts
for your case?
Many facts go into a personal injury case and many things affect the value.
Witnesses are one of them.
There's a chance the insurance company knows about a witness that's horrible for their
defense such as someone who thinks they're insured with speeding or someone who saw
substance on the floor a long time before you slipped and fell.
Ask the adjuster what are the worst facts in your case?
You're going to get a good idea of how many cards the adjuster is showing you.
The eighth question a claims adjuster doesn't like being asked is does your insurance company
typically increase the offer when a lawsuit is filed?
They may say no, they may not be telling you the truth, but the reality is not in every
case, but in many cases when you file a lawsuit, the case gets transferred to a different adjuster
who has more authority to settle your case essentially for more money.
It goes to a higher level adjuster.
Sometimes the reserves get increased.
That's the amount of money set aside to pay the claim.
It doesn't always happen.
There's certain insurance companies that stick to their final offer before a lawsuit, but
oftentimes insurance companies, particularly if they have to pay an outside attorney and
they're not one of the large auto insurers that has their own attorneys on staff, will
increase an offer after you file the lawsuit.
I had a case against a very large supermarket and they denied liability and forced me to
file a lawsuit for my client who was injured when something fell on her, and as soon as
I filed the lawsuit, the insurance adjuster gave me a call and she said, I don't know
what the other adjuster was thinking, which we hear this often, and she offered $18,000.
Now we continued to litigate that lawsuit and settled for more money, but oftentimes
insurance companies will not be fair.
You'll file a lawsuit and the new adjuster will put all the blame on the pre-suit adjuster
saying, I don't know what they were thinking, or the defense attorney that's assigned to
the case will put blame on the prior adjuster who was handling the case.
So sometimes a lawsuit can be huge.
In one case, we represented a gentleman who slipped and fell.
Insurance adjuster denied liability.
We filed a lawsuit and later settled for $300,000.
So take what insurance adjusters tell you with a grain of salt.
The ninth question that claims adjusters don't like being asked is, how much is your insured
at fault?
Insurance companies have an insured who is their client.
You want to ask them, what percentage of negligence are you placing on your insured?
Sometimes I've had cases where the insurance adjuster will tell me.
In this case where our driver hit your insured, we're placing 60% blame on our client and
40% on yours.
So some of them will tell you.
Some of them will say, I'm not going to go into that, that's privileged information.
But knowing their insured's percentage of fault, or at least what they're saying it
is, helps you understand why they're making the offer that they're making and you can
see if what their percentage of fault is in line with your evaluation.
You need to know if their insured is negligent.
And it's one of the main factors when evaluating how much your case is worth.
Number 10, insurance adjusters hate when you ask them, how much blame are they assigning
to you?
Just like number nine, sometimes they will tell you.
I've had cases where I've filed a lawsuit and the defense attorney says, listen, we're
placing 25 to 50% blame on your client for not seeing something that she tripped over
that she should have seen before she tripped.
Sometimes insurance adjusters will tell me we're placing 50% blame on your client for
crossing the road in the middle of daytime when she wasn't in a crosswalk.
I actually had a case like that where my client fractured her lower leg bone and we settled
for $70,000, but the insurance adjuster let me get inside her head and she told me 50%
of the blame they were accepting on their client and 50% on my client.
As a bonus question, you want to ask the insurer.
If you had health insurance that paid some of your bills, the health insurance is going
to have a right to recover money from your settlement if you reach a personal injury
settlement or may have a right.
You're going to ask the insurance adjuster, what percentage of the health insurance lien
are you paying me back for?
See if they're giving you full reimbursement.
The same is true with your medical bills.
Ask them if your medical bills, out of pocket medical bills are 10,000, ask them, are you
paying me for 100% of my medical bills?
They may tell you they may not.
I hope you enjoyed this video.
Please subscribe to our channel.
Please comment.
Please like the video.
I'm attorney Justin Ziegler in Miami serving Florida.
Have a wonderful day.
