What actually is a photon? Is it a real physical thing that exists in the universe, or is it simply a mathematical description of an excitation in the electromagnetic field? If a photon is only a mathematical description, then how can it carry real energy and transfer that energy to matter? In this video, we will go deeper into what happens when a single photon is created, how the electromagnetic field’s excited modes combine to form its quantum state, why its probability can be spread across space, and what really happens when it is detected. We will explore whether the photon itself is real—or whether something deeper is actually happening.
This video re-evaluates the nature of light through Quantum Field Theory (QFT), arguing that photons are not discrete particles but quantized excitations of a universal electromagnetic field. It explains how the apparent paradox of wave-particle duality is resolved by viewing \"particles\" as emergent phenomena resulting from the interaction of field modes during measurement.
Look at a very dim galaxy in the far reaches of the universe.
A galaxy so faint that it emits only one photon at a time.
Imagine that during its billion-year journey across the cosmos,
this single photon does not interact with absolutely anything.
By the time it finally reaches us, that single photon's probability wave
has expanded so much that it is actually many times larger than the Earth itself.
I am not joking. This is real.
But wait, if this is what a photon really is,
what happens when a detector on Earth finally records it?
Well, the moment the detector records the photon,
suddenly this massive, Earth-sized probability wave
collapses into a tiny, particle-like object with a discrete amount of energy.
If this vast electromagnetic excitation is the photon,
how can such a colossal object collapse so suddenly?
How can the very edge of this probability wave,
which might now be millions of miles away from Earth,
instantly vanish in the blink of an eye?
That would break the ultimate speed limit of the physical universe.
Nothing can travel faster than light.
Scientists resolve this by explaining that the wave function collapse
doesn't break the speed of light,
because the probability wave isn't a physical object at all.
It is just a mathematical tool.
But that raises a terrifying question.
If it is just a mathematical tool, does that mean the photon isn't actually real?
And if it isn't physically real,
how does it carry physical energy across the universe?
However, in 1905, Albert Einstein first revealed this particle-like behavior of light
through his explanation of the photoelectric effect.
He showed that when light strikes a material,
its energy is transferred to electrons in discrete amounts.
It is as if each electron is hit by a single quantum of energy,
which we call a photon.
Then came the famous double-slit experiment, which changed everything.
It revealed that light behaves like both a wave and a particle.
But this is where things become even stranger.
Whenever we try to detect light,
we observe discrete photon-like detection events.
Yet, when we don't measure or disturb it,
light behaves like a wave capable of interfering with itself.
This led to an astonishing idea.
Could it be that photons, as tiny localized particles,
only appear when light interacts with a detector?
In other words, perhaps photons don't actually exist in the way we usually imagine them.
This strange behavior of light has puzzled scientists
ever since the birth of quantum mechanics.
Even today, there is no universal agreement on what light really is.
But then came quantum field theory,
which completely changed our understanding of light.
In this video, we'll explore how quantum field theory explains what light actually is,
and why this theory suggests that photons may not exist in the way we have traditionally imagined them.
According to quantum field theory,
the entire universe is filled with invisible fields.
These quantum fields exist throughout the universe,
covering all of space, like an infinite ocean.
But remember, this field is not actually a fluid,
nor is it an invisible substance made of tiny parts.
It is a fundamental layer of reality,
meaning it isn't made up of anything else.
It is simply an invisible, continuous entity
that exists as a real, physical part of our universe.
Now that we understand what the quantum field actually is,
let's talk about one specific layer of this framework,
the electromagnetic field.
It exists everywhere, overlapping with all the other quantum fields.
When nothing seems to be happening in a region of space,
a condition scientists call the vacuum state or zero-point energy state,
the electromagnetic field rests in its most calm and quiet state.
But if you look closely, this quiet state isn't completely calm.
Random fluctuations are constantly rippling through the field.
When I say random fluctuations,
I don't mean that the electromagnetic field is physically vibrating
or moving up and down like water.
The quantum field itself isn't physically changing its shape
or moving through space in that way.
So, if the field isn't literally vibrating,
what does a quantum fluctuation actually mean?
Let's understand why this ground state has strange quantum fluctuations
and what these quantum fluctuations really mean.
Physicists describe the electromagnetic field
as having physical quantities associated with every location in space.
Imagine choosing one particular point in space.
At that location, the electromagnetic field has an electric field value
and a magnetic field value.
These quantities determine how charged matter would respond
if it interacted with the field.
For example, the electric field tells us the direction and strength
of the electric force that a stationary charged particle
would experience at that location.
The magnetic field also affects charged particles,
particularly when they are moving.
So when physicists talk about the electromagnetic field
at a particular location,
they are talking about physical quantities
that determine the results of possible measurements and interactions.
In our everyday classical world,
we can imagine these quantities having perfectly definite values
at every moment.
For example, if you measure the speed of a moving car
at a specific location and at a specific moment,
you would expect to get one definite value.
But quantum fields don't behave in quite the same way.
In a quantum state, a measurable quantity,
such as the electric field strength,
does not necessarily have one definite value
at a particular location before it is measured.
Instead, the quantum state tells us the different values
that could be obtained and the probability of obtaining each one.
To visualize this, imagine preparing the exact same quantum state
again and again, as if we had many identical copies
of the same system, rather than different physical realities.
In every copy, we measure the electric field strength
at exactly the same location and at the same moment.
After repeating the experiment many times,
we can collect all those results and build a probability distribution
showing how frequently each value occurs.
This is what it means when physicists say
that a quantum observable does not have a single definite value
in a particular quantum state.
The theory gives us a range of possible measurement outcomes
and their probabilities,
rather than one predetermined classical value.
And scientists visualize the uncertainty in these possible values
Only when we perform a measurement do we get one of the possible values.
Until then, the quantum state does not assign
one definite classical value to the electric field strength
at that location.
Instead, there is a range of possible values,
each with its own probability.
We can visualize this as the field having quantum fluctuations
at that location.
Look, there is no particle physically appearing and disappearing
everywhere in the field.
And the electromagnetic field itself
is not literally moving up and down
like water or a piece of cloth.
The fluctuations refer to the unavoidable uncertainty
in the measurable quantities of the field
and the different results that can be obtained when we measure them.
So, if we now consider a one-dimensional slice of the field.
In the classical model, each point in that line
has a definite value of electric field strength.
So we can create a curve along that line.
And this curve represents the electric field strength
at different spatial locations along that line.
But, as we know, in a quantum state,
the field strength has possible different values at each point.
So this time, we can't say that the field
has one definite classical curve.
Rather, when we measure the electric field strength
many times along the line,
we can get different values of electric field strength
at different points in each measurement.
Each measurement can therefore produce
a particular field configuration,
which can be represented as a different curve.
So, in the quantum description,
the field state allows many possible measurement curves
rather than one definite classical curve.
In a 2D view, you can imagine
many possible patterns of the field.
And if you try to imagine the full 3D electromagnetic field,
the complete quantum description becomes extremely complex.
But how can we mathematically describe
such a complicated quantum field?
Now get back to the 1D slice of the field.
Imagine that we made a particular measurement of the field
at every point along that line.
And it produced a complex curve.
Scientists can describe such a field configuration
using combinations of simpler, fixed vibration patterns
called modes.
So, the whole electromagnetic field
can now be described using these fundamental modes.
Now let's understand a bit about these modes.
The electromagnetic field exists throughout the universe.
And these modes are mathematical patterns
that we can use to describe the field.
Like a particular sound produced by a guitar string
can be explained using combinations
of fundamental vibration patterns, or modes.
Similarly, the electromagnetic field
can be described using different modes.
There can be infinitely many possible modes
that can be used to describe the electromagnetic field.
All these modes have fixed spatial patterns and frequencies.
To understand this, consider the modes in one dimension.
Each mode has a definite spatial pattern
determined by the conditions we impose on the field.
For example, if we consider a region of length L with boundaries,
a mode may have to be zero at both ends.
So, only certain spatial mode patterns
are allowed inside the boundaries.
So these modes have fixed spatial vibration patterns.
But here is an interesting thing.
Scientists found that these modes behave
like quantum harmonic oscillators.
This means each mode can have only certain
definite quantities of energy,
rather than having a continuously varying amount of energy.
And scientists have shown that all these modes
can have only these quantized energy levels.
Here is a representation of the energy levels a mode can have.
The lowest energy a mode can have
is called the ground state energy.
Look at the lowest energy state.
It is not simply a state with zero vibration or zero energy.
Even in its lowest energy state,
the mode has a minimum amount of energy
called zero-point energy.
So the modes are continuous fixed patterns in space.
And each mode can have only certain quantized energy levels,
not anything in between.
So we now understand what modes actually are.
Now let's understand how we can use these fundamental modes
to describe the quantum state of the electromagnetic field.
But before going into that, we have to imagine something.
Describing the entire electromagnetic field of the universe
using all of its possible modes,
which can be infinitely many,
throughout three-dimensional space
is extremely complex.
The mathematics becomes very difficult to visualize.
So to understand the basic idea more easily,
let's imagine a simplified one-dimensional universe
that we describe using only six modes.
It means that, in this simplified example,
we are using only six modes as the building blocks
needed to describe the electromagnetic quantum field.
Here, the electromagnetic field is represented
along a one-dimensional line.
As we know, the quantum state of a field
is not simply fixed in the classical sense.
It can exist in a quantum superposition
of different possible states.
And because we are describing the field using modes,
the quantum state of the field can be expressed
in terms of the quantum states of those modes.
Look here. This quantum state of the modes
can contain different possible configurations
at a single time.
And each possible configuration can correspond
to a particular value of a measurable quantity.
So in a quantum state,
the different possible configurations of the modes
can correspond to different possible values
of a measurable quantity at the same time.
This explains why a single quantum state
can give different possible values
when we measure the same quantity.
This spread of possible measurement values
is what we previously called quantum fluctuations.
So this is what the quantum state of the field
actually looks like.
It is a probabilistic configuration
of all the fundamental modes.
Now from here, let's understand
what happens to the one-dimensional field
when we give energy to create a single photon in that field.
As we have already imagined,
this one-dimensional field is made of
only six fundamental modes.
So the quantum state of the field
can be described by the possible configurations
of these six modes.
And in the vacuum state,
all the modes are in their ground state,
which means their lowest energy state.
But when we add the energy of a single photon to the field,
the quantum field now enters
the first excited state, or one-photon state.
And the quantum modes now become excited,
which means the modes can now be
in their excited energy states.
But when we add energy,
this doesn't mean that all the modes become excited.
The excitation state of the modes
depends on how the energy is added to the field
while creating a photon.
What I mean here is that
a single photon can be created
by adding energy to the field in a way that
all six modes that define the field
get excited to the one-photon state.
And their combination can describe a single photon.
In another way, we can add the energy
in a way that only one mode contributes.
And the photon in the field
can be described by only one mode.
For example, we add the energy of a single photon
to the one-dimensional field
in a way that only three modes get excited
to the one-photon state.
We can represent this one-photon state like this.
But remember, there is still only one photon in total.
The three terms represent
the three possible mode components
that together make up the one-photon state.
However, the modes also have
a spatial spread in the electromagnetic field.
This means they occupy space.
And because each of these modes
has its own spatial pattern,
their combination also has a spatial distribution
along our one-dimensional line.
We can describe this spatial amplitude like this.
Here, u1x, u2x, and u3x
represent the spatial patterns
of the three modes, and c1, c2, c3
tell us how strongly
each mode contributes to the one-photon state.
So, the single photon
is not simply sitting at one particular point
on the line. Its quantum state
has a spatial spread along the line.
At each point, the combination of these three modes
gives a particular quantum amplitude.
And the probability density of detecting
the photon at that position
is given by this equation.
This means that different locations along the one-dimensional line
can have different probabilities
of detecting the photon.
And because the line is continuous, we don't add the probabilities
point by point as a simple sum.
Instead, we integrate the probability
density over the region.
For the entire one-dimensional space, we can write like this.
This means that if we consider
the entire region of the one-dimensional field,
the total probability of detecting
the one photon is 1.
So, this equation describes the spatial probability
distribution associated with our
one-photon state in the one-dimensional field.
And remember, this function here
is the combined spatial amplitude
of the three modes that make up our one-photon state.
So, that energy
excites three fundamental modes.
And the combination of these three modes
gives a spatial pattern,
with probability amplitudes describing
how much each mode contributes to that state.
And when we take the square of the spatial amplitude,
it gives the probability density
of finding the photon at each location
in the field.
So, this final spatial probability distribution
is what we use to describe the single photon.
So, when scientists say that a photon
is in a wave packet, it means that the photon
is described by a spatial combination of excited modes,
with a probability distribution
associated with that spatial state.
And you can see that it actually looks like
a small packet of waves spread over
a region of space.
Similarly, we can explain the excitation
in a two-dimensional slice of the field
by expanding the line integral into a surface area integral.
And now, the probability distribution
of the excitation is spread over a surface.
Here's how the excited fundamental modes
look like in two-dimensional space.
But, the three-dimensional representation
of these excitations is very complex.
We can only visualize the probability wave
of that photon in space,
which shows the probability density of finding the photon.
But imagine how complex
the three-dimensional fundamental modes would be.
So, the photon is actually a probability
distribution of a spatial combination
of excited modes
in the electromagnetic field.
And remember, the energy we added to the field
is actually carried by these excited modes.
As we already discussed, when we add energy
to the field, it mostly has a spatial spread,
and the excited modes also evolve
with time. So, the excitation
in the field spreads as time passes.
If the excitation spreads without any
interaction, then a single photon's
probability wave can become as big as a
planet, or even bigger.
With all this understanding about a photon,
let's understand some of the weird quantum phenomena.
The first one is that a photon can exist
in many places at the same time.
So, we know that the spatial amplitude
of the combined modes gives a probability
distribution of the photon's location
in the field. Some scientists believe
that this probability distribution is a real
and non-local thing, and that the
photon is actually in many places at
once. Whenever you perform a measurement
at any location within that probability
density region, you will find a full
single photon. But most scientists
believe that the photon doesn't actually
exist in many places. Instead,
its probability is distributed, because
the energy-carrying modes have a spatial
spread throughout space. Another weird
phenomenon is the double-slit experiment.
If we consider our understanding of a
photon, we discussed that a single photon's
probability wave can have a spatial
spread in the electromagnetic field.
It evolves with time, and can become
larger as it propagates. So, when a
single photon, which is described by a
probability wave, moves toward a double
slit, that photon's probability wave
can pass through both slits. And this
is what scientists mean when they say that a
single photon passes through two slits
at the same time. It doesn't mean that a
tiny physical photon is literally
passing through two slits at the same time.
Rather, it is the photon's probability
wave, which has a spatial spread
and can pass through both slits.
But when you put a detector at the slits,
the measurement changes the quantum state,
localizing the detection outcome to one
slit. So, when we detect the photon,
we observe a localized, particle-like
outcome. But the most interesting
and weird part of the photon is
the collapse of the wave function.
Imagine a single photon's probability
wave traveling through the electromagnetic
field and evolving as time passes,
without interacting with anything for a long
time. Its probability wave can
become very large, even as large as
a planet or bigger. This is possible
because the photon can have a spatially
spread quantum state. But when the photon
interacts with something on Earth,
such as a detector, suddenly that
huge probability distribution gives
a single, localized detection result.
And here comes the weird part.
How can that very edge of the probability
wave appear to collapse faster
than the speed of light? The collapse of the
wave function is treated as an instantaneous
change in the mathematical
description of the quantum state.
So, if the probability wave is spread over
a huge distance, it can appear as though
the entire wave has collapsed at once.
Some scientists believe that the wave
function is mainly a mathematical
description of the quantum state.
In that view, the collapse doesn't necessarily
mean that a physical wave is actually
traveling through space and collapsing.
It can simply represent a change in the
mathematical description of the system after
a measurement. But there are other interpretations
in which the quantum state is considered
to represent something physically real.
So, a photon is not a tiny particle,
nor is it something that has a particular
physical shape. Rather,
a photon is a spatial combination of
excited fundamental modes that describes
a quantum state of the electromagnetic
field. So, what do you think?
Is a photon something that physically exists
in the universe, or is it simply a
mathematical representation of an excitation
of the electromagnetic field?