An archaeological analysis breaking down the counterfactual concept of futuristic Roman soldiers and debunking lazy AI-generated images. The narrative explores actual historical military equipment from the Republic, high Empire, late antiquity, and the medieval Eastern Roman Empire. It highlights how the Roman army was defined by a constant willingness to modernize, adapt, and completely abandon outdated tactics or weapons rather than preserving static aesthetics like segmented armor and rectangular shields. The speaker also discusses historical text accounts, including John Lydus's descriptions of sixth-century troops, and evaluates the limitations of modern ceremonial units to explain why a surviving Roman Empire would field forces looking more like modern combat soldiers than Gladiator movie extras.#RomanHistory#AncientRome#RomanArmy#Archaeology#MilitaryHistory#LateAntiquity#MedievalRomanEmpire#WhatIfHistory#AltHistory
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Archaeologist Hadley critiques AI-generated images of futuristic Roman soldiers, arguing that they incorrectly rely on the \"High Empire\" aesthetic. By examining archaeological evidence and the Roman military's history of adaptation, Hadley explains that a surviving Roman Empire would have modernized its equipment to remain effective, rather than clinging to ancient uniforms.
I often see these AI images of the Roman Empire if it never fell and the uniforms of the soldiers
are usually based on some kind of centurion from the High Roman Empire, but if the Roman
Empire somehow made it into the future, soldiers of course wouldn't have looked like this.
Hello, my name is Hadley and I'm an archaeologist.
In this video I'm going to show you archaeological remains of Roman military equipment throughout
the ages and explain why I don't think futuristic Roman soldiers would have looked like this
The stereotypical Roman soldier we all imagine is usually from the 1st to 3rd century AD,
the high point of the Roman Empire in popular imagination and certainly the point in history
when the Roman Empire was at its greatest extent.
These soldiers are the ones from the film Gladiator, they're the ones most reenactors
accurately depict.
No Roman soldier would have looked exactly the same though, even if they did use very
similar military equipment.
You see there was no bog standard uniform, but since a lot of Roman military equipment
was made in a similar spec in workshops that had to pass a quality assurance, the equipment
that survives is very similar.
If we look at Trajan's column for example, legionary citizen soldiers are shown to all
have segmented armour and these rectangular shields, whereas non-citizen auxiliary soldiers
tend to show male armour with oval shields.
This distinction was probably more of a neat artistic differentiator than any kind of reality.
Real archaeological evidence backs up this depiction of Roman legionary soldiers on Trajan's
column though.
This segmented armour from Germany, this shield from Syria, this helmet from Britain.
The fact that these artefacts have been found all over the empire does imply that there
was a strong harmony in how Roman legionary soldiers looked and how they were equipped
during this period.
But the Roman empire lasted much longer than the 3rd century AD and the look of the soldiers
and civilians for that matter changed.
This is what a Roman soldier of late antiquity might look like.
You can see some typological similarities with this soldier but the fashions and technologies
are moving quickly.
The Roman army was famous for adopting more effective military technologies and equipment
and they were never afraid to completely abandon old ways of doing things just because they
had always done it that way.
The East Roman writer John Lydus wrote this in the 6th century.
The present day soldiers however have emulated the barbarians, he says with a slightly sad
patriotic sigh, but it's clear that the barbarians, that's just the Roman word for non-Romans
by the way, had more modern and relevant equipment at that point than the Romans.
After all in this period the Roman empire did hire a lot of these barbarians to fight
on their behalf.
The Roman empire didn't end when the western part of it fell away in AD 476, the eastern
empire continued for centuries.
The look of these soldiers naturally changed with the times.
The Roman empire was influenced by the people who invaded it, constantly adapting and changing
as the centuries rolled by.
So by the 15th century AD when the mighty Roman empire ruled Constantinople and not
much else, Roman soldiers who called themselves Roman and fought on behalf of the legitimate
Roman emperor looked a bit like this.
They looked exactly like late medieval Mediterranean soldiers, because they were.
So back to our AI Roman soldiers, they probably wouldn't have looked like this if somehow
the Roman empire had survived.
Just as American soldiers today don't look like this, and British soldiers don't look
like this.
If anything, Roman soldiers would look like modern soldiers do today because the Roman
army famously modernised itself and changed with the times.
There would be no reason for the Roman soldiers to look like these silly AI images.
Some of you may be thinking that when people say what if the Roman empire never fell, they
mean that if the high Roman empire, the one depicted in Gladiator and Trajan's column,
that empire continued.
And that is an interesting point.
I said earlier that the key element of the Roman army, one that made it so successful,
was its willingness to embrace change.
The people who commanded it, and the people who served as soldiers, wanted the most effective,
most modern weapons, armour and tactics.
The equipment of this soldier and the tactics of his commanders employed simply wasn't
suited to the high-paced, cavalry-dominated warfare of the 5th century and beyond.
Warfare and tactics always change in war, and if the Roman empire somehow managed to
hold onto all of its territories in the 5th century, when the western part of it was wrestled
away, I believe they would have changed fundamentally to more modern equipment.
So the AI Roman soldier still wouldn't look like this.
Additionally, this soldier, the one with the segmented armour and oval shield, was not
the soldier who conquered the Roman empire.
For most of Rome's existence, it was scraping to survive.
But if we go to 146 BC, this is the year that everything changed.
It's the year that it defeated every one of its major enemies in the Mediterranean,
basically ruling unchallenged for the next 400 years.
The Roman soldier that conquered this looked a bit like this.
This soldier that conquered the Roman empire was not a full-time professional.
He was a part-time militiaman who used to go back home at the end of the campaigning
season to tent his farm, which was often left in ruins.
Even towards the end of the Roman Republic, when smaller states were being absorbed by
Rome, the Roman soldier still didn't look like this.
He looked a bit more like this.
The armour is different, the helmet, the shield, and by the time the Roman soldier started
looking like this, the Roman soldier that we're used to, most of the Roman empire had
already been conquered.
A few provinces were added here and there, particularly Britain and Dacia, which is modern
day Romania, but most of the empire was already conquered.
That last part is really important, actually, because when Rome conquered Britain, all these
British archaeologists started studying it to no end, which is why this image of Roman
soldiers is so pervasive in our popular culture.
So when the AI futuristic Roman soldiers look like this, they are basing it off a very specific
iteration of a Roman soldier from a specific time in Roman history.
We've established that the Roman army embraced change, but perhaps the Roman army would establish
a ceremonial unit that used the weapons, armour, equipment used by the soldiers of the High
Roman Empire.
Even to this day, the Swiss Guard of the Vatican City still use Renaissance-style dress uniform
and a halberd, unbelievably, equipment thoroughly inadequate for modern warfare.
Should be noted, however, that these Swiss guardsmen have completed basic training with
the Swiss military and are familiar with modern weapons.
Other modern units preserve historical uniform and equipment.
The King's Guard, formerly the Queen's Guard of the UK, is based on Victorian-era uniform,
and the Old Guard of the USA is often based on revolutionary-era uniforms and equipment.
The previously mentioned John Lydus wrote in the 6th century of a ceremonial unit of
palace guards called the Excubitores.
They wore the dress of ancient Roman soldiers from his perspective.
Here's what John Lydus says about the ancient Roman soldiers.
The entire Roman army at that time had the same dress, a helmet that was brazen, a cuirass
that was ringed, a sword that was broad, short, and suspended on the left thigh.
Two javelins at the right side that had a broad-headed blade, black greaves too, that
were woven, and shoes for the feet.
He doesn't mention the segmented armour, nor does he mention the famous rectangular shield.
And unfortunately, he doesn't really describe the shape and form of the helmet other than
the material.
The short broadsword is almost certainly the gladius, and the javelins are the pila.
Both of these weapons were favourites of the 1st to 3rd century AD Roman army.
It's particularly interesting to me, though, how John Lydus mentions the male armour as
uniquely ancient.
Perhaps in his age and his observations, most foot soldiers didn't wear male.
Even if we give the Excubitores the benefit of the doubt and assume they look similar
to Roman soldiers from the High Roman Empire, they didn't last as a ceremonial unit.
They were converted into a combat unit, using the most appropriate equipment for fighting,
not the parade ground.
This is exactly what we should expect, though, because most ceremonial units we see today
trace their history back 80, 200, and even 400 years in the case of the Swiss Guards.
The Excubitores fit into this category, so we shouldn't expect a futuristic Roman ceremonial
unit to last from the 3rd century AD to the Space Age, as these AI images might imply.
Thank you for watching to the end of this video, I really hope you enjoyed it.
In this video, I've tried to explain why I think futuristic Roman soldiers wouldn't
look anything like this.
The Roman army embraced change and even modernisation.
Even ceremonial units wouldn't preserve ancient equipment and uniforms forever, as
we've seen in the case of the Excubitores.
It's incredibly difficult to dismiss these counterfactuals and what-if historical questions
because you can never prove that something wouldn't happen, but that is certainly
part of the fun, isn't it?
Let me know what you think in the comments.
Thanks again for watching.