You weren't at fault in the car accident, but now you're stuck dealing with insurance calls, paperwork, and stress. It can feel like you're the one being blamed even though you did nothing wrong. Texas personal injury attorney Shane McGuire walks you through exactly how the not-at-fault car accident claims process works in Texas.
Shane McGuire from McGuire Firm covers: What to do immediately after a not-at-fault car accident in Texas Why calling the police and gathering evidence protects your claim How Texas modified comparative fault laws can affect your compensation How property damage, medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering are calculated Why you should be careful with insurance adjusters and settlement offers When to hire a Texas personal injury lawyer and how lawsuits work
AI Generated·May contain errors
You weren't at fault in the car wreck, but nobody's telling you what to do.
You've got medical bills, insurance companies giving you the run around,
and you have no idea what the claims process is really like.
I'm Shane McGuire.
I'm a personal injury lawyer here in Texas.
In this video, I'm going to walk you the steps in a nutshell of the claims
process in a not at fault wreck.
Number one, and this is something you have to do after a wreck.
And I'm going to tell you, you're not going to want to do it.
Somebody's going to tell you, Hey, we don't have to do it, but you have to do it.
Call the police and gather evidence.
Even if it seems minor.
This morning, before I got in front of the camera and started this YouTube
video this morning, the client called me, somebody who's signing up today.
And she was in a wreck six months ago.
And in that wreck, the guy who rear ended her, who was really nice.
I'm sure he's a lovely person said, Hey, I've got to go.
I'm on my way to go pick up son or daughter.
Can we not call the police and this client?
She's a nice person.
And so she was like, sure, let's not call the police.
Give me your insurance information, which he did.
And so they did that.
They exchanged insurance information.
Didn't call the police.
Now what's happened now, six months later.
And the reason I got a call this morning is now the insurance
company is denying the claim.
Okay.
And they're saying, well, we think you might have contributed to the wreck in some way.
I mean, it's a rear end collision.
It's stupid that they're saying this, but that's what they're saying.
Now, if a police officer had come out and worked the scene, as you know, there is a
certain candor people develop when the man with the badge comes up and he's
working the wreck and he kind of gruff what happened.
And in that moment, the at fault driver, probably, I mean, if he's halfway decent,
he's not going to want to lie to the police.
He's going to say, I rear ended her.
And the police officer is going to document that on the crash report.
And they're going to generate a report that puts a hundred percent fault on
that guy who rear ended you.
And then on the back end, the at fault driver can't really wiggle his way out of
it because he's on the police officer's body cam saying, I'm at fault.
All right.
Now, in this particular instance, we don't have that.
So now what do I have to do?
I've got a, my client's very credible.
And so she's going to explain what happened.
And she had kids in the car, but it's not just this case.
It's dozens of others that I've handled over the years.
I'll cross audit, file suit, cross examine the at fault driver and just have him just
come up with some cock and bull story that he's going to come up with to explain why
it's okay for him to rear end my client.
And I'm going to have to take his deposition and embarrass him a little
bit under oath, and then package that together and send it to the insurance
company as part of our demand.
That could all be avoided.
That whole process could be avoided.
If my client had just called the police right there in that moment.
Now she's a nice person and I understand why she didn't do it.
And you know, if I weren't a lawyer, I would have probably
let the guy go on his way too.
But I'm telling you, if you are in a wreck, even if it's relatively minor,
get police documentation for that.
That's what they're for.
You know, you're not bothering them.
They are out there to make the road safe and it needs to be documented to
get medical attention.
Don't put it off.
You know, these insurance companies, they love the phrase gap in treatment.
It's like holy writ to them.
You know, you get in a wreck on Monday and you're a little sore, but you know,
you don't want to go to the ER and wait two hours, which I understand.
And then, you know, you wake up the next day, you're still hurting.
Now I'm 47, so I'm not, you know, in my twenties anymore.
In my twenties, just like you in your twenties, you're made out of rubber and
you feel like you're going to get better in two weeks because you've always gotten
better in two weeks after any injury.
But now you're a little older and you don't get better right away.
And so you wait a couple of weeks, takes a while to get into the doctor or
whatever, and then the insurance company says, you know what, if you were really
hurting, you would have gone to the doctor right away.
And so even if it's just to get checked out, get your injury documented,
you need to go to a doctor.
Okay.
You don't have to go to the ER necessarily that night, but in 24 hours, you need to
get checked out by somebody to document that you're hurting from the wreck because
for an insurance company, if you're not treating, you're not hurting.
Three, report the accident to both insurance companies, but be careful what you say.
You know, in the claims process, both insurance companies play a role, your own
insurance company and the at-fault drivers.
And the reality is in most instances, if you're in a wreck and the police worked
the accident, I shouldn't say in most instances, in many instances, you may not
have the at-fault drivers insurance information right away, you may have to
wait 10 days for that crash report to be ready.
So in the meantime, you need to report the wreck to your own insurance company
and they can get the process started on getting your car repaired or
totaling it out or whatever.
And then once the other person's insurance information becomes available, you can
reach out to them and you're talking about, you know, maybe at that point, you're
actually going to have that insurance company pay for the car, pay for a rental
and work the bodily injury claim.
But be careful what you say.
I've said it a thousand times.
These insurance companies, it's like being in a bad relationship with somebody who's
going to use what you say against you later.
Hey, they're documenting everything.
Even if it's not a recorded call, they're putting it in their claim notes.
What you said, what they said to you, they're trained to express empathy, to
act like they really care for you, like they're going to bring you a gift basket
or something, but they're not doing that.
They're documenting everything so that later, if you have to make a bodily
injury claim, and because they're not being fair with you, hey, they're
documenting all the stuff you said so they can use it against
you and minimize your damages.
Four, the insurance investigation.
Here's what really happens behind the scenes.
You know, going along with what I said a minute ago, these insurance
adjusters are documenting everything.
They're going to call their own insurance.
At this point, you know, think about the motivations that are in play.
So your insurance company calls you, okay, you caused a wreck.
What are the things you're worried about in that moment?
You're three days past the wreck.
You know, you saw the person you hit, that person walked away.
Maybe they went to an ambulance, but they weren't killed.
It's not catastrophic.
So in your head, that person is now out of sight, out of mind.
Your insurance company calls you, you're the at fault driver.
What's your motivation?
In that moment, your motivation isn't make sure your insurance company pays
the person you hit a bunch of money.
I mean, great if it were, but that's not the person's motivation.
That person's motivation is make sure their insurance rates don't go up.
And as you know, most people, when they're in a conversation with
somebody, they tell that person what they want to hear.
So the insurance adjuster who calls them, what do they want to hear?
They want to hear we don't have to pay on this flight.
They want to hear that if we do have to pay on the property damage, surely
we don't have to pay any bodily injury because that person was walking around.
It was fine, the person that you hit.
And so that insured, that at fault driver is now telling his insurance company,
you know, I rear-ended her, but she was walking around.
I think she's fine.
I really think she's fine.
And they document that, you know, claimant, that's what you're called.
Claimant, you're not a name.
You're just a claimant, claim number, was walking around,
appeared fine to the scene.
They're documenting that.
You're at home trying to get better.
They're documenting how you're okay.
So they do that.
They talk to their insurer.
They look at the car and they start measuring property damage.
They're assessing, okay, do we think, do we as an insurance company believe
that this claimant could be injured due to this property damage?
And that insurance adjuster, he or she is not an expert on your injury.
They are an expert on the insurance company process of
minimizing payout on the back end.
So just be aware that while you're convalescing, while you're getting
better, while you're treating, there's some insurance company out there
who's trying to make sure they document their file in such a way that they're
paying you as little as possible.
Five, property damage.
How do you get your car repaired or replaced?
I have to tell you something.
I've been doing this almost 20 years.
And I can't tell you how many times a client has come in and they are not
just sold, but seriously hurt.
And what they care about first and foremost is the car.
I had a client a few years ago.
It's a case that we ultimately settled for over a million dollars.
He was hit by a drunk driver, had orthopedic injuries, ankle, knee, back.
And we got all the insurance there was.
It was 1.1 million.
And he comes in and his girlfriend literally wheels him in on a wheelchair.
Okay.
His leg is propped up in a cast.
Hey, he can't drive.
He's months away from being able to drive.
One of the first questions he asked me in my office was, Hey,
when can I get a new car?
Okay.
I'm telling you everybody in a personal injury case that they care about first,
even if they're hurting, is getting their car repaired or replaced.
Okay.
Here's the deal.
That insurance company does not care that you put new tires on that car.
They don't care.
They're looking at the actual cash value of the car.
And when you go to sell your car, there's not a plus side of newish tires.
There's not a plus side of put a stereo in that was pretty
good a couple of years ago.
Okay.
They're not doing that.
They are looking at Kelly blue book, actual cash value, and they're trying
to squeeze you on the value of your car.
So you need to go out and you need to be looking at comparative sales
in your geographic region of that car.
So get on the internet and look up, you know, 2017 GMC Acadia, like
whatever it is you're driving and look at what those are going for.
And then you can use that to the insurance company to try to increase
the value of your property damage settlement.
We handle property damage claims here.
We don't charge a fee for it.
If you signed up with us on a bodily injury claim, just part of the service
we provide is working the property claim.
And I'm telling you, it is a pain.
I wouldn't wish it on anybody.
I was going through a personal injury claim myself.
I would not also be working my own property claim.
I mean, I would have my staff do it here, but if I'm you and I'm working
through a bodily injury claim, I'm healing that insurance company is just
going to try and take advantage.
Every day of the week and twice on Sunday, you need to know that they're
trying to squeeze you down to that property damage because
they know the pressure point.
They know that you need to get back into a car immediately.
And so here's the reality.
If your car is totaled and y'all can't agree on a number, you
know what they do with that car?
They tow it back to your house.
And Hey, if you're like me and I had a broken down car towed to my house, my
wife is looking at me like Shane, why did you let this broken down
car get towed to our house?
They know it's a pressure point.
They know that most people can't just go out and write a check for a new car
that they've been financing the car that they're in and that they need
to get a down payment for a new car.
They're trying to squeeze you.
Don't let them do it.
Document, document, document, document what you paid for it, what you owe on it
and what the similar cars are going for in your geographic region
and send that to the adjuster.
Six, medical damages and lost wages.
We've got to make sure that you're compensated.
What do I mean by medical damage?
What I mean is just the bills.
You know, when you go to the emergency room after a wreck, you don't realize
this, but you find yourself, it doesn't sound right, but it is the case.
Immediately you are squeezed in between the business model of a
hospital and an insurance company.
And here's what I mean.
You go to an ER within 72 hours of a wreck in Texas, that ER has the option
by statute to either bill your health insurance company or put a lien on the
claim you had against the at fault driver's insurance company.
And so just think about this.
You've all seen an EOB or explanation of benefits on your health insurance, and
you see the charged amount for the hospital, and then what the hospital
actually gets paid, 10 cents on the dollar, 40 cents on the dollar.
The hospital, it turns out would rather not take 10 cents on the dollar and
get that in 60 days from whatever health insurance carrier you have.
Instead, they put a lien on your auto claim for the full amount of their bill.
But then we have to go back in and negotiate down.
And they don't like tell you as you're getting wheeled out of
the ER that they're doing that.
You just get a letter in the mail at some point that says
we have a lien on your claim.
Now it's not a lien on your house and it's not a lien like on
your paycheck or something, but it is a lien on the claim.
I've seen people come into my office upset because they undersettled their
case just themselves before they hired a lawyer, they undersettled for a couple
grand and they get this letter in the mail saying the ER didn't bill their
health insurance company and they're just squeezed because they thought
everybody was doing the right thing.
But it turns out that the hospital and the insurance company did not have the
injured person's best interest at heart.
That's why you need a personal injury lawyer, someone who is your advocate,
who is your advocate to get your medical bills worked down and who's your
advocate for the at-fault driver's insurance company, negotiating with
them to make sure you get the compensation you deserve, but not
only do you have medical bills, you got lost wages, whether you're a W-2
employee working for a company or self-employed, I mean, I have a lot
of clients who are plumbers, electricians, contractors, who are
1099 and who are just self-employed and they're going out and they're
earning a living and most people in the world, as you know, are paycheck
to paycheck and all of a sudden they are stuck, they are stuck because
they don't have six months income reserve to make sure they can get
compensated or make sure they can make it through when some insurance
company has given them the runaround.
So you have to make sure that we've documented all of your lost wages.
Here's what we need.
I need five years tax returns.
Okay.
If you don't file tax returns, shame on you, but you still need to be
able to get me documents showing what you were making.
Okay.
You've got to have that documentation.
If you don't have that documentation, think of making this claim, like
what would you need in order to go get a home loan to show your income?
That's what we need.
We need W-2 info, 1099 info, tax returns, get that stuff.
And then you got to wait a little bit, you know, we have to see,
okay, can you get back to work?
Can you work the same level you were working at before the wreck?
If you can, that's great.
But if you can't, we need to document how much wages you're going to lose in
the future as a result of the accident.
Seven, settlement offers.
Why you shouldn't rush to accept.
You know, I can't tell you how many cases I've had where somebody comes to me and
they say, Shane, insurance companies offered me $3,000, $5,000 to whatever it
is, if I just settle now and I could really use $5,000, $3,000 to whatever it
is and settle now, you know, whether it's because they've got bills piling up or
because it's Christmas and they want to take care of their family or because
they've got a wedding to pay for, whatever it is, there's always some
financial emergency somebody has.
It turns out that in this world, we could all use $5,000 right now.
Okay.
And the insurance companies know that.
And they know that everybody's in need of a little bit of money.
And they know that after a wreck, if you've had to miss some work, if now
you had to go, because interest rates are going up and you had to buy a new
car and you can't get the same deal you had on the prior car, hey,
they know that you're squeezed.
They want to try to buy you off for as cheap as possible.
$1,500.
Sounds great.
Tax-free $2,500.
Sounds great.
Tax-free $5,000.
Sounds great.
Tax-free.
Every time I've ever represented a client who got one of those
offers and they come hire me, I have invariably every single time.
Now there's going to come a time when that's not true, I suppose, but I'm
telling you every single time over 20 years, I've gotten a more than what
they were offered by that insurance company before they hired me every time.
Why?
Because that initial offer is so low that it's insulting, but the poor
person on the other side of the call doesn't know it's insulting.
Why?
Because in most instances, insurance companies have taken care of them.
They got a new roof replaced on their house.
Health insurance pays for their medical bills, something like that.
Most of our common experience with insurance companies is actually there's
a bureaucracy to work through, but it's pretty positive, but in a personal
injury context, they're trying to buy you off before you realize how hurt you really
are.
Okay.
Hey, when should you get a lawyer?
Listen to me.
You should get a lawyer within 24 hours of being in a car wreck.
You just should, even if it's just a consult, it's not going to
cost you anything out of pocket.
You call me, honestly, if you call any personal injury lawyer, they're
going to work for you on a contingency fee basis, meaning we don't get
paid unless our clients get paid.
I have never taken a fee unless my client got paid.
Okay.
If I have thousand dollars in expenses and it was a case where, you know,
turns out there's no insurance for the at-fault driver, cost of doing business
for me, so it's not going to cost you any money upfront to hire a personal
injury lawyer, but man, it could mean the world because all the stuff we've
talked about up to this point, documenting, no gaps in treatment, making
sure that you get the compensation you deserve, mapping out the lost
wage situation, do you need an MRI getting you in to get an MRI?
Do you need pain management, figuring out how much insurance the at-fault
driver has, taking care of the hospital leave, all of that.
That stuff we do.
And then at the end of the case, what happens?
Get a check from the insurance company and you never write me a check.
At the end of the case, I'm going to write you a check.
We're going to have that money in our trust account.
And then you see a settlement statement and you get a check out of that trust
account for the damages you had in that lawsuit.
Okay.
What if the insurance company won't settle right away?
What do we do?
We file a lawsuit.
Man, that's the hammer.
Insurance companies are scared of juries, especially on big cases.
It's happened so many times.
Tell you one example.
I had a case.
It went to trial in 2019 out in West Texas, out, hey, West of Midland.
It was in Monahans.
And so far West Texas, it's where New Mexico is due North.
That's where we were.
And my clients, husband and wife, nice salt of the earth people, country
is cornbread, hit in an 18-wheeler wreck.
He had had a shoulder surgery as a result, and she had just had some injections.
And the at-fault driver was in an 18-wheeler.
He had no business being in an 18-wheeler.
His employment history was sketchy at best and come to find out
after we had filed suit on it.
This guy, okay.
You're going to love this.
You're not even going to believe it.
It was supposed to take a drug test after the wreck.
Federal Motor Carrier Safety Act regulation.
He goes into the drug testing facility, signs in.
He don't take the test.
Okay.
This is out in West Texas.
In West Texas, as you know, out in the oil patch, hey, there's a drug testing
facility, like every block once you're in town, I mean, in Midland, Odessa,
how many drug testing facilities do you think there are?
I mean, dozens in each place.
There's gotta be.
This guy walks out and says his testimony was they wouldn't let me back in because
I'd walked out to smoke a cigarette.
Like, okay, buddy.
We can go to the next one.
Go to Walgreens and get one of those drug testing kits that parents of
teenagers get to make sure their kids aren't on drugs.
There's a way to go get tested for drugs after a wreck.
And he didn't do it.
This insurance company though, hey, wouldn't pay us.
They offered at mediation $300,000 total from my clients.
And I said, Hey, listen, until you get to a million, I'm not talking to you.
Okay.
I know the value of this case, but they wanted to test my metal.
They want to see if we go try it.
That's really what they did because most lawyers don't want to go try a case.
Most lawyers aren't willing to go try a case.
And I'm out in East Texas and most people don't want to drive nine hours
to go to West Texas to try a case.
I love trying cases.
That's why I became a lawyer.
I love getting in front of a jury.
I love arguing in front of a judge.
I love cross-examining the witness on the other side.
I love it.
I love putting the puzzle together and then presenting it to a
jury to get value for my clients.
So here's what happened.
We put that jury in the box.
We go do what's called voir dire, pick the jury, got a jury selected,
and I'm telling you, and they take a break.
Judge swore the jury in, and then we took an hour break.
And I'm telling you right after that, insurance lawyer comes up to me and
he says, Shane, I'd like to make a settlement offer to you.
Now, keep in mind in this story, they've offered me 300 grand.
I've been authorized to offer you what's called a high-low agreement.
A high-low agreement is kind of what it sounds like.
It means if you try the case, no matter what the verdict is, you
can't go below a certain amount.
So if the verdict is zero, you'd still get the low, but no matter what the
verdict is, you can't get above a certain amount.
So if you get a verdict of a bajillion dollars and your high was a
million, you would get a million.
Okay.
And I said, okay, well, what's your proposed high-low?
They've never offered more than 300 grand, but now we've got a jury in the box.
The low was 400,000.
And the high they offered was, I think it was a million and a half, but I
worked the high up to $2 million.
Okay.
So just in like a 30 minute conversation, talk to the clients.
They were okay with it.
Try the case.
That verdict came in at $1.9 million.
Before filing a lawsuit, they had offered like 50 grand total.
After filing a lawsuit, the insurance company had offered no more than $300,000.
Once a jury was sitting in the box and they knew we were serious and
they knew we knew what we were doing and they knew we had it, they said,
okay, we're going to pay you.
And it turned out to be the perfect high-low agreement and my clients
were fully compensated and it worked out great for them.
But the point is, unless you're willing to file a lawsuit, unless you have the
reputation as a personal injury lawyer, that you're someone who tries cases and
knows how to try a case and get max compensation for your client, unless
you have that, they ain't scared of you.
Okay.
And so you've got to make them scared.
And you do that with the threat of a jury, rendering a verdict in the case.
Lastly, getting your money.
How long is it going to take to get paid?
How long is it going to take for your case to fully resolve?
And that I've got other videos on this, but the reality is,
depends on how bad you're hurt.
Depends on if you did all the things we've talked about.
And it depends on how much insurance the at-fault driver has.
Small case, you go to the ER, a little bit of PT and you're fine.
You're going to sell that case in a few months, probably.
You get a back surgery and there's a multimillion dollar insurance policy,
and you don't want to settle that case in the first year.
You can't, because the way to build value is all the things we've talked
about and filing a lawsuit and taking depositions and seeing all the
stuff they've done wrong and develop what I call piss off factors.
That's how you turn that case from a half a million dollar case to a
million dollar case and a 2 million or more dollar case is you build up the
value during the litigation process.
So how long will it take to settle your claim?
Depends on the nature and extent of damages.
The nature of liability and showing who's at fault, the documentation
we've done, the treatment you've gotten, the wages that are lost and
how much insurance there is available.
So if you're in a not at fault car wreck in Texas, the claims
process in a nutshell is simple.
Call the police, gather evidence, get medical care, report the
wreck to both insurance carriers.
Protect yourself in all statements that you may.
Push for fair car repair or replacement, claim all of your losses, medical
bills, lost wages, et cetera.
Don't jump at the first offer.
Get a lawyer.
If you need a lawyer, are you ready to take the next steps to make sure your
rights are protected after a car wreck and you don't get short
changed by the insurance company?
Then you need to watch our next video.
The three biggest lies insurance companies tell people after a car wreck in Texas.
I'll break down exactly what not to fall for so that you get
the compensation you deserve.
I'll see you over there.