Chicago Pizza Is More Than Deep Dish

Great Food
96 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
The United States is home to some of the most famous and delicious pizza on the entire planet.
Insane. Insane.
And love it or hate it, you can't have a conversation about
pizza in America without talking about Chicago.
The thing is, most people only know about deep dish,
but really the culture runs a lot deeper than that.
Deeper than the deepest deep dish, you could say.
Where's the cheese?
Some of the sauce.
So to do this right, we're going to run things on a timeline.
From the day pizza first landed in Chicago,
to the many different styles that define it today.
And later, we're even going to take an exclusive field trip
to one of Chicago's most iconic establishments
to see how pizza is really made here in the city.
And definitely stick around because later in the video,
I'm going to reveal something to you guys that I've been working on for literally months,
and I'm really stoked to share it with you.
Pizza people, let's ride.
Pizza in the United States really starts as a New York story first.
Italian immigrants, mostly from Napoli, came over here in the late 1800s.
Now in 1905, a guy named Gennaro Lombardi opens up Lombardi's in Manhattan,
which is generally credited as the first licensed pizzeria in the entire country.
From there, pizza spread in much the same way that immigrants do.
It followed the work.
Which is exactly why there are so many great pizza spots up and down the entire east coast.
As those immigrants pushed west chasing factory jobs,
really the first big city they ran into was the Windy City.
The city of big shoulders, the hog butcher for the world, sweet home Chicago.
Which is exactly why pizza doesn't really arrive here until the late 1920s.
And when I say arrive, I kind of really mean like timidly touch your big toe into the water,
because it was super low-key.
It began in Chicago's Little Italy neighborhood, mostly on Taylor Street.
It started with home cooks and small family run spots feeding local families on the block.
Businesses like Pompeii, the famous bakery, opened up in 1909.
They didn't start selling pizza really until the 50s, but you know,
they were there doing bread, not too far off from pizza.
Tom Granado's, again off Taylor Street,
becomes the first pizzeria anybody bothered to write down,
which was recorded to have been opened up in the early 1920s.
And really for the next 20 or so odd years, that's pretty much it.
There was no come with me to this local hidden gem culture to, you know, poison our brains with.
It was under the radar.
Pizza was a neighborhood secret that people outside the neighborhood
really didn't know about or really cared that much about to begin with.
Don't disrespect the pizza parlor.
And then Chicago did what the Midwest does best.
It took an idea, made it bigger, heavier, and impossible to ignore.
In 1943, Pizzeria Uno opens up on the corner of Ohio and Wabash Street.
And this is the moment where Chicago stops borrowing
and starts building its own pizza identity.
It begins with a deep cast iron.
Dough is pulled to the sides, kind of like a bowl.
You add in the cheese, the toppings, the sauce goes on top, not the bottom.
It's under the sauce.
And the sauce is really the tell here because, you know,
it's much darker, sweeter, richer, and way more spiced than,
you know, the bright, simple, fresh stuff back East.
This is not a pie from Napoli or New York.
This is a definitive Chicago creation.
It's the pizza synonymous with a city that everybody around the world knows about.
This is deep dish pizza.
And deep dish pizza really is just about as Midwest as it gets.
Not to get too caught up here,
but Chicago is the city Carl Sandburg called the city of big shoulders.
The railways that stitched the whole country together ran through here.
The stockyards that fed most of the country were here.
These were people who worked their asses off
and people who work like that show up to the table hungry.
So the pizza got big.
There was never really a slice shop culture here like there was in New York, right?
This is a sit down, tucked your napkin in your collar,
kind of like a bib style pizza.
Full knife and fork status.
If you want, you can still totally pick up a slice.
That notion is kind of a myth.
Now, who actually invented deep dish is one of Chicago's greatest culinary mysteries.
But most people point to Pizzeria Uno.
For decades, the credit went to Ike Sewell,
a Texas liquor salesman whose name is still on the door at Pizzeria Uno.
Here's the thing though.
Sewell almost certainly didn't make the pizza himself.
He didn't even sign on as a partner until 1944,
a full year after the place already opened and was already selling this pizza.
The guy who actually built it was Rick Ricardo,
the artist who opened up the restaurant
and so happens to have the coolest name I've ever heard about in my life.
The cooks did the work and the business guy got a statue.
A tale as old as restaurants.
But the dough, the one that you picture with deep dish today, right?
That came later from a cook named Alice May Redmond,
who rebuilt the whole recipe using a biscuit technique
that she brought up from Mississippi during the Great Migration
when Black Americans came up from the South to the North looking for factory jobs.
She completely got ridden out of this story decades ago, right?
Super messed up.
She's a legend.
Obviously, like, we wouldn't have the same pizza today
if she didn't step into the picture.
Funny how that keeps on happening.
When it comes to Chicago pizza, everybody on Earth thinks of deep dish.
It's synonymous with the city.
But really, the pizza that most people who actually live here eat,
probably since they were in diapers, couldn't be more different.
Okay, so we know that deep dish blessed us back in the 1940s,
but let's rewind a little bit, just a few years to the 1930s.
Prohibition-era Chicago.
Real quick, little history buffer in case you forgot here.
Prohibition was the roughly 13-year period where the federal government made alcohol illegal.
It went fantastic.
Zero bumps, zero notes.
It was the best.
It handed off the entire booze business to bootleggers and gangsters
and basically funded the rise of world-class organized crime
and the beginnings of the American mob.
Al Capone, remember that sturdy young gentleman?
Yeah, at this time, Chicago was his.
Anyways, in 1933, Prohibition ends.
And basically overnight, Chicago goes from a handful of speakeasies
to literally thousands of licensed taverns scattered all across the city.
Well, maybe not overnight, but you get it.
Soon after.
And now, every single one of these spots had a challenge to face.
How do you keep somebody bellied up to the bar long enough to
keep buying your booze and not go home?
Well, if they're drinking, naturally, they're gonna get the drunk cheese, right?
You know, they're gonna get hunger.
They're gonna want some grub.
I feel them.
And what do people want to muck when they're intoxicated?
Well, amongst other things, pizza.
But not right away.
See, pizza shows up to the bar fashionably late, mostly in the 1940s.
A lot of it right after World War II.
So really, 1940s, 1950s.
Around this time, somebody had the genius idea to make pizza sort of cheaply,
less filling, and easier to eat at a bar.
Remember when I talked about the Slice Shop culture not existing?
This was, you know, easier to eat than a big heavy deep dish.
It starts by rolling the dough super thin so it bakes up kind of like a cracker, more or less.
You cut it into little squares instead of wedges.
Then you serve it on a napkin, not a plate, which keeps one hand open, right?
One for the beer, one for the pizza.
Or if you're a pro, one for the beer, one for the pizza, one for the shot, one for the pizza.
So it's like beer, shot, pizza, pizza situation, right?
We call that a handshake here, but that's an advanced move.
This is tavern-style pizza, and it's basically an American pincho, right?
Those little, you know, bar snacks that you get in Basque Country Spain.
Not quite a tapas, but kind of similar.
You get it.
Maybe that's a little too deep of a cut.
Whatever.
You'll also hear tavern be called party cut, thin crust, you know, or just Chicago thin.
It goes by many names, but, you know, tavern, because it was traditionally served at taverns,
right?
That's the whole etymology.
The cool part about this is that no one person claims to have invented this style,
because, you know, 100 bars basically kind of landed on it around the same time,
which kind of makes it the entire city's thing, which is kind of cool.
The legendary Vito and Nick, or Nick and Vitos, opened up in 1946.
Home Run Inn followed suit right there, too, around the same time.
The idea was so good that it actually leaked across the entire Midwest.
That's why in St. Louis, you know, you have thin square cut pizza.
In parts of Wisconsin, same thing.
They sell the stuff.
It really is that same family tree, but different branches.
You know, cousins, not clones.
Chicago Tavern is definitely its own thing.
Now, if you're a pizza nerd, maybe you've noticed that tavern style has had a real
moment these last few years.
Suddenly, it's trendy, right?
It's getting written up about.
Visitors are seeking it out when they come here into town,
alongside their Italian beef and their Chicago dog.
It really is getting the respect it deserves, which is great.
Okay, style number three.
This one gets a little nerdy.
In the 1960s, a dude named Bert Katz starts messing around with pizza.
He bounces through a couple of spots, a place called the Inferno, then Gulliver's.
And in 1971, he opens up one that sticks, Pequod's, which is out in the suburbs in
Morton Grove, at least the first location is.
Later, he'd go on to open Bert's place as well, because he could not stop tinkering.
What Bert cracked was the edge.
He pushed the cheese all the way down into the gap between the dough and the pan here,
kind of before it hit the oven, right?
So when it came out, it was wearing this dark, caramelized, almost burnt collar, right?
That frico, that cheese rim around the entire thing.
It's a super distinct style of pizza.
And this guy, there could definitely be books and videos and maybe even a movie written
about this guy.
So we won't dwell on him too hard.
He was a legend.
I actually talked about him in my pan pizza video.
You can check that out if you'd like.
Now, on paper, this sounds like a mistake, but in your mouth, it's incredible.
Anthony Bourdain, a guy who didn't exactly hand out compliments like Snickers bars,
called it the only deep dish he'd ever loved.
This is Chicago pan pizza.
And as you can tell by what Tony Bourdain said, this is where everybody gets a little
mixed up, a little confused here, because deep dish is also baked in a pan, but it isn't
actually pan pizza.
Something different, okay?
I know it gets esoteric here, but it's a completely different style.
Different enough to definitely earn its own category.
Which brings us to our fourth and final style today.
The one that I just kind of sort of prematurely mentioned, right?
Stuffed deep dish.
Let's kill the obvious confusion here first.
Stuffed does not mean stuffed crust, right?
Get that out of your dome.
Sorry, Papa John.
He's never been in the pizza category.
Chicago stuffed deep dish pizza, or just stuffed or stuffed pizza, is actually a take on an
old Italian Easter pie.
A double-crusted, cheese-filled thing called, bear with me here, Scarsidia.
Scarsidia, Scarsid, Scarsidia.
That.
That thing.
Holy ----.
And yeah, obviously I'm butchering that name, but the build is unique here, right?
Dough is on the bottom, all the cheese and the fillings go in next, then a second layer
of thin dough is put on top of that, and then the sauce goes on top of that, right?
So, two crusts, one pizza.
The story starts in a small town near Turin, Italy, with a woman named Mama Giordano.
She's famous around town for one dish, her Italian Easter pie.
Then, her two sons, Efren and Joseph, carried that recipe across the ocean to Chicago's
south side.
And in 1974, they opened the first Giordano's and turned their mom's famous Easter pie
into stuffed pizza.
And that name went everywhere, man.
Giordano's.
This is one of a small handful of places in the city that stopped being a restaurant and
kind of turned into a landmark, right?
It's where to meet, it's where to take your cousin when they want to visit, it's the
give directions, buy it kind of spot.
But the thing I love about it is who eats there.
Now, Chicago likes to argue, right?
They'll literally argue about everything here, from neighborhoods to, you know, politics
to ketchup.
But Giordano's, man, Giordano's has always been there.
Now, were these two brothers the literal first people to ever invent stuffed pizza in this
town?
That's a genuine bar fight, right?
I'm gonna let the historians keep swinging on that one.
But Giordano's is the name that took this thing mainstream and made the rest of the
country care about it.
That part is definitely not up for debate.
So, just like pan and deep dish, stuffed is technically its own creature.
But, again, to use the metaphor to beat it to death, it's hanging from the same branch,
right?
It's on that same tree, just stuffed with cheese.
All right.
I know that was a lot.
But that is the map, more or less.
Four styles, one city.
Deep dish, tavern, pan, and stuffed.
Stuffed deep dish.
I did want to shout out to the Pizza Puff and the Double Dough Pizza, right?
They both deserve a little shout out too.
Maybe we'll do videos on those later.
Comment below if you want to see that.
So good.
Okay, before we go on, I gotta tell you guys about something that I've been working on
for literally months.
I haven't told anybody about this yet.
Giordano's and I have partnered up to make my very own custom designed stuffed deep dish
pizza that you can, as of literally right now, right at this exact moment, purchase
yourself on the internet and eat with your very own mouth.
Really, though.
Since I started making videos, one of the things that I've wrestled with, and I know
a lot of you feel the same way too, is that no matter how many OLED screens you attempt
to lick, you still can't taste what I'm cooking.
That changes today.
This is a stuffed deep dish that I'm calling the Great Chicago Fire.
Of course, named after the fire that leveled a chunk of the city and forced it to rebuild
into the metropolis that it is today.
A true phoenix rising moment, right?
And that's exactly what you'll be the second you take a bite of this pie, right?
A gorgeous, majestic arcane bird of myth and mystery.
Just imagine it.
I'm so sorry.
Okay, basically, if I could build and eat any deep dish on Earth, it would be this one,
right?
And that's exactly what I did.
Obviously.
It's a fiery deep dish loaded with a proprietary blend of Wisconsin's finest cheese, Calabrian
chili sausage, and pepperoni.
Again, both custom blends designed for more flavor and less grease.
Then it's topped with crunchy, spicy, fierce giardiniera, and finished with Calabrian chili
honey.
It took a lot of iterations to get here, and this is the one that I landed on, and I really
can't wait for you to try it.
It's really tasty.
So if you're into food with a bit of a kick, you're gonna dig this.
I know you will.
And if not, that's totally chill too, right?
There's a whole lineup of other pizzas that they offer on the website, so, you know, you
can choose from those.
No worries.
Which brings me to the best part.
You do not have to be in Chicago to get this pizza.
I repeat, this pizza ships nationwide, frozen, packed in dry ice, so it shows up at peak
freshness and is basically ready whenever you want to thaw it and bake it off.
So whether you moved away and you miss it, you've never had a real Chicago pizza, and
or you just want to try my food, you can grab your very own Great Chicago Fire stuffed deep
dish by following the link in my description.
And last thing, just a fair warning here.
When these things sell out, they're gone, right?
We're only making a limited run, so don't sleep on it.
So if you're looking for a way to support what I do here, this is it.
Every order goes straight back into the channel, which means that you're keeping these videos
going and getting a pizza night out of the deal, right?
And pizza night is always a good night.
You've earned it.
So grab yourself a pizza.
Thank you so much for being here and watching.
I appreciate it way more than you know.
Let's get back to the video.
So I went down to Giordano's to make two iconic pies and got to work side by side with
their executive chef.
Chef Jesse Harris, the corporate executive chef of Giordano's, pizza master himself.
What's up?
What's up, man?
How you doing, dude?
Good to see you.
Great to see you as well.
He walked me through the technique behind the iconic Giordano's stuffed pizza just
before showing me something very new and very exciting.
So stuffed pizza is what put these guys on the map, right?
Mostly because they just do it right.
It starts with homemade dough that's closer really to a pie crust.
So, you know, it's flaky and it's sturdy.
Then your proteins go down before the cheese or the sauce.
Today, it's a Chicago classic, which at Giordano's means pepperoni made from a 50-50
blend of pork and beef that's got less fat in it.
So it doesn't really get sogged out with grease.
Then you pile in an obscene amount of mozzarella sourced from our neighbors to the north in
Wisconsin.
And we all know if the cheese heads know anything, it's cheese.
Go figure.
This pizza is then topped with mushrooms, onions, and peppers before getting covered
with another layer of dough, officially crowning this as a stuffed pizza and not just a deep
dish.
An interesting move here is that they pinch little holes in the top layer to kind of vent
the steam and let it out while it bakes, which keeps things crispy.
Then it's topped with sauce, which is kind of where these guys differ from a lot of other
joints around town.
Where's the cheese?
Some of the sauce.
Right?
Most Chicago sauces are on the sweeter side.
You know, they're very herbaceous.
This is more sort of a sauce that you would maybe expect to find in New York.
Or dare I say, Italy.
It's lighter and relies on the freshness of the tomato for that sort of naturally sweet,
bright, acidic punch that you expect from a great sauce.
Finally, it's dusted with parmesan, then slid into a ripping hot rotating carousel
oven.
And boom, that's your classic Chicago stuffed deep dish.
Now, I gotta keep it real with you.
When I heard Giordano's was releasing a tavern style pizza, I was skeptical.
I mean, this definitely is not the style that these guys are known for.
And I didn't think they could make something that stood up to some of Chicago's most iconic
tavern style spots.
There's a ton of people that do tavern style really, really good in this city, right?
Whether it's one of these new school spots or a place that's been established, you know,
one of the more classic pizzerias.
And Giordano's is definitely not known for their tavern style pizzas.
And I really didn't think that they could stand up to some of these, you know,
iconic Chicago establishments.
And now looking back on all of this, I'm able to admit that I was completely wrong.
First, they laminate mozzarella directly into the dough in two stages, right?
Almost kind of like making a croissant.
They add the sauce on edge to edge like usual,
but you're going to notice that it goes on pretty light.
The Wisconsin maz comes in, then you top it with whatever you want.
For me, that's usually going to be hot Italian sausage and hot giardiniera,
aka Italian hot pickled peppers, right?
You gotta have the giardiniera.
Try it if you've never tried it.
And then, and I've never seen anywhere else do this with tavern,
more sauce gets dolloped on top of the pie, which is actually a really nice touch.
Then parmesan cheese and oregano goes over the top to bolster that classic pizza energy.
And again, boom, you got Giordano's tavern pizza,
which are three words I'd never thought that I would put in a sequence, but I'm glad that I am.
Cheers, brother.
Not only is it laminated, it's super crispy.
And you get these like cheese chips in it.
Like you were saying, that frico that creates these air pockets
and gives it a completely different experience.
Like you can't make that up.
I know.
You can't make it up.
Caramelization of the cheese, the texture of the sausage, that super crisp bottom.
The dollop move is incredible.
Yeah, right?
Yeah, I was skeptical at first, but I love how thin you go.
It's basically just like almost like,
and you don't even care if like some of the more watery bits of the sauce gets it.
As long as it's kind of like covered in that liquid for a tiny little bit,
it counts as being sauced and then you finish it with the dollops.
And to me, sausage and jarred in a tavern style pizza is just about as Chicago as anything gets.
Just as Chicago as an Italian beef, a Chicago dog, et cetera.
I got to keep it real.
I was extremely skeptical when you said that you guys were coming out with this tavern style pizza
because you guys are, Giordano's is deep dish.
It's one of the iconic, like Mount Rushmore's of deep dish pizza.
So to hear that you guys were doing tavern style, I was like, how could it be good?
Are they just following the trend?
Like, you know, blah, blah, blah.
You blew my mind with this one, man.
Oh, here we go.
Here's the, here's the secret.
Okay.
The lay and then with a spatula, you got to cut it.
There you go.
Yum, dude.
Then it's so buttery too.
Oh, the crust is where it's at.
Get a little of that into the sauce and the cheese in there.
It's like strong enough to hold up to the cheese and the sauce and not sog out,
but it is still tender.
You know what I mean?
When you do that first slice, the temperature of the pizza has hit perfectly.
It's about 10 degrees less than when it comes out of the oven.
The actual perfect, perfect, perfect temperature for a cheese pull is 167.3 is what we found.
Write that down.
I think we're going to get a tad at 167.3.
That's kind of sick.
People are like, dude, 312.
It's like, no, 167.3.
Thank you for coming in, man.
I really appreciate you coming in and spending some time.
It's always fun to talk food with people.
Talk shop.
Awesome, brother.
I hope you guys enjoyed this video as much as I liked making it.
If you liked it, give it a like.
If you're new to the chan, sub to the chan.
If you're not new to the chan, welcome back, friend.
I'm going to shake your hand.
I want to shake his hand.
The best way to support is, of course, trying my new pizza, the Great Chicago Fire,
which again, you can cop in the link below, right?
Off of Giordano's website.
It's shipped straight to your door.
It's really good, guys.
I spent a lot of time and energy on it.
I know you're going to like it.
Give it a try.
That's all I got for you.
So until we meet again, take care now, okay?
Okay.
Over there.
Take care over there.
Take care now.
That's my Chicago accent.
You're going to happen in 2024.
Chevy's a two-tone Suburban.
You're going to put a plow.
You're going to do your own lot.
You know, we do our own lot.
Shout out that guy.
Do your own lot.
Al, Al Storch, Al Storch, Al Storch.
