#permaculture#foodforest#vegetablegarden A dense food forest can look like the perfect place to squeeze in even more crops but not everything wants to grow under a canopy. In this Q&A, Geoff explains what works in the shade, why most annual vegetables still need plenty of sun and how food forests and kitchen gardens can work together rather than compete.
This video is taken from Geoff Online Permaculture Design Course, where students bring their own questions into weekly Q&A sessions and explore how permaculture principles apply in practice.
Key takeaways:
Not every food forest is heavily shaded, and crops such as taro, yams, ginger and cassava can occupy lower layers where conditions suit them. A food forest can be managed for higher production by opening the canopy and cutting support species harder, or left denser for lower-maintenance, more casual production. Most annual vegetables are better suited to a sunny kitchen garden rather than being squeezed beneath a mature food forest canopy. Groundcovers and shade-tolerant species can still play important functional roles beneath fruit trees, helping occupy space and support the developing canopy system. The same plant can behave differently depending on where it is grown — sweet potato can function as food forest groundcover, but moving it into a sunny, mounded garden can produce a much larger root crop. Ultimately, food forests and vegetable gardens are different systems designed for different kinds of production, and good design puts each crop where it performs best.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video discusses the strategic placement of plants within a food forest versus a traditional vegetable garden. The speaker explains that while food forests utilize dense, layered systems for long-term canopy establishment and low-maintenance production, annual vegetables require full sun and should be placed in clearings or on the edges of the forest to maximize yield.
All right, Rory has a question here.
I see Jeff drawing food forest very densely,
but the video footage tends to show
more open space with ground covers.
In my experience thus far,
gardening many crops seem to need a lot of sun.
If I transplant crops under dense trees,
their growth usually halts.
How do we determine what species will mix well
in a layered, dense system like a food forest,
and which ones are better suited
for open, sunny vegetable gardens?
Well, not everything grows in the shade,
and not all food forests are as shady as this one,
that's for sure.
So we choose our crops that like the shade,
and it depends how much production we want.
I've got cocoa yam there, there'd be cassava,
there's climbing yam, there's gingers,
there's taros, there's a chocolate pudding fruit there,
ice cream bean here, mango here.
They're all the way through,
there's little track running through.
Pretty dense, because I don't want to do a lot of work.
I've got a lot of food forest,
I don't need it all in full production.
It can be in casual production,
so I do very little work,
and I get well and truly enough fruit.
If I wanted more fruit, I could open it more,
I could cut the support species back more,
I could do more work of that cutting and fertilizing,
and I'd get more production on the fruit trees.
I like to show that you don't have to do that,
I know you can do that, we can show examples of that.
When it comes to vegetables,
you mean your vegetables you eat in your main annual garden,
with a few perennials of course,
but your annual garden needs full sun,
six hours of sun, it doesn't fit in a food forest.
It fits on the edge of a food forest,
it fits between a food forest.
Our kitchen garden here is in a clearing in a food forest,
it gets the nutrient runoff from the food forest.
There are some plants that will grow in the shade,
but most here is just ground cover function,
and occupying the space of the weeds and cycling nutrient
to favor the long-term and very long-term canopy
establishment of large fruit trees.
Understory fruit trees that don't mind the shade,
they fit in as well.
So you do check out, what's a garden crop?
You don't grow carrots in a food forest,
they need full sun, you don't grow potatoes in here too.
You can grow sweet potatoes,
and they'll grow as a ground cover,
but if you want a really good crop,
with a lot of sweet potato roots,
you move them into a garden, you put them on a mound,
and you get a really good root production.
So you rev up the function in the full sun,
and you put them to functional interactions
in the food forest, because the main assembly
is going towards a canopy productive ecosystem.
They're horses for courses,
they're different types of systems.
Some interact both ways,
but most of your production is in more full sun,
and of course in the end, the full sun's going to be
on the canopy of these large fruit trees
on the top of the food forest.
So you're on your way there,
you can go quicker if you want to do more work,
or you can go casual and get there anyway.
It all just depends which way you want to play it.