New Mazda 3 Review – Better than a VW Golf?

POP Cars
24 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
When the Ford Focus was in its pomp, it was often cited as the go-to car if you wanted
something that was not just practical and usable, but fun to drive. The trouble is,
the Ford Focus is long gone now, so can the Mazda 3 fill the breach? After all,
it's built by Mazda, who also, as many of you will know, build the sporty MX-5 convertible,
so it knows a thing or two about adding a bit of zestiness into a car.
But what about all the other elements of a family hatchback, things like ride and refinement,
interior quality and the infotainment system? All those things, if you get right, you don't just
make a good family hatchback, you make a great one. In this review, I'm going to tell you how
the Mazda 3 competes on all those fronts, and I'll tell you which engine and trim we think
make the best combination. Plus, I'll also tell you what options, if any, you might want to consider.
But first, let's have a little look at the overall design, and I'm going to quote here,
because Mazda says that the Mazda 3 hatchback is a true work of art. Blimey, they're not backward
in coming forward, are they? It's designed to spark joy and exhilaration in every situation.
Well, to be honest, it's raining and miserable today, so I'm not exactly feeling joyous and
exhilarated. However, I take their point, it's not a bad-looking car, is it? Mazda calls this
design language Kodo design, which is all about creating taut, muscular, dynamic presence.
And arguably, it demonstrates those qualities. But what I really like about the Mazda 3,
in a world of complex, over-designed cars, it's just simple design, simple elegance.
And then there are some nice details as well. Take the headlights, which start at the front
wings here and then come around, pointing into the grille. And although it's got a big grille,
it's not exactly too big, it's not too fussy. And then you walk around the side,
and there's, again, a purity to the design. Yes, you've got some defined bits like that,
but then there's a lot of curved surfaces that give it a nice flowing form. And that also follows
around to the rear of the car, which is, again, clean and simple, but with some nice design
touches like the twin exhaust pipes or these ringed taillights, which, when you put the
indicators on, don't just come on and off like a normal car. They come on really brightly,
then fade out in pulses, which is meant to emulate a heartbeat, make the car feel alive,
a living, breathing thing, which, of course, it isn't. But the point is, it's not a bad design
for something that came out in 2019. It's hardly looking old and withered, is it? In fact,
I'd even argue that it looks quite premium. But the good news is the starting price isn't.
While a BMW 1 Series or Mercedes A-Class starts at around £32,000, and the price of a Volkswagen
Golf begins at about £30,000, the Mazda3 range starts from a much more reasonable £25,300.
That's if you go for the entry-level Primeline trim. That's about the same as a basic Seat
Leon hatchback. And it's not even like it's some bare-bones box on wheels. Even the entry-level
trim comes with 16-inch alloy wheels, reverse parking sensors, a rear-view camera and bright
LED headlights. You even get some really nice safety features that you'd have to pay a lot
extra for on a lot of premium cars like blind spot monitoring. But we'd recommend stepping up
to centre-line trim because for an extra £1,600, which pushes the price up to a not unreasonable
£2,600-£2,900, you get some really nice luxuries. Things like heated front seats, keyless entry,
an auto-dimming rear-view mirror, a wireless phone charger, a better stereo with eight speakers
and dual-zone climate control, rather than just plain old manual air conditioning. Not bad, huh?
You do start to degrade the price of arches, though, when you're moving up the range to
going up to Homura trim, exclusive line, or what we have here, which is Takumi. That's because
you're moving then very near to those premium rivals, things like the BMW 1 Series, the Audi A3
and, of course, the Mercedes A-Class. However, if you do spend the extra money and get one of these
instead of one of those premium alternatives, you'll get more toys because you'll get things
like rear privacy glass, black 18-inch alloy wheels and adaptive LED headlights. Earlier on,
I said I'd let you know what options to go for, but the truth is there aren't that many.
Metallic paint, £650, or if you want this particular crystal red, that's £950. Other
than that, it's just a bunch of accessories. So, for example, you can get sportier lower bumpers,
you can get sportier side skirts, but perhaps more usefully, you could go for a detachable tow bar,
a boot organiser or a floor protector. And what about engines? Well, no plug-in hybrid option,
nor even a self-charging hybrid option, just a choice of two naturally aspirated petrol engines.
And I say naturally aspirated, that's quite unusual. Most of the rivals in this class come
with turbocharged petrol engines, but we would go for the cheaper of the two, the 2.5 Skyactiv-G.
That comes with 138 horsepower, which is good enough for 0-62 in about 9.5 seconds or 9.8
seconds if you go for the auto. Now, that's not especially quick, but it's fine. The main thing
about this petrol engine is it's really efficient because it'll actually average over 47 mpg.
The engine in this car is the more powerful petrol engine, but it's only available in the
more expensive trim, so they're pushing up the price again. But it is more powerful with 183
horsepower, which drops the 0-62 time down to 8.1 seconds with the manual, although you can
have an auto if you want to as well. The weird thing is, you know I said that the entry level
engine is a 2.5 litre. This more powerful engine is a 2 litre, so it's smaller. I won't go into
all the details of why, because it's all about how the engine works. Effectively, this engine
in the Skyactiv-X works a bit like a petrol and a diesel combined. That does make it very efficient
though, so you know I said the 2.5 litre engine did 47 mpg. This one does over 50 mpg officially,
and the CO2 emissions are only 126 grams per kilometre, which is actually really good for a
2 litre petrol engine. In fact, that's fewer emissions than some of the smaller engines in
rivals like the Seat Leon. As I mentioned though, it does push up the price. The minimum you'll have
to spend to get this engine is £29,795, or if you want the top spec Takumi trim like this one,
it's £33,295. So this is a family hatchback, so let's have a look and see what the hatchback is
like. Well, actually, do you know what? Space isn't too bad in there. We managed to get six
carry-on suitcases in the back of the Mazda3's boot, which is one more than a Vauxhall Astra
and a Volkswagen Golf. Actually, that's the same number of suitcases we managed to get in the back
of a Honda Civic. However, if you want the best load lugger in the class, that's got to be the
Skoda Octavia. So what else about the Mazda3's boot then? Well, it's not the best thought through in
a number of ways. First of all, the hatchback opening, it's quite narrow compared to some of
its competitors. And look, there's a massive drop down to the boot floor here. And also,
if you've got anything heavy to load over, you've got to get it over that big lip as well. Then
there are no handy cubbies in the boot just to store little loose items. There's no height
adjustable boot floor, and there's not really much storage space under the boot floor either.
Plus, if you want to fold the 60-40 rear seats down, which by the way, apart for the course in
this class, most cars do get 60-40 rear seats. But it would be nice if you could fold the rear
seats down from some handles on the side of the boot, but you can't. So you have to go and walk
round and do that from inside. But when you do fold the rear seats down, you get a reasonably
flat extended load area with no great step up in it. So overall, it's a bit of a mixed bag,
but generally practical boot. But what about the rear seats? OK, as you can see, this is not an
area of strength for the Mazda 3. Because yes, I'm tall. Yes, that seat is in my driving position,
so it's very far back. But there aren't many cars I don't fit in the back of. But the Mazda 3 is one
of the ones that I don't. Look, and I'm not messing around here. My foot is sticking outside the door,
so I can't actually close the door. And I really can't get my right foot underneath the driver's
seat. But even if I magically made the seat move forward, just to at least allow me to fit in,
and close the door, I'm not exactly experiencing business class travel in the back of here. Look,
my legs are jammed in the back of the seat. And while I've just about got enough headroom,
if I really wanted to lean back, no, that's not going to work. And if I've barely got enough
headroom in this seat, I'm going to have next to none in the middle seat because I can see
that's raised up. And you've got a large central floor tunnel, which is going to make it really
awkward for your feet. Basically, it's not the best in the back. So if you need something bigger
and you're regularly going to be traveling with adults in here and you don't want to give them
back problems, I would suggest you look at something like the Skoda Octavia or Honda Civic.
Oh, now I've had the osteopath pummel me back into shape. I've got the space to breathe up
the front here, and I've got enough room as well. Not the most room in the class,
but I have enough legroom, enough headroom, and look, even enough width that I'm not feeling
compressed and I can put my elbows out a bit. And the storage space is good as well. Because look,
under here, the center armrest, I've got a handy divider that I can divide this nice
reasonable sized cubby up with. I've got two cupholders down here and I can put a bottle
of water in the door bins because they're a good size. I've got a nice wireless charging pad for my
phone and even a decent sized glove box. And then there's the driving position, which is also really
good. First of all, top marks for having two really nice, comfortable armrests either side
for my elbows. And then there's just the basic architecture. So, for example, the seating
position, the pedals, everything feels right, plenty of adjustment. So the reach and rake
adjustment in the steering wheel is really good. And because this is the Takumi edition,
the top spec, I've got electrically adjustable seats with adjustable lumbar support. Now,
the only thing is you only get lumbar support with this trim. You can't get it on any other model.
So that is a bit disappointing, but the seat is generally supportive on long journeys.
It's a little bit narrow, so you could feel if you're a bit wider, a bit broader, a little bit
hemmed in and maybe a little bit more shoulder support would be good. And then there are the
dials. I really like the dials because it's almost unique these days to have analog dials. There is
a digital display, but it sort of incorporates a traditional looking speedometer. So I can bring
up functions like my trip info and infotainment stuff in there. But overall, it's a really clear,
simple layout. And that extends to everything else because look, I've just got an array of simple,
straightforward physical buttons. And let me show you something.
Look, if I put my hand over my eyes, I can still turn the temperature down half a degree or one
degree. So it was on 19. I now know it's on 18. And that is the difference between having physical
buttons over having to do everything through an infotainment screen or touch sensitive buttons,
because you can do it by feel. Obviously, you're not going to drive down the road with your eyes
closed. But what it does mean is that if I can do that, I can keep my eyes fixed on the road,
therefore be more safe. And that is something that the master three has in common with other
cars that we like in this class, like the Honda Civic and a big advantage over things like the
Volkswagen Golf. And it's not just me saying that because Volkswagen itself has said that they've
made a mistake in putting too many touch sensitive buttons or loading everything into a touchscreen.
And they are going to also bring back physical buttons. Speaking of touchscreens, we do have one
10.25 inches, but you can only use it as a touchscreen when you're stationary. The rest
of the time you've got to use this physical controller, which is very much like the BMW
iDrive system. And actually, they've got rid of it on the latest one series, which is a real shame
because it's really easy to use. I can just easily flick through all the menus, press down to select
something. And again, I can do all of that while I'm broadly speaking, looking at the road. The
only time you realize there's a little bit of a limitation is when you're using Apple CarPlay,
because that is a system that's really designed just to be used for a touchscreen.
And actually trying to scroll through the menus on Apple CarPlay with this wheel can be a little
bit of a protracted process. But we'd still have this over just a purely touchscreen system. While
I'm being a bit critical, the screen itself isn't as sharp and the graphics aren't as high end as
some of the systems out there, but it is actually really responsive and the menus are pretty easy
to use. It comes with an impressive array of features too. So all trims have inbuilt sat nav,
wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and you get wireless charging, as I mentioned earlier on.
And because this is the top spec Takumi trim, we've even got a 12 speaker surround sound stereo
system made by Bose, which sounds really premium and high end. And that's not the only thing that's
premium high end about the Mazda 3, because look at the interior. Now, bearing in mind, this is not
one of the most expensive cars. It's not even one of the sort of mid price cars in this sector,
but it outscores things like the Volkswagen Golf and the BMW 1 Series when it comes to interior
quality. Because look, everything here is soft touch material. I've got some lovely neat stitching
across there, and it's the same with the tops of the doors. I've even got with this Bose stereo,
these really nice aluminium speaker grills, which is something you tend to get on really premium
models. And this gloss black finish around the centre console feels pretty good at this price
point. But it's not just the finish of the materials, it's how everything works, like the
buttons, because these have a nice click to them. And it's the same with the rotary controller for
the infotainment system. It all feels, dare I say it, like an Audi, but not one of the modern
Audis because they've sort of dropped the ball. It feels like an Audi of old in here. In fact,
the interior in this car is so good that we voted it the best in the family car class in the 2026
What Car Awards. Now, I mentioned that it's good to keep your eyes on the road a little while ago,
but that's not always easy in the Mazda 3 because of visibility. So these front pillars are
relatively thick, but they're also quite close to you and angled, so they can tend to create a few
blind spots at junctions. If I look out the back, well, as you can see, that's pretty terrible. So
if all round visibility is something that's important to you and your next family car,
have a look at things like the Skoda Scala instead. But at least the Mazda 3 does come
with plenty of parking features. As we mentioned at the start, it comes with rear parking sensors
and a rear camera on every trim. This trim's got front parking sensors and also a 360 degree
surround view camera. Another advantage of going for this Takumi trim is that you also get
adaptive LED headlights, which are really good because they can stay on main beams longer at
night without blinding other people. But to be honest, even the standard LED headlights in the
rest of the range, they're pretty good too. So now you know pretty much everything there
is to know about the Mazda 3, except what it's like to drive. So earlier on, I mentioned that
the engines in the Mazda 3 are naturally aspirated. And I did that for a reason, because it's different
from most of its rivals, which are turbocharged. Rivals like the 1.5 TSI Gold, for example.
And that makes a big difference. So let me explain. If I was in a turbocharged car right now,
and I put my foot down at, say, 1,500 rpm in third or fourth gear, when I put my foot down,
there'll be a moment's delay while the turbocharger just took a little time to spool up.
But then it's like a big performance pump energising the engine and off you'd go. But because
this car doesn't have a turbocharger, it behaves rather differently. So for example, let's just
drop down to, there we go, 1,500 rpm. And if I put my foot down, nothing really happens. It's picking
up speed gradually, but it's hardly electrifying until we get a bit higher up in the rev range.
And you can see just then it starts to pick up. And that's all down to something called torque.
Now, a bit of a mysterious science to some people, but essentially it's just a twisting force. And
the more of it you have, the more effortlessly the car gets going. And that's why turbochargers
are great, because they produce a lot of low-end torque. And that's why any turbocharged car will
generally feel a lot livelier at low revs. Now, you can get over that with this car by revving it out.
So I said it would do 0-60 in 8.1 seconds. And once you start revving it, yes, it gets up there
quite quickly. So as long as you keep the revs up high, the car's fine. But it's just when you're
driving normally, ambling along, that you just miss that extra drivability. And that's the other
reason why we recommend the 2.5-litre, the cheaper engine, because remember, this is the one that
you're paying more for that performance. And yes, it's there when you rev it out. But when you're
just driving normally, the 2.5-litre feels pretty much similar in terms of performance. Now, the
other thing about this engine design is because you need to work the engine harder, you're probably
going to be using the gearbox a lot more as well. Now, the good news is with the Mazda3 is it's got
one of the best gearboxes in this family car class. It feels really nice and precise and positive.
So it's actually quite a pleasure to change gear in the Mazda3. And actually, if you're the kind
of person that enjoys driving, you enjoy the interactive process of driving, it's really good.
And it's one of the reasons why we'd stick clear of the automatic because not only do you lose that
level of interaction, but it also dulls the performance even more. The other thing about
having to rev this engine out a little bit more is obviously you're going to hear a bit more noise
from it. Yes, it is more vocal, especially when you're revving at the top end of the rev range.
But the good news is it's not an uncouth engine. It doesn't sound coarse or grating like some cars
can. And actually, that's how the rest of the car comes across. Because look, a Volkswagen Golf
produces a bit less road noise at 70 miles an hour. However, the Mazda3 isn't a noisy car,
not when you're taking wind noise and road noise into consideration. In fact, you can bowl along
at 70 miles an hour, having a nice conversation with your passengers without having to raise your
voice. And also, we talked about the gearbox, how sweet that is. The clutch pedal is also really nice
and easy to use. So you're not going to be making any weird jerky starts. And the same applies to
brake pedal. Actually, it's almost not sensitive enough because you really have to put quite a bit
of effort into stopping the car just at the top of the travel. But the thing is, that does make
it really easy to predict once you just get used to it. So in stop start traffic, the car's not
kangarooing around. And then we come on to the ride. And this is where there's a bit more of an
issue because this car is set up relatively firm. Now, it's not punishingly so. So along a road like
this, with lots of sort of reasonably rounded off undulations, it's it's kind of dealing with
those quite nicely, soaking them all up. But compared with something like a Volkswagen Golf
or the Toyota Corolla or the Honda Civic, which are softer cars, it does tend to struggle a bit
more over broken surfaces. So really patchy tarmac. But where it's really bad and really
comes across as a bit jarry is if you're on a motorway, you hit a ridge with both front wheels
at the same time. Wow, you really get a thwack for your seat. And when it comes to ride, that's the
bit that really does great a little bit. And what about the handling? Because that was the question
I asked at the very start of this video. Has a little bit of Mazda sporting DNA rubbed off on
the Mazda 3? And the simple answer is not really. It's not a bad car to drive in the sense that
go through bends like this. And when I turn the steering wheel, the car goes round them. That's
all you really need at the end of the day. And it doesn't really have an awful lot of body lean
because it's quite firm. But the thing is, where's the fun? That's what the focus was great at.
It didn't just deliver a car that went round corners. You enjoyed driving it because you
enjoyed interacting with it. So why do I not enjoy so much interacting with the Mazda 3?
Well, grip. It hasn't got as much grip as some of its rivals, especially on roads like this,
a little bit damp. You can suddenly find just enter a bend with a little bit too much speed
and the nose just starts running wide. It's not bad. It's still got the stability control to help
you out, but it's just a bit unnerving. It's absolutely a bit of confidence. And then there's
the steering just doesn't connect you quite as much with the road surfaces. The best cars are
certainly not something like the focus used to do. And it focus had really nicely weighted
steering, whereas this feels sort of a bit lifeless, a bit heavy. And it's also a bit
slower than you'd expect. But the real bugbear for me isn't quite self-centered properly.
Now, when you let go of a car steering wheel, it's got this self-centering action. It's meant to
go back to the straight ahead. So you don't have to do that. But in this car, if I just leave it
a little bit turned to the right, the car just stays there and carries on drifting over to the
right. Now, it's more exacerbated by certain cameras in the road and it's worse at lower
speeds, but it will still do it on motorways as well as 70 miles an hour. Now, normally,
if you make a lane change on the motorway, you don't have to consciously think about returning
the steering wheel to center. So you carry on driving straight, do you? It just happens
intuitively because the car does it for you. Whereas in this car, there are times when you
think I'm still drifting. Oh, I've got to do it, have I? And you have to steer it. That is a bit
of a pain. And that is why dynamically the car that's taken over the mantle from the Ford Focus
isn't the Mazda 3, it's actually the Seat Leon.
So we've established that the Mazda 3 isn't the second coming of the Ford Focus 10,
and it's got some other weaknesses. For example, it'd be great if it had a plug in hybrid version,
because if you're a company car driver, as efficient as those engines are, that is the
cheapest way to run a company car these days. But perhaps his biggest issue is the rear seat space,
which, as you can see for me, is pretty useless. But it would be fine if your kids are a bit
smaller and there is a reasonable boot. And that brings us on to the Mazda 3's good points,
because it's OK on the road. It drives perfectly well. It's perfectly comfortable. But where it
really, really scores well are things like efficiency, that great interior. And let's face
it, you're getting all that for a bargain price because it's one of the cheaper cars in the class
and it's really well equipped. So it's not the best family car you can buy at the moment,
which, in our opinion, is the Honda Civic. But it's got some great attributes. And if
those attributes tick all your boxes, the Mazda 3 is still well worth considering.
Thanks for watching this video. If you liked it, don't forget to subscribe to our channel.
If you want to see another one just like it, head up there. Or if you want to read all about the
Mazda 3 or any other new or used car, head over to whatcar.com just there.
