Should you buy a USED Tesla Model Y?

Ex Used Car
15 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis evaluation of the Tesla Model Y as a used vehicle weighs its industry-leading technology and utility against significant build quality inconsistencies and steep depreciation. While praised for its safety, acceleration, and charging network, the car faces criticism for its minimalist interface, thin paint, and specific mechanical wear patterns.
Here's a question for you. Is one of the world's most popular cars any good as a used car or is
it just aging tech that you really should avoid? Well, you know what? That's exactly what we're
here to find out because this is ReDriven and we take you through all the pros and cons of used
cars so hopefully you don't buy a ---- one. ReDriven is powered by WiperTech. More on them
later. In the meantime, scan that QR code. How about we start with something very controversial.
Compared to China, it seems the Americans really suck when it comes to these. See,
in countries that receive both the Chinese and US-made model wires, the consensus is really
clear. The Shanghai-built models boast far superior build quality. In fact, in these countries,
both the owners and the service centers have confirmed that they receive far fewer issues
with the Chinese-built model wires. And look, this is great news for us here in Australia because all
of our model wires come from China. Not so great if you're watching this in the US because all of
your cars are made in America. I'm really sorry. However, Chinese-built does not equate to
perfection. How about we dive into the common issues these things can suffer from no matter
where they're made? See, plenty of owners have complained about sudden unexpected braking when
the car's on autopilot or even just random speed changes when it's in cruise control.
Now, this often happens on the freeway or if you're going under an overpass or if the system's
just misread a speed sign or misdetect an object. Now, best case scenario, this can just be
startling and kind of shock you when it happens. But worst case scenario, there have been reports
of cars getting rear-ended because someone behind them isn't expecting the car to suddenly jump on
the brakes in front. Also, owners have had a problem where, say, you try to avoid a pothole.
Well, the lane keep assist can try to take over and sort of forces you back in line again.
This can be especially bad on country Australian roads where there are no road markings or the
edges of the road are a bit unfinished. The car can just get confused. Also, it seems like
no matter sort of which iteration of car or software update, these kind of problems still
persist. Although in Tesla's defence, this isn't necessarily a Model Y thing. It seems like every
newer car that we feature of late have these sorts of safety system complaints with them to the point
that they can almost feel dangerous. Still, it's incredibly important to remember that the Model Y
is still one of the safest cars money can buy, to the point that you might be safer driving one of
these than you are when you're tucked up in bed. The next issue that owners have experienced no
matter where the car is made is just poor paint quality. But again, like so many new cars that
we've featured of late, the paint is just so thin that it can mark and scratch and chip really
easily. But on these, other owners have found that it can almost start feeling like it's made
of latex. It's like it's a bit not that solid. But look, the hot tip from owners here is that if
you're driving in conditions where stone chips and crap can just hit your car all the time,
get the thing PPF'd. Also, the panel gaps and how some of the trim kind of lines up, it could be a
bit, I don't know, interpretive on some of the earlier cars. Although this has been improved
with the more recent models. Unless your car's made in the US, because apparently they can still
have some pretty hectic panel gap issues. Unfortunately, though, no matter where it's
made, these could have a problem where the tailgate was so misaligned, it could let water
into the boot. Now I say could because Tesla did issue a service bulletin to fix this water leakage
issue. So if you're looking at one on the used market, just make sure that this has all been
Also, there are a few complaints that the window glass can sort of misalign over time. So when you
close it, it doesn't quite match up with the body. But I have a theory on this. If you're having this
problem, I reckon it's your fault. See with a frameless door, if you close it by pushing on
the glass, that puts enormous amounts of stress on all the mechanisms in the door. So when you're
opening and closing the door, actually use, actually use the door, not the glass. Also,
the Juniper update has fixed this. Just sounds a bit, sounds a bit cheap and nasty. On the Juniper,
it sounds very, very premium. Also on glass related issues, a few owners have had problems
where the little wiper nozzles have become blocked. This is generally fixed under warranty.
But the problem is some owners that have had it fixed under warranty, the problem has just come
back again. So just make sure it squirts correctly. But as the old saying goes, a squirt is only as
good as its wipe. And if you want 15% off and free express shipping on some of the best wiper
blades in the business, scan that QR code to get a set of Wipertech blades. They're the only ones
we use because they are so, so good. And they're a great Aussie company. Show them some love and do
yourself a favor. Actually, you know what? On second thoughts, don't do any of that if you're
going to do what Sam has done and lend us your car to feature. If you do that, we're going to give you
a set of Wipertech blades for free as a thank you present. To volunteer your car, there's a link down
below. Get it. But another global common complaint is that on some of the earlier cars, up till about
2023, there have been reports of the steering wheel material delaminating. This is especially
common in hot climates like here in Australia. The good news is it's generally always covered
under warranty. And from 2023, the material's improved and they don't really have a problem
anymore. Actually, just on the whole materials improving thing, Tesla have taken on quite a
Toyota or Lexus approach with these. Rather than having major updates every year or two,
these have just sort of constantly evolved and improved as the life cycle has gone on.
There was a substantial update in 2025 with the Juniper update. That has been the most
comprehensive update these have had since their launch back in 2020. In fact, Tesla have stated
that over 50% of the parts are brand new. It also seems like the build quality and overall NVH levels
have been improved. And I'll tell you what, that is saying something because this is a base spec
rear-wheel drive car with a few Ks on it, and the NVH levels in this are really, really impressive.
Okay, there are a couple of little rattles here and there, and it can feel like the whole chassis
has a bit of a slight shimmy thing going on, but these are terrible roads. Overall, pretty bloody
good. Also, some of the owners of the early 2022 cars have complained that the ride quality was
quite harsh, even to the point of being crashy. In fact, one owner we spoke to said that his 2022
Model Y had the worst suspension he's felt in a car in 20 years. But look at this one. Okay,
it's a little bit on the firm side, but it's not harsh or crashy at all. It feels quite well
controlled. I think for like a family-friendly SUV like this, it would be nice if it was a little
bit cushier, but then there's a lot of weight going on here. So to be kind of dynamic through
the corners, it's got to have a bit of firmness to it. It's not the best suspension I've experienced,
but it's certainly not the worst. Also, the Juniper Update Model Y, apparently that has
improved the suspension calibration substantially. Although, as any Model Y ages, there is another
problem with the driving experience that can pop up. Actually, I should say, can jiggle about. But
this is more of a mechanical complaint, so it does make sense to actually throw to an actual mechanic
to explain what's going on here. Luckily, we have Jim. Now, the rattling and clunky that these things
are known for is typically coming from the upper control arm bushes, which often wear prematurely.
Now, more often than not, these are getting fixed under warranty, and some owners are having to get
them done twice within the warranty period. But that does seem to be more of a problem for the
early build cars here. And another issue with the worn up control bushes is wheel alignment. Now,
these things are already very heavy on tyres, so the slightest issue with alignment makes it much
worse. And because typically these don't get serviced every year like a typical ICE car, often
the tyre wear isn't even noticed, and most certainly the tyres aren't rotated to make the tyres last
longer. So it's a big problem with these. And another thing, if you're hearing a bunch of clunking
and rattling from the suspension, have a look at the stabiliser link pins. They often wear and
rattle like crazy, but that's actually every car, not just these cars. And because these have
regenerative braking, the brakes just aren't used as much as an ICE car, and actually that can lead
to issues. Sometimes we see the actual disc rotors rusting up, and the slides on the calipers can
seize as well, and all these can actually make the brake pads wear unevenly too. So while you might be
saving money on brakes initially, you might end up having to do a whole brake overhaul just because
you're not using them as much. Another suspension related issue can also apparently cause premature
tyre wear. But in this situation, we kind of think it's to be expected. See, owners of some of the
performance models have reported that the inner part of their rear tyres can just wear really
quickly. But we're talking about a nearly two-ton vehicle that can do zero to 100 kilometres an hour
in three and a half seconds. With that amount of performance on tap, and the weight of the car,
I think just extra tyre wear is something you're going to have to deal with. But while we're out
here, another common complaint we found, and I completely agree with the owners, are the bloody
door handles. It's not that there's something that goes wrong with them, it's just a stupid design.
And now look, this isn't just something that's exclusive to Tesla. Plenty of other manufacturers
are doing this with this whole flush door handle thing. But why take something that is so commonly
used, and should be just completely intuitive, and then make it more complex? Like, you've got to
push there first and then pull open. Why make it more complicated than it needs to be? And look,
sorry to harp on about this, but look, if you're right-handed in a right-hand drive car, this kind
of makes sense because you just push your thumb and it opens like that. But I'm left-handed, so
it doesn't make sense for me. Unless I get in the passenger side. Because being left-handed over
here, this makes sense. But if you're right-handed over here, again, it's just stupid. I think we
have a solution. Welcome to 1997, and look at this. It makes sense. One movement. Who would have
thought? Before you go making excuses for Tesla going, oh no, it has to be flush for aerodynamics,
I call complete bullshit on that. Look at this. Completely flush. This surely isn't an aerodynamic
disaster compared to that bloody thing. And not only that, if they can design and engineer all
the other amazing things on this car, surely they can get a door handle right while also being
aerodynamic. That shits me. And I hate to say it, but the same goes for this thing. But look,
before we get into the negatives here, let's focus on the positives. This screen has now been
superseded by the Juniper. It's slightly larger. But even with this, it's still one of the fastest
screens and most responsive I have ever used in any car at any budget. Plus, even though there's
no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto as such, which kind of can suck, it's such an intuitive system,
and it's so in-depth on what you can do. It runs Google for navigation, so that's ultra-intuitive,
and we've all used that a million times. But then some of the other fun things, like you've got this
arcade function, you've got a toy box function. We don't have time to go through what this system
is capable of, but it is outstanding. Also, even the sound system is outrageously good. It's one
of the best you'll hear in any car at any budget. And the camera quality is exceptional. Check this
out. Like, that's fantastic. Just shush, shush for a second. But you also get like little distance
kind of calculations when you're backing up to something, so that's wonderful. And if that's
not enough, thanks to the over-the-air updates, sometimes you can wake up in the morning and have
new features and functions, or if there's been any kind of weird infotainment gremlins happening,
they can just get fixed due to that update. But the negatives. It sucks that everything is
operated through the screen, and I mean pretty much everything. Okay, yes, you have these little
multi-function little wheel ball-y things on the steering wheel, but you've got to go into a menu
first to tell these what to actually control. We're talking adjusting the mirrors, the air vents,
the windscreen, the mist, the steering wheel position, even the glove box all require you to
actually use the bloody screen. And if you're trying to do this while you're driving, especially
on a bumpy road, and you're trying to find the icon, well you've got to look at the screen to
try to find what you want, then you've got to kind of aim your finger at it and hope that you're
hitting the right icon. Honestly, I agree with the owners here, it's bloody dangerous. In fact,
numerous studies have concluded that having to use a touchscreen in a car while driving
is substantially more dangerous than actually having physical tactile buttons and knobs.
In fact, one study done by the UK's Transport Research Lab found that using a screen like
this while driving can slow your reaction times down by more than 50%. And to put that into
perspective, that level of driving impairment to your response times is actually worse than
driving at the illegal blood alcohol limit or driving under the influence of cannabis.
And before you go defending Tesla saying, oh yeah, but it's all through a screen because
Tesla have a software-first philosophy and the whole visual minimalism is what the brand is
built on, that is complete bullshit. It is cost-cutting, as simple as that. Look, tactile,
physical buttons and knobs and controls cost a fortune to design and engineer and manufacture,
let alone make right for both left and right-hand drive markets. Ditching all that to have purely
a mass-produced screen that just requires simple software updates has saved Tesla millions,
if not billions of dollars. But the real cost here is the user experience or lack of,
or more seriously, your safety. Speaking of which, even the speed that you're travelling
is displayed on the centre screen, so you kind of have to look across to see the speed. There's
no head-up display. Now, look, I'm sure you get used to this, but even like the old Toyota Echo
and Yaris where they had their speedo in the middle of the dashboard, I just feel like looking
across to see your speed isn't intuitive at all. Again, you'll get used to it, but I just think
it's a bit annoying. Also, Tesla phased out the ultrasonic parking sensors from about 2023,
instead relying on the TeslaVision camera system. But the problem with this can be that sometimes
it can struggle for accuracy in really tight parking scenarios, and it can also struggle
at night time. Also, if you'd rather not rely on the cameras and the sensors, there's a bit of a
blind spot with the C-pillar. It's a decent chunk of a thing, so just judging the rear of the car
can be a bit of a challenge when you're parking. But look, luckily the cameras are really good
quality, so when you are parking it at daytime, it's an absolute breeze. In the front of the car,
it's really easy to judge where the car ends, so parking is a breeze. Although, for some cars,
they no longer have sort of the beeps and boops for your parking sensors. Why? Why would you get
rid of that? Look, it's super handy that you've kind of got like the distance graphic to show you
how far you are away from the thing you're backing into, but wouldn't it be nice if there was just a
button to turn on or off the parking sensor sound? But driving this thing also raises the big elephant
in the room, range anxiety. But how often do you travel more than 300 kilometers in a single trip?
If you said, well, all the time, yeah, maybe an EV isn't for you. But if you said, well, hardly ever,
actually probably never, well in that case, range anxiety for these shouldn't be an issue for you.
Look, depending on the exact model, the claimed WLTP range varies from about 514 kilometers to
622 kilometers. Although as we know, those WLTP ranges are about as reliable as my biological dad
and I haven't seen him in decades. But in the real world, owners are experiencing anywhere from about
300 Ks to a smidge over 500 kilometers, which surely for most of us is plenty, right? As long
as you can charge it at home or work, which I can't. See, this is where Tesla Model Y ownership
can really depend on your particular lifestyle. I've tried to live with multiple different EVs,
including pretty much the entire Tesla range. And as much as I want to have one, it just simply
doesn't suit my lifestyle. Charging becomes a nightmare. Honestly, the whole car has become
an inconvenience no matter which EV it is. This situation might be completely different for you,
and that is completely fine. But before you buy one of these or really any EV, seriously have a
look at your lifestyle and work out if you're okay for the car to dictate how you drive. Luckily
though, Tesla does boast Australia's largest and possibly most reliable fast charging DC network.
Although there are some other costs involved here that we haven't discussed yet. You know what,
let's do the good news first because the bad can be honestly bloody confronting. Unlike plenty of
hybrid cars out there, these things can suffer from catastrophic levels of depreciation. The good
news is that a used Model Y seems to offer incredible value for money, but our condolences
if you bought one of these new. Now this horrific depreciation can be due to the market trends,
the absolute onslaught of cheap Chinese EVs coming into the market, and even Elon testing
his customers loyalty when it comes to discounting these things over their lifespan. But so many
Model Ys have shed massive chunks of their original value. To put this into perspective,
you can now pick up an older base model for a smidge over $30,000 at the other end of the
spectrum and near new mint condition performance. That's going to be asking around about $85,000
on the used market, but you've got to remember that's a $10,000 discount on a car that's not
even a year old. Also the Model Y frequently loses value faster than its rivals like the
And look, while this depreciation obviously it will slow down as the cars age, you got to think
about how quickly battery and just vehicle tech in general is improving. So early models of these
could start feeling really old pretty soon, and there's a good chance that's going to drop the
values even more. And the bad financial news might not end there because the insurance premiums on
well, a premium. Now to put this into perspective, a really good mate of mine owns both a Model Y
and a newish 250 series Land Cruiser Prado. But the Model Y costs more to insure than his Prado,
even though the Model Y is insured for less than half of what the Prado is. And the reason that
the insurance premiums are so high is because just fixing these can ask a lot of money. There can
and there is a bit of a lack of Tesla approved panel beaters and repairers out there. So it just
all sends the insurance prices up. It's bloody annoying. And look, obviously the insurance
premiums can have as much to do with your situation as the actual car you're insuring.
But before you go diving in, just crunch the numbers because there's a chance that
these don't make as much financial sense as you might anticipate. But let's focus on some more
positives here. Aside from the questionable user experience of the screen, the interior layout,
this design, while controversial, is just beautiful to look at. It's a really lovely place to be.
Even the ergonomics, there's so much adjustability to the steering wheel, in the seat. It just,
it's just right. I don't know if I'm kind of getting the message across, but it just,
when you sit in this and get the positioning right, it's just a chef's kiss. Beautiful.
Even as far as living with it, absolute breeze. You've got two wireless charging pads there for
your phone and they're also kind of felt line so things don't rattle around. You've got more
storage under here. Another little shelf here. Two cup holders that unfortunately don't have the
little fingery things to hold my small pretentious coffees. And I know from experience, when I put
like a little oat piccolo down there, it does kind of get lost. It's a bit annoying. Under the armrest,
you've got even more storage under here. A little tray, this is removable, so there's even more
storage under there. And then in the doors, great size door bins and they're felt line so nothing
kind of rattles around. And there's a glove box, which I've got to go into here to bloody open.
Imagine if it had like a button or a latch to open it. Amazing. Also, as far as other common
problems with these interiors, aside from the ones we've already mentioned, honestly, hardly any.
A few really high kilometre examples might have a tiny rattle here and there, but it's not a
major problem. And those little rattles are probably just going to be more obvious because
of how silent the car is. The white seats, actually just on the seats, they are incredibly comfortable
as well. But the white seats, sometimes they don't play nicely with new blue denim jeans. They can
kind of get stained, although that is easily cleaned, both the jeans and the seats. Actually,
if you want a huge range of cleaning products, not to mention aftermarket suspension parts and wheel
and tyre packages and dash cams and hi-fi gear, scan that QR code, type in your Rego and the
Automotive Superstore site will show you all of the accessories that are best suited to your car.
And they're mates of ours and they ship Australia-wide. Check them out. Also,
some international owners, especially those that are in really cold climates, have had a few
problems with the heater pump playing up. Sometimes it's a software issue, other times it
can be a mechanical problem. But generally this is sorted with an over-the-air update or under
warranty if it's something mechanical. But here in Australia, these things have hardly any heater
or air conditioning problems at all. Although some owners would prefer the feeling of it just
blowing on their face, or at least their sort of the upper torso area, maybe this is just an
Australian thing that we like the feeling of things blowing in our face. But this isn't really designed
for the flow to hit you directly. It's more designed for the airflow to just kind of fill
the cabin with a different temperature. In the back seat, I'm exactly the same height as serial
tweeter Elon Musk. This is in my driving position. Cop the amount of space back here. Heaps of knee
room. My feet are just having so much fun. I've got slightly bigger shoes on today than I normally
wear as well, but I don't feel at all claustrophobic in the foot department. Seats themselves could be
a little comfier. Needs a little bit more squidge, a little bit more support, but they do the job.
And all the materials back here, again like the front, just feel great. And again, according to
the owners, even if you've got ---- children that try to abuse everything, the resilience is really
good. Although a quick note back here, thanks to the enormous glass roof in hot climates like here
in Australia, this can make the interior of the car feel like it's the same temperature as the
fiery pits of hell. Likely with the Tesla app you can pre-cool your car, and some models even have
a camp mode, so it keeps the interior temperature of the car really consistent. Although I reckon
having to deal with a scorching hot car interior is just a fundamental part of being an Australian,
so don't use the app or pre-cool your car. Just toughen up, princess. Although also on that app,
it can be used for a whole bunch of different functions, from being used as the car's key if
your friend wants to drive the car, through to showing the car's battery status, and a whole
bunch of other things. It's actually really good. But as far as features and practicality back here,
on the updated Juniper models, they have an eight-inch rear passenger touchscreen that
controls climate and entertainment, and it even has a Bluetooth head support for two headphones.
And in this car, you've got air vents, beautifully integrated USB-C ports, matte pockets on the backs
of the seats here. I think this little storage compartment, I'm pretty sure that's an aftermarket
one. I don't think that comes factory. Door bins, good size, and you can actually get to them when
you've got legs and the doors are closed. That's a nice change compared to other cars. You've got a
pull-down armrest, I think. Yep, pull-down armrest here, with a couple of cup holders there.
These do have the little fingery things to hold my small pretentious coffees, so why didn't they
include it in the front? That's annoying. I think that's about it. That's about it for features and
practicality back here. It's a really lovely place to be. And then in the boot, compared to the
alternatives, this actually has one of the smaller boots out there. Don't stress, it's still a copious
amount of space, and a good shape too, so it's very, very usable. Also, the standardised measurement
system really only tells part of the story with these. See, under the floor, you'll find another
105 litres, and with the seats down, loads of space. Heaps of room. And not only that, unlike
plenty of the competition, this also has 117 litres of extra space in the front, so surely this is
enough space to make life easy? Something else that makes life really easy is just the huge
dollop of instant torque. Oh, wow. And look, I know that now we have EVs that can do 0 to 100
kilometres an hour in under three seconds, and quarter miles in, you know, 10 seconds and under.
A base-spec rear-wheel drive Model Y seems almost pedestrian, but this thing can do 60 kilometres
an hour to 100 kilometres an hour in just 2.6 seconds. That's basically the same performance
figures as a Volkswagen Golf R, a Subaru WRX or a Hyundai i30 N. They are all celebrated performance
cars. This thing can match them for the critical kind of overtaking speeds, and yet it's a sensible
family SUV. This thing is plenty fast enough in the real world. Overtaking, pulling into traffic,
an absolute breeze. If you are a psychopath and you need more performance than this,
the Model Y performance, honestly, that thing, that is so fast it feels like it's rearranging
your internal organs. But look, it's all good and well that these things go like a scalded cat.
What about things like battery degradation? And are they as mechanically reliable as the hype
suggests? Well, this is really another question for Jim, isn't it? Now, before I answer the battery
questions, first of all, in Australia there are two types of batteries delivered in the Australian
Model Ys. There's the LFP, which is the lithium-ion phosphate, and the NMC, which is the nickel-based
lithium-ion. Now, I'm not going to bore you with all the details, but the LFP is more tolerant of
a 100% charge up. It's typically more thermally stable, but it does have slightly lower energy
density. The NMC has a higher energy density, typically have a longer range, but doesn't really
like being charged to 100%. The LFP in the rear wheel drive is fit for purpose for most buyers.
The NMC in the long range and performance is better for the buyers who want that.
But as a consumer in the real world with regular use, you're really not likely to
notice much of a difference. Both are very reliable, and as far as battery degradation
goes, look, ignore the internet haters. Most owners are seeing between 85% and 90% battery health
right up to and beyond 200,000 kilometres. But it's not all good news. Sometimes these
batteries can suffer if there is a heat pump problem. Now, the heat pump system and the HVAC
systems on these cars, it's a very complicated system. And with complexity and time brings
problems. And at the moment, most of those problems are being covered by warranty, but that
warranty won't be around forever. And the same can be said for the drive units. They're not
problematic now, but as time goes on, they are likely to see some issues. They can have some
internal bearing issues, which you will likely hear. And although the Model Y is not known for
a coolant leak in the drive unit, other Teslas are, it might be an issue on these later. We don't
know yet. Typically though, when that does happen, it's a very expensive fix. And because these don't
share any other parts with any other cars, really, in the long run, you're still going to have to get
these parts from Tesla and they will be expensive. Okay, so should you buy one? You know what, Tesla
are going to hate us saying this, but we certainly wouldn't recommend buying a brand new one. So with
such steep depreciation, even for models that are only a year old, why not save thousands of dollars
and just buy a slightly used example? Many still have warranty left on them, but it's not like
they're going to break down anyway, and all the over-the-air updates should keep a used Model Y
pretty fresh for the foreseeable future. Still, make sure you get a full pre-purchase inspection
and make sure it ticks all of the, you know, critical pre-purchase boxes. Also, just make sure that an EV
is actually going to suit your lifestyle. But really, the only other reason we'd be cautious
on buying a used Model Y is due to the fact that there are some absolute other bargains out there
in the used EV space. And if you want to see what they are, go and watch this. And in the meantime,
why don't you smash that subscribe button? Honestly, it helps us more than you know.
And why not share this video with all of your EV and Tesla-loving friends,
even those that hate Teslas and EVs? A few owners have had problems with the
little... And I'm going to tell you if she be... And I'm going to...
