This housing market update from Steven Thomas of Reports On Housing explains why condominiums have become a weak spot in today’s housing market. The analysis examines softer condo values, elevated HOA dues, rising insurance costs, inadequate reserves, special assessments, and financing challenges that are putting additional pressure on attached housing. It also breaks down the latest Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac changes and why new HOA reserve requirements could further restrict the condo buyer pool heading into 2027.
👉🏼 "Housing Debrief" - Season 7, Episode 32 👈🏼
Not a subscriber? Go to www.ReportsOnHousing.com and use the coupon code "CONDO" for a free month.
*The content in this video is accurate as of the posting date. This is not investment advice.
Time Stamps: 00:00 Introduction 01:13 Detached Home Price Trends 04:14 Why Condos Are Falling Behind 05:32 A Slight Buyer’s Market 06:07 Mortgage Rates Add Pressure 07:33 Why Condos Are Struggling 09:41 Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Changes 10:38 New HOA Reserve Requirements 12:03 What Happens to Condo Prices Next 13:01 The Homeownership Stepping Stone 14:12 Conclusion
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi there, it's me, Stephen Thomas, Chief Economist at Reports on Housing.
Today we've got another housing debrief and this week we're focusing on housing's weak spot,
which happens to be condominiums. So there's been a definite condominium slowdown for attached homes
and we'll explain really what's going on. Condos for a lot of young families or young kids
getting into homeownership, they first buy condominiums and it's kind of like the stepping
stone to later on down the road purchasing a single family residence home. So that's what
condominium complexes have been for years. It's been that stepping stone for so many different
generations. But let's get into the nitty gritty of what's going on with the condominium slowdown.
Why is it happening? And before I do that, I always forget to do this. I'm just going to be
really brief. I'm asking you to, if you like this channel, subscribe, like the video. I appreciate
it. It helps out with YouTube algorithms. I'll move on. And this is the Zillow Home Price Index.
Now, Zillow gets each of the individual houses wrong. And we've talked about that before. But
as far as broad macro areas, they're pretty decent. And it's pretty decent like this through
all the different home price indices that are out there. There are a number of them. There's Freddie
Mac. There's the Intercontinental Exchange, ICE. And there's plenty of them that are out there,
Case Shiller. So just know that these home price indices are better than following medians.
It's a little bit more precise. And Zillow not only does it for metro areas, they do it by county.
They also bring it down to the zip code level. And they have detached versus attached, which is
pretty fantastic. And they've been doing this for such a long time. They've got this,
they have an AI machine in the background that they've been constantly working on with
millions and millions of data points that they've been working on for such a long time.
So they get the macro areas right. They just don't get that micro area in each specific house.
But let's talk about the Zillow House Price Index for detached homes. We're going to compare that to
attached. And you can see that values went up, the Great Recession towards the left.
And then still a bit surely over time, about 5% per year, it went up from 2012 all the way
through 2019. And you could actually see that spike during COVID. And then it came down in 2022
slightly and then went up in 2023. And it's kind of hit a plateau at this point. So know that that's
what's going on. It's up 5.1% since August of 2022. So that's been four years, it's gone up 5%
and this is across the United States for detached homes. Every metro is different. And like I said,
they actually have this by the zip code. If you want to see more, you can go to Zillow Research
Data. But as far as Zillow is concerned, it's up 5.1% since August of 2022. And now we're going to
look at the Zillow House Home Price Index on a monthly basis. And you could see on the right
hand side, it's slightly positive for detached, but the prior two months, that was July, but the
prior two months were actually slightly negative. And so these are what the numbers look like. It's
up 0.3% year to day. So that's since January, it's up 0.3%. And if you look at year over year,
so July of this year compared to July of last year, it's up 1.1%. So not a lot of juice in
any direction. It's kind of flat. That's that balanced market that we've been talking about.
And there's nuanced changes on a monthly basis, as well as there's a different seasonality to
housing as well. We have a Stevenomics episode that we just released. It is regarding the
seasonality of housing. But you can see right now, prior two months were negative. This month was
positive for July. It's only up 0.03% month over month. So that's basically nothing. It's gone
absolutely nowhere over the last month, but the prior two months were a little bit negative,
I think down 0.2%. And so this is attached. It's a little bit different. It too went up like crazy
during prior to the great recession and then came down and then from 2012 all the way to 2019 was
a really good bet. And then during COVID, it went up like crazy and then it came down in 2022. And
then it went up and then it has come down a little bit since. So if you really want to know, it's
only gone up 0.2%. So basically it's done nothing since August of 22. It's been flat. Well, hasn't
been flat. It's come down, it's gone up and it's sideways, come down a little bit. And if you want
to know what the numbers look like recently, this is what they look like. What you can't see here is
July. Why? Because it's up 0% year over year. And it's down 0.4% since January. It's down 0.5% year
over year. And you could actually see that it was positive for many months when we had low interest
rates below 6.5%. And that started like in October, September, October, November, December,
January, that type of thing. But we have July that was zero. And then you have the three months
prior. So you have April, May, June that were all negative months. Now it was positive for the month
of July, but you need to know that things could change from here to the rest of the year. And I'll
explain what's going on. Really what we've had, and we're seeing it in all markets. We have a
supply and demand. There's a bit more supply than demand. And it's just slightly, but it's enough
to create a bit of pressure on the market. So really what's going on is there's a tug of war.
And we've talked about this as well. Many different times between home affordability,
buyers are pulling back because interest rates are a little bit higher than they were even earlier
this year. And homeowners are pulling back because a lot of the homeowners don't really have to sell.
But buyers are pulling back a little bit harder because of where interest rates have gone. And
you can actually see that earlier, prior to the Iran conflict, we were at 5.99%. And we were there
for like three days, 5.99, 6, 5.99. And then the following Saturday, February 28th, we started the
Iran conflict. And ever since then, it has been going up. And since the start of August, it has
been hovering right about 6.75%, has not changed much at all. So it's at 6.75%. And that's a lot
higher than where we were at six. That's three quarter percent higher. And that's going to take
the gas, a little bit of the steam off of buyer purchasing power, as well as buyer demand within
the marketplace. And it's just boils down to the reason we have higher rates is because of the
impact of rising fuel costs and oil. Oil goes up and pretty much every kind of commodity out there
requires gas, although we're not seeing that big of a push yet in core. And we're not, you know,
all commodities as well as services haven't really gone up. But the longer that the oil
lingers on, the more that you're hearing louder and louder that the Federal Reserve might be
increasing the federal funds rate. And that's what's actually built into where interest rates
are at today. Interest rates go up based upon where the market thinks that that needs to go.
And right now, there are at least two hikes that are built into where today's interest rates are
at 6.75%. So it all has to do with oil and the Iran conflict. So you're wondering, okay, well,
why then at the end of the day are attached slower than detached? What's going on with
condominiums? And really what it boils down to is there's a number of issues with homeowners,
with condominium complexes right now. And one of those is how high HOA dues are getting.
So HOA dues are becoming a bigger piece of the overall pie of homeownership. And you have to
those cannot be written off, those HOA dues. And then you have rising insurance costs. It's
like that for everybody across the United States, but it's like that for condominium complexes as
well. And insurance can get really expensive for condominium complexes. And for a variety
of different reasons, if you're in a tornado zone, or if you're in hurricane zones, or if
you're in wildfire zones, those are all issues that are compounding the problems with insurance
and how high they are. And then on top of that HOA reserves, there are a lot of reserves that
actually aren't adequate enough. So, and you're going to need adequate reserves in order to get
proper financing and have more buyers able to purchase a condominium. You have to have adequate
reserves. And there's also a lot of litigation that's going on across the United States.
We're a very litigious society. And as a result, when any of these, when any condominium complex,
homeowner association is, has a litigation against it, you can't get the typical conventional
financing. You have to get what is called, it's not really conforming. It's a little bit different.
So a little bit harder to get and requires more down. And it just limits overall lending when
there is litigation. So, and then we also have special assessments. There have been a lot of
special assessments to make up for lack of reserves and different problems with condominium
complexes. So there's been a lot of special assessments when you have problems with
balconies or things need to be redone, repainted, all that stuff that's done through. A lot of
times they don't have enough in reserves and they're not collecting enough. They actually
charge special assessments to all homeowners within an area. So, and then starting on August 3rd,
this is interesting. Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, they used to have something called a limited,
it's a streamlined project review. So there was limited and streamlined project reviews and that,
it had very limited documentation and that's no longer in existence as of August 3rd, 2026.
And now it requires lenders to conduct a full review of the condo association's finances,
reserves, funding, insurance coverage, and building conditions, which means that there
are more complexes out there that won't be able to get Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae,
what we call conventional financing. So because that is an issue and it just starts to limit the
buyer pool that's able to purchase, which puts more pressure on pricing. And as there's something
else coming up on top of it. So there's, I've talked about all the different hurdles and then
on August 3rd, a new hurdle. And then on January 4th, even another hurdle, and that is condo reserve
requirements are rising. So that's starting January 4th, 2027. Once again, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae
HOA reserve allocation is not only 10% of what your annual budget, it's now 15% of the annual
bundle. They need to have that in reserves. Now, if they don't have that in reserves, they
want to continue to have conventional financing. They're going to have to make up for it either
with higher HOA dues, or they have special assessments to make up for that. And so if
they don't, the warrantability is at risk. So if they can't submit it to Freddie Mac and Fannie
Mae, their guidelines, then it has to go outside of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac government financing.
And when you go outside, there's a smaller buyer pool once again, because not as many people
qualify when it's no longer backed by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. So that's a further hurdle that is
coming on January 4th. So they're going to have to get non-qualified mortgages if they do not
meet Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae standards. So all of these combined, everything that I just
mentioned, as well as these changes on August 3rd and the changes coming up in January of 2027,
just puts even more pressure on pricing. So there was already pressure because of everything that
I had mentioned, and the pressure is just increasing. But at the end of the day, as far as
the detached and attached, the attached market condominiums is going to be slightly less than
where what's going on with detached. And what we project is going to happen for the rest of the
years, there's going to be some pressure on pricing. Well, there's going to be a bit more
pressure on pricing for condominiums. But we're not going to see plunging prices. We've explained
why in many different episodes. It really upsets all those people that are plugged into that
narrative, that narrative that crash is going to happen. Prices must come down. Nobody's buying
homes, which is simply not true. Four million people have been buying homes for four years now,
and they continue year in, year out, four million. Normal would be 5.2 million, but we still have
four million buyers within the marketplace and a whole bunch of sellers that don't really have
to sell and not enough homes. Currently, our inventory is way less than where it was prior
to the Great Recession and during the Great Recession. So those are the reasons we'll get
plunging prices. And so that stepping stone is beginning to disappear for that stepping
stone to home ownership. And that's what's placing a bit more pressure on pricing for
attached condominiums across the United States. This is an issue. So once again, like this video
if you liked it, and please subscribe. Go to ReportsInHousing.com for more information.
The latest report that came out is AI pricing inaccuracies. No buyer, no seller should be
turning to AI to figure out what their price is. You shouldn't be turning to Zillow. Zillow is the
original AI, the best one that's out there, and it's not very good. And I've explained it in
various episodes. I just did a report on it, and this gets down to the nitty-gritty of how it's
just really kind of a starting point when you have a Zestimate or any of these what they call AVMs
that are out there that are giving you automated generated values. And when you receive those
values, it's just a starting dialogue because they can't see underneath of the roof, and there's
a myriad of things that they're missing. So if you'd like a free month, subscribe to one of our
many housing reports we have. We dot throughout SoCal, Bay Area, Phoenix, and Vegas. And this
coupon code for this episode for a free month is CONDO. So thank you so much for joining us for
another housing debrief. I hope you learned a lot. We're just here bringing you the truth,
bringing you the real data, the real stats, not a narrative, all the trend analysis, and we're
bringing it to you so you can make really good adult decisions. Thank you so much. I appreciate
it, and we will see you next week. See you on the other side.