The True History of Deep Dish Pizza

Chicago Cuisine
3 followers
Aug 22, 2026 #ChicagoCuisine
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the history and evolution of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, debunking popular myths about its origins. By recreating recipes from the 1940s and citing food historian Peter Regas, the host explores the transition from traditional Italian styles to the heavy, layered dish known today, while highlighting the overlooked contributions of key figures like Alice May Redmond.
Chicago-style deep-dish pizza has to be one of the most polarizing and controversial foods out there.
From John Stewart's famous rant,
It's a f***ing casserole.
to the feuds between fellow Chicagoans about which deep-dish pizza place is the best.
And since I am not one to ever sidestep a quagmire,
I have decided to jump into this controversy by making the first recipe from the 1940s
for what would eventually evolve into the modern deep-dish pizza.
So thank you to HelloFresh for sponsoring this video as I look at the sordid and controversial history of deep-dish pizza.
This time on Tasting History.
So I am back in my kitchen finally after like six weeks,
and I'm loving it. It looks different. Different is scary,
but frankly it's more user-friendly and since this is actually my kitchen and not just a set where I film,
user-friendly is good.
Unfortunately that did mean that I had to get rid of my beautiful gas oven.
And it was leaking and not great,
but that means I have a new oven that I have to christen,
and I decided what better to christen a new oven with than pizza.
And when deciding on a pizza, I decided to do Chicago deep-dish
and since this is Tasting History, I'm not just making a deep-dish pizza.
I am looking back in time to find one of the earliest recipes for Chicago-style deep-dish.
And one has to ask do you prefer Chicago-style deep-dish
or do you prefer a New York-style or just more traditional-style crust pizza?
I have to say I've always fallen into the traditional-style pizza camp,
but that's what I grew up eating like Peter Piper pizza and stuff,
but I actually didn't even get to try a real Chicago-style pizza until I went to Chicago last year.
I went to several places that served deep-dish and stuffed pizza.
We'll get into that, but I didn't go to the place that it all originated
which was Pizzeria Uno located at 29 East Ohio Street in Chicago.
It opened in 1943 and in 1945 newspapers around the country published an article
that had a recipe from the owner Rick Ricardo, not to be confused with Ricky Ricardo.
And I love that at the time pizza was such a novelty food at least here in the U.S.
that the author Gaynor Maddox had to explain what it was.
Pizza pronounced Pete-za is an Italian pie with a savory filling usually made of sausage or anchovies and cheese.
It's the after-the-movie snack favorite of teenagers.
Also I came across this old 1945 article while reading a modern article by Peter Regas
who is a Chicago-based food historian who is obsessed with pizza and knows like everything about it.
I was really, really impressed with his research and he just kept popping up while I was working on this video.
Anyway we'll talk more about him and his work in the history section of the video,
but this is the recipe section of the video.
And I'm actually going to be using two recipes to make this recipe
because the first recipe from 1945 has details on how to make the crust and how to make the sauce,
but in 1947 another article was published that detailed how to assemble a deep dish pizza.
Both recipes were written by Rick Ricardo so I feel like I can kind of mash the two together
to make one recipe that's like the pizza that he would have been serving around 1947,
and I'll put actually both full recipes on the website tastinghistory.com so you can see them,
but for the purpose of the video I'm mashing them together to make it easier to follow along,
and recipes should be easy to follow along just like the wonderful recipes from today's sponsor HelloFresh.
Now that I have my kitchen once again I can finally get back to making my weekly HelloFresh meals,
and I love making them because they're super easy and you don't have to go grocery shopping
because all of the ingredients are delivered to your door and they are pre-portioned
so there isn't even any prep work you can just get right to cooking.
They have over 45 weekly recipes to choose from including vegetarian and pescatarian recipes,
and my favorite they're quick and easy recipes like the shawarma spiced beef and golden raisin pitas that I made last night.
They only took around 15 minutes to make and they were as delicious as all of the meals that I've had from HelloFresh,
and it's not just their meals that are delicious but also their appetizers like these sesame ginger chicken gyoza
which I had for a great snack before filming today.
And right now both new and returning customers can go to HelloFresh.com
and use my code APPSTASTINGHISTORY to get free appetizers for life.
That is one free appetizer in every box while your subscription is active.
So use my code APPSTASTINGHISTORY at HelloFresh.com for free appetizers for life.
But I am making a main dish and that main dish is deep dish pizza.
Now the original recipe calls for making six pizzas and while I could probably eat six pizzas I'm not going to do that.
Instead I'm going to make one 12-inch pizza.
So to make the dough which is rather different than the modern style deep dish dough
what you'll need is one cup or 235 milliliters of whole milk,
one teaspoon of salt, two tablespoons of sugar, two tablespoons of melted butter,
two and a half teaspoons of dried yeast, two and a half cups or 300 grams of flour,
and two tablespoons of lukewarm water.
So first scald the milk by heating it to around 180 degrees Fahrenheit or 82 Celsius
and then remove it from the heat and whisk in the sugar and the salt.
Set it aside to cool to lukewarm as you add the yeast to the water.
Now once the milk is cooled you can add it to the yeast and then add in the melted butter and about half of the flour.
Mix the dough until it starts to come together then begin to add the rest of the flour in
but just a little at a time working it in before adding any more.
You may not actually even need all of the flour you just want to add enough
so that you end up with a smooth but not sticky dough.
Knead it for a few minutes either in a machine or by hand and then set it in a lightly oiled bowl,
cover it and let it rise for about an hour.
Then uncover it, then punch it down, knead it into a ball and set it back into the oiled bowl
and cover it and put it in the refrigerator for one hour.
Now as I said this recipe makes a very different dough than what you would typically have for a deep dish today
which has a lot more butter or sometimes even olive oil or other oils
to make it more like a short crust, kind of a crumbliness rather than bread-like
whereas this is pretty bread-like because it has a lot more gluten worked into the dough.
And just as the dough is different so too is the sauce.
First of all the recipe actually calls for canned tomatoes
and I'm thinking that maybe that was just for the purpose of the article
and that he used fresh tomatoes in the restaurant but I don't know so I am going to be using canned tomatoes.
Also the amount of sauce in that original recipe is not adequate
and I did not realize that until I was actually assembling the pizza
and then I looked closely at both recipes.
So the 1945 recipe is definitely for thin crust
and a just a little bit of sauce like you would find in Italy at the time.
Something though happened between 1945 and 1947
that totally changed the way he was making this pizza.
First he says that the dough should not be thin and he says that you should be generous with the tomatoes
so more like a deep dish pizza.
So I am doubling the amount of the sauce.
So use four cups of crushed tomatoes which you'll pass through a conical sieve
and then add one finely minced garlic clove.
Not nearly enough garlic in my opinion but there it is.
A quarter teaspoon of thyme, a quarter teaspoon of rosemary,
and a quarter teaspoon of basil and all of those should be dried rather than fresh.
Then one dried bay leaf, one teaspoon of salt, and one whole onion.
I thought that the onion would need to be chopped but if you look later in the recipe
it says to take out the whole onion so it's just a whole onion that he pops into the sauce.
Mix everything together and then add in four cups of water.
I also thought that this was kind of odd because you're just going to make a very watery sauce
but then you're going to simmer the sauce for two to three hours
and you're going to let all of that water evaporate until you have a nice thick sauce once again.
Now as the sauce cooks you can take the dough out of the refrigerator,
let it come to room temperature, and then spread it out into a circle
or whatever polygon I ended up making, and then set that into a cake pan that has been oiled with olive oil.
And you want to have the dough come up the sides just as you would for a pie.
Now I brought mine all the way up which to be honest is probably too thick
because if you look at pictures from the 1940s and early 50s the pies are not quite as thick.
They're only about an inch and I think I went closer to an inch and a half, even two inches.
C'est la vie.
Once the dough is in though you can cover it up and let it rise until the sauce is ready
and then it is time to assemble the pizza and this is where things get kind of weird.
See in that 1945 recipe it is getting assembled like a traditional pizza
with the sauce and then the cheese and toppings on top of that
but something happened by 1947 where that switched and the cheese goes on bottom
and the sauce goes on top which is what is done in a deep dish pizza today.
I just think it's cool that looking at these two recipes separated by only two years
we can see this very major change in how deep dish pizza was assembled.
Now what is weird, that's not weird, what is really quite weird
is that at the time you could have a cheese pizza or you could have an anchovy pizza
or you could have a sausage pizza.
You wouldn't get the cheese and the toppings
so it was sauce and one of those three things which I think is kind of odd.
So if you want to do sausage that's fine but you should omit the cheese
if you're sticking to this original recipe.
I'm playing it safe and just going with a traditional cheese pizza.
And to make a cheese pizza the 1947 recipe says that once the dough is in
you should fill the plate with thin slices of mozzarella cheese,
cover the cheese with tomato sauce and be generous with the tomatoes.
On top of the tomatoes sprinkle plenty of grated parmesan cheese,
a couple of generous pinches of oregano and some freshly ground pepper.
Then sprinkle with a few drops of olive oil all over.
Then you pop that into an oven at 500 degrees Fahrenheit, 260 Celsius for 20 minutes
or until it's done. This is a new oven for me so I'm still trying to gauge the time.
20 minutes was a little too long, darkened up the crust too much
so it ended up being about 18 but just keep an eye on it.
And while you do that we can talk about the rather controversial history
of Chicago's deep dish pizza.
Now there are numerous stories about the origins of the deep dish pizza
and frankly most of them conflict with each other so they can't all be true.
I have been won over personally by the story told by Peter Regas.
He is the food historian that I mentioned earlier because his research is fantastic.
Rather than just accepting the stories that are told he actually went and looked at evidence
from the period to disprove a lot of the falsities and half-truths in many of these stories.
But to uncover the truth about the history of deep dish we actually have to start
with the official and probably incorrect story that comes from Pizzeria Uno themselves.
The original home of the deep dish pizza.
See according to the company it was founded in 1943 by Ike Sewell and Rick Ricardo.
Ike being from Texas wanted to open up a Mexican food restaurant but Rick had never tried Mexican food
so they made some and Rick became violently ill and decided that he didn't like Mexican food
and so he fled to Italy for three months to come back with a recipe for pizza
and an idea to open up a pizza restaurant.
Well Ike was fine with that except being from Texas he thought that that Italian pizza was too thin,
too namby-pamby and that he needed a heftier everything is bigger in Texas style pizza
and so he wanted it deeper hence the deep dish.
Now you'll note that that version of events is from Ike Sewell
and he only started telling that story after Rick had died
and that my dear viewer is because it is utter codswallop.
For me the story falls apart right at the beginning when Rick tries Mexican food
and doesn't like it because how can you not like Mexican food?
But more telling is what Peter Regas points out and that is that in 1943
when Rick made his vacation to Italy to study pizza
he would have done so at the same time that the Allies were invading Italy
during the height of World War II.
Yeah that just doesn't really pan out.
Even more evidence comes in the form of leases and liquor license applications
that show that Ike Sewell was not really part of it for the first year pretty much
that the restaurant was going on and so that's probably why years later
Rick's then wife was quoted as saying Ike Sewell didn't know beans about deep dish pizza.
I think Sewell is a crook.
Now I don't know if he's a crook or not that might be going a bit too far
but a teller of tall tales most definitely.
What's interesting is that it might not have even been Rick Ricardo's idea
to make it into a pizza restaurant because it kind of already was a pizza restaurant.
See Rick and his wife lived in the building of Pizzeria Uno
or that would become Pizzeria Uno but when they were living there
the ground floor was actually a place called the Pelican or the Pelican Tap
and they served pizza but it was a really rough and tumble kind of place.
It probably actually closed down to a murder that took place there
and so when that happened Rick bought the place downstairs
and decided that he would turn it into a pizza place
probably because it was already fitted out with pizza stuff.
Mostly though it wasn't that he wanted to make pizza,
it was that he didn't want it to become the kind of place that it had been before.
Ricardo then living above the place bought it for a pizzeria restaurant
so that no damned noisy tavern with a jukebox could take it.
Now when it first opened in 1943 Pizzeria Uno was simply called The Pizzeria
and then it was Ricardo's Pizzeria or Pizzeria Ricardo
and had several other names before it finally became Pizzeria Uno
which is still what it's called and it's still in its original location
on Ohio and Wabash in Chicago.
Not long after they opened business was booming
so they opened another spot just down the street called Pizzeria Due
and many of Chicago's other famous deep dish places
like Lou Malnati's and Gino's East can also trace their origins
back to this original Pizzeria Uno
but those origin stories also are maybe not so true.
For instance Lou Malnati's, some often claim that Lou's father Rudy
was the original manager of Pizzeria Uno
and was the real genius behind the first deep dish pizza
but that ain't true because the original manager was Rick Ricardo's cousin
and after he left there was another guy named Gino Volpi
who was manager for a number of years.
It wasn't until the 1950s that it seems Rudy even appears as manager.
Now his son Lou, Lou Malnati also worked there as a bartender
and in 1971 he decided to strike out on his own
and open up his own pizza place.
Lou Malnati's now has lots of locations and I did eat at one
when I was in Chicago last fall.
Now the other spot that has ties to Pizzeria Uno is Gino's
and then Gino's East which were opened by Sam Levine,
Fred Bartoli, and George Laverdi
but while two of those guys were actually from Italy
later they admit we didn't know pizza from nothing.
So they had the rather bright idea of poaching the chef
from the most popular pizza place in town at the time
and at the time that was Pizzeria Due
and the head chef there was a woman named Alice May Redmond.
Now she had come to Chicago back in the 1940s from Mississippi
and she is the person who probably has the most effect
on what would become Chicago deep dish pizza
because she totally changed the style of the crust.
See she was working with the crust that we are making today
which is more like a bread dough
and she said that she had trouble stretching it into the pan
and that's because a bread dough kind of shrinks back in.
It is a little difficult to work with.
So she like doubled or even tripled the amount of butter.
Basically what she said that she did was
she used a biscuit recipe that her family had been using
to make the dough more like a biscuit
so she could stretch it out more
and that's kind of what it is today.
Now some say that she was successfully poached from Pizzeria Due
though her daughter said that actually
she was working at both places at the same time.
She was at Pizzeria Due during the day
and then at night she would go to Gino's
and it was only when somebody at Pizzeria Due found this out
that they said well you got to pick one.
Well she chose Gino's and she was there for a while
then she went to Gino's East
and it seems that wherever she went
that was the best pizza place in town.
First it was Pizzeria Uno, she was chef there,
then it was Due, then it was Gino's, then it was Gino's East.
So she should get a lot of the credit I think from making the best pizza
and yet she is the one person in this story
who never had a restaurant of her own.
Now it's also during this time period like the 60s and 70s
that so she's changed the crust
but also the pizzas start getting deeper.
They go from about an inch to an inch and a half to two inches
and they start playing with it.
Some people start making what's known as a stuffed deep dish pizza
and that's basically an extra layer of dough
and all of the stuff is on the inside and then there's stuff on top.
Just makes it even more like a casserole.
The place that made that stuffed deep dish pizza famous
is a place called Giordano's and I did go there as well
and that place actually I think has the best cheese pull
but it's just way too heavy.
Then there is Pequod's which I didn't get to go to
and they also do not have any connection to the original pizzeria Uno
but they were making deep dish pizza and they started putting cheese
like on the outside and kind of made a crust of caramelized cheese.
Next time I go really want to try that.
Now each of these pizza places in Chicago seems to have their fans
and their detractors and I think that it's like a favorite pastime
of Chicagoans to argue about which is best especially when talking to tourists
because I feel like a lot of the Chicagoans don't actually even go to these places
as much as the tourists do but I was a tourist so I went.
Anyway I'm not going to weigh in on what's best and what's not
except that I am going to weigh in on a pizza that isn't served anymore
because it is the original deep dish style pizza from the 1940s.
And here we are, Rick Ricardo's original 1940s deep dish pizza.
I mean look at that melty cheese.
It smells amazing but let's give it a try
and this is definitely a fork and knife pizza.
You don't pick this up with your hand.
Here we go.
That is really, really good.
So the sauce is a little more watery than I would like
and I think that that's just, I just needed to cook it a little bit longer
to let more of the water evaporate but the flavor,
the flavor is fantastic.
It is, I would like maybe a little bit more garlic but it is plenty flavorful enough
and that cheese, it's a nice good amount of cheese
and the sauce isn't too, too much.
Sometimes you get deep dish today and it's like 80% sauce, 20% cheese.
I'd say this is 50-50 and that's the way I like it.
One more bite.
And the crust on the bottom is, it's cooked.
It's not crisp but it's nice and cooked through and bready
but I am going to just take a piece of this crust which is really more like bread.
It is not like a traditional deep dish that you'd have today.
Get some sauce on there.
Mmm, nice and chewy, super flavorful.
I love it.
I gotta say it lies somewhere between modern deep dish
and something more like a New York style pizza
and I kind of like that.
Deep dish to me is just so heavy.
Two bites and I'm done for the day, I'm down for the count
but this, I could have several slices.
Now one more funny thing about that 1947 article.
So the author talks about you get cheese or you get anchovies
or you get sausage but someday when I'm very hungry
I'm going to try pizza with the mozzarella cheese and the sausage
and the anchovies.
That should be something.
This of course is how we eat pizza all the time today
with the cheese and the toppings.
There's no reason to choose between the two
and frankly he's right, it is something because pizza is awesome
and I will see you next time on Tasting History.
