What is the best time to eat your evening meal? - The Food Chain podcast, BBC World Service

Food and your body
293 followers
#health #food #healthyfood #dietfood
This video is an episode of the podcast The Food Chain from the BBC World Service. The content revolves around discussions with experts in circadian rhythms, nutrition, and food history to answer the question: is there a best time to eat your evening meal? The video analyzes how circadian rhythms affect metabolism, the importance of eating within the right time window, and how to arrange meals properly even for those with busy schedules or night shifts.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hello and welcome to The Food Chain from the BBC World Service. I'm Ruth Alexander and today we're
asking what time should you eat dinner? In some parts of the world the evening meal is served at
six o'clock sharp and others as early as four o'clock. Elsewhere not till nine or ten o'clock
even later. But when it comes to your health is there a best time? Joining me today are Dr Emily
Manoobian, a scientist from the Salk Institute in California. She's an expert in the circadian
Hi, welcome to be here. Sarah Berry, a professor of nutrition from King's College London.
Hi Ruth. And Professor Geoffrey Pilcher, a food historian from the University of Toronto in Canada.
Hello. So I've got to ask you all, what time did you have dinner yourself yesterday?
You know humans are actually very bad at knowing when they ate unless you write it down
but I think I actually ate around 6.15 last night. That's very precise. It was because I got my
daughter home from dance class and then we ate when we got home so I have a marker there.
Sarah, how about you? I would say yeah I had my dinner about eight and it was dictated as well
by my child care duties that I took my son carting and that's when we got back from carting.
When I had my last meal is a whole different matter so I'm quite a snacker so I probably was
snacking away until probably about 10.30. Not that I'm advocating for snacking here Ruth but
giving you an honest answer. Not just me then. I had yes I had some toast and honey about that time
having had my main meal about five o'clock and found I was a little bit hungry later.
Geoffrey, what time did you eat last night? About six, something around there.
So my next question is when should you eat dinner? Emily?
Really it's not any specific time on a clock. There's no universal magic hour.
From our point of view at least and I think really what's driving everything is the circadian system
which is an anticipatory system which helps your body prepare for what it needs to do
and that is coordinated by the light that you're around, by your sleep wake schedules,
all those other kinds of things. So depending on your environment and your schedules everyone's
going to have a little bit different time and I think the kind of easiest way to cheat that
answer is to say it should end at least three or four hours before you go to bed. So if you're
right okay so it's slightly different for everybody but that is a good rule of thumb
three or four hours before bedtime. And I think Ruth another point to add to what Emily said is
I think thinking about when you have your last meal should also take into consideration when
you have your first meal. We now know that having a smaller eating window and a period overnight
of at least 12 hours when your body is at rest, your body is not digesting food
for example, is beneficial for health and so if you are someone that gets up early and is having
your breakfast at 6am for example, you might want to consider bringing forward your last meal
a little bit earlier. To what kind of time? 6pm? I don't know you would have to finish at 6pm so
usually it's recommended to be like a 10 or 11 hour eating window so if you're starting your
breakfast at 6am you should probably be ending by 4 or 5. 6 I would say is the latest you should be
consuming something I think longer than a 12 hour window we see kind of some negative effects there
and usually the other side of that is because you're still trying to adjust it to your sleep
because of melatonin levels and other things that are going on we usually recommend people
waiting at least an hour after they wake up to go to start eating and so you kind of get this
if you say you're in bed for eight hours and then you don't eat for three hours before and one hour
after you wake up that's already a 12 hour window if you just stuck to that 12 hours you'd probably
be fine we usually recommend shortening it to 8 to 10 hours I think 10 hours is perfectly reasonable
and feasible for most people then you get this kind of magic window so then you can say okay
in that 12 hour span when do I need to eat is it I have dinner with my family at six or seven
because we're never going to say don't eat dinner with your family that's not feasible it's not
a great way to do it so if you're having dinner with your family at 6 30 and you want to count
backwards maybe you're doing 8 30 to 6 30 something along those lines but just like Sarah said if
you're starting to eat at six because maybe you woke up at five and there are early birds like
that then yeah you probably should be ending your dinner a lot earlier and you're also going
to be going to bed a lot earlier Jeffrey if our bodies are set up to eat relatively early in the
day why is it that in so many places in the world we eat late well let me start by just saying that
the whole idea of the meal is relatively modern for the first 200,000 years humans ate what was
called a one continuous picnic right where hunter gatherers would just munch whatever they found as
they wandered through the landscape and so it was only with the origins of agriculture about 10,000
years ago that it became convenient to break up the food preparation into a into meals and
you know for most people you would have a meal before you started work and a meal when you came
back from the fields because most people were farmers and as societies became more stratified
then people who were wealthy and powerful would eat their meals and when other people couldn't
as kind of a way of claiming status and so the ancient romans and medieval nobles the
chinese emperor would all eat their meals in the midday and not that they wouldn't have other
other kind of snacks later on and certainly they would but in some ways the dinner as such
is sort of a more industrial i think phenomenon of eating meals large meals later on
ruth i think you also raised something really important with jeffrey which is about how
different countries have quite different eating patterns and people often say to me but hold on
in the mediterranean they all eat a lot later and look they're so much healthier well what they're
eating is healthier the rest of their lifestyle often is healthier but actually if you look at
the distribution of their calories over the day whilst they're eating later the distribution is
very different so many mediterranean countries so spain portugal france and so forth they tend
to have their largest meal so the most calorie dense meal actually at lunchtime and so yes while
they're eating later in the day they're actually consuming less in the evening than for example we
are in the uk or people are in the us and there's now some good evidence from clinical trials
showing actually it's not just so much the timing it's also the weighting so the distribution
so if you're kind of front loading your calories so having more of your calories at breakfast and
lunchtime compared to having more of your calories maybe at lunch and evening time
that that's associated with less hunger better metabolic health fewer calorie intake so
and what's what kind of health problems can you end up with then if you if you eat too close to
the time you sleep and your body just isn't ready for that food can't handle it
sarah so this is still an area of emerging evidence what we do know like emily said is
how you metabolize the food is different so you have bigger blood sugar responses bigger
dips you have differences in hormonal responses to food you potentially have great inflammatory
responses as well after eating etc and so what we know then from large population studies is that
those people who are eating later the day because of these differences that we see mechanistically
are more likely to have poorer metabolic health so they're more likely for example to have higher
blood pressure potentially higher cholesterol higher rates of type 2 diabetes and so forth
there aren't robust clinical trials yet um you know with these clinical endpoints but we know
there's this mechanistic link and we know populations who and groups of individuals
within populations who are eating later tend to have a higher risk of many of these chronic diseases
i think that it's likely that inflammation underpins much of this um but yeah time will tell
emily you were talking about how like people can end up eating later you know because the sun's
shining outside you know in some countries um can the body like adapt to eating later on and
closer to bedtime or are you just is it just always going to be a biological problem so you
can kind of adjust your body's rhythms to some extent it takes in light food activity those are
the three main things that are going to affect your biological clocks and going to kind of set
that time the more consistent they are the more robust and ample and higher amplitude you can have
of those of those rhythms um but again it's gonna actively make it so you shouldn't be eating at
night on purpose right because when you're fasting you don't have sugar coming into your body right
and so you have to be able to you don't want a lot of insulin going around that would take any
sugar that got into the blood out of the blood so insulin secretion is actually suppressed by
melatonin which is also suppressed by light right so as things get dark melatonin gets higher and
that actually suppresses insulin so then you can't really take glucose out of the blood very quickly
um but at the same time that allows you to break down fat that you're storing break down other
energy stores that you have during the night and so getting that kind of fast in allows your body
to properly do that it also allows you to do other things in the body like you know repairing the
lining of your gut if you've got food coming through there all the time you're not going to be
able to properly repair that it's like trying to repair a road without actually closing it
it's not going to work very well um and if you think of it as a stimulant too you're you're kind
of giving these mixed signals to when your body should be awake right and so the more you can
kind of align all of these behaviors align the light with the food and your activity
the better the system can kind of work and then you'll be able to process food better
you'll be able to break down more fats all these things kind of come together and it can be shifted
a bit of course um but there's limits to that you still need to make sure you're getting enough sleep
and it needs to somewhat align with the light jeffrey do you think some of our ancestors maybe
knew some of this instinctively like back in the day do you think people were once more likely to
to you know eat like with their body rhythms well i think that if they did it was really more uh
accidental i mean that that was their life and um and and it just happened to coincide with what was
very healthy um it in terms of of modern changes right and and the the ways that industrialization
has posed imposed all of these uh these these rhythms of you know the time clock and the um
well the school bill which you know teaches us time discipline uh that these were sort of created
to you know for more efficient um you know factory production and uh and of course you know for people
especially people who you know may be on that second or third shift uh that throws everything
out of out of whack um but you know it's it it comes to be about the the efficiency of the system
rather than necessarily the the well-being of the workers who are you know we're in it so uh i think
that uh you know i think humans are on the whole pretty aware of what is going on within their
bodies uh and so uh but but then there's a lot of social pressure as well which may you know sort of
influence us to do other things i was just gonna say really quickly i think the social impact is
actually huge and i think when we had industrialization we had lights available 24 hours
and we had refrigerators available and you had access to food whenever you wanted it that really
changed a lot of things because a lot of times we're not eating because we're hungry we're eating
because of a social event or because of our schedules that dictate it or because you know it's
fun or an emotional eating or some other type of reason that isn't actually hunger or need and i
think one thing to keep in mind is it's not like circadian rhythms are unique to humans at all all
forms of life have circadian rhythms and if you look at animals in the wild they have times of
days that they eat and they have times of days that they fast and so this is kind of an inherent way
that life works even when you look at plants and algae and single cell bacteria they all have these
circadian rhythms and those things dictate when they eat when they avoid predators all those
types of things so i do think a lot of our more erratic eating patterns our later eating patterns
most of it is due to schedule and whenever we've run clinical trials with participants
we've never found someone who couldn't actually fit to a 10-hour window because it was physically
demanding it was people couldn't do it because of social pressures they had to pick care of their
kids in the morning and they had to work late at night or had to do a exercise late and then by
the time they got to make their dinner it was too late to do it it wasn't because they couldn't
physically it always came back to kind of this external pressures these social you know schedules
and work schedules and all those types of things that kind of dictated when they ate which is
precisely what you and sarah said at the beginning about why you ate late and i ate
late because i was i went out to the theater you know and i guess electricity allowed me to do that
um what's a night shift worker to do sarah well it's tough we know that shift workers are at
increased risk of many metabolic diseases so increased risk of cardiovascular disease type
likely to have high blood pressure and so forth and it's a very difficult problem to solve for
given that more and more of us are night shift workers and given that you often as a night shift
worker are also having an erratic sleeping pattern and so you might do three nights on
three nights off etc you know you might have family that you're then looking after on your
other three nights so you're not getting the consistency that emily talked about as well as
the fact that you're eating out of line with your circadian rhythm out of line with your body clock
there are some practical things that you can do and there's been some really interesting studies
both in the us and the uk looking at how can we improve the health of shift workers
there is no silver bullet though ruth it all boils down to the fact that you have to be even
more mindful than ever about the food that you're eating be more mindful about having refined
carbohydrates because we know as emily said that if you're having refined carbohydrates you're more
likely to have a bigger blood sugar peak that's more likely to lead to a big blood sugar dip
we know if you have a big blood sugar dip it just sets you off on a roller coaster
yeah so ideally what you would do what we would all do but i think this is even more pertinent
for shift workers you would build meals that have a balance of healthy fats so these are your mono
and polyunsaturated fats so extra virgin olive oil oily fish avocados those kind of sources
you would have a healthy source of protein ideally plant-based proteins that you're also
getting plenty of fiber that also balances out your absorption your digestion this could be from
nuts from seeds from whole grain sources so swapping white rice white pasta white bread
for whole grain sources of those having beans and pulses and then making sure that you're having
plenty of minimally processed other plant-based foods so fruits and vegetables and it's really
about making sure that that is dominating your plate rather than heavily processed rapidly
absorbable food rapidly digested food that's going to put you on kind of a blood glucose roller
coaster you know really kind of stress out your hormones that are already going to be struggling
overnight a problem i have is that if i try and eat three or four hours before i go to sleep i
find i'm then hungry as i get into bed and um you know that way late night snacking
lies and all the sorts of foods that you're saying that we shouldn't have um so what advice do you
have for the for a kind of thing you can eat at dinner time that will fill you up for a long time
see you through for right into bedtime and beyond so my first piece of advice would be to have a
decent amount of food so eat until you're full a lot of the time people are hungry later or
snacking because actually they're just not having a big enough main meal can dessert be a good idea
if it's a healthy dessert and you enjoy it absolutely i think building your meals around
having lots of fiber in it lots of protein in it and healthy fats what that does is it delays the
rate at which your stomach empties it means that you're absorbing the food more slowly the other
thing is is uh you know and i know this is is quite obvious to people but again really focusing
on the minimally processed foods and the reason for this is because we know if food is quite
minimally processed in its whole form as well as us as well as the the stomach emptying it more slowly
into our small intestine what happens is a lot of it remains more intact as it passes through the
small intestine and it's often reaches the lower parts of our small intestine where we have a lot
more concentrated number of fullness receptors so for example whole nuts whole seeds whole fruits
whole vegetables whole pulses you tend to absorb them lower down the gastrointestinal tract
they're absorbed more slowly and then you have this more slow feedback signal of fullness
um you know and i think these are kind of simple things that we can do so it's not enough to think
about just like when you eat your main meal you've really got to think about what it is as well if
you're going to have any kind of success with this timing strategy absolutely you know we could do
exactly as emily said we could finish three hours before bedtime but if you are having
white bread with no protein sauce fat sauce with it um you know crisps that kind of thing
well you know you're going to feel hungry in about 60 minutes most people will because you're
digesting it so quickly and it's not healthy for you anyway i think ruth you had mentioned like you
know you start to feel hungry after and a hundred percent what sarah said if you don't have a
satiating meal then of course that's going to happen but also because the system's anticipatory
if it thinks you're going to eat it can sometimes take two or three weeks for your body to like
not expect food anymore at that time and so sometimes it's better to just do like move it
forward a little bit at a time rather than jumping all the way in but if you resist that craving and
the more consistent you stay those hunger cues at night will kind of just go away do you imagine
you know whole cultures changing like rearranging their eating eating patterns as we get to know
more and more about the science of what eating at certain times does to our bodies could you
imagine that change happening oh absolutely because i mean when we think about it you know
a lot of these changes are ones that have have already happened right and i mean there are
societies that haven't made that change to a strong big even evening meal uh in germany um you
know children still go home from school for the for the mitoxicin right the the main meal during
the middle of the day and you know workers or university students will eat at the canteen
and um and then the the evening meal is is habenbrot right just bread in the evening and of
course in germany it's all whole wheat bread so uh you know that very dense uh very very healthy
things and so that's a society where where they have you know held on to those things uh china
is much the same way where that that uh big midday meal uh under communism people still went home to
have that meal and maybe to even take a little siesta and today they may be you know working at
the uh uh you know we're taking that big meal at at at the desk but at least it is still you know
kind of done in that way and so yeah i think that absolutely uh it is possible uh to change
emily what final piece of advice would you have to someone listening who has got a really busy
home life that you know do long working hours and they have to ferry the children around the
different activities like how when you are busy with so many competing demands can you
arrange your life so that you can eat three or four hours before bedtime
emily i'm glad you've been asked that one
i mean i think a lot of us on this call have that situation
and i think so many people do and and really i think one of the main things is meal planning
and it sounds so simple but like if you know what you're gonna eat and you know when you
think ahead of time and say this is when i have time to cook it so on a night i'm gonna get home
late i already have it cooked and i can just warm it up so i can eat it quickly rather than spending
an hour and a half to cook it um or you know sharing off cooking responsibilities with another
those things go such a far way i mean if i don't meal plan i cannot stick to my schedule so i think
meal planning is super important it also helps you make better decisions about the types of foods
that you're eating because you're doing it when you're not just like starving and need to grab
something quickly so you you can make more you know it's easier to make healthier decisions kind
of um objectively um and one thing i want to say that we hadn't covered yet is we also crave
worse quality foods later at night there's some really interesting research um that shows like
as it gets later in the night we actually will crave saltier fattier less quality foods you're
not really craving a salad or a whole wheat piece of toast or some lean chicken at night
and so that when you do make it so you don't eat enough at dinner just like sarah said then
when you do get hungry at night you're usually going for something that's not very high quality
so what i would say is figure out what your typical sleep time is try to make that as
consistent as possible work backwards from there find when you're eating dinner with your family
and what works with that and then you know set a 10 hour window from that you know i think there
have been some research on meal frequency and other things like that seems like three meals
a day with a snack or something along those lines that's kept consistent in a reasonable window
ideally if it's light outside but really to fit to your schedule more than anything
that really can go a long way to improve your health sarah what would your tip be your one
tip for someone wanting to make a change wanting to um you know allow eat a little bit earlier
further away from bedtime how could they at least nudge their way towards that this week
i think it's about really focusing on what your last meal of the day is and making sure that it
is substantial so it's going to fill you up making sure it's got nutrients in that will keep you full
for longer so protein healthy fats plenty of fiber and really focus on eating foods that
resemble the foods that they came from you know that's the best way to to know that they're in
their original structure so they will keep you fuller for longer will be metabolized in a way
that keeps you as healthy as possible the problem is ruth is really difficult we're surrounded by
all these hyper palatable tasty food that emily really rightly pointed out your brain actually
craves later at night and so you know maybe the best thing is out of sight out of mind don't have
those foods in your house if possible now that's difficult when if you have a husband like i do that
wants to snack on our healthy stuff or kids that sneak things into the house but that's one strategy
is also making sure out on your table out on your kitchen side you have healthy snacks if you are
going to snack later to go to and actually if you are choosing healthy snacks they can actually
significantly improve your health having nuts having seeds having whole fruits vegetables and
and you both confess to not getting it right all the time at least not last night anyway
um does that mean that you know although consistency is key you don't actually have to
be perfect every single day you never have to be perfect there's healthy ways to live like you
should exercise you shouldn't you know drink huge amounts of alcohol you shouldn't eat ice cream all
the time like there's so many things in life that are wonderful that you can do that you shouldn't
do all the time um and so i you could kind of think about it like brushing your teeth like you
should brush your teeth every day but if you didn't brush your teeth one night you're not going to wake
up with a mouthful of cavities the next morning right so like it should be occasional that you
cheat it should try to be as consistent as possible but if you need to eat late because you're at a
celebration or some other kind of social event or you've just had a day and that's what you need
right then i think that's fine um it's it's a matter of just don't overstarve yourself the next
day just get back to your regular schedule the next day and try to get back on that track and
occasional unhealthy habits if they're occasional are really not so unhealthy excellent advice i
will try to take at least some of it on board professor sarah berry thank you very much indeed
pleasure thanks for being uh well thanks for inviting me it's great to be part of a wonderful
discussion with jeffrey and emily so thank you and emily manoogian thank you very much to you too
thank you so much for having me this is a lot of fun it was great talking with everyone
and professor jeffrey pilcher thank you it was my pleasure i've really learned a lot
and you can watch more episodes of the food chain here on youtube like the one where we asked
is breakfast really the most important meal of the day we're available as a podcast every week to
search for the food chain online or wherever you get your bbc podcasts
